Whether a missing person is considered to meet preconceived norms and societal expectations heavily influences the response of the police, public, and media. Nils Christie's ‘ideal victim’ theory therefore lends itself well to the study of missing people. This article examines this using police data from the United Kingdom. A comparison of solved versus long-term unresolved cases are used as a case study to explore the hypothesis that perceptions of weakness, vulnerability, and blameworthiness may be reflected in the outcome of missing persons cases. To test this, a multivariable logistic regression model is used to compare cases and confirms individuals with characteristics of ideal missing persons, such as being a girl, being suicidal or being bullied, are less likely to remain missing long-term. In contrast, individuals perceived as ‘non-ideal’, such as being of Asian ethnicity, those who prepared to go missing, or are recorded in the Child Protection Registry are more likely that their cases remain unresolved long-term. The implications potentially highlight the influence of biases and stereotypes in police missing persons risk assessments, underscoring the need for greater awareness and objectivity in managing missing person cases.
BabutaASidebottomA (2020) Missing children: On the extent, patterns, and correlates of repeat disappearances by young people. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice14(3): 698–711.
2.
BennettKFergusonL (2024) Police responses to cold and long-term missing person cases: A comparative study. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice48(1): 53–73.
3.
Ben-ShacharMSLüdeckeDMakowskiD (2020) Effectsize: Estimation of effect size indices and standardized parameters. Journal of Open-Source Software5(56): 2815.
4.
BonnyEAlmondLWoolnoughP (2016) Adult missing persons: Can an investigative framework be generated using behavioral themes?Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling13(3): 296–312.
5.
BoultonLPhoenixJHalfordE, et al. (2023) Return home interviews with children who have been missing: An exploratory analysis. Police Practice and Research24(1): 1–16.
6.
BowlingBPhillipsC (2007) Disproportionate and discriminatory: Reviewing the evidence on police stop and search. The Modern Law Review70(6): 936–961.
7.
BowlingBWeberL (2011) Stop and search in a global context: An overview. Policing and Society21(4): 480–488.
8.
BradfordBLoaderI (2016) Police, crime, and order: The case of stop and search. In: BradfordBJaureguiBLoaderI, et al. (eds) The SAGE Handbook of Global Policing. London: Sage Publications, 241–260.
9.
BryantSASpencerGA (2003) University students’ attitudes about attributing blame in domestic violence. Journal of Family Violence18(6): 369–376.
10.
CaseyL (2023) Baroness Casey Review: Final report: An independent review into the standards of behaviour and internal culture of the Metropolitan Police Service. London: Baroness Casey of Blackstock DBE CB.
11.
ChopinJBeauregardEBarocheC, et al. (2022) An exploration of unsolved missing persons cases suspected of a criminal outcome: A forensic victimology approach. Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling19(3): 118–134.
12.
ChristieN (1986) The ideal victim. In: FattahEA (eds) From Crime Policy to Victim Policy: Reorienting the Justice System. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 17–30.
13.
ClarkJ (2007) Adult siblings of long-term missing people: Loss and ‘unending not knowing’. Grief Matters: The Australian Journal of Grief and Bereavement10(1): 16–19.
14.
ClementJGWinshipVCeddiaJ, et al. (2006) New software for computer-assisted dental-data matching in Disaster Victim Identification and long-term missing persons investigations: ‘DAVID Web’. Forensic Science International159: S24–S29.
CorriganPWMarkowitzFEWatsonAC (2004) Structural levels of mental illness stigma and discrimination. Schizophrenia Bulletin30(3): 481–491.
17.
CrossC (2018) Denying victim status to online fraud victims: The challenges of being a ‘non-ideal victim’. In: DugganM (eds) Revisiting the ‘Ideal Victim’. Bristol: Policy Press, 243–262.
18.
DelsolRShinerM (2006) Regulating stop and search: A challenge for police and community relations in England and Wales. Critical Criminology14(3): 241–263.
19.
DiBiaseTWaltonRH (2017) Long-term missing-persons and No-body cold case investigations. In: DiBiaseT (eds) Cold Case Homicides. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 139–150.
20.
DoyleRBarnesGC (2020) Targeting missing persons most likely to come to harm among 92,681 cases reported to Devon and Cornwall police. Cambridge Journal of Evidence-Based Policing4: 160–177.
21.
EastwoodNShinerMBearD (2013) The Numbers in Black and White: Ethnic Disparities in the Policing and Prosecution of Drug Offenses in England and Wales. London: Release.
22.
EllisK (2019) Blame and culpability in children's narratives of child sexual abuse. Child Abuse Review28(6): 405–417.
23.
FirthD (1993) Bias reduction of maximum likelihood estimates. Biometrika80(1): 27–38.
24.
FlacksS (2020) Law, necro politics and the stop and search of young people. Theoretical Criminology24(2): 387–405.
25.
FohringS (2018) Revisiting the non-ideal victim. In: DugganM (eds) Revisiting the ‘Ideal Victim’. Bristol: Policy Press, 195–210.
26.
FoxNMilesCSolymosiR, et al. (2024) Too risky yet not risky enough: The intersecting characteristics, vulnerabilities, harm indicators and guardianship issues associated with seriously harmed missing children. Policing and Society34(7): 641–657.
27.
GotellL (2002) The ideal victim, the hysterical complainant, and the disclosure of confidential records: The implications of the charter for sexual assault law. Osgoode Hall Law Journal40(2): 251–293.
GreerC (2007) News media, victims, and crime. In: DaviesPFrancisPGreerC (eds) Victims, Crime, and Society. London: Sage Publications, 20–37.
30.
HalfordE (2024) Classifying missing persons cases: an analysis of police risk assessments using multi-dimensional scaling. Police Practice and Research. Epub ahead of print 16 April 2024. 10.1080/15614263.2024.2356111.
31.
HaydenCShalev-GreeneK (2018) The blue light social services? Responding to repeat reports to the police of people missing from institutional locations. Policing and Society28(1): 45–61.
32.
HeinzeGPlonerMDunklerD, et al. (2023) Package ‘logistf’. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
33.
His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabularies, Fire and Rescue Services (HMICFRS) (2016) Missing Children: Who Cares? - The Police Response to Missing and Absent Children. London: HMICFRS.
34.
HueyLFergusonLKowalskiL (2020) The ‘power few’ of missing persons’ cases. Policing: An International Journal43(2): 360–374.
35.
HuntDMojtahediD (2024) Prospective person memory and own-race bias of missing person appeals. Journal of Criminal Psychology. Epub ahead of print 2 April 2024. 10.1108/JCP-12-2023-0049.
36.
KiepalLCCarringtonPJDawsonM (2012) Missing persons and social exclusion. Canadian Journal of Sociology37(2): 137–168.
37.
LamJKerstholtJ (2023) The influence of case characteristics, attitude, and effect on citizens’ willingness to help search for a missing person. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology38(3): 691–701..
38.
LenferinkLIde KeijserJWesselI, et al. (2018) Cognitive-behavioural correlates of psychological symptoms among relatives of missing persons. International Journal of Cognitive Therapy11(3): 311–324.
39.
LennonGMurrayK (2018) Under-regulated and unaccountable? Explaining variation in stop and search rates in Scotland. England, and Wales. Policing and Society28(2): 157–174.
40.
LewisJAHamiltonJCElmoreJD, et al. (2019) The effects of severity and number of misfortunes on reactions to victims. Social Justice Research32(3): 445–458..
41.
LewisJAHamiltonJCElmoreJD (2021) Describing the ideal victim: A linguistic analysis of victim descriptions. Current Psychology40(9): 4324–4332..
42.
LüdeckeD (2024) Package ‘sjPlot’. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
43.
MarmoMChazalN (2010) The trafficked woman: Ideal or blameworthy victim?Advances in Sociology Research7(7): 125–140.
44.
MietheTDWetherellKITRegoecziWC (2023) Missing persons: A national survey approach assessing the predictors of case outcomes. Criminal Justice Studies36(2): 112–132.
45.
MillerJSchwartzMD (1995) Rape myths and violence against street prostitutes. Deviant Behaviour16(1): 1–23.
46.
MillsC (1997) The Racial Contract. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
MorrisL (2010) A comparison of the stereotypes that police and members of non-governmental organisations have of missing people. PhD Thesis. University of Leicester, UK.
49.
National Crime Agency (2022) UKMPU Statistical Bulletin 2021/2022. London: National Crime Agency.
50.
National Missing Persons Coordination Centre (NMPC) (2024) Myths and Facts About Missing Persons. Canberra: NMPC.
51.
NewissG (1999) Missing Presumed…? The Police Response to missing Persons. London: Home Office Research, Development and Statistics Directorate.
52.
NewissG (2005) A study of the characteristics of outstanding missing persons: Implications for the development of police risk assessment. Policing and Society15(2): 212–225.
53.
PeeblesC (2021) Victim blame of missing people based on race and media framing. MA Thesis. University of Leicester, UK.
54.
PhoenixJFrancisBJ (2023) Police risk assessment and case outcomes in missing person investigations. The Police Journal96(3): 390–410.
55.
PuhrRHeinzeGNoldM, et al. (2017) Firth’s logistic regression with rare events: Accurate effect estimates and predictions?Statistics in Medicine36: 2302–2317. DOI: 10.1002/sim.7273.
56.
R Core Team (2021) R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
RumneyPN (2013) Gay male rape victims: Law enforcement, social attitudes, and barriers to recognition. In: QueerISelinaM (eds) Protection of Sexual Minorities Since Stonewall. London: Routledge, 101–118.
59.
SagovskyAJohnsonSD (2007) When does repeat burglary victimisation occur?Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology40(1): 1–26.
60.
SchisselB (1997) Blaming Children: Youth Crime, Moral Panics and the Politics of Hate. Halifax: Fernwood.
61.
SchisselB (2021) Still Blaming Children: Youth Conduct and the Politics of Child Hating. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing.
62.
SidebottomABoultonLCockbainE, et al. (2019) Missing children: Risks, repeats and responses. Policing and Society30(10): 1157–1170.
63.
SidebottomADaviesT (2024) Development and Validation of a Statistical Model for Predicting Harm in Missing Person Incidents. London: Office of the Police Chief Scientific Adviser STAR Fund.
64.
SjobergDDWhitingKCurryM, et al. (2021) Reproducible summary tables with the gtsummary package. The R Journal13(1): 570–580.
65.
Skinner-DorkenooALGeorgeMWagesJEIII, et al. (2023) A systemic approach to the psychology of racial bias within individuals and society. Nature Reviews Psychology2(7): 392–406.
66.
SlakoffDCFradellaHF (2019) Media messages surrounding missing women and girls: The ‘missing white woman syndrome’ and other factors that influence newsworthiness. Criminology, Criminal Justice, Law and Society20: 80–102.
67.
SmithRShalev GreeneK (2015) Recognizing risk: The attitudes of police supervisors to the risk assessment process in missing person investigations. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice9(4): 352–361.
68.
SommersZ (2016) Missing white woman syndrome: An empirical analysis of race and gender disparities in online news coverage of missing persons. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology106(2): 275–314.
69.
StevensonMSergeantE (2024) epiR: Tools for the Analysis of Epidemiological Data (R Package Version 2.0.76). Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
70.
Van WijkJ (2013) Who is the ‘little old lady’ of international crimes? Nils christie's concept of the ideal victim reinterpreted. International Review of Victimology19(2): 159–177.
71.
WalklateS (2006) Imagining the Victim of Crime. London: McGraw-Hill Education.
72.
WaltonRPettemS (2016) Investigation of long-term missing persons as cold case homicides: An American perspective. In: MorewitzSJSturdy CollsC (eds) Handbook of Missing Persons. Cham: Springer, 233–249.
73.
WardJ (2018) The past, present and future state of missing persons investigations in Australia. Australian Journal of Forensic Sciences50(6): 708–722.
74.
WardJ (2022) A multifaceted, multijurisdictional, multiagency, and multidisciplinary approach to investigating unidentified and missing persons cases in Australia. Forensic Science International: Genetics Supplement Series8: 53–55.
75.
WhatleyMA (2005) The effect of participant sex, victim dress, and traditional attitudes on causal judgments for marital rape victims. Journal of Family Violence20(3): 191–200.
76.
WickhamHAverickMBryanJ, et al. (2022) Welcome to the tidyverse. Journal of Open Source Software4(43): 1686.
