Luck egalitarianism about educational justice requires, roughly, that educational policy be arranged so as to minimize unchosen inequality in how well lives go. Luck egalitarianism famously faces the objection that it is an implausibly overdemanding theory of educational justice—especially when it is applied to educators in non-ideal conditions like our own, who are tasked with educating in social circumstances that are marred by the effects of pervasive background and historical injustices. I show that luck egalitarianism can be rescued from that overdemandingness objection. I effect that rescue by showing, first, the importance of distinguishing between the ideal-theoretic and non-ideal-theoretic parts of a normative principle like luck egalitarianism and showing then that, having made that distinction, there is a version of luck egalitarianism whose non-ideal-theoretic part does not entail implausibly overdemanding requirements for educators in non-ideal conditions. I also show that my discussion suggests useful directions and resources for further work in non-ideal theorizing about luck egalitarianism and other theories of educational justice.
AndersonE (2007) Fair opportunity in education: A democratic equality perspective. Ethics117(4): 595–622.
2.
ArnesonR (1989) Equality and equal opportunity for welfare. Philosophical Studies56(1): 77–93.
3.
AziziFDe Francisci MoralesGMejovaY, et al. (2021) On the interplay between educational attainment and nutrition: A spatially-aware perspective. EPJ Data Science10: 18.
BrighouseH (2015) Non-ideal theorizing in education. Educational Theory65(2): 215–231.
7.
BrighouseHLaddHFLoebS, et al. (2018) Educational Goods: Values, Evidence, and Decisionmaking. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
8.
CarrollT (2007) The high cost of teacher turnover (policy brief). National Commission on Teaching and America’s Future. Available at: https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED498001 (accessed June 2025).
9.
CohenGA (1989) On the currency of egalitarian justice. Ethics99(4): 906–944.
10.
CohenGA (2000) If you’re an egalitarian, how come you’re so rich. The Journal of Ethics4: 1–26.
11.
CohenGA (2008) Rescuing Justice and Equality. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
12.
CohenGA (2009) Why not Socialism?Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
13.
DuncanGMurnaneR (2011) Whither Opportunity? Rising Inequality, Schools, and Children’s Life Chances. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
14.
EnglandPBudigMFolbreN (2002) Wages of virtue: The relative pay of care work. Social Problems49(4): 455–473.
15.
GausG (2016) The Tyranny of the Ideal: Justice in a Diverse Society. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
16.
GhanemN (2021) The effect of violence in childhood on school success factors in US children. Child Abuse & Neglect120: 105217.
17.
GlazerN (1980) The effects of poor housing. In: HartmanC (ed.) Housing Urban America, pp. 187–198. New York: Routledge.
18.
Goldrick-RabS (2017) Paying the Price: College Costs, Financial Aid, and the Betrayal of the American Dream. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
19.
Harel Ben-ShaharT (2016) Equality in education—why we must go all the way. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice19(1): 83–100.
20.
HaslangerS (2017) Culture and critique. Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume91(1): 149–173.
21.
HaslangerS (2021) Political epistemology and social critique. In: SobelDVallentynePWallS (eds) Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy, vol. 7, pp. 23–65. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
22.
HemeltSLaddHCliftonC (2021) Do teacher assistants improve student outcomes? Evidence from school funding cutbacks in North Carolina. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis43(2): 280–304.
23.
HopsonLLidbeAJacksonM, et al. (2022) Transportation to school and academic outcomes: A systematic review. Educational Review76(3): 648–668.
24.
JencksC (1988) Whom must we treat equally for educational opportunity to be equal?Ethics98(3): 518–533.
KarneinA (2014) Putting fairness in its place: Why there is a duty to take up the slack. Journal of Philosophy111(11): 593–607.
27.
KelleherJP (2016) Health inequalities and relational egalitarianism. In: WalkerRBuchbinderMRivkin-FishM (eds) Understanding Health Inequalities and Justice: Bridging Perspectives for New Conversations, pp. 88–111. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
28.
KolbeTDhueyEDoutreS (2022) More money is not enough: (Re)considering policy proposals to increase federal funding for special education. American Journal of Education129(1): 721846.
29.
LazenbyH (2016) What is equality of opportunity in education?Theory and Research in Education14(1): 65–76.
30.
LevinsonM (2015) The ethics of pandering in Boston Public Schools’ school assignment plan. Theory and Research in Education13(1): 38–55.
31.
LevinsonM (2022) Merit, wealth, and the ethics of college admissions. In: CahnS (ed.) Academic Ethics Today: Problems, Policies, and Prospects for University Life, pp. 199–208. London: Rowman & Littlefield.
MillerD (2011) Taking up the slack? Responsibility and justice in situations of partial compliance. In: KnightCStemplowskaZ (eds) Responsibility and Distributive Justice, pp. 216–229. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
MillsC (2017) Black Rights/White Wrongs: The Critique of Racial Liberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
35.
MurphyL (1993) The demands of beneficence. Philosophy and Public Affairs22(4): 267–292.
36.
O’BrienD (2019) The unit and currency of egalitarian concern. Journal of Moral Philosophy16(5): 613–643.
37.
RawlsJ (1999) A Theory of Justice (Revised Edition). Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
38.
RobeynsI (2008) Ideal theory in theory and practice. Social Theory and Practice34(3): 341–362.
39.
SatzD (2007) Equality, adequacy, and education for citizenship. Ethics117(4): 623–648.
40.
SchoutenG (2012) Fair educational opportunity and the distribution of natural ability: Toward a prioritarian principle of educational justice. Journal of Philosophy of Education46(3): 472–491.
41.
SchoutenG (2023) Equal educational opportunity: What should it mean? In: CurrenR (ed.) Handbook of Philosophy of Education, 1st edn, pp. 187–198. New York: Taylor & Francis.
42.
SchoutenG (2024) The Anatomy of Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43.
SegallS (2007) In solidarity with the imprudent: A defense of luck egalitarianism. Social Theory and Practice33(2): 177–198.
44.
SegallS (2016) Why Inequality Matters: Luck Egalitarianism, Its Meaning and Value. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
45.
SenA (2011) The Idea of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
46.
SingerP (1972) Famine, affluence, and morality. Philosophy and Public Affairs1(3): 229–243.
47.
SouthgateL (2024) Rethinking anonymous grading. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice27(2): 237–251.
48.
StarkC (2013) Luck, opportunity, and disability. Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy16(3): 383–402.
49.
SwiftA (2008) The value of philosophy in nonideal circumstances. Social Theory and Practice34(3): 363–387.
50.
TanKC (2012) Justice, Institutions, and Luck: The Site, Ground, and Scope of Equality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
