Do We Really Need Another Municipal Fiscal Health Analysis? Assessing the Effectiveness of Fiscal Health Systems

Abstract

One of the difficulties faced in the effective and efficient management of public organizations is the understanding of when the organization is showing symptoms of financial distress. Administrators and researchers alike have typically relied upon financial condition systems such as Brown's (1993) 10-point test and Wang, Dennis, and Tu's (2007) financial condition index (FCI). the evidence is mounting that these systems are ineffective at predicting fiscally distressed communities; however, previous studies are limited to either case studies or entities in a few states. in an attempt to generalize over a longer period of time and across more states, this analysis utilizes a sample of 150 municipalities for the period of 1977 to 2012. the authors test the efficacy of the measurement approaches with a series of rare event history analyses (EHA) that captures their utility in predicting municipal bankruptcy or state takeover of financial operations. the findings are consistent with previous studies - financial condition systems do not predict fiscally distressed communities. Measures of fiscal reserves and long-term liabilities were more effective at predicting distress, suggesting that scholars should continue to work on the refinement of measures rather than systems of fiscal condition as predictors of fiscal distress.

Keywords

fiscal health municipal governance municipal bankruptcy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam

, Mussari

, and Jones

(2011) “The Diversity of Accrual Policies in Local Government Financial Reporting: An Examination of Infrastructure, Art and Heritage Assets in Germany, Italy and the UK”, Financial Accountability and Management, 27(2):107–133.

Altman

E.I.

(1968) “Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy,” Journal of Finance, 23(4):589–609.

Arnett

(2014) “State Fiscal Condition: Ranking the 50 States”, Working Paper, Mercatus Center, George Mason University.

Baden-Fuller

C.W.F.

(1989) “Exit from Declining Industries and the Case of Steel Castings”, The Economic Journal, 99(398):949–961.

Bahl

(1984). Financing State and Local Government in the 1980's, New York: Oxford University Press.

Benson

E.D.

, Marks

B.R.

, and Raman

K.K.

(1988) “Tax Effort as an Indicator of Fiscal Stress”, Public Finance Quarterly, 16(2):203–218.

Berry

F.S.

and Berry

W.D.

(1990) “State Lottery Adoptions as Policy Innovations: An Event History Analysis”, American Political Science Review, 84(2):395–415.

Bird

R.M.

(2015) “Reflections on Measuring Urban Fiscal Health”, in: Bird

R.M.

and Slack

(eds) Is Your City Healthy? Measuring Urban Fiscal Health, Toronto: University of Toronto, pp. 11–42.

Box-Steffenmeier

J.M.

and Jones

B.S.

(1997) “Time is of the Essence: Event History Models in Political Science”, American Journal of Political Science, 41(4):1414–1461.

10.

Brown

K.W.

(1993) “The 10-Point Test of Financial Condition: Toward and Easy-to-Use Assessment Tool for Smaller Cities”, Government Finance Review, 9(6):21–26.

11.

Clark

B.Y.

(2015) “Evaluating the Validity and Reliability of the Financial Condition Index for Local Governments”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 35(2):66–88.

12.

Crosby

and Robbins

(2013) “Mission Impossible: Monitoring Municipal Fiscal Sustainability and Stress in Michigan”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 25(3):522–555.

13.

Cyert

R.M.

, and March

J.G.

(1963) A Behavioral Theory of the Firm, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

14.

Drew

(2018) “Playing for Keeps: Local Government Distortion of Depreciation Accruals in Response to High Stakes Public Policy-Making”, Public Money and Management, 38(1):57–64.

15.

Finkler

S.A.

, Smith

D.L.

, Calabrese

T.D.

, and Purtell

R.M.

(2017) Financial Management for Public, Health, and Not-for-Profit Organizations, Washington, DC: CQ Press.

16.

Foulke

R.A.

(1961) Practical Financial Statement Analysis, New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

17.

Gerton

and Mitchell

J.P.

(2019) “Grand Challenges in Public Administration: Implications for Public Service Education, Training, and Research. Journal of Public Affairs Education, 25(4):435–440.

18.

Gorina

, Maher

, and Joffe

(2018) “Local Fiscal Distress: Measurement and Prediction”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 38(1):72–94.

19.

Governing (2015) Bankrupt Cities, Municipalities List and Map, accessed August 11, 2020 (http://www.governing.com/gov-data/municipal-cities-counties-bank-ruptcies-and-defaults.html).

20.

Groves

S.M.

, Godsey

W.M.

, and Shulman

M.A.

(1981) “Financial Indicators for Local Governments”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 1(2):5–19.

21.

Hendrick

(2004) “Assessing and Measuring the Fiscal Health of Local Governments: Focus on Chicago Suburban Municipalities”, Urban Affairs Review, 40(1):78–114.

22.

Honadle

B.W.

, Costa

J.M.

, and Cigler

B.A.

(2004) Fiscal Health for Local Governments: An Introduction to Concepts, Practical Analysis, and Strategies, London: Elsevier.

23.

Horrigan

J.O.

(1968) “A Short History of Financial Ratio Analysis”, The Accounting Review, 43(2):284–294.

24.

Hummel

(2015) “Right-Sizing Cities: A Look at Five Cities”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 35(2):1–18.

25.

Jacob

and Hendrick

(2013) “Measuring and Predicting Local Government Fiscal Stress: Theory and Practice”, in: Levine

, Justice

J.B.

, and Scorsone

E.A.

(eds) Handbook of Local Government Fiscal Health, Burlington, MA: Jones and Bartlett Learning, pp. 11–41.

26.

Jimenez

B.S.

(2009) “Fiscal Stress and the Allocation of Expenditure Responsibilities Between State and Local Governments: An Exploratory Study”, State and Local Government Review, 41(2):81–94.

27.

Justice

J.B.

and Scorsone

E.A.

(2013) “Measuring and Predicting Local Government Fiscal Stress”, in: Levine

, Justice

J.B.

, and Scorsone

E.A.

(eds), Handbook of Local Government Fiscal Health, Burlington, MA: Jones and Bartlett Learning, pp. 43–74.

28.

Kieso

D.E.

, Weygandt

J.J.

and Warfield

T.D.

(2011) Intermediate Accounting, Volume 1, Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons.

29.

Kiewiet

D.R.

and McCubbins

M.D.

(2014) “State and Local Government Finance: The New Fiscal Ice Age”, Annual Review of Political Science, 17:105–122.

30.

Kim

, McDonald

B.D.

, and Lee

(2018) “The Nexus of State and Local Capacity in Vertical Policy Diffusion”, American Review of Public Administration, 48(2): 188–200.

31.

King

and Zeng

(2001) “Logistic Regression in Rare Events Data”, Political Analysis, 9(2):137–163.

32.

Klamer

(2013) “Governors Dataset”, accessed August 11, 2020 (http://hdl.handle.net/1902.1/20408).

33.

Kloha

, Weissert

C.S.

, and Kleine

(2005) “Developing and Testing a Composite model to Predict Local Fiscal Distress”, Public Administration Review, 65(3):313–323.

34.

Ladd

H.F.

and Yinger

(1989) America's Ailing Cities: Fiscal Health and the Design of Urban Policy, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

35.

Maher

C.S.

and Deller

S.C.

(2011) “Measuring Municipal Fiscal Condition: Do Objective Measures of Fiscal Health Relate to Subjective Measures?” Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 23(3):427–450.

36.

Maher

C.S.

, Deller

S.C.

, Stallmann

J.I.

, and Park

(2016) “The Impact of Tax and Expenditure Limits on Municipal Credit Ratings”, American Review of Public Administration, 46(5):592–613.

37.

Maher

C.S.

, Ebdon

, and Bartle

J.R.

(2020) “Financial Condition Analysis: A Key Tool in the MPA Curriculum”, Journal of Public Affairs Education, 26(1):4–10.

38.

Maher

C.S.

and Nollenberger

(2009) “Revisiting Kenneth Brown's ‘10-Point Test’”, Government Finance Review, 25(5):61–66.

39.

Maher

C.S.

, Park

, and Harrold

(2016) “The Effects of Tax and Expenditure Limits on Municipal Pension and OPEB Funding During the Great Recession”, Public Finance and Management, 16(2): 121–146.

40.

Maser

S.M.

(1998) “Constitutions as Relational Contracts: Explaining Procedural Safeguards in Municipal Charters”, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 8(4):527–564.

41.

McDonald

B.D.

(2010) “The Bureau of Municipal Research and the Development of a Professional Public Service”, Administration and Society, 42(7):815–835.

42.

McDonald

B.D.

(2015) “Does the Charter Form Improve the Fiscal Health of Counties?” Public Administration Review, 75(4):609–618.

43.

McDonald

B.D.

(2018) “Local Governance and the Issue of Fiscal Health”, State and Local Government Review, 50(1):46–55.

44.

McDonald

B.D.

(2019). The challenges and implications of fiscal health. South Carolina Journal of International Law and Business, 75(20):78–99.

45.

McDonald

B.D.

and Gabrini

C.J.

(2014) “Determinants of County Charter Decisions: An Event History Analysis of Florida Counties”, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 24(4):721–739.

46.

Mead

D.M.

(2013) “The Development of External Financial Reporting and its Relationship to the Assessment of Fiscal Health and Stress”, in: Levine

, Justice

J.B.

, and Scorsone

E.A.

(eds), Handbook of Local Government Fiscal Health, Burlington, MA: Jones and Bartlett Learning, pp. 77–124.

47.

Nollenberger

, Groves

S.M.

, and Valente

M.G.

(2003) Evaluating Financial Condition: A Handbook for Local Government, Washington, DC: International City/County Management Association.

48.

Park

(2018) “Game-Theoretic Thinking of State-Imposed Tax and Expenditure Limitations: Rule Design, Institutional Diversity, and Municipal Fiscal Outcomes, Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, University of Nebraska at Omaha.

49.

Pew Charitable Trusts (2016) State Strategies to Detect Local Fiscal Distress, Washington, DC: Pew Charitable Trusts.

50.

Scorsone

E.A.

, Levine

, and Justice

J.B.

(2013) “Introduction”, in: Levine

, Justice

J.B.

, and Scorsone

E.A.

(eds) Handbook of Local Government Fiscal Health, Burlington, MA: Jones and Bartlett Learning, pp. 1–7.

51.

Silvey

S.D.

(1969) “Multicollinearity and Imprecise Estimation”, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B, 31(3):539–552.

52.

Stallmann

J.I.

, Maher

C.S.

, Deller

S.C.

, and Park

(2017) “Research on the Effects of Limitations on Taxes and Expenditures”, Journal of Public and Nonprofit Affairs, 3(2):197–222.

53.

Stone

S.B.

, Singla

, Comeaux

, and Kirschner

(2015) “A Comparison of Financial Indicators: The Case of Detroit”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 35(4):90–111.

54.

Trussel

J.M.

and Patrick

P.A.

(2013) “The Symptoms and Consequences of Fiscal Distress in Municipalities: An Investigation of Reductions in Public Services”, Accounting and the Public Interest, 13(1):151–171.

55.

Wall

(1919) “Study of Credit Barometrics”, Federal Reserve Bulletin, 5.

56.

Wang

(2014) “Firth Logistic Regression for Rare Variant Association Tests”, Frontiers in Genetics, 5:1–2.

57.

Wang

, Dennis

, and Tu

Y.S.

(2007) “Measuring Financial Condition: A Study of U. S. States”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 27(2):1–21.

58.

Wassmer

R.W.

and Anders

(1999) “County Fiscal Stress: Cause and Consequence in California After Proposition 13”, Working Paper, Department of Public Policy and Administration, California State University at Sacramento.

59.

Zhang

and Ibrahim

(2005) “A Simulation Study on SPSS Ridge Regression and Ordinary Least Squares Regression Procedures for Multicollinearity Data”, Journal of Applied Statistics, 32(6):571–588.