This article reviews and analyzes two national studies of the efficacy of treatment for war veterans suffering from post–traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). A careful analysis of the studies conducted by the Department of Veterans Affairs (DVA) Northeast Program Evaluation Center (NEPEC) reveals conceptual, methodological, and design flaws in the research, which reports minimal treatment efficacy for PTSD. Based on this limited, if not biased, data, the results were used for policy purposes to dismantle inpatient PTSD hospital units and trauma-focus treatments. A critique is offered as a review to suggest how future studies might be conducted, designed, and evaluated, including the need for independent, “outside” peer reviews inasmuch as the issue of treatment outcomes generalizes to many nonmilitary populations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aldwin, C. (1993, Summer). Coping with traumatic stress. PTSD Research Quarterly, 4(3), 1-3.
2.
American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
3.
American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
4.
Archibald, H. C., & Tuddenham, R. D. (1965). Persistent stress reaction after combat. Archives of General Psychiatry, 12, 475-481.
5.
Blank, A. (1993). Vet centers: A new paradigm in delivery of services for victims and survivors of traumatic stress. In J. P. Wilson & B. Raphael (Eds.), International handbook of traumatic stress syndromes. New York: Plenum.
6.
Carlson, J. G., Chemtob, C. M., Rusnak, K., Hedlund, N. L., & Muraoka, M. (1998). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR). Treatment for combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 11, 3-24.
7.
Carver, C., Scheier, M., & Weintraub, J. (1989). Assessing coping strategies: A theoretically-based approach. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 56(2), 267-283.
8.
Cooper, N. A., & Clum, G. A. (1989). Imaginal flooding as a supplementary treatment for PTSD in combat veterans: A controlled study. Behavior Therapy, 20, 381-391.
9.
Creamer, M., Morris, P., Biddle, D., & Elliott, P. (1999). Treatment outcome in Australian veterans with combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder: A cause for cautious optimism. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 12(4), 545-558.
10.
Donovan, B., Padin-Rivera, E., & Kowaliw, S. (2001). “Transcend”: Initial outcomes from a posttraumatic stress disorder substance abuse treatment program. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 14(4), 757-772.
11.
Foa, E., Keane, T. M., & Friedman, M. J. (2001). Effective treatments for PTSD. New York: Guilford.
12.
Folkman, S., & Lazarus, R. (1985). If it changes it must be a process: A study of emotion and coping during three stages of a college examination. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 48, 150-170.
13.
Fontana, A., & Rosenheck, R. (1996a). An evaluation of the inpatient treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder in Department of Veterans Affairs specialized PTSD programs. West Haven, CT: Department of Veterans Affairs, Northeast Program Evaluation Center (NEPEC), VA Connecticut Health Care System—West Haven Campus.
14.
Fontana, A., & Rosenheck, R. (1996b, January). Effectiveness and cost of three in-patient treatments of posttraumatic stress disorder: Comparison of three models of treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry, 154, 758-765.
15.
Fontana, A., & Rosenheck, R. (1996c, January). Improving the efficiency of outpatient treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder. Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 23(3), 197-210.
16.
Fontana, A., & Rosenheck, R. (1997, June). Effectiveness and cost of the inpatient treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder; Comparison of three models of treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry, 154(6), 758-765.
17.
Ford, J., & Stewart, J. (1999). Group psychotherapy for war-related PTSD with military veterans. In B. Young & D. Blake (Eds.), Group treatments for post–traumatic stress disorder (pp. 75-1000). Philadelphia: Brunner/Mazel.
18.
Friedman, M. J. (2000). Post–traumatic stress disorder. Kansas City, KS: Campact Clinicals.
19.
Frisch, M. (1994). QOLI: Quality of Life Inventory. Minneapolis, MN: National Computer Systems. (Available from P. O. Box 1416, Minneapolis, MN 55440)
20.
Fromme, K., & D’Amico, E. (1999). Neurological bases of alcohol’s effects. In K. E. Fromme & H. T. Blane (Eds.), Psychological theories of drinking and alcoholism (2nd ed., pp. 232-276). New York: Guilford.
21.
Frueh, C. (1998, September 24-25). Compensation policy and treatment outcome assessment. Paper Presented and VISN12 PTSD Symposium: Treatment Outcome, Chicago, IL.
22.
Hyer, L., Scurfield, R., Boyd, S., Smith, D., & Burke, J. (1996). Effects of Outward Bound experience as an adjunct to inpatient PTSD treatment of war veterans. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 52(3), 263-278.
23.
Johnson, D., Feldman, S., Southwick, S., & Charney, D. (1994, April). The concept of the second generation program in the treatment of post–traumatic stress disorder among Vietnam veterans. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 7(2), 195-216.
24.
Johnson, D., Rosenheck, R., Fontana, A., Lulbin, H., Southwick, S., & Charney, D. (1996). Outcome of intensive inpatient treatment for combat-related PTSD. American Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 771-777.
25.
Keane, T. M., Fairbank, J. A., Caddell, J. M. & Zimering, R. T. (1989). Implosive (flooding) therapy reduces symptoms of PTSD in combat veterans. Behavior Therapy, 20, 245-260.
26.
Kirk, A., & Einbinder, S. (Eds.). (1994). Controversial issues in mental health. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
27.
Kulka, R. A., Schlenger, W. E., Fairbank, J. A., Hough, R. L., Jordan, B. K. Marmar, C. R., et al. (1990). Trauma and the Vietnam War generation: Report of findings from the National Vietnam Veterans Readjustment Study. New York: Brunner/Mazel.
28.
Lilienfeld, S. (Ed.). (1995). Seeing both sides: Classic controversies in Abnormal Psychology. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole.
29.
Murphy, R. T., Cameron, R. P., Sharp, L., Ramirez, G., Rosen, C., Drescher, K., & Gusman, D. F. (in press). Readiness to change PTSD symptoms and related behaviors among veterans participating in a Motivation Enhancement Group. The Behavior Therapist.
30.
Murphy, R. T., Rosen, C. S., Cameron, R. P. & Thompson, K. E. (in press). Development of a group treatment for enhancing motivation to change PTSD symptoms. Cognitive & Behavioral Practice.
31.
Najavits, L. (2001). PTSD and substance abuse. New York: Guilford.
32.
Prochaska, J. O., & Diclemente, C. C. (1982). Transtheoretical therapy: Toward a more integrated model of change. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 19(3), 276-288.
33.
Prochaska, J. O., & Diclemente, C. C. (1992). Stages of change in the modification of problem behaviors. In M. Hersen, R. M. Eisler, & P. M. Miller (Eds.), Progress in Behavior Modification (pp. 184-214). Sycamore, IL: Sycamore Press.
34.
Ragsdale, K. G., Cox, R. D., Finn, P. & Eisler, R. M. (1996). Effectiveness of short-term specialized inpatient treatment for war-related posttraumatic stress disorder: A role for adventure-bound counseling and psychodrama. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 9(2), 269-283.
35.
Rogers, S. (1998). An alternative interpretation of “intensive” PTSD treatment failures. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 11(4), 769-775.
36.
Schnurr, P., & Foy, D. (2001, December 8). Predictors of outcome in trauma-focused versus present-centered group therapy. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Society for Traumatic Stress, New Orleans, LA.
37.
Scurfield, R. (1993). Treatment of post–traumatic syndrome disorder among Vietnam veterans. In J. P. Wilson & B. Raphael (Eds.), The international handbook of traumatic stress syndromes (pp. 879-889). New York: Plenum.
38.
Scurfield, R. (1994). War-related trauma: An integrative experiential, cognitive and spiritual approach (Treatment of survivors of war). In M. B. Williams & J. Sommers (Eds.), Handbook of post-traumatic therapy (pp. 179-204). Westport, CT: Greenwood.
39.
Scurfield, R. (1997, October 29). Critique of report by Drs. Fontana & Rosenheck (Memorandum submitted by director, Pacific Islands Division, VA National Center for PTSD, Honolulu, HI, to director, Mental Health and Behavioral Sciences Service [111C], DVA, Central Office, Washington, DC). Unpublished manuscript.
40.
Scurfield, R. M. (in press). War-related trauma: Psychosocial interventions and healing. Encyclopedia of Trauma and Abuse.
41.
Scurfield, R., Kenderdine, S., & Pollard, R. (1990). Inpatient treatment for war-related post–traumatic stress disorder: Initial findings on a longer-term outcome study. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 3(2), 185-201.
42.
Scurfield, R., Pouch, I., & Perkal, A. (1997). The journey of healing: An outpatient PTSD therapy group with veterans of three wars [Video]. Honolulu, HI: Department of Veterans Affairs, VA National Center for PTSD, Pacific Islands Division.
43.
Shapiro, F. (1996). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR): Evaluation of controlled research. Journal of Behavioral & Experimental Psychology, 27(3), 1-10.
44.
Solomon, Z., Mikulincer, M., & Avitzu, E. (1998). Coping, locus of control, social support, and combat-related posttraumatic stress disorder: A prospective study. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 55, 279-285.
45.
Solomon, Z., Mikulincer, M., & Benbenishsty, R. (1989). Locus of control and combat-related post–traumatic stress disorder: The intervening role of battle intensity, threat appraisal and coping. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 28, 131-144.
46.
Van der Kolk, B., McFarlane, A. C., & Weisaeth, L. (Eds.). (1996). Traumatic stress. New York: Guilford.
47.
Wilson, J. P., Friedman, M. F., & Lindy, J. (2001). Treating psychological trauma and PTSD. New York: Guilford.
48.
Wilson, J. P., & Keane, T. (1997). Assessing psychological trauma and PTSD. New York: Guilford.
49.
Wilson, J. P., & Raphael, B. (Eds.). (1993). International handbook of traumatic stress syndromes. New York: Plenum.
50.
Wolfe, J., Keane, T. M., Kaloupek, D. G., Mora, C. A., & Wine, P. (1993). Patterns of positive readjustment in Vietnam veterans. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 6, 179-193.
51.
Zadecki, J. (1999, July). PTSD treatment outcome: A conference report. Veterans Health System Journal, 4(7), 15-16, 19-22.
