Criminalizing unintentional mistakes in medicine as the offence of gross negligence manslaughter has always been a contentious issue. The threshold of prosecution is not well-defined, and even less clear when faced with a situation in which an intern doctor is held liable. This commentary attempts to review the current legal position of holding an intern doctor liable for gross negligence medical manslaughter.
WongBHeungS.Hong Kong’s justice department drops manslaughter case against 2 doctors linked to liver patient’s death, says charges fell short of prosecution standards. South China Morning Post. 2023.
2.
LauC.What the arrests of 2 Hong Kong doctors over a medical blunder mean for city’s patients and the healthcare system. South China Morning Post. 2013.
3.
HKSAR v Harry Sudirman CACC 486/2003; HKSAR v Chow Heung-Wing, Stephen and 2 others HCCC 437/2015.
4.
CheungE.Hong Kong patient’s death sparks call for better supervision of intern doctors. South China Morning Post. 2017.
5.
Rex v Williamson; 1807 [8 C&P 635].
6.
WheelerRWheelerR. Medical manslaughter: resolving circularity. J Pediatr Surg2019; 54: 239–243.
7.
R v Bateman; 1927 [19 Cr. App. R.8].
8.
Andrews [1937] AC 576 at 583.
9.
Stone and Dobinson [1977] QB 354.
10.
R v Lawrence (Stephen) [1982] AC 510.
11.
R v Adomako [1994] UKHL 6.
12.
MullockA. Gross negligence (medical) manslaughter and the puzzling implications of negligent ignorance: rose v R [2017] EWCA crim 1168. Med Law Rev2018; 26: 346–456.
SamantaASamantaJ. Gross negligence manslaughter and doctors: ethical concerns following the case of Dr Bawa-Garba. J Med Ethics2019; 45: 10–14.
20.
Rush v Akron General Hospital, 71 NE2d 378 (Ohio Ct App 1957).
21.
Jenkins v Clark, 454 NE2d 541 (Ohio Ct App 1982).
22.
Centman v Cobb, 581 NE2d 1286 (Ind Ct App 1991).
23.
Mercil v Mathers; No C3-93-140, 1994 WL 1114 (Minn Ct App Jan 4, 1994), rev’d on other grounds, 517 NW2d 328 (Minn 1994).
24.
Phelps v Physicians Ins Co of Wis, 681 NW2d 571, 582 (Wisc Ct App 2004), rev’d on other grounds, 698 NW2d 643.
25.
WegmanBStannardJPBalBS. Medical liability of the physician in training. Clin Orthop2012; 470: 1379–1385.
26.
LeungGK. Medical manslaughter in Hong Kong-how, why, and why not. Hong Kong Med J Xianggang Yi Xue Za Zhi2018; 24: 384–390.
27.
AdejumoOAAdejumoOA. Legal perspectives on liability for medical negligence and malpractices in Nigeria. Pan Afr Med J2020; 35: 44.
28.
Cassidy v Ministry of Health [1951] 2 KB 343.
29.
SchneiderA. Corporate Liability for Manslaughter – A comparison between English and German Law [Internet]. Zeitschrift für Internationale Strafrechtsdogmatik; Available from: www.zis-online.com.
