Although COVID-19 vaccines are free and readily available in the United States, many healthcare workers remain unvaccinated, potentially exposing their patients to a life-threatening pathogen. This paper reviews the ethical and legal factors surrounding patient requests to limit their care teams exclusively to vaccinated providers. Key factors that shape policy in this area include patient autonomy, the rights of healthcare workers, and the duties of healthcare institutions. Hospitals must also balance the rights of interested parties in the context of logistical constraints, equity, and public health considerations.
AhmedRWilliamsonMHamidMA, et al.United States County-level COVID-19 death rates and case fatality rates vary by region and urban Status. Healthcare2020; 8: 330.
2.
OlliaroPTorreeleEVaillantM. COVID-19 vaccine efficacy and effectiveness-the elephant (not) in the room. Lancet Microbe2021 Jul; 2: e279–e280.
3.
GuarinoBChaAEWoodW, et al.'The weapon that will end the war': First coronavirus vaccine shots given outside trials in U.S. The Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/12/14/first-covid-vaccines-new-york/ (14 December 2020, accessed 24 January 2022).
4.
PeltzJHillM. NYC Orders City Health Workers to Get Vaccinated or Tested. USNews https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/new-york/articles/2021-07-21/vaccinations-or-testing-mandated-for-nyc-health-care-workers (21 June 2021, accessed 26 July 2021).
5.
GoodmanBMillerA. Huge Number of Hospital Workers Still Unvaccinated. WebMD https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/covid-19-vaccine/news/20210628/huge-number-of-hospital-workers (28 June 2021, accessed 26 July 2021).
6.
KirzingerAKearneyAHamelL, et al.KFF/The Washington Post Frontline Health Care Workers. Report, The Washington Post/KFF Survey Project. https://files.kff.org/attachment/Frontline%20Health%20Care%20Workers_Full%20Report_FINAL.pdf (March 2021, accessed 27 July 2021).
7.
HamelLLopesLKearneyA, et al.KFF Covid-19 Vaccine Monitor: June 2021. KFF https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/poll-finding/kff-covid-19-vaccine-monitor-june-2021/ (30 June 2021, accessed 27 July 2021).
8.
KaplanS. A judge dismisses houston hospital workers’ lawsuit about vaccine mandates. New York Times13 June 2021.
9.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. FDA Approves First Covid-19 Vaccine, https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-approves-first-covid-19-vaccine (August 23, 2021, accessed 8 November 2021).
10.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Emergency Use Authorization for Vaccines Explained, https://www.fda.gov/vaccines-blood-biologics/vaccines/emergency-use-authorization-vaccines-explained (November 20, 2020, accessed 8 November 2021).
11.
HarrisJ. Consent and End of life decisions. J Med Ethics2003; 29: 10–15.
12.
LantosJMatlockAMWendlerD. Clinician integrity and limits to patient autonomy. JAMA2011; 305: 495–499.
13.
AppelJM. Smoke and mirrors: one case for ethical obligations of the physician as public role model. Camb Q Healthc Ethics2009; 18: 95–100.
14.
KimaniPE. Patient racial preferences and the medical culture of accommodation. UCLA L. Rev. 4622012; 60: 463–504.
15.
MassachusettsJv. 197 U.S. 11. 1905.
16.
MuhlCJ. The employment-At-will doctrine: three Major exceptions. Monthly Labor Review2001: 3–11.
17.
FieldRI. Mandatory vaccination of healthcare workers: whose rights should come first?P T2009; 34: 615–618.
18.
HermannDHJSorYS. Property rights in one's Job: the case for limiting employment-at-will. Ariz Law Rev1982; 24: 766.
19.
WallisPL. The protection of job security: the case for property rights in one’s job. Otago Law Rev1992; 7: 640.
20.
U.S. Equal Opportunity Employment Commission. What You should know about COVID-19 and the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act, and Other EEO Laws, https://www.eeoc.gov/wysk/what-you-should-know-about-covid-19-and-ada-rehabilitation-act-and-other-eeo-laws (28 June 2021, accessed July 26 2021).
21.
American Nurses Association. Code of Ethics with Interpretive Statements. MD: Silver Spring, 2015.
22.
AnthesE. Medical groups call for mandatory vaccination of U.S. health care workers. The New York Times, 26 July 2021.
23.
NYCRR Title 10 Section 405.7(c)(3) (2019)
24.
DaganNBardaNKeptenE, et al.BNT162b2 mRNA COVID-19 vaccine in a nationwide mass vaccination setting. N Eng J Med2021; 384: 1412–1423.
25.
EyreDWTaylorDPurverM, et al.The impact of SARS-CoV-2 vaccination on Alpha & Delta variant transmission. medRxiv Preprint 15 October 2021. https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.09.28.21264260.
26.
ShahASVGribbenCHanslonP, et al.Effect of vaccination on transmission of SARS-Cov-2. N Eng J Med2021; 385: 1718–1720.
27.
BravemanPGruskinS. Defining equity in health. J Epidemiol Community Health2003; 57: 254–258.
28.
WhiteheadM. The concepts and principles of equity in health. Int J Health Serv1992; 22: 429–445.
29.
GrumbachKJudsonTDesaiM, et al.Association of race/ethnicity With likeliness of COVID-19 vaccine uptake Among health workers and the general population in the San Francisco Bay area. JAMA Intern Med2021; 181: 1008–1011.
30.
AppelJM. When scarcity meets disparity: “resources allocation and COVID-19 patients with diabetes”. J Diabetes Sci Technol2021: 1–5.
31.
Cleveland ManchandaECSankyCAppelJM. Crisis standards of care in the USA: a systematic review and implications for equity amidst COVID-19. J Racial Ethn Health Disparities2021 Aug; 8: 824–836.
32.
Coronavirus in the U.S.: Latest Map and Case Count. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/us/covid-cases.html (2021 August; accessed 30 July 2021).
33.
New York Codes, Rules and Regulations. Title: Section 405.7 - Patients’ rights, https://regs.health.ny.gov/content/section-4057-patients-rights (13 November 2019, accessed 3 August 2021).
