Various education finance and taxation reforms in the past several decades have substantially changed China's system for funding basic education, but the present system is still characterized by insufficient funding and large inequalities across localities. Using data of more than 2000 county-level units all over the country during 1998–2005, this study uses Theil index to spatially decompose the pattern of funding inequality in China's basic education across four geographic and administrative levels. The analysis shows that the level of inequality remained high after the rural taxation and education finance reforms since 2000, despite the efforts to increase education-purpose fiscal transfers to local governments, and that the gaps are especially severe across provinces in the same region and across prefectures in the same province.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BerneR. and StiefelL. (1984) The Measurement of Equity in School Finance: Conceptual, Methodological, and Empirical Dimensions, Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
2.
BrockA.HuW., and WongW. C. P. (2008) “Free Compulsory Education: A Natural Next Step after ‘Two Exemptions and One Subsidy’ (TEOS)”, Chinese Education and Society, 41(1)87–95.
3.
ChengG. (2009) “Study on Provincial Compulsory Education Financial Equity Based on School-level Data from One Province”, Chinese Education and Society, 42(5)26–46.
4.
General Office of the State Council (2002) The Notice of Completing the Management System of Compulsory Education in Rural Areas (Guowuyuan bangongting guanyu wanshan nongcun yiwu jiaoyu guanli tizhi de tongzhi). AccessedMay11, 2011 (http://news.xinhuanet.com/zhengfu/2002-05/16/content_395826.htm).
5.
JiangMXuJ., and WangH. (1997) “Education Finance in China's Counties in Poverty and the Cost of Basic Education: An Analysis on 491 National-level Counties in Poverty (Zhongguo Pingkunxian Jiaoyu Caizheng yu Chudeng Jiaoyu Chengben: 491 Ge Guojiaji Pingkunxian De Fenxi)”, Education and Economics (Jiaoyu yu Jingji), No. 4, 31–55.
6.
KennedyJ. J. (2007) “From the Tax-For-Fee Reform to the Abolition of Agricultural Taxes: The Impact on Township Governments in North-West China”. The China Quarterly, 189(1)43–59.
7.
LeggeJ. S. and ZhaoZ. (2004) “Morality Policy and Unintended Consequences: China's ‘One Child’ Policy”. Chinese Public Administration Review, 2(3/4): 30–45.
8.
LiX. (2008) The Reform of the Compulsory Education Finance System in the Evolution of the Finance System in China (Woguo Caizheng Tizhi Bian-qianzhong de Yiwu Jiaoyu Caizheng Zhidu Gaige), Beijing: Peking University Press.
9.
LinT. (2009) “Intra-provincial Inequality in Financing Compulsory Education in China: Exploring the Role of Provincial Leaders (1994–2001)”, Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 29(3)321–340.
10.
LuW. et al. (2004) The Public Investment Policy for Rural Compulsory Education (Nongcun Jichujiaoyu de Gonggong Touru Zhengce), The Economic and Social Development Research Institute of Northeastern University of Finance and Economics (Dongbei Caijing Daxue Jingji yu Shehui Fazhan Yan-jiuyuan Ketizu). Accessed accessed March 29, 2011 (http://academy.dufe.edu.cn/resources/neibuwengao/images/nongcunjichujiaoyugonggongtouru.pdf).
11.
MurrayS. E.EvansW. N., and SchwabM.R. (1998) “Education Finance Reform and the Distribution of Education Resources”, American Economic Review, 88(4)789–812.
PanT. (2000) “On the Regional Disparity of Financing Compulsory Education across County Level (Woguo xianji yiwujiaoyu touzi de diqu cayi jiqi yingxiang yinsu fenxi)”, Education and Economy (Jiaoyu yu jingji), 4: 36–44.
14.
ShahA., and ShenC. (2008) “Fine-tuning the Intergovernmental Transfer System to Create a Harmonious Society and a Level Playing Field for Regional Development”, in: Jiwei Lou and Shuilin Wang (eds) Public finance in China: Reform and Growth for a Harmonious Society, pp. 129–154, Washington, DC: World Bank.
15.
State Council (2001) The Decision on the Reform and Development of Basic Education (Guowuyuan guanyu jichu jiaoyu gaige yu fazhan de jueding). AccessedMay11, 2011 (http://www.edu.cn/20010907/3000665.shtml).
16.
TsangM. C. (1994) “Costs of Education in China: Issues of Resource Mobilization, Equality, Equity, and Efficiency”, Education Economics, 2(3)287–312.
17.
TsangM. C. (2000) “Education and National Development in China Since 1949: Oscillating Policies and Enduring Dilemmas”, in: LauChung-ming and ShenJianfa (eds) China Review, pp. 579–618, Hong Kong: The Chinese University of Hong Kong.
18.
TsangM. C. (2002) “Establishing and Developing a Substantial and Regularized Scheme of Intergovernmental Grants in Compulsory Education in China”, Harvard China Review, 5: 11–15.
19.
TsangM. C. and DingY. (2005) “Resource Utilization and Disparities in Compulsory Education in China”, China Review, 5(1)1–31.
20.
WangR. (2001) “Regional Disparity in School Finances in China (Woguo Yiwu Jiaoyu de Diqu Chayi Yanjiu)”, Paper presented at the Peking University International Conference on the Economics of Education (Beijing Daxue Jiaoyu Jingjixue Guoji Yantaohui), Bejing, China.
21.
WangW. and DuncombeW. (2009) “School Facilities Funding and Capital Outlay Distribution in the States”, Journal of Education Finance, 34(3)324–350.
22.
WangW.ZhengX. and ZhaoZ. (2012) “Fiscal Reform and Public Education Spending: A Quasi-natural Experiment of Fiscal Decentralization in China”, Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 42(2)334–356.
23.
WangW. and ZhaoZ. (2012) “Rural Taxation Reforms and Compulsory Education Finance in China”, Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting, and Financial Management, 24(1)136–162.
24.
WongC. P. W. (1997) “Rural Public Finance”, in: Christine P. W. Wong (eds) Financing Local Government in the People's Republic of China, pp. 167–212, Hong Kong: Oxford University Press.
25.
WongC. P. W. and BirdM.R. (2005) China's Fiscal System: A Work in Progress, Working paper 05–20, International Studies Program, Andrew Young School of Public Policy, Georgia State University. Accessed March 29, 2011 (http://aysps.gsu.edu/isp/files/ispwp0520.pdf).
26.
XueL. and ShiT. (2001) “Inequality in Chinese Education”, Journal of Contemporary China, 10(26)107–124.
27.
YepR. (2004) “Can ‘Tax-For-Fee’ Reform Reduce Rural Tension in China: The Process, Progress and Limitations”, The China Quarterly, 177:42–70.
28.
YuanX. (2009) “Current State of Guangxi Compulsory Education Equity and Countermeasures”, Chinese Education and Society, 42(5)26–46.
29.
ZhaoZ. (2009) “Fiscal Decentralization and Provincial-level Fiscal Disparities: A Sino-US Comparative Perspective”, Public Administration Review, 69: S67–S74.
