Philosophy of education and the history of educational thought

Abstract

Scholars in philosophy of education who discuss the history of educational thought, by which I mean thought about education in the history of philosophy and/or the history of social science, continue to miss a vital opportunity. Their work, more often than it has in recent decades, should do what many essays in fields like ancient philosophy and modern philosophy have traditionally done in examining the past: pick out counterintuitive parts of it and try to show that they are more defensible than they seem. Among other reasons, facing pushback from historical figures is an important way to prevent or offset the effects of group polarization, as democratic theorists have called it. The danger that this sort of polarization poses for philosophers of education today is that, on a range of issues, since they all agree with one another and encounter no opposition, they will lose the true beliefs they already have.

Keywords

philosophy of education history of philosophy history of social science philosophy of the history of philosophy Michael Della Rocca monism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam

Tannery

(eds) (1902) Oeuvres De Descartes (“Discours de la méthode” et essais). Vol. 6. Léopold Cerf.

Ahlstrom-Vij

(2013) Epistemic Paternalism: A Defence. Palgrave Macmillan.

Aikin

Casey

(2022) Argumentation and the problem of agreement. Synthese 200(1): 1–23.

Boote

(2002) Durkheim’s naturalistic moral education: Pluralism, social change, and autonomy. Philosophy of Education 58: 319–327.

Brennan

(2016) Against Democracy. Princeton University Press.

Burnyeat

(2001) Plato. Proceedings of the British Academy 111: 1–22.

Cladis

(1998) Emile Durkheim and moral education in a pluralistic society. In: Walford

Pickering

WSF

(eds) Durkheim and Modern Education. Routledge, pp.18–29.

Cottingham

(2005) Why should analytic philosophers do history of philosophy? In: Sorell

Rogers

GAJ

(eds) Analytic Philosophy and History of Philosophy. Clarendon Press, pp.25–41.

Cottingham

Stoothoff

Murdoch

, et al. (1985) The Philosophical Writings of Descartes. Vol. 1. Cambridge University Press.

10.

Dahl

(1989) Democracy and Its Critics. Yale University Press.

11.

Dahlbeck

(2021) Spinoza: Fiction and Manipulation in Civic Education. Springer.

12.

Dahlbeck

(2024) Educating the Ingenium: On Spinoza’s perfectionism and the pedagogical relation. Theory and Research in Education 22(3): 272–286.

13.

Declos

Grandjean

(2025) Mereological anti-conservatism. Acta Analytica 40(4): 659–676.

14.

Della Rocca

(2020a) The Parmenidean Ascent. Oxford University Press.

15.

Della Rocca

(2020b) Thinking with parmenides. The Philosopher 108(4): 76–82.

16.

Dishon

(2016) Fulfilling the Rousseauian fantasy: Video games and well-regulated freedom. Philosophy of Education 72: 113–121.

17.

Estlund

(2008 [2003]) Why not an epistocracy of the educated? In: Estlund

(ed.) Democratic Authority: A Philosophical Framework. Princeton University Press, pp.206–222.

18.

Fantuzzo

(2015) A course between bureaucracy and charisma: A pedagogical reading of Max Weber’s social theory. Journal of Philosophy of Education 49(1): 45–64.

19.

Frances

(2021) Philosophical proofs against common sense. Analysis 81(1): 18–26.

20.

Garber

(2001 [1989]) Does history have a future? Some reflections on Bennett and doing philosophy historically. In: Garber

(ed.) Descartes Embodied. Cambridge University Press, pp.13–30.

21.

Goodpaster

(1978) On being morally considerable. Journal of Philosophy 75(6): 308–325.

22.

Grande

(2015) Red Pedagogy: Native American Social and Political Thought. Rowman and Littlefield.

23.

Iversen

(2024) Norm critique and the dialectics of Hegelian recognition. Journal of Philosophy of Education 58(6): 869–894.

24.

Jessop

(2012) Education for citizenship and “ethical life”: An exploration of the Hegelian concepts of Bildung and Sittlichkeit. Journal of Philosophy of Education 46(2): 287–302.

25.

Jonas

Nakazawa

(2020) A Platonic Theory of Moral Education: Cultivating Virtue in Contemporary Democratic Classrooms. Routledge.

26.

Jonas

Yacek

(2018) Nietzsche’s Philosophy of Education: Rethinking Ethics, Equality and the Good Life in a Democratic Age. Routledge.

27.

Kaufmann

(1974) Nietzsche: Philosopher, Psychologist, Antichrist. 4th ed. Princeton University Press.

28.

Kaufmann

(trans) (1966 [1954]) The Portable Nietzsche. Penguin.

29.

Kotsonis

(2023) Plato’s legacy to education: Addressing two misunderstandings. Journal of Philosophy of Education 57(3): 739–747.

30.

Kristjánsson

(2015) Aristotelian Character Education. Routledge.

31.

Ladyman

Ross

(2007) Every Thing Must Go: Metaphysics Naturalized. Oxford University Press.

32.

Lee

George

(2008) Body-self Dualism in Contemporary Ethics and Politics. Cambridge University Press.

33.

Lyotard

J-F

(1997) Marie goes to Japan. In: Van Den Abbeele

(trans.) Postmodern Fables. University of Minnesota Press, pp.3–15.

34.

Mintz

(2016) The use and abuse of the history of educational philosophy. Philosophy of Education 72: 406–413.

35.

Mintz

(2019) Plato: Images, Aims, and Practices of Education. Springer.

36.

Nadler

(2020) Think Least of Death: Spinoza on How to Live and How to Die. Princeton University Press.

37.

Nietzsche

(1922) Gesammelte Werke. Vol. 6. Musarion Verlag.

38.

Richardson

(2012) Disrupting the coloniality of being: Toward de-colonial ontologies in philosophy of education. Studies in Philosophy and Education 31(6): 539–551.

39.

Rinard

(2013) Why philosophy can overturn common sense. Oxford Studies in Epistemology 4: 185–213.

40.

Rosenow

(2000) Nietzsche’s educational legacy: Reflections on interpretations of a controversial philosopher. Journal of Philosophy of Education 34(4): 673–685.

41.

Roth

(2024) Spinoza on blessedness for human beings: Possible for a few, but not for the whole human species. Theory and Research in Education 22(3): 287–302.

42.

Sanderse

(2020) Does Aristotle believe that habituation is only for children? Journal of Moral Education 49(1): 98–110.

43.

Schwitzgebel

(2024) The Weirdness of the World. Princeton University Press.

44.

Sider

(2013) Against parthood. Oxford Studies in Metaphysics 8: 237–293.

45.

Singer

(1974) Sidgwick and reflective equilibrium. Monist 58(3): 490–517.

46.

Singer

(1975) Animal Liberation. HarperCollins.

47.

Sorabji

(2007) Ideas leap barriers: The value of historical studies to philosophy. In: Scott

(ed.) Maieusis: Essays in Ancient Philosophy in Honour of Myles Burnyeat. Oxford University Press, pp.374–425.

48.

Stroessner

Beckerman

Whittaker

(2009) All the world’s a stage? Consequences of a role-playing pedagogy on psychological factors and writing and rhetorical skill in college undergraduates. Journal of Educational Psychology 101(3): 605–620.

49.

Sunstein

(2017) #Republic: Divided Democracy in the Age of Social Media. Princeton University Press.

50.

Talisse

(2019) Overdoing Democracy: Why We Must Put Politics in Its Place. Oxford University Press.

51.

Tröhler

(2012) Rousseau’s Emile, or the fear of passion. Studies in Philosophy of Education 31(5): 477–489.

52.

Weiler Gur Arye

(2022) Rousseau and Emile: Learning language and teaching language. Journal of Philosophy of Education 56(6): 925–938.

53.

Weinberg

Gonnerman

Buckner

, et al. (2010) Are philosophers expert intuiters? Philosophical Psychology 23(3): 331–355.

54.

Williams

(2006 [1994]) Descartes and the historiography of philosophy. In: Williams

(ed.) The Sense of the Past: Essays in the History of Philosophy. Princeton University Press, pp.257–264.

55.

Yacek

(2023) Nietzsche and moral education. In: Yacek

Jonas

Gary

(eds) Moral Education in the 21st Century. Cambridge University Press, pp.69–93.

56.

Youpa

(2020) The Ethics of Joy: Spinoza on the Empowered Life. Oxford University Press.

57.

Zinkin

(2021) Kant on wonder as the motive to learn. Journal of Philosophy of Education 55(6): 921–934.