This case study, focusing on the Scottish press, analyzes emerging media constructions of Scottish identity as articulated through the prism of the new Scottish parliament, with the focus on that institution's preliminary relationships with the United Kingdom and the European Union. The study covers a six-month period leading up to the historic opening of the new parliament in July of 1999. It provides a clearer picture of how Scotland's political relations with the UK and the EU were being framed and presented at that time, as the Scottish nation and its new polity began the process of redefining themselves within these larger entities. Four dominant media packages are identified, each of which articulates a different vision for Scotland's future in relation to the UK and the EU. Three of the four packages emphasize versions of the Scottish-UK relationship that place Scotland in a subservient or regressive position vis-à-vis the UK. However, one of the identified packages represents a genuinely original framework for Scotland's external relations, and provides a progressive model for medium-and long-term media coverage of these relations. However, in order for this package to predominate, a number of institutional and cultural factors reinforcing the status quo must be overcome.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
A nation once again? (1999, May 1). The Economist, 53–55.
2.
A polished performance. (1999, March 13). The Herald, p. 14.
3.
BagdikianB. (2000). The media monopoly.Boston: Beacon Press.
4.
BarbrookR. (1992). Broadcasting and national identity in Ireland. Media, Culture & Society, 14 (2), 203–227.
5.
BellD. (1999, May 5). Financial restraints mean the Parliament has to look around to help spread the initial load. The Herald, p. 9.
6.
BellI. (1999, June 30). No hiding place at Holyrood. The Scotsman, p. 17.
7.
BennettW. L. (1988). News: The politics of illusion.New York: Longman.
8.
BoyleR. (1992). From our Gaelic fields: Radio, sport and nation in post-partition Ireland. Media, Culture & Society, 14(4), 623–636.
9.
BrewerG. (1999, March 6). Now the genie of independence is out of the bottle. The Herald, p. 13.
10.
BroganB. (1999a, March 4). Blair targets ordinary Scots. The Herald, p. 6.
11.
BroganB. (1999b, March 6). Dewar brands SNP Luddites as Prime Minister promises a PC for every teacher in Scotland. The Herald, p. 7.
12.
BroganB. (1999c, June 28). Whispering campaign puts Dewar in the dock. The Herald, p. 1.
13.
BroganB.McGregorS. (1999, May 3). Penny dreadful for low paid. The Herald, p. 7.
14.
CampbellD. (1999, January 20). CBI chief questions economics of going it alone. The Herald, p. 6.
15.
Cause for celebration. (1999, June 22). The Herald, p. 16.
16.
CohenR. (1999, January 22). Germany's pragmatic ex-radical thinks globally. The New York Times, p. A3.
17.
ColemanB. (1999). Monarchy and nation in Britain since the eighteenth century. In CameronK. (Ed.), National identity.Exeter: Intellect, pp. 125–142.
18.
CopleyJ.CarrellS. (1999, January 15). English MPs will get their own committee. The Scotsman, p. 2.
19.
CopleyJ.TaitR. (1999, January 22). Prescott's hard sell for Holyrood. The Scotsman, p. 6.
20.
CornfordJ. (1991). Towards a constitutional equation. In CrickB. (Ed.), National identities: The constitution of the United Kingdom.Oxford; Cambridge: The Political Quarterly Publishing Co. Ltd.
21.
CurranJ.GurevitchM.WoollacottJ. (1977). Mass communication and society.Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
22.
Descent into puerile politics (1999, January 25). The Herald, p. 12.
23.
DevineT. (1999). The Scottish nation: A history, 1700–2000.New York: Viking.
24.
DicksonM. (1999, May 8). Short steps on long road. The Herald, p. 8.
25.
DinwoodieR. (1999a, March 13). Scotland's party principles. The Herald, p. 7.
26.
DinwoodieR. (1999b, May 5). Lib Dems are more bullish on good deal. The Herald, p. 9.
27.
DinwoodieR. (1999c, May 12). Salmond on attack over Millbank meddling. The Herald, p. 7.
28.
DinwoodieR.BroganB. (1999, May 10). Coalition talks test Dewar's resolve. The Herald, p. 1.
29.
EntmanR. M. (1989). Democracy without citizens: Media and the decay of American politics.New York: Oxford University Press.
30.
GamsonW. A.LaschK. E. (1983). The political culture of social welfare policy. In SpiroS. E.Yuchtman-YaarE. (Eds.), Evaluating the welfare state: Social and political perspectives (pp. 397–415). New York: Academic Press.
31.
GamsonW. A.ModiglianiA. (1989). Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power: A constructionist approach. American Journal of Sociology, 95(1), 1–37.
32.
GrayA. (1999, May 8). Blair's Babes no role models for rising woman stars. The Scotsman, p. 7.
33.
GroomB. (1999, January 22). Voices from the margin. Financial Times, p. 2.
34.
GurevitchM.LevyM.R., (Eds.) (1985). Mass communication review yearbook, vol. 5. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
35.
HallS. (1980). Coding and encoding in the television discourse. In HallS. (Eds.), Culture, media, language (pp. 197–208). London: Hutchinson.
36.
HardieA. (1999, May 1). Cardinal Winning condemns election 'venom. The Scotsman, p. 12.
37.
HardieA.PercivalJ. (1999, May 11). Blair pulls strings in talks on coalition. The Scotsman, p. 1.
38.
Haunted house (2003, November 1). The Economist, 34.
39.
Holyrood achievement (1999, January 16). The Herald, p. 14.
40.
HorsburghF. (1999a, January 16). Laying out the rules to govern. The Herald, p. 6.
41.
HorsburghF. (1999b, May 4). A broadside from Canon Wright. The Herald, p. 8.
42.
HorsburghF. (1999c, May 6). Rifkind urges Labour supporters to give Tories their second vote. The Herald, p. 7.
43.
HorsburghF. (1999d, Jun. 22). Crowning glory for the new parliament. The Herald, p. 1.
44.
HutchisonD. (1987). The press in Scotland: Articulating a national identity, in McCroneDavid (Ed.), Scottish Government Yearbook 1987.Edinburgh: Unit for the Study of Government in Scotland.
45.
IyengarS.SimonA. (1993). News coverage of the Gulf crisis and public opinion: A study of priming, agenda-setting, and framing. Communication Research, 20(3), 365–383.
46.
JeffreyC. (1996). Towards a ‘third level’ in Europe? The German Läänder in the European Union. Political Studies, 44(2), 253–266.
47.
KerevanG. (1999, January 18). Blair's middle-class smokescreen. The Scotsman, p. 6.
48.
Labour's education targets (1999, January 28). The Herald, p. 18.
49.
MacartneyA. (1997). Scots must decide - do they want to be an independent nation or remain a region (speech to IPI World Congress and 46th General Assembly, Granada, Spain, 1997). IPI Report. June–July, 1997, p. 10.
50.
MacMahonP.CarrellS. (1999, January 23). Scots a ‘role model for England’. The Scotsman, p. 6.
51.
MacWhirterI. (1999a, May 5). Get your retaliation in first to curb the Labour lords of misrule. The Herald, p. 6.
52.
MacWhirterI. (1999b, May 13). An end to an auld moan. The Herald, p. 6.
53.
McBainB. (1999, June 29). The funding dilemma. The Herald, p. 12.
54.
McCreadieR. (1991). Scottish identity and the constitution. In CrickB. (Ed.), National identities: The constitution of the United Kingdom.Oxford; Cambridge: The Political Quarterly Publishing Co.
55.
McCroneD. (2001a). Scotland and the Union: Changing identities in the British state. In MorleyD.RobinsK. (Eds.). British cultural studies: Geography, nationality, and identity.Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 97–108.
56.
McCroneD. (2001b). Understanding Scotland: Sociology of a nation.London; New York: Routledge.
57.
McGregorS. (1999, May 6). Tooth and nail for every vote. The Herald, p. 7.
58.
McLynnF. (1999, May 3). Why Connery is right. The Herald, p. 6.
59.
McMillanJ. (1999, May 7). Beginning to feel the force. The Scotsman, p. 23.
60.
McQuailD. (1994). Mass communication theory: An introduction.London: Sage.
61.
MeechP.KilbornR. (1992). Media and identity in a stateless nation: The case of Scotland. Media Culture and Society, 14 (2), 245–259.
62.
MeekB. (1999, March 3). From the fat into the fire. The Herald, p. 17.
63.
MilneK. (1999a, May 3). The SNP hopefuls know what they want to achieve. The Scotsman, p. 6.
64.
MilneK. (1999b, May 21). Why can't we talk about Europe. The Scotsman, p. 19.
65.
NairnT. (1981). The breakup of Britain: Crisis and neo-nationalism.London: NLB.
66.
NairnT. (2000). After Britain: New Labour and the return of Scotland.London: Granta.
NeilA. (1999a, Jan. 29). Who wants to leave a winning team. The Scotsman, p. 21.
69.
NeilA. (1999b, May 7). Dewar faces dilemma over coalition. The Scotsman, p. 23.
70.
NeumanW. R.JustM. R.CriglerA. N. (1992). Common knowledge: News and the construction of political meaning.Chicago, London: University of Chicago Press.
71.
Oskar Lafontaine, a role model for Alex Salmond? (1999, March 13). The Scotsman, p. 14.
72.
PattersonL. (2001). New Scotland, new politics.Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
73.
ReidJ. (1999, May 10). We have to be different. The Herald, p. 13.
74.
Reid right for tough job. (1999, May 12). The Herald, p. 20.
75.
Respect for our readership. (1999, May 4). The Herald, p. 16.
76.
RitchieM. (1999a, March 6). Blair bids to unite party in SNP war. The Herald, p. 1.
77.
RitchieM. (1999b, March 15). Brown warns 1p tax to cost jobs. The Herald, p. 7.
78.
RitchieM. (1999c, May 1). The cost of independence. The Herlad, p. 1.
79.
RitchieM. (1999d, May 13). Time for a new song. The Herald, p. 1.
80.
RitchieM. (1999e, June 23). Dewar bid for more exciting Question Time. The Herald, p. 6.
81.
RitchieM.DinwoodieR. (1999a, March 12). The party which knows how to enjoy itself hopes nothing goes wrong. The Herald, p. 7.
82.
RitchieM.DinwoodieR. (1999b, May 12). Pact rows push Labour near Home alone Rule. The Herald, p. 1.
83.
SahinH.AksoyA. (1993). Global media and cultural identity in Turkey. Journal of Communication, 43(2), 31–41.
84.
ScheufeleD. A. (1999). Framing as a theory of media effects. Journal of Communication, 49(1): 103–122.
85.
SchlesingerP. (1991). Media, the political order and national identity. Media, Culture & Society, 13(3), 297–308.
86.
SchlesingerP. (1992). Media, state, and nation.London: Sage Publications.
87.
SchlesingerP. (1993). Wishful thinking: Cultural politics, media, and collective identities in Europe. Journal of Communication, 43(2), 6–17.
88.
SchlesingerP. (1998). Scottish devolution and the media. In SeatonJ. (Ed.), Politics and the media (pp. 55–74). Oxford: Blackwell.
89.
SchwarzB. (2001). Britain, America, and Europe. In MorleyD.RobinsK. (Eds.), British cultural studies: Geography, nationality, and identity.Oxford; New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 157–170.
90.
Scotland at the crossroads. (1999, May 6). The Herald, p. 17.
91.
ScottD. (1999a, Jan. 16). Politicians unite to back Holyrood plan. The Scotsman, p. 6.
92.
ScottD. (1999b, May 4). Findlay warns voters against opting out. The Scotsman, p. 5.
93.
ScottD. (1999c, May 6). Tories urge tactics to save union. The Scotsman, p. 2.
