Providing in-utero treatments to target specific conditions in the fetus is a relatively new approach in perinatal care, with the vast majority of these treatments being used off-label. The high degree of off-label medication use in the perinatal and neonatal settings raises concern for the safety of both the fetuses and expectant mothers.
This report presents two examples of intra-amniotic drug administration based on reported clinical cases. From the ethical framework of medical principlism, we examine the competing ethical duties of autonomy, beneficence, and non-maleficence in this setting. We then lay out three fundamental ethical principles for obtaining informed consent and maximizing clinical benefit.
AllenHCGarbeMCLeesJ, et al.Off-label medication use in children, more common than we think: a systematic review of the literature. J Okla State Med Assoc2018; 111: 776–783.
2.
AdashiEYWaltersLBMenikoffJA. The Belmont report at 40: reckoning with time. Am J Public Health2018; 108: 1345–1348.
GoreRChughPKTripathiCD, et al.Pediatric off-label and unlicensed drug use and its implications. Curr Clin Pharmacol2017; 12: 18–25.
5.
MachadoCMCastroJMCamposRA, et al.Graves’ disease complicated by fetal goitrous hypothyroidism treated with intra-amniotic administration of levothyroxine. BMJ Case Rep2019; 12: e230457.
6.
MiaoYXuYTengP, et al.Efficacy of propylthiouracil in the treatment of pregnancy with hyperthyroidism and its effect on pregnancy outcomes: a meta-analysis. PLoS One2022; 17: e0265085.
MastroliaSAMandolaAMazorM, et al.Antenatal diagnosis and treatment of hypothyroid fetal goiter in an euthyroid mother: a case report and review of literature. J Matern Fetal Med2015; 28: 2214–2220.
9.
Corbacioglu EsmerAGulADagdevirenH, et al.Intrauterine diagnosis and treatment of fetal goitrous hypothyroidism. J Obstet Gynaecol Res2013; 39: 720–723.
10.
AbuhamadAFisherDWarsoffS, et al.Antenatal diagnosis and treatment of fetal goitrous hypothyroidism: case report and review of the literature. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol1995; 6: 368–371.
11.
FerianecVPapcunPGrochalF, et al.Prenatal diagnosis and successful intrauterine treatment of severe congenital hypothyroidism associated with fetal goiter. J Obstet and Gynaecol Res2017; 43: 232–237.
12.
López Ramón y CajalCCouceiro NaveiraEPiñón MosqueraA, et al.Treatment of fetal supraventricular tachycardia by intra-amniotic administration of digoxin. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol2019; 54: 698–699.
13.
BulgerRJBarbatoAL. On the hippocratic sources of western medical practice. Hastings Cent Rep2000; 30: S4–S7.
14.
BeauchampTLChildressJF. Principles of biomedical ethics. 8th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019.
15.
O’BrienDC. Medical ethics as taught and as practiced: principlism, narrative ethics, and the case of living donor liver transplantation. J Med Phil2022; 47: 95–116.
16.
MillikenABSadovnikoffN. Clinical ethics and ethical principles. In: MichalsenASadovnikoffNKeseciogluJ (eds) Ethics in intensive care medicine. Lessons from the ICU. Cham: Springer, 2023, pp.6–10.16.
17.
DaleS. A critique of principlism: virtue and the adjudication problem in bioethics. Voices Bioethics2023; 9: 1–5.
TruogRD. Expanding the horizon of our obligations in the clinician-patient relationship. Hastings Cent Rep2017; 47: 40–41.
20.
MillerRK. Fetal drug therapy: principles and issues. Clin Obstetr Gynecol1991; 34: 241–250.
21.
ZhangZImperialMZPatilea-VranaGI, et al.Development of a novel maternal-fetal physiologically based pharmacokinetic model I: insights into factors that determine fetal drug exposure through simulations and sensitivity analyses. Drug Metab Dispos2017; 45: 920–938.
22.
UtamaDPCrowtherCA. Transplacental versus direct fetal corticosteroid treatment for accelerating fetal lung maturation where there is a risk of preterm birth. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2018; 6: CD008981.
23.
FeghaliMVenkataramananRCaritisS. Pharmacokinetics of drugs in pregnancy. Semin Perinatol2015; 39: 512–519.
24.
MilesSH. The Hippocratic Oath and the ethics of medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005.
25.
BrodyHDoukasD. Professionalism: a framework to guide medical education. Med Educ2014; 48: 980–987.
26.
DeAngelisCD. Medical professionalism in the twenty-first century. In: DeAngelisCD (eds) Patient care and professionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013, pp.61–76.
27.
SullivanDMAndersonDCColeJW. Ethics in pharmacy practice: a practical guide. Cham: Springer Nature, 2021.
28.
JonsenARSieglerMWinsladeWJ. Clinical ethics: a practical approach to ethical decisions in clinical medicine. 8th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Education, 2015.
29.
LewisJ. Respect for autonomy: consent doesn’t cut it. Clin Ethics2023; 18: 139–141.
30.
Menut-RuelABarthodMGauchezAS, et al.Fetal hypothyroidism induced by maternal anti-TSH receptor blocking antibodies and complicated by polyhydramnios despite the absence of goiter. Treatment by intra-amniotic injections of levothyroxine. Ann Endocrinol2017; 78: 61–64.
31.
HamamotoKIwamotoHSRomanCM, et al.Fetal uptake of intraamniotic digoxin in sheep. Pediatr Res1990; 27: 282–285.
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, Committee on Ethics; American Academy of Pediatrics, Committee on Bioethics. Maternal-fetal intervention and fetal care centers. Pediatr2011; 129: e473–e478.
34.
DickensBMCookRJ. Legal and ethical issues in fetal surgery. Int J Gynecol Obstet2011; 115: 80–83.
35.
ElwynGLaitnerSCoulterA, et al.Implementing shared decision making in the NHS. Br Med J2010; 341: c5146.
