Challenging Deliberation

Abstract

Civic education is a primary aim of public schooling in liberal democratic states, which rely on a well-educated, civic-minded citizenry for their perpetuation. Because liberal democracies can differ, it is important to decide for what kind of democracy schools should be educating. Recently, deliberative democracy has come into vogue as a political - and hence civic educational - goal. Because of differences in perspectives as a result of life experiences, however, racial, ethnic, economic, and/or religious minorities are disadvantaged in deliberative settings. Even if they fully participate, and even if all citizens welcome their participation, minority group members are unlikely to be able to influence debate appropriately. Furthermore, the steps that teachers or schools might take to overcome this problem in the future themselves impose serious costs on children, especially those who grow up in segregated minority communities. These costs may outweigh deliberative democracy's putative benefits over adversarial democracy.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bushnell, H. (1971) `Common schools: a discourse on the modifications demanded by the Roman Catholics', in R. Welter (ed.) American Writings on Popular Education, the Nineteenth Century. New York: The Bobbs-Merrill Company Inc.

Delpit, L. (1995) Other People's Children. New York: The New Press .

Guinan, M.E. (1993) `Black communities' belief in “AIDS as genocide”. A barrier to overcome for HIV prevention' . Annals of Epidemiology 3(2): 193-195 .

Gutmann, A. and Thompson, D. (1996) Democracy and Disagreement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .

Levinson, M. (1999) The Demands of Liberal Education. Oxford: Oxford University Press .

Mansbridge, J. (1980) Beyond Adversary Democracy. New York: Basic Books .

Miller, D. (2000) Citizenship and National Identity. Oxford: Polity Press .

Orfield, G., Eaton, S.E. and The Harvard Project on School Desegregation (1996) Dismantling Desegregation: The Quiet Reversal of Brown v. Board of Education. New York: The New Press .

Orfield, G. and Yun, J.T. (1999) `Resegregation in American schools', June. Available at http://www.law.harvard.edu/groups/civilrights/publications/resegregation99.html

10.

Siegel, K., Karus, D. and Schrimshaw, E.W. (2000) `Racial differences in attitudes toward protease inhibitors among older HIV-infected men' . AIDS Care 12(4): 423-434 .

11.

Smith, R.C. and Seltzer, R. (2000) Contemporary Controversies and the American Racial Divide. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield .

12.

Tatum, B.D. (1997) Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria? New York: Basic Books .

13.

Thomas, S.B. and Quinn, S.C. (1991) `The Tuskegee Syphilis Study, 1932 to 1972: implications for HIV education and AIDS risk programs in the black community' . American Journal of Public Health 81(11): 1498-1505 .

14.

Wright, M.A. (1998) I'm Chocolate: You're Vanilla: Raising Healthy Black and Biracial Children in a Race-Conscious World. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .