This article raises serious ethical concerns regarding the medical discourse on obesity. It offers a description of three alternate positions on the fat body: the scientific approach dominant within medicine, the critical view mainly raised by social scientists, and the voices of fat people themselves. By viewing and comparing the perspectives these positions reveal, it is possible to underline the complexity of the problem labeled as the “obesity epidemic” and draw attention to serious ethical concerns in the mainstream medical discussion. Medicalization of fat people narrows the focus on the “obesity epidemic” where it is framed as private and personal rather than social and political. It is also argued that the hegemonic discourse of medicine omits the social embeddedness of fat people and ignores their own voices and narratives. This undermines the well-being of fat people and hides their humanity as well.
DietzWHBlandMGGortmakerSL, et al.
Policy tools for the childhood obesity epidemic. J Law Med Ethics2002;
30: 83–87.
2.
LauDCDouketisJDMorrisonKM, et al.
2006 Canadian clinical practice guidelines on the management and prevention of obesity in adults and children [summary]. CMAJ2007;
176: S1–S13.
3.
RalstonJBrinsdenHBuseK, et al.
Time for a new obesity narrative. Lancet2018;
392: 1384–1386.
4.
KuczmarskiRJFlegalKM.Criteria for definition of overweight in transition: background and recommendations for the United States. Am J Clin Nutr2000;
72: 1074–1081.
5.
CaballeroB.The global epidemic of obesity: an overview. Epidemiol Rev2007;
29: 1–5.
BrauerPGorberSCShawE, et al.
Recommendations for prevention of weight gain and use of behavioural and pharmacologic interventions to manage overweight and obesity in adults in primary care. CMAJ2015;
187: 184–195.
8.
PattersonMJohnstonJ.Theorizing the obesity epidemic: health crisis, moral panic and emerging hybrids. Soc Theory Health2012;
10: 265–291.
9.
RothblumED.Why a journal on fat studies?Fat Studies2012;
1: 3–5.
10.
DietzWHBenkenDEHunterAS.Public health law and the prevention and control of obesity. Milbank Q2009;
87: 215–227.
11.
NoëlPHPughJA.Management of overweight and obese adults. BMJ2002;
325: 757–761.
12.
WilliamsEPMesidorMWintersK, et al.
Overweight and obesity: prevalence, consequences, and causes of a growing public health problem. Curr Obes Rep2015;
4: 363–370.
13.
World Health Organization. Obesity: Preventing and managing the global epidemic; report of a WHO consultation. Report no. 9241208945. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1999.
14.
AllisonDBDowneyMAtkinsonRL, et al.
Obesity as a disease: a white paper on evidence and arguments commissioned by the council of the obesity society. Obesity2008;
16: 1161–1177.
15.
GardMWrightJ.The Obesity Epidemic: Science, Morality and Ideology.
New York:
Routledge, 2005.
16.
CamposPSaguyAErnsbergerP, et al.
The epidemiology of overweight and obesity: public health crisis or moral panic?Int J Epidemiol2006;
35: 55–60.
17.
NichollsSG.Standards and classification: a perspective on the ‘obesity epidemic’. Soc Sci Med2013;
87: 9–15.
18.
In this discussion I use the pronoun she for the patient and he for the doctor. This is to draw attention to the need for the discussion on the fat body to be relational and gendered, see for example Warin et al.67
19.
MaziakWWardKStocktonM.Childhood obesity: are we missing the big picture?Obes Rev2008;
9: 35–42.
20.
HeshkaSAllisonDB.Is obesity a disease?Int J Obes2001;
25: 1401–1404.
21.
PellegrinoE.The goals and ends of medicine: how are they to be defined. In: Mark J Hanson and Daniel Callahan (eds) The Goals of Medicine: The Forgotten Issues in Health Care Reform.
Washington, DC:
Georgetown University Press, 1999, pp. 55–68.
22.
Britannica World Language Dictionary: “patient: ...1. A person undergoing treatment for disease or injury. 2. Anything passively affected; the object of external impressions or actions: opposed to agent … [<OF pacient <L patiens.-entis, ppr. of patiri suffer].”
23.
WechslerJGLeopoldK.Medical management of obesity. Langenbecks Arch Surg2003;
388: 369–374.
24.
Have MBeaufortIDd, Teixeira PJ,, et al.
Ethics and prevention of overweight and obesity: an inventory. Obes Rev2011;
12: 669–679.
25.
Abarca-GómezLAbdeenZAHamidZA, et al. Worldwide trends in body-mass index, underweight, overweight, and obesity from 1975 to 2016: a pooled analysis of 2416 population-based measurement studies in 128,9 million children, adolescents, and adults. Lancet. 390: 2627–2642.
BaconLSternJSLoanMDV, et al.
Size acceptance and intuitive eating improve health for obese, female chronic dieters. J Am Diet Assoc2005;
105: 929–936.
28.
AbramsonE.On the futility of dieting. MedGenMed2005;
7: 31.
29.
SjöströmL.Review of the key results from the Swedish Obese Subjects (SOS) trial – a prospective controlled intervention study of bariatric surgery.J Intern Med2012;
273: 219–234.
30.
WooleyCGarnerDM.Controversies in management: dietary treatments for obesity are ineffective. BMJ1994;
309: 655–656.
31.
KatanMB.Weight-loss diets for the prevention and treatment of obesity. N Engl J Med2009;
360: 923–925.
32.
KleinertSHortonR.Rethinking and reframing obesity. Lancet2015;
385: 2326–2328.
33.
HawkesCSmithTGJewellJ, et al.
Smart food policies for obesity prevention. Lancet2015;
385: 2410–2421.
34.
HawkinsKWLinvillDL.Public health framing of news regarding childhood obesity in the United States. Health Commun2010;
25: 709–717.
35.
GreenerJDouglasFvan TeijlingenE.More of the same? Conflicting perspectives of obesity causation and intervention amongst overweight people, health professionals and policy makers. Soc Sci Med2010;
70: 1042–1049.
36.
SpearBABarlowSEErvinC, et al.
Recommendations for treatment of child and adolescent overweight and obesity. Pediatrics2007;
120: S254–S288.
37.
CrawfordD.Population strategies to prevent obesity. BMJ2002;
325: 728–729.
38.
HillJOPetersJC.Environmental contributions to the obesity epidemic. Science1998;
280: 1371–1374.
39.
JefferyRW.Public health strategies for obesity treatment and prevention. Am J Health Behav2001;
25: 252–259.
40.
WangYBeydounMALiangL, et al.
Will all Americans become overweight or obese? Estimating the progression and cost of the US obesity epidemic. Obesity2008;
16: 2323–2330.
41.
SobalJ.The medicalization and demedicalization of obesity. In: DMaurerSobalJ (eds) Eating Agendas: Food and Nutrition as Social Problems.
New York:
Walter de Gruyter, Inc., 1995, pp.67–90.
42.
ChangVWChristakisNA.Medical modelling of obesity: a transition from action to experience in a 20th century American medical textbook. Sociol Health Illn2002;
24: 151–177.
43.
PuhlRMHeuerCA.The stigma of obesity: a review and update. Obesity2009;
17: 941–964.
44.
SadlerJZJotterandFLeeS, et al.
Can medicalization be good? Situating medicalization within bioethics. Theor Med Bioeth2009;
30: 411–425.
45.
SontagS.Illness as Metaphor and AIDS and Its Metaphors.
New York:
Anchor Books Doubleday, 1978.
KwanS.Framing the fat body: contested meanings between government, activists, and industry. Sociological Inquiry2009;
79: 25–50.
48.
WilkinsonRPickettK.The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better.
London:
Penguin UK, 2009.
49.
CallahanDWasunnaAA.Medicine and the Market: Equity vs. Choice.
Baltimore, MD:
The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006.
50.
GarryA.Medicine and medicalization: A response to Purdy. Bioethics2001;
15: 262–269.
51.
SaguyACAlmelingR.Fat in the fire? Science, the news media, and the “obesity epidemic”. Sociol Forum2008;
23: 53–83.
52.
BaconLAphramorL.Weight science: evaluating the evidence for a paradigm shift. Nutr J2011;
10: 9.
53.
WooleySCWooleyOW.Obesity and women – I. A closer look at the facts. Women’s Stud Int Q1979;
2: 69–79.
54.
WooleyOWWooleySCDyrenforthSR.Obesity and women – II. A neglected feminist topic. Women’s Stud Int Q1979;
2: 81–92.
55.
RothblumESolovayS.The Fat Studies Reader.
New York and London:
New York University Press, 2009.
56.
RichEEvansJ.‘Fat ethics’ – the obesity discourse and body politics. Soc Theory Health2005;
3: 341–358.
57.
MurdochIConradiPJ.Existentialists and Mystics: Writings on Philosophy and Literature.
New York:
Penguin, 1999.
58.
OrwellG.The Penguin Essays of George Orwell.
London:
Penguin Books, 1984.
59.
ThoreauHD.A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers; Walden, or, Life in the Woods; the Maine Woods; Cape Cod. 12th printing ed.
New York: Library of America, 1985.
60.
SharmaAMKushnerRF.A proposed clinical staging system for obesity. Int J Obes2009;
33: 289–295.
61.
The Lancet.
Obesity and diabetes in 2017: a new year. Lancet2017;
389: 1.
62.
EvansB. ‘
Gluttony or sloth’: critical geographies of bodies and morality in (anti)obesity policy. Area2006;
38: 259–267.
63.
McClureKJPuhlRMHeuerCA.Obesity in the news: do photographic images of obese persons influence antifat attitudes?J Health Commun2011;
16: 359–371.
64.
AhlquistD.G. K. Chesterton: Apostle of Common Sense (A Kindle Version).
San Francisco, CA:
Ignatius Press, 2003.
65.
TauberAI.Confessions of a Medicine Man: An Essay in Popular Philosophy.
Cambridge and London:
A Bradford Book, the MIT Press, 2000.
66.
MontgomeryK.How Doctors Think; Clinical Judgement and Practice of Medicine.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2006.
67.
WarinMTurnerKMooreV, et al.
Bodies, mothers and identities: rethinking obesity and the BMI. Sociol Health Illn2008;
30: 97–111.
68.
MackenzieCStoljarN.Relational Autonomy: Feminist Perspectives on Autonomy, Agency, and the Social Self.
New York and Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 2000.
69.
ColesSKeenanSDiamondB.Madness Contested; Power and Practice.
Monmouth:
PCCS Books, 2013.
