A criminology of extinction: Biodiversity,extreme consumption and the vanity of species resurrection

Abstract

This article explores an issue pertaining to the commodification of nature and related market processes – reviving extinct species. It begins by offering an overview of the aesthetic, economic, scientific and ethical reasons to preserve biological diversity. The article then considers how and why biological diversity is actually being reduced at an unprecedented rate – the ways in which, and the explanations for why, human acts and omissions are directly and indirectly, separately and synergistically, causing extinctions, quite possibly of species that we do not even know exist. From here, the article draws on the growing body of research on resurrecting species – a process known as de-extinction – to contemplate the questions raised about the permanency of extinction, as well as whether we should revive extinct species and the meaning and criminological implications of doing so.

Keywords

Biodiversity/biological diversity consumption de-extinction extinction hunting/poaching wildlife (crime,trade,trafficking)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agnew

(2012) Dire forecast: A theoretical model of the impact of climate change on crime. Theoretical Criminology 16(1): 21–42.

Angelici

(ed.) (2016) Problematic Wildlife: A Cross-Disciplinary Approach. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

AWF (African Wildlife Foundation) (n.d.) Sustainable tourism. URL: https://www.awf.org/economic/sustainable-tourism.

Bayrachnaya

Nadtochiy

Isaev

Surenova

(2018) The crimes that affect the animal and plant world: The problems of penalization. Amazonia Investiga 7(16): 380–390.

Beirne

(1995) The use and abuse of animals in criminology: A brief history and current review. Social Justice 22(1): 5–31.

Beirne

(1997) Rethinking bestiality: Towards a concept of interspecies sexual assault. Theoretical Criminology 1(3): 317–340.

Beirne

(1999) For a nonspeciesist criminology: Animal abuse as an object of study. Criminology 37(1): 117–148.

Beirne

(2009) Confronting Animal Abuse: Law, Criminology, and Human-Animal Relationships. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Beirne

(2014) Theriocide: Naming animal killing. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 3(2): 50–67.

10.

Brannen

(2017) This is how your world could end. The Guardian, 9 September. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/sep/09/this-is-how-your-world-could-end-climate-change-global-warming.

11.

Brisman

(2017) Tensions for green criminology. Critical Criminology 25(2): 311–323.

12.

Brisman

South

(2013) A green-cultural criminology: An exploratory outline. Crime Media Culture 9(2): 115–135.

13.

Brisman

South

(2014) Green Cultural Criminology: Constructions of Environmental Harm, Consumerism and Resistance to Ecocide. London and New York: Routledge.

14.

Brisman

South

(2015a) ‘Life stage dissolution’, infantilisation and anti-social consumption: Implications for de-responsibilisation, denial and environmental harm. Young – Nordic Journal of Youth Research 23(3): 209–221.

15.

Brisman

South

(2015b) New ‘folk devils’, denials and climate change: Applying the work of Stanley Cohen to green criminology and environmental harm. Critical Criminology 23(4): 449–460.

16.

Brisman

South

(2017) Consumer technologies, crime and environmental implications. In: McGuire

Holt

(eds) The Routledge Handbook of Technology, Crime and Justice. London and New York: Routledge, 310–324.

17.

Brisman

South

(2018a) Green Criminology, zemiology, and comparative and inter-relational justice in the Anthropocene era. In: Boukli

Kotzé

(eds) Just Harm? Rethinking Zemiology and the Broader Context of Social Harm. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 203–221.

18.

Brisman

South

(2018b) Environment, conflict and profit: Harmful resource exploitation and questionable revenue generation. In: Spapens

White

van Uhm

Huisman

(eds) Green Crimes and Dirty Money. London and New York: Routledge, 19–41.

19.

Brisman

South

(2018c) Perspectives on wildlife crime: A green criminological approach. In: Moreto

(ed.) Wildlife Crime: From Theory to Practice. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, 17–37.

20.

Brisman

South

White

(eds) (2015) Environmental Crime and Social Conflict: Contemporary and Emerging Issues. Surrey: Ashgate.

21.

Bryant

(1979) The zoological connection: Animal-related human behavior. Social Forces 58(2): 399–421.

22.

Buckley

(2010) Conservation Tourism. Wallingford: CABI.

23.

Carlin

Wurman

Zakim

(2014) How to permit your mammoth: Some legal implications of ‘de-extinction.’ Stanford Environmental Law Journal 33(1): 3–57. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://law.stanford.edu/publications/how-to-permit-your-mammoth-some-legal-implications-of-de-extinction/.

24.

Cazaux

(1999) Beauty and the beast: Animal abuse from a non-speciesist criminological perspective. Crime, Law and Social Change 31(2): 105–126.

25.

Ceballos

, et al. (2015) Accelerated modern human–induced species losses: Entering the sixth mass extinction. Science Advances 1(5) [e1400253]: 1–5. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/1/5/e1400253.full.

26.

Cohen

(2001) States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering. Cambridge: Polity.

27.

Cook

Roberts

Lowther

(2002) The international wildlife trade and organised crime: A review of the evidence and the role of the UK. WWF-UK.

28.

Courchamp

Angulo

Rivalan

Hall

Signoret

Bull

Meinard

(2006) Rarity value and species extinction. PLoS Biology 4(12): 2405–2410. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0040415.

29.

Courchamp

, et al. (2018) The paradoxical extinction of the most charismatic animals. PLoS Biology 16(4): e2003997. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.2003997.

30.

Daskin

Pringle

(2018) Warfare and wildlife declines in Africa’s protected areas. Nature 553 (7688): 323–332. doi: 10.1038/nature25194.

31.

Dawson

(2016) Extinction: A Radical History. New York and London: OR Books.

32.

EEA (European Environment Agency) (2015) Growing Pressures on Ecosystems. Copenhagen: EEA. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.eea.europa.eu/soer-2015/global/ecosystems.

33.

Eliason

(2003) Illegal hunting and angling: The neutralization of wildlife law violations. Society & Animals 11(3): 225–243.

34.

Evans

(1987 [1906]) The Criminal Prosecution and Capital Punishment of Animals. London: William Heinemann [Faber and Faber].

35.

Fernandez

(2017) Blood and beauty on a Texas exotic-game ranch. The New York Times. 27 October, A14. Published online, 19 October 2017. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/19/us/exotic-hunting-texas-ranch.html.

36.

Froestad

Shearing

Van der Merwe

(2015) Criminology: Re-imagining security and risk. In: Bourbeau

(ed.) Security: Dialogue across Disciplines. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 177–195.

37.

Fukuyama

(2002) Our Posthuman Future: Consequences of the Biotechnology Revolution. London: Profile.

38.

Gettleman

(2017) ‘Everyone wants a baby’: The dark market for apes. The New York Times, 4 November, A1. Published online as ‘Smuggled, beaten and drugged: The illicit global ape trade’, 4 November 2017. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/04/world/africa/ape-trafficking-bonobos-orangutans.html.

39.

Gibbs

Gore

McGarrell

Rivers

(2010) Introducing conservation criminology: Towards interdisciplinary scholarship on environmental crimes and risks. British Journal of Criminology 50(1): 124–144.

40.

Giller

(2018) Finding refuge. The New York Times, 31 July, D1. Published online as ‘Vanishing in the wild, these salamanders found refuge in a convent’, 30 July 2018. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/30/science/achoques-salamanders-nuns-mexico.html.

41.

Goyes

Sollund

(2016) Contesting and contextualising CITES: Wildlife trafficking in Colombia and Brazil. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy 5(4): 87–102.

42.

Graham

(2017) Tauros program would bring back Europe’s famed Auroch cattle. Digital Journal, 10 January. URL (accessed 3 February 2019): http://www.digitaljournal.com/tech-and-science/science/tauros-program-would-bring-back-europe-s-famed-auroch-cattle/article/483359.

43.

Guzmán

JCC

Saldaña

MES

Grosselet

Gamez

(2007) The Illegal Parrot Trade in Mexico. Washington DC: Defenders of Wildlife. URL (accessed 3 February 2019): https://www.defenders.org/publications/the_illegal_parrot_trade_in_mexico.pdf.

44.

Halsey

White

(1998) Crime, ecophilosophy and environmental harm. Theoretical Criminology 2(3): 345–371.

45.

Harding

(1983) Nuclear energy and the destiny of mankind – Some criminological perspectives. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 16(2): 81–92.

46.

Hay

(1975) Poaching and the game laws on Cannock Chase. In: Hay

Linebaugh

Rule

Thompson

Winslow

(eds) Albion’s Fatal Tree: Crime and Society in Eighteenth-Century England. London: Allen Lane.

47.

Herbig

(2010) The illegal reptile trade as a form of conservation crime: A South African criminological investigation. In: White

(ed.) Global Environmental Harm: Criminological Perspectives. Cullompton, Devon: Willan, 110–131.

48.

Hogan

(2014) Causes of extinction. In: Caley

(ed.) Encyclopedia of Earth. Environmental Information Coalition. Washington, DC: National Council for Science and the Environment. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://editors.eol.org/eoearth/wiki/Causes_of_extinction.

49.

Kahn

(2018) Should some species be allowed to die out? The New York Times Magazine, 18 March, MM30. Published online, 13 March 2018. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/13/magazine/should-some-species-be-allowed-to-die-out.html.

50.

Katz

(1998) Whose nature, whose culture? Private productions of space and the ‘preservation of nature’. In: Braun

Castree

(eds) Remaking Reality: Nature at the Millennium. London: Routledge, 45–62.

51.

Keller

Perrings

(2011) International policy options for reducing the environmental impacts of invasive species. BioScience 61(12): 1005–1012. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://doi.org/10.1525/bio.2011.61.12.10.

52.

Kiff

Peakall

Wilbur

(1979) Recent changes in California condor eggshells. Condor 81(2): 166–172. doi: 10.2307/1367284.

53.

Kolbert

(2014) The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History. New York: Henry Holt.

54.

Krisfalusi-Gannon

Ali

Dellinger

Robertson

Brady

Goddard

MKM

Tinker-Kulberg

Kepley

Dellinger

(2018) The role of horseshoe crabs in the biomedical industry and recent trends impacting species sustainability. Frontiers in Marine Science 5(185), 5 June: 1–13. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2018.00185.

55.

Ledec

Goodland

(1988) Wildlands: Their Protection and Management in Economic Development. Washington, DC: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/102041468739335376/pdf/multi-page.pdf.

56.

Lee

Sigouin

Pinedo-Vasquez

Nasi

(2014) The harvest of wildlife for bushmeat and traditional medicine in East, South and Southeast Asia: Current knowledge base, challenges, opportunities and areas for future research. Occasional Paper 115. Bogor Barat, Indonesia: Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR). URL (accessed 30 January 2019): http://www.cifor.org/publications/pdf_files/OccPapers/OP-115.pdf.

57.

Lemieux

(ed.) (2014) Situational Prevention of Poaching. Abingdon: Routledge.

58.

Linebaugh

(1976). Karl Marx, the theft of wood, and working class composition: A contribution to the current debate. Crime and Social Justice 6: 5–16.

59.

McGoey

(2012) The logic of strategic ignorance. British Journal of Sociology 63(3): 553–576.

60.

Maher

Sollund

(2016) Law enforcement of the wildlife trafficking: A comparative strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats analysis of the UK and Norway. Journal of Trafficking, Organized Crime and Security 2(1): 82–99.

61.

Maher

Beirne

Pierpoint

(eds) (2017) The Palgrave International Handbook of Animal Abuse Studies. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

62.

Mai

(2017) Reversing extinction. Time for Kids 8(5): 4–5.

63.

Maxwell

Fuller

Brooks

Watson

(2016) Biodiversity: The ravages of guns, nets and bulldozers. Nature 536 (7615): 143–145.

64.

Mirzoeff

(2014) Visualizing the Anthropocene. Public Culture 26(2): 213–232.

65.

Monks

(2017) The wild, extinct supercow returning to Europe. CNN, 9 January. URL (accessed 3 February 2019): https://www.cnn.com/2017/01/09/world/auroch-rewilding/index.html.

66.

Moreto

(ed.) (2018) Wildlife Crime: From Theory to Practice. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

67.

Moreto

Brunson

Braga

(2015) ‘Such misconducts don’t make a good ranger’: Examining law enforcement ranger wrongdoing in Uganda. British Journal of Criminology 55(2): 359–380.

68.

Myers

(1979) The Sinking Ark: A New Look at the Problem of Disappearing Species. New York: Pergamon.

69.

Natali

(2010) The big grey elephants in the backyard of Huelva, Spain. In: White

(ed.) Global Environmental Harm: Criminological Perspectives. Cullompton, Devon: Willan, 193–209.

70.

Natali

(2015) A critical gaze on environmental victimization. In: Sollund

(ed.) Green Harms and Crimes: Critical Criminology in a Changing World. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 63–78.

71.

Nordland

(2018) These elephants have no tusks. No poachers either. The New York Times, 16 June, A6. Published online as ‘Where female elephants without tusks roam – and poachers stay away’, 16 June 2018. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/16/world/africa/south-africa-elephants-tusks.html.

72.

Novacek

(2007) Terra: Our 100-Million-Year-Old Ecosystem – and the Threats That Now Put It at Risk. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

73.

Nurse

(2013) Animal Harm: Perspectives on Why People Harm and Kill Animals. Surrey: Ashgate.

74.

Nurse

(2015) Policing Wildlife: Perspectives on the Enforcement of Wildlife Legislation. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

75.

Nuwer

(2017) A watchful eye on wildlife. The New York Times, 14 March, D6. Published online as ‘High above, drones keep watchful eyes on wildlife in Africa’, 13 March 2017. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/13/science/drones-africa-poachers-wildlife.html.

76.

Nuwer

(2018a) The snake handlers. The New York Times, 10 April, D6. Published online as ‘That python in the pet store? It may have been snatched from the wild’, 9 April 2018. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/09/science/illegal-wildlife-reptiles-amphibians.html.

77.

Nuwer

(2018b) Killing field haven. The New York Times, 20 May, TR1. Published online as ‘In Chad, the elephants (so many elephants) are back’, 14 May 2018. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/14/travel/chad-elephants-zakouma-park.html.

78.

O’Sullivan

Walters

(2016) Criminology, war and environmental despoliation. In: McGrary

Walklate

(eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Criminology and War. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 79–96.

79.

Pacifici

Visconti

Butchart

SHM

Watson

JEM

Cassola

Rondinini

(2017) Species’ traits influenced their response to recent climate change. Nature Climate Change 7(13 February): 205–208. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3223.

80.

Pires

Clarke

(2011) Sequential foraging, itinerant fences and parrot poaching in Bolivia. British Journal of Criminology 51(2): 314–335.

81.

Raworth

(2012) A safe and just space for humanity: Can we live within the doughnut? Oxfam Policy and Practice: Climate Change and Resilience 8(1): 1–26.

82.

Ripple

, et al. (2017) World scientists’ warning to humanity: A second notice. BioScience 67(12): 1026–1028.

83.

Rivett-Carnac

(2017) Brigade gives Mali elephants a fighting chance to survive. The New York Times, 29 October, A8. Published as ‘Mali’s desert elephants, on edge of annihilation, get a fighting chance’, 20 October 2017. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/29/world/africa/mali-elephants-gourma.html.

84.

Roman

Y-W

(2018) Vulnerable species in the cross hairs. The New York Times, 26 July. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/26/opinion/vulnerable-species-in-the-cross-hairs.html.

85.

Schneider

(2008) Reducing the illicit trade in endangered wildlife: The market reduction approach. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 24(3): 274–295. https://doi.org/10.1177/1043986208318226.

86.

Schneider

(2012) Sold into Extinction: The Global Trade in Endangered Species. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.

87.

Sellar

(2017) Extinction through profitable crime: The rhinoceros. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 11 January. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://leb.fbi.gov/articles/featured-articles/extinction-through-profitable-crime-the-rhinoceros.

88.

Shepherd

Connelly

Hywood

Cassey

(2017) Taking a stand against illegal wildlife trade: The Zimbabwean approach to pangolin conservation. Oryx 51(2): 280–285. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://doi.org/10.1017/S0030605316000119.

89.

Slater

(2014) Wild obsession. National Geographic 225(4): 96–119.

90.

Sodhi

Brook

Bradshaw

CJA

(2009) Causes and consequences of species extinctions. In: Levin

(ed.) The Princeton Guide to Ecology. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 514–520.

91.

Sollund

(2011) Expressions of speciesism: The effects of keeping companion animals on animal abuse, animal trafficking and species decline. Crime, Law and Social Change 55(5): 437–451.

92.

Sollund

(2013a) Animal trafficking and trade: Abuse and species injustice. In: Walters

Westerhuis

Wyatt

(eds) Emerging Issues in Green Criminology: Exploring Power, Justice and Harm. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 72–92.

93.

Sollund

(2013b) The victimization of women, children and non-human species through trafficking and trade: Crimes understood through an ecofeminist perspective. In: South

Brisman

(eds) Routledge International Handbook of Green Criminology. Abingdon: Routledge, 317–330.

94.

Sollund

(ed.) (2015) Green Harms and Crimes: Critical Criminology in a Changing World. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

95.

Sollund

(2017) Doing green, critical criminology with an auto-ethnographic, feminist approach. Critical Criminology: An International Journal 25(2): 245–260.

96.

The Stanford Environmental Law Society (2001) The Endangered Species Act. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

97.

Stenøien

Andersen

(2018) Arten som forandret alt. Historien om menneskets erobring av nature. [The species that changed everything. The story of humankind’s conquest of nature.] Oslo: J.M. Stenersens Forlag.

98.

Stephens

(2018) Apocalypse not. The New York Times, 8 February. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/08/opinion/environment-oil-scare.html.

99.

Thompson

(1975) Whigs and Hunters: The Origins of the Black Act. New York: Pantheon Books.

100.

Tilman

(1999) The ecological consequences of biodiversity: A search for general principles. Ecology 80(5): 1455–1474.

101.

Van Erp

Huisman

(2013) Opportunities for environmental crime: A test of situational crime prevention theory. British Journal of Criminology 53(6): 1178–1200.

102.

Van Uhm

(2018) The social construction of the value of wildlife: A green cultural criminological perspective. Theoretical Criminology 22(3): 384–401.

103.

Werblow

(2018) Spotting potential: Africa’s game ranchers are on the prowl for new opportunities. The Furrow 123(1): 15–16.

104.

White

(2007) Green criminology and the pursuit of social and ecological justice. In: Beirne

South

(eds) Issues in Green Criminology: Confronting Harms Against Environments, Humanity and Other Animals. Cullompton, Devon: Willan, 32–54.

105.

White

(2013) Environmental Harm: An Eco-justice Perspective. Bristol: Policy Press.

106.

Wilson

(1998) Consilience: The Unity of Knowledge. New York: Knopf.

107.

Wilson

(2004) The Future of Life. New York: Knopf.

108.

Wolf

(1987) On the Brink of Extinction: Conserving the Diversity of Life on Earth. Worldwatch Paper 78. Washington, DC: Worldwatch Institute. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED282737.pdf.

109.

Wray

(2017) Rise of the Necrofauna: The Science, Ethics and Risks of De-Extinction. Vancouver: Greystone.

110.

WWF (World Wide Fund for Nature) (2016) Living Planet Report 2016: Summary. Gland, Switzerland: World Wide Fund for Nature. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): awsassets.panda.org/downloads/lpr_living_planet_report_2016_summary.pdf.

111.

Wyatt

(2013) Wildlife Trafficking: A Deconstruction of the Crime, the Victims and the Offenders. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

112.

Wyatt

Brisman

(2017) The role of denial in the ‘theft of nature’: A comparison of biopiracy and climate change. Critical Criminology 25(3): 325–341. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10612-016-9344-5.

113.

Zhang

(2018) The last days of the blue-blood harvest. The Atlantic, 9 May. URL (accessed 30 January 2019): https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/05/blood-in-the-water/559229/.

114.

Zimmer

(2013) Back to life. National Geographic 223(4): 28–43.