Nonprofit Exemptions and Homeowner Property Tax Burden

Abstract

This paper examines the question of whether there is any correlation between the prevalence of nonprofit organizations with property, plant, and equipment exempt from property taxation and the property tax burden for homeowners. Data from the Tax Foundation and Internal Revenue Service was used to analyze general-purpose local governments within larger counties (populations greater than 65,000) in the United States for years 2005 and 2006. Several econometric specifications were used to estimate homeowner property tax burden as a function of the value of nonprofit fixed assets, government tax structure characteristics, and a series of control variables. Our estimates suggest that county geographies with greater presence of nonprofits tend to have higher homeowner tax burdens on average. Specifically, the value of nonprofit tax-exempt fixed assets within a county geography that is 10% above the mean of $15.4 million is generally associated with a median property tax paid by homeowners as a % of household income that is between 0.0009% and 0.0154% above the mean or between $2 and $24 higher on average. The median property tax paid as a % of homeowner's home value would be between 0.0006% and 0.0069% above the mean or between $3 and $12 higher on average. Overall, we find a strong, positive correlation between nonprofit fixed assets and property tax burden for homeowners at the local level.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrams

B. A.

and Schmitz

D.M.

(1984) “The ‘Crowding-Out’ Effect of Governmental Transfers on Private Charitable Contributions: Cross-Section Evidence”, National Tax Journal, 37 (4) 563–568.

Andreoni

and Payne

(2003) “Do Government Grants to Private Charities Crowd Out Giving or Fund-Raising?”, American Economic Review, 93 (3) 792–812.

Augustine

N. Y.

Bell

M. E.

Brunori

, and Youngman

M.J.

(2009) “The property tax under siege”, in: Augustine

N. Y.

Bell

M. E.

Brunori

and Youngman

J. M.

(eds) Erosion of the Property Tax Base: Trends, Causes and Consequences, pp. 1–16, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

Bell

and Kirschner

(2008) “A Reconnaissance of Currently Available Measures of Effective Property Tax Rates”, Unpublished Working Paper, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

Ben-Ner

and T. Van Hoomissen (1991) “Nonprofits in a Mixed Economy: A Demand and Supply Analysis”, Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62 (4) 519–550.

Bergstrom

T. C.

Blume

, and Varian

(1986) “On the Private Provision of Public Goods”, Journal of Public Economics, 29 (1) 25–49.

Bielefeld

and Murdoch

C.J.

(1997) “The Influence of Demographics and Distance on Nonprofit Location”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 26 (2): 207–225.

Bielefeld

and Murdoch

C.J.

(2004) “The Locations of Nonprofit Organizations and Their For-Profit Counterparts: An Exploratory Analysis”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 33 (2) 221–246.

Blackley

P. R.

and DeBoer

(1987) “Tax Base Choice by Local Governments”, Land Economics, 63 (3) 227–236.

10.

Bowman

Cordes

, and Metcalf

(2009) “Preferential Tax Treatment of Property Used for Social Purposes: Fiscal Impacts and Public Policy Implications”, in: Augustine

N. Y.

Bell

M. E.

Brunori

and Youngman

J. M.

(eds) Erosion of the Property Tax Base: Trends, Causes and Consequences, pp. 269–294, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

11.

Brody

(1998) “Of Sovereignty and Subsidy: Conceptualizing the Charity Tax Exemption”, The Journal of Corporation Law, 23 (4) 585–629.

12.

Brody

(2010) “All Charities Are Property-Tax Exempt, But Some Charities Are More Exempt Than Others”, New England Law Review, 44: 621–732.

13.

Brunori

(2003) “Local Tax Policy”, Washington D.C.: The Urban Institute Press.

14.

Buchanan

J. M.

and Tullock

(1962) “The Calculus of Consent“, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.

15.

Carroll

D. A

. (2009) “Diversifying municipal government revenue structures: Fiscal illusion or instability?”, Public Budgeting and Finance, 29 (1) 27–48.

16.

Carroll

D. A.

and Johnson

(2010) “Examining Small Town Revenues: To What Extent Are They Diversified?”, Public Administration Review, 70 (2) 223– 235.

17.

Carroll

D. A.

and Sharbel

J.B.

(2006) “The Property Tax: Past, Present and Future”, in: Frank

H. A.

(ed) Public Financial Management, pp. 151–178, Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.

18.

Chang

C. F.

and Tuckman

P.H.

(1996) “The Goods Produced by Nonprofit Organizations”, Public Finance Quarterly, 24 (1) 25–43.

19.

Core

J. E.

Guay

W. R.

, and Verdi

S.R.

(2006) “Agency Problems of Excess Endowment Holdings in Not-for-Profit Firms”, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 41 (3) 307–333.

20.

Douglas

(1987) “Political Theories of Nonprofit Organizations”, in: Powell

W. W.

(ed) The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, pp. 43–54, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

21.

Dugan

I. J

. (2010) “Strapped Cities Hit Nonprofits with Fees”, Wall Street Journal, December 27, 2010.

22.

Duncombe

and Yinger

(2001) “Alternative Paths to Property Tax Relief”, in: Oates

W. E.

(ed) Property Taxation and Local Government Finance, pp. 243–290, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

23.

Ferris

J. M

. (1998) “The Role of the Nonprofit Sector in a Self-Governing Society: A View from the United States”, Voluntas, 9 (2) 137–151.

24.

Fischel

W. A

. (1975) “Fiscal and Environmental Considerations in the Location of Firms in Suburban Communities”, in: Mills

E. S.

and Oates

W. E.

(eds) Fiscal Zoning and Land Use Controls, pp. 119–173, Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.

25.

Fischel

W. A

. (2001) “Homevoters, Municipal Corporate Governance, and the Benefit View of the Property Tax”, National Tax Journal, 54 (1) 157–173.

26.

Fisman

and Hubbard

G.R.

(2005) “Precautionary Savings and the Governance of Nonprofit Organizations”, Journal of Public Economics(11–12), 89: 2231–2243.

27.

Fullerton

D. E.

and Metcalf

G. E

. (2003) “The Distribution of Tax Burdens”, in: International Library of Critical Writings in Economics, Vol. 155, Northampton, MA: Elgar Reference Collection.

28.

Giving USA (2010) The Annual Report on Philanthropy for the Year 2009, Indianapolis, IN: The Center on Philanthropy at Indiana University.

29.

Green

R. K.

and Weiss

(2009) “Property Tax Exemptions, Revenues, and Equity: Some Lessons from Wisconsin”, in: Augustine

N. Y.

Bell

M. E.

Brunori

and Youngman

J. M.

(eds) Erosion of the Property Tax Base: Trends, Causes and Consequences, pp. 51–68, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

30.

Gronjberg

and Paarlberg

(2002) “Extent and Nature of Overlap Between Listings of IRS Tax-Exempt Registration and Nonprofit Incorporation: The Case of Indiana”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 31 (4) 565–594.

31.

Hall

P. D

. (2002) “Is Tax Exemption Intrinsic or Contingent? Tax Treatment of Voluntary Associations, Nonprofit Organizations, and Religious Bodies in New Haven, Connecticut, 1750–2000”, in: E. Brody (ed) Property-Tax Exemption for Charities: Mapping the Battlefield, pp. 253–298, Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.

32.

Hamilton

B. W

. (1975) “Zoning and Property Taxation in a System of Local Governments”, Urban Studies, 12 (2) 205–211.

33.

Hamilton

B. W

. (1976) “Capitalization of Intra-Jurisdictional Differences in Local Tax Prices”, American Economic Review, 66 (5) 743–753.

34.

Hendrick

Yonghong

, and Jacob

(2007) “Tax Competition Among Municipal Governments”, Urban Affairs Review, 43 (2) 221–255.

35.

Harrison

T. D

. (2008) “Taxes and Agglomeration Economies: How Are They Related to Nonprofit Firm Location?”, Southern Economic Journal, 75 (2) 538–557.

36.

Kenyon

D. A.

and Langley

H.A.

(2009) Payments in Lieu of Taxes: Balancing Municipal and Nonprofit Interests, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

37.

Kingma

B. R

. (1989) “An Accurate Measure of the Crowd-out Effect, Income Effect and Price Effect for Charitable Contributions”, Journal of Political Economy, 97 (5) 1197–1207.

38.

Ladd

H. F

. (1992) “Mimicking of Local Tax Burdens Among Neighboring Counties”, Public Finance Review, 20 (4) 450–467.

39.

Ladd

H. F.

and Yinger

(1989) America's Ailing Cities: Fiscal Health and the Design of Urban Policy, Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

40.

Leland

(2002) “PILOTs: The Large-City Experience”, in: Brody

(ed) Property-Tax Exemption for Charities: Mapping the Battlefield, pp. 193–210, Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.

41.

Meyer

J. A.

Legnini

M. W.

Fatula

E. K.

, and Stepnick

S.L.

(1999) “The Role of Local Governments in Financing Safety Net Hospitals: Houston, Oakland, and Miami”, in: Occasional Paper Number 25 – Assessing the New Federalism Project, Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.

42.

Mieszkowski

(1972) “The Property Tax: An Excise Tax or a Profits Tax?”, Journal of Public Economics, 1 (1) 73–96.

43.

Mullins

D. R.

and Wallin

A.B.

(2004) “Tax and Expenditure Limitations: Introduction and Overview”, Public Budgeting & Finance, 24 (4) 2–15.

44.

Muthitacharoen

and Zodrow

R.G.

(2010) “The Efficiency Costs of a Local Property Tax”, in: Bahl

Martinez-Vazquez

and Youngman

(eds) Challenging the Conventional Wisdom of the Property Tax, pp. 15–42, Cambridge, MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

45.

National League of Cities (2004) Cities and the Future of Public Finance: A Framework for Public Discussion, Washington, DC: National League of Cities.

46.

Oates

W. E

. (1969) “The Effects of Property Taxes and Local Public Spending on Property Values: An Empirical Study of Tax Capitalization and the Tiebout Hypothesis”, The Journal of Political Economy, 77 (6) 957–971.

47.

Oates

W. E.

and Schwab

M.R.

(1988) “Economic Competition Among Jurisdictions: Efficiency-Enhancing or Distortion-Inducing?”, Journal of Public Economics, 35 (3) 333–354.

48.

Office of Management and Budget (OMB) (2010) Analytical Perspectives: Budget of the U.S. Government. Accessed February 14, 2012 (www.budget.gov).

49.

Okten

and Weisbrod

A.B.

(2000) “Determinants of Donations in Private Nonprofit Markets”, Journal of Public Economics, 75 (2) 255–272.

50.

Payne

(1998) “Does the Government Crowd-Out Private Donations? New Evidence from a Sample of Non-Profit Firms”, Journal of Public Economics, 69 (3) 323–345.

51.

Plummer

(2003) “Evidence on the Incidence of Residential Property Taxes across Households”, National Tax Journal, 56 (4) 739–753.

52.

Roberts

(1984) “A Positive Model of Private Charity and Public Transfers”, Journal of Political Economy, 92 (1) 136–148.

53.

Ross

and Yinger

(1999) “Sorting and Voting: A Review of the Literature on Urban Public Finance”, in: Cheshire

and Mills

E. S.

(eds) Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics, Vol. 3, pp. 2001–2060, Amsterdam: North-Holland.

54.

Schiff

and Weisbrod

(1991) “Competition Between For-Profit and Nonprofit Organizations in Commercial Markets”, Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 62 (4) 619–640.

55.

Sears

D. O.

and Citrin

(1982) Tax Revolt: Something For Nothing in California, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

56.

Sjoquist

D. L.

Walker

M. B.

, and Wallace

(2005) “Estimating Differential Responses to Local Fiscal Conditions: A Mixture Model Analysis”, Public Finance Review, 33 (1) 36–61.

57.

Stater

K. J

. (2010) “How Permeable is the Nonprofit Sector? Linking Resources, Demand, and Government Provision to the Distribution of Organizations Across Nonprofit Mission-Based Fields”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 39 (4) 674–695.

58.

Strauss

(2001) “Pennsylvania's Local Property Tax”, State Tax Notes, June 4: 1963–1983.

59.

Swords

(2002) “The Charitable Real Property – Tax Exemption as a Tax Base-Defining Provision”, in: Brody

(ed) Property-Tax Exemption for Charities: Mapping the Battlefield, pp. 377–382, Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.

60.

Tiebout

C. M

. (1956) “A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures”, The Journal of Political Economy, 64 (5) 416–424.

61.

Warr

P. G

. (1982) “Pareto Optimal Redistribution and Private Charity”, Journal of Public Economics, 19 (1) 131–138.

62.

Weisbrod

B. A

. (1977) The Voluntary Nonprofit Sector, Lexington, KY: D.C. Heath and Company.

63.

Weisbrod

B. A.

and Dominguez

(1986) “Demand for Collective Goods in Private Nonprofit Markets: Can Fund-Raising Expenditures Help Overcome Free-Rider Behavior?”, Journal of Public Economics, 30 (1) 83–95.

64.

White

M. J

. (1975) “Firm Location in a Zoned Metropolitan Area”, in: Mills

E. S.

and Oates

W. E.

(eds) Fiscal Zoning and Land Use Controls, pp. 31–100, Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.

65.

Wilson

J. D

. (1986) “A Theory of Inter-Regional Tax Competition”, Journal of Urban Economics, 19 (3) 296–315.

66.

Wolpert

(1993) “Decentralization and Equity in Public and Nonprofit Sectors”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 22 (4) 281–296.

67.

Wolpert

(1995) “Giving and Region: Generous and Stingy Communities”, New Directions for Philanthropic Fundraising, 7: 11–30.

68.

Wooldridge

J. M

. (2009) Introductory Econometrics, 4th Edition, Mason, OH: Southwestern Cengage Learning.

69.

Zodrow

G. R

. (2007) “The Property Tax Incidence Debate and the Mix of State and Local Finance of Local Public Expenditures”, Economic Studies, 53 (4) 495–521.

70.

Zodrow

G. R

. (2001) “The Property Tax as a Capital Tax: A Room with Three Views”, National Tax Journal, 54 (1) 139–156.

71.

Zodrow

G. R.

and Mieszkowski

(1986) “Pigou, Tiebout, Property Taxation and the Under-Provision of Local Public Goods”, Journal of Urban Economics, 19 (3) 356–370.