A Common Good-Based Justification for Non-Compliance with the Political Obligation of Homeland Defence

Abstract

Non-compliance with compulsory military service as a form of homeland defence (i.e. conscription) is typically justified by various types of conscientious objections. However, in this article, I offer an alternative type of justification that is based on the common good. To achieve this, I present the concept of the common good and its relationship to the political obligation of homeland defence from the perspective of different traditions of political thought. Subsequently, I outline two types of exceptions to this political obligation: the liberal type of exceptions and the membership-based ones.

Keywords

common good homeland defence conscription political obligation conscientious objection

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asheri-Shahaf

(2016) Patriotic Conscientious Objection to Military Service. Res Publica – A Journal of Moral Legal and Political Philosophy 22 (2): 155–172.

Barbieri

(2001) Beyond the Nations: The Expansion of the Common Good in Catholic Social Thought. The Review of Politics 63 (4): 723–754.

Baroš

(2021) Whose Public Reason? Which Justification of Laws? A Natural Law Response. Revue de métaphysique et de morale 112 (4): 507–524.

Baroš

(2023) Společné dobro: minimalistické, instrumentální, či robustní? Studia Theologica 25 (2): 191–213.

Bellamy

(2000) Rethinking Liberalism. London and New York: Pinter.

Beran

(1977) In Defense of the Consent Theory of Political Obligation and Authority. Ethics 87 (3): 260–271.

Beran

(2020) The Consent Theory of Political Obligation. London and New York: Routledge.

Borg

(2023) In Search of the Common Good: The Postliberal Project Left and Right. European Journal of Social Theory. https://doi.org/10.1177/13684310231163126

Brett

Townhead

(2012) Conscientious Objection to Military Service. In: Gilbert

Hampson

Sandoval

(eds) Strategic Visions for Human Rights: Essays in Honour of Professor Kevin Boyle. London: Routledge, pp.91–107.

10.

Brhlíková

(1997) Suverenita štátu. Právny obzor 80 (3): 362–364.

11.

Çınar

ÖH

(2013) Conscientious Objection to Military Service in International Human Rights Law. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

12.

Carter

(1998) Liberalism and the Obligation to Military Service. Political Studies 46 (1): 68–81.

13.

Casey

Vermeule

(2022) Myth of Common Good Constitutionalism. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 45 (1): 103–146.

14.

Chomsky

(2013) What Kind of Creatures Are We? Lecture III: What Is the Common Good? The Journal of Philosophy 110 (12): 685–700.

15.

Cohen

(1968) Conscientious Objection. Ethics 78 (4): 269–279.

16.

Cowen

(2006) Fighting for ‘Freedom’: The End of Conscription in the United States and the Neoliberal Project of Citizenship. Citizenship Studies 10 (2): 167–183.

17.

Dahl

Soss

(2014) Neoliberalism for the Common Good? Public Value Governance and the Downsizing of Democracy. Public Administration Review 74 (4): 496–504.

18.

Dahl

(1989) Democracy and Its Critics. New Haven, CT; London: Yale University Press.

19.

Diggs

(1973) The Common Good as Reason for Political Action. Ethics 83 (4): 283–293.

20.

Douglass

(1980) The Common Good and the Public Interest. Political Theory 8 (1): 103–117.

21.

Downing

Thigpen

(1993) Virtue and the Common Good in Liberal Theory. The Journal of Politics 55 (4): 1046–1059.

22.

Downs

(1962) Public Interest: Its Meaning in a Democracy. Social Research 29 (1): 1–36.

23.

Duke

(2016) The Distinctive Common Good. The Review of Politics 78 (2): 227–250.

24.

Dunn

(1980) Political Obligation in Its Historical Context: Essays in Political Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

25.

Dupré

(1993) The Common Good and the Open Society. The Review of Politics 55 (4): 687–712.

26.

Edmundson

(2010) Political Authority, Moral Powers and the Intrinsic Value of Obedience. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 30 (1): 179–191.

27.

Etzioni

(2014) Communitarianism Revisited. Journal of Political Ideologies 19 (3): 241–260.

28.

Ferencei

(2015) Občianska neposlušnosť a demokracia. Studia Political Slovaca 8 (1): 62–72.

29.

Foran

(2023) Rights, Common Good, and the Separation of Powers. Modern Law Review 86 (3): 599–628.

30.

Francis (2020) Encyclical Letter Fratelli tutti. October 3, 2020. Available at: https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/documents/papa-francesco_20201003_enciclica-fratelli-tutti.html (accessed July 31 2023).

31.

Galston

(2005) The Practice of Liberal Pluralism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

32.

Garrett

(2021) Doomsday Preppers and the Architecture of Dread. Geoforum 127: 401–411.

33.

Gavendová

(2023) Individuálna sloboda a spoločné dobro z pohľadu Jacqua Maritaina. Studia Aloisiana 14 (1): 63–76.

34.

Gluchman

(2023) The Idea of the Common Good in the Young Marx and Nonutilitarian Consequentialism. History of European Ideas 49: 1345–1358.

35.

Gray

(1981) Hayek on Liberty, Rights, and Justice. Ethics 92 (1): 73–84.

36.

Gross

(2008) Is There a Duty to Die for Humanity? Humanitarian Intervention, Military Service and Political Obligation. Public Affairs Quarterly: 22 (3): 213–229.

37.

Gruntová

Jireš

(2023) Obrana země není úkol jen pro vojáky. Možnost mobilizace ze zákonů nezmizela, říká Jireš z obrany, April 9, 2023. Available at: https://www.irozhlas.cz/zpravy-domov/jan-jires-ministerstvo-obrany-mobilizace_2304090600_gut (accessed July 27 2023).

38.

Hanyš

(2016) Občanská neposlušnost v myšlení Hannah Arendtové. Filosofický časopis 64 (1): 59–74.

39.

Hart

HLA

(1993) The Concept of Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

40.

Hayek

(1998) Law, Legislation, and Liberty. London: Routledge.

41.

Honohan

(2017) Liberal and Republican Conceptions of Citizenship. In: Shachar

Bauböck

Bloemraad

al.

(eds) The Oxford Handbook of Citizenship. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.83–106.

42.

Huemer

(2013) The Problem of Political Authority: An Examination of the Right to Coerce and the Duty to Obey. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

43.

Huemer

Layman

(2022) Is Political Authority an Illusion? A Debate. New York: Routledge.

44.

Káčer

(2017) Politika: vôľa k moci či vôľa k spoločnému dobru? Časopis pro právní vědu a praxi 25 (3): 391–402.

45.

Keys

(2006) Aquinas, Aristotle, and the Promise of the Common Good. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

46.

Klosko

(1994) Political Obligation and the Natural Duties of Justice. Philosophy & Public Affairs 23 (3): 251–270.

47.

Klosko

(1998) Fixed Content of Political Obligations. Political Studies 46 (1): 53–67.

48.

Klosko

(2003) Samaritanism and Political Obligation: A Response to Christopher Wellman’s ‘Liberal Theory of Political Obligation’. Ethics 113 (4): 835–840.

49.

Klosko

(2004) Multiple Principles of Political Obligation. Political Theory 32 (6): 801–824.

50.

Klosko

(2011) Are Political Obligations Content Independent? Political Theory 39 (4): 498–523.

51.

Klosko

(2020) Fair Play, Reciprocity, and Natural Duties of Justice. Ratio Juris 33 (4): 335–350.

52.

Klosko

Keren

Nyikos

(2003) Political Obligation and Military Service in Three Countries. Politics, Philosophy & Economics 2 (1): 37–62.

53.

Kollert

(2022) Právo na odpor v kontextu demokratického právního státu. Právník 161 (10): 957–972.

54.

Koniar

(2009) Zdôvodnenie vojny v prácach sv. Augustína. Studia Theologica 11 (4): 15–36.

55.

Kosonen

Puustinen

Tallberg

(2019) Saying No to Military Service – Obligation, Killing and Inequality as Experienced Problems in Conscription-Based Military in Finland. Journal of Military Studies 8: 46–57.

56.

Kozák

(2013) Občanská neposlušnost z perspektivy práva a právní teorie. Právník 152 (4): 361–376.

57.

Krehoff

(2008) Legitimate Political Authority and Sovereignty: Why States Cannot Be the Whole Story. Res Publica 14 (4): 283–297.

58.

Kuna

(2018) Význam princípu subsidiarity pre MacIntyrovu víziu politiky. Filozofia 73 (5): 389–399.

59.

Leipold

(2015) Political Anarchism and Raz’s Theory of Authority. Res Publica 21 (3): 309–329.

60.

Lewis

(2019) Catholic Social Teaching on the Common Good. In: Bradley

Brugger

ECh

(eds) Catholic Social Teaching: A Volume of Scholarly Essays. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.235–266.

61.

Locke

(2003) [1689] Two Treatises of Government and A Letter Concerning Toleration. New Haven, CT; London: Yale University Press.

62.

MacIntyre

(1998) Politics, Philosophy and the Common Good. In: Knight

(ed.) The Macintyre Reader. Notre Dame: The University of Notre Dame Press, pp.235–252.

63.

Maritain

(1948) The Person and the Common Good. London: Geoffrey Bles.

64.

Maritain

(1951) Man and the State. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.

65.

Míčka

(2010) Kdo vlastní klíče k interpretaci sociální nauky církve? Studia Theologica 12 (2): 86–101.

66.

Mills

(2021) Obamageddon: Fear, the Far Right, and the Rise of ‘Doomsday’ Prepping in Obama’s America. Journal of American Studies 55 (2): 336–365.

67.

Mittendorf

(2023) Conspiracy Theories and Democratic Legitimacy. Social Epistemology: A Journal of Knowledge, Culture and Policy 37 (4): 481–493.

68.

Mokrosińska

(2013) What Is Political about Political Obligation? A Neglected Lesson from Consent Theory. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 16 (1): 88–108.

69.

Murphy

(2005) The Common Good. The Review of Metaphysics 59 (1): 133–164.

70.

Nozick

(1974) Anarchy, State, and Utopia. New York: Basic Books.

71.

Paret

(1993) Justifying the Obligation of Military Service. Journal of Military History 57 (5): 115–126.

72.

Pettit

(2004) The Common Good. In: Dowding

Goodin

Pateman

(eds) Justice and Democracy: Essays for Brian Barry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.150–169.

73.

Pettit

(2019) The General Will, the Common Good, and a Democracy of Standards. In: Elazar

Rousselière

(eds) Republicanism and the Future of Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.13–40.

74.

Pinz

(1999) Občanská neposlušnost – Demokratické právo občanské společnosti. Scientific Papers of the University of Pardubice: Series D Faculty of Economics and Administration 4: 272–278.

75.

Pontifical Council of Justice and Peace (2004) Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church. Vatican: Libreria Editrice Vaticana.

76.

Raeder

(1998) Liberalism and the Common Good: A Hayekian Perspective on Communitarianism. The Independent Review 2 (4): 519–535.

77.

Rawls

(1999) A Theory of Justice, Revisited edn. Cambridge: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

78.

Raz

(1994) [1979] The Authority of Law: Essays on Law and Morality. New York: Oxford University Press.

79.

Rogers

(2020) Virtue Ethics and Political Authority. Journal of Social Philosophy 51 (2): 303–321.

80.

Rusch

(2022) Liberalism and the Common Good. New Blackfriars 103 (1105): 359–375.

81.

Sandel

(2013) What Money Can’t Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets. London: Penguin Books.

82.

Sandel

(2021) Tyranny of Merit: What’s Become of the Common Good?. London: Penguin.

83.

Scrandis

(2017) Jacques Maritain on the Rights of Man and the Common Good. The National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly 17 (4): 615–621.

84.

Shklar

(2019) On Political Obligation. New Haven, CT; London: Yale University Press.

85.

Simmons

(2001) Justification and Legitimacy: Essays on Rights and Obligations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

86.

Simon

(1960) Common Good and Common Action. The Review of Politics 22 (2): 202–244.

87.

St. John XXIII (1963) Pacem in terris, April 11, 1963. Available at: https://www.vatican.va/content/john-xxiii/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_j-xxiii_enc_11041963_pacem.html (accessed July 10 2023).

88.

Tosi

(2017) A Fair Play Account of Legitimate Political Authority. Legal Theory 23 (1): 55–67.

89.

Vermeule

(2022) Common Good Constitutionalism: Recovering the Classical Legal Tradition. Cambridge: Polity Press.

90.

Waldron

(1993) Liberal Rights: Collected Papers 1981–1991. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

91.

Walzer

(1970) Obligations: Essays on Disobedience, War, and Citizenship. Cambridge, MA; London: Harvard University Press.

92.

Wojnarowska-Szpucha

(2020) Defense Benefits: One of the Forms of Compliance with the Common Obligation of Defense. In: Soliman

(ed.) Proceedings of the 35th International-Business-Information-Management-Association Conference (IBIMA). Education excellence and innovation management: A 2025 Vision to Sustain Economic Development during Global Challenges. Seville: International Business Information Management Association, pp.14078–14083.

93.

Zürn

(2017) From Constitutional Rule to Loosely Coupled Spheres of Liquid Authority: A Reflexive Approach. International Theory 9 (2): 261–285.