Philosophical and scientific understandings of compassion converge, both stressing its necessity for the moral life and human flourishing. I conceptualise a dynamic and frangible account of professional virtues, including compassion, and propose that mechanistic organisational systems of care and the biomedical paradigm create a strong risk of dehumanisation and the obliteration of compassion in healthcare. Additionally, the neoliberal market ideology, with its instrumental approach to individuals and commodification of healthcare creates a corrosive influence that alienates clinicians from their patients and severely curtails the scope for compassionate practice. The tension between efficiency and patient orientated care – although they need not be mutually exclusive – has become more acute in the current economic climate, at a time when the boundaries of medicine have broadened and expectations for healthcare have risen. This has created an unsustainable dynamic within which alienated healthcare professionals struggle to fulfil their healing roles and patients experience abandonment and more anxiety.
ChochinovHDignity and the essence of medicine: the A, B, C and D of dignity conserving care. BMJ. 2007335. 184–187
2.
3.
BatsonCDHow social an animal?Am Psychol. 199045. 3336–346
4.
5.
FrankAWThe renewal of generosity. Illness, medicine and how to live. 2004Chicago. University of Chicago
6.
BarnesMCare in everyday life. An ethic of care in practice. 2012Bristol. The Policy Press
7.
8.
EisenbergNMillerPAThe relation of empathy and prosocial and related behaviours. Psychol Bull. 1987101. 91–119
9.
10.
AtkinsPSParkerSKUnderstanding individual compassion in organizations: the role of appraisals and psychological flexibility. Acad Manag Rev. 201237. 4524–546
11.
12.
MacnaughtonJThe dangerous practice of empathy. The Lancet. 2009373. 1941–1942
13.
GrovesJETaking care of the hateful patient. N Engl J Med. 1978298. 883–887
14.
AmatoTRespecting the power of denial. Croskerry P. Commentary: the affective imperative: coming to terms with our emotions. Acad Emerg Med. 20072. 184–186
15.
16.
17.
MacIntyreAAfter virtue. 19842nd ed. Indiana. University of Notre Dame
18.
19.
PellegrinoEDTowards a virtue-based normative ethics. Kennedy Inst Ethics J. 19955. 3253–277
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
DamasioADescartes’ error: emotion, reason and the human brain. 1994New York. Avon Books
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
KanovJMMaitlisSWorlineMCCompassion in organizational life. Am Behav Scientist. 200447. 6808–827
35.
FrostPTDuttonJEWorlineMCFinemanSNarratives of compassion in organizations. Emotion in organizations. 2000London. Sage Publications25–25
36.
37.
BoyatzisRESmithMLBlaizeNDeveloping sustainable leaders through coaching and compassion. Acad Manag Learn Educ. 20065. 8–24
38.
HochschildARThe managed heart. Commercialization of human feeling. 1983Berkeley CA. University of California Press
BroyardAIntoxicated by my illness. And other writings of life and death. 1992New York. Fawcett Columbinepp. 40, 55
45.
46.
47.
BallattJCamplingPIntelligent kindness. Reforming the culture of healthcare. 2011London. The Royal College of Psychiatrists, RCPsych Publications53–53
48.
CohenSStates of denial. Knowing about atrocities and suffering. 2001Cambridge. Polity Press
49.
RentmeesterCAMoral damage to health care professionals and trainees: legalism and other consequences for patients and colleagues. J Med Philosophy. 200833. 27–43
50.
HaglundMEMRotMAHCooperNSResilience in the third year of medical school: a prospective study of the associations between stressful events occurring during clinical rotations and student well-being. Acad Med. 200984. 258–268
51.
LemairJBWallaceJENot all coping strategies are created equal: a mixed methods study exploring physicians’ self reported coping strategies. BMC. 201010. 208–208
52.
LarsonEYaoXClinical empathy as emotional labor in the patient-physician relationship. JAMA. 2005293. 91100–1106
53.
Menzies LythISocial systems as a defence against anxiety. An empirical study of the nursing service of a general hospital. Hum Relat. 196013. 95–121
54.
DelbancoTBellSKGuilty, afraid and alone – struggling with medical error. N Engl J Med. 2007357. 1682–1683
55.
MarsallMHeathISweeneyKClinical practice. When things go wrong. The Lancet. 2010375. 1491–1493
56.
57.
MilgramSBehavioral science of obedience. J Abnorm Soc Psychol. 196367. 371–378
58.
HaslamNDehumanization: an integrative review. Pers Soc Psychol Rev. 200610. 3252–264
59.
60.
Cato 6. Dirtball. JAMA. 1982347. 3059–3060
61.
62.
DecetyJYangCYChengYPhysicians down-regulate their pain empathy response: an event-related brain potential study. NeuroImage. 201050. 873–883
63.
HaqueOSWaytzADehumanization in medicine. Causes, solutions and functions. Perspect Psychol Sci. 201120. 101–11
64.
PorterRThe greatest benefit to mankind. a medical history of humanity from antiquity to the present day. 1997London. Harper Collins671–671
65.
FoucaultMThe birth of the clinic. An archeology of medical perception. 1973London. Vintage Books
66.
67.
PedersenREmpathy development in medical education. A critical review. Med Teacher. 201032. 593–600
68.
EngelGLThe need for a new medical model: a challenge for biomedicine. Science. 1977196. 129–136
69.
TaylorFWThe principles of scientific management. 1911New York. Harper and Brothers
70.
LewisSPassmoreJCantoreSAppreciative inquiry for change management. Using AI to facilitate organizational development. 2008London. Kogan Page21–21
71.
SeddonJSystems thinking in the public sector. The failure of the reform regime and a manifesto for a better way. 2008Axminster. Triarchy Press
72.
DeciELFlasteRWhy we do what we want to do. Understanding self-motivation. 2002NY. Oxford University Press
73.
CohnSWhere have all the flowers gone?BMJ. 2009339. b5406–b5406
74.
BroyardAIntoxicated by my illness. And other writings of life and death. 1992New York. Fawcett Columbine55–56
75.
76.
FrankAWThe renewal of generosity. Illness, medicine and how to live. 2004Chicago. University of Chicago
77.
WolgastEEthics of an artificial person: lost responsibility in professions and organizations. 1992Stanford, CA. Stanford University Press
78.
FrankAWThe renewal of generosity. Illness, medicine and how to live. 2004Chicago. University of Chicago127–127
79.
IliffeSFrom general practice to primary care. The industrialization of family medicine. 2008Oxford. Oxford University Press
80.
81.
82.
SandelMWhat money can't buy, the moral limits of the market. 2012London. Allen Lane
83.
IacobucciGMore than a third of GPs on CCG boards have conflicts of interests. BMJ. 2013346. f1569–f1569
84.
85.
PorterRThe greatest benefit to mankind. A medical history of humanity from antiquity to the present day. 1997London. Harper Collins718–718
86.
TrontoJCMoral boundaries. A political argument for an ethics of care. 2009New York. Routledge
87.
88.
KleinmanACaregiving as moral experience. The Lancet. 2012380. 1550–1551
89.
90.
IgnatieffMThe needs of strangers. An essay on privacy, solidarity, and the politics of being human. 1986London. Penguin142–143
91.
BursztajnJHJFeinbloomRIHammRMMedical choices, medical chances. how patients, families and physicians can cope with uncertainty. 1990Lincoln. iUniverse
92.
BatsonCDAltruism in humans. 2011New York. Oxford University Press
93.
94.
McGilchristIThe master and his emissary. The divided brain and the making of the western world. 2009London and New Haven. Yale University Press
