The National Health Service Consultants’ Distinction Award Scheme - History and Personal Critique 1

Consultation Paper. Proposal to establish a Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards. February 1998. Scottish Office, Department of Health.

Professor Brian Abel-Smith. The hospitals 1800–1948: A study in social administration in England & Wales. London: Heinemann, 1964;486.

Report of the Inter-departmental Committee on the Remuneration of Consultants and Specialists, 1948 (Cmd 7420). London:HMSO. (The Spens Report).

Guide to the NHS Consultants Distinction Award Scheme. 1999 Awards Round. NHS Executive, October1998.

Foot M . Aneurin Bevan Vol 2 1945–1960 London:Grenada, 1975.

Guillebaud CW . National Health Service: report of the committee of inquiry into the cost of the National Health Service Cmnd. 9663 Session 1955–56. London:HMSO, 1995.

Lovell J . Churchill's doctor, a biography of Lord Moran London: Royal Society of Medicine Ltd, 1992.

Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General. National Health Service: hospital based medical manpower (Cmd 373), HMSO, May 1985, 15.

Report of the Working Party on the Review of the Consultants Distinction Award Scheme. London: Department of Health, October 1994 (Kendell Report).

Webster C . The health services since the War: problems of health care in the National Health Service before 1957 London: HMSO, 1988.

Pilkington WH Lord . Royal Commission on doctors and dentists remuneration London: HMSO, 1960. Session 1959–60 Cmnd 939 xii.

Bruggen P Bourne S . The Distinction Award System in England and Wales. BMJ 1982; 284:1579–80.

Social Services Committee (Session 1980–81). ‘Medical Education’ Minutes of Evidence, 25 March 1981. London: HMSO, 3526–60.

Centre for Health Economics, University of York. Rewarding excellence? Consultants Distinction Awards and the need for reform Bloor K, Maynard A. Discussion paper 100, September 1992.

Appelby J . Merit Awards attacked by economists. BMJ 1992; 305:863.

Williams B . Distinction Awards. BMJ 1978; 1:860.

Smith R . Medicine's core values. BMJ 1994; 309:1247–8.

Editorial. Dr Goldstein's victory overturned. BMJ 1992; 305:1439.

Editorial. All over in five minutes. BMJ 1986; 293:340.

Esmail E Everington S Doyle H . Racial discrimination in the allocation of Distinction Awards? Analysis of list of Award holders by type of award, specialty and region. BMJ 1998; 316:193–5.

Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards, Annual Report. February 1997, Table6.

General Medical Council, Professional Conduct Committee. Extract of Professional Conduct Committee 5–7 June 1995: Pearce, John Malcolm Frederick. London:General Medical Council, 1995.

General Medical Council, Professional Conduct Committee. Extract of Professional Conduct Committee 16–17 July 1997: Anderton, John Leslie. London:General Medical Council, 1997.

Editorial. Cardiologist admits research misconduct. BMJ 1997; 314:1501.

Dyer C . Wisheart begins to give evidence at GMC. BMJ 1998; 316:646.