This article examines the 2011 England riots and seeks to place them in their recent comparative context. Briefly, it sets out a ‘life-cycle’ model for (historical and comparative) analysis, and then uses this as the basis for contrasting the English experience with the rioting witnessed in other European countries in recent times – in particular the riots in France in 2005 and in Sweden in 2013. Using a range of sources, the analysis identifies a number of similarities and differences between the aetiology, nature and aftermath of the riots in the different countries, and argues that this illustrates both the potential of comparative analysis and the importance of moving beyond an examination of their causes, to study riots ‘in the round’.
Body-GendrotS (2000) The Social Control of Cities. Oxford: Blackwell
6.
Body-GendrotS (2013) Urban violence in France and England: Comparing Paris (2005) and London (2011). Policing and Society23(1): 6–25.
7.
Body-GendrotSSavitchHV (2012) Urban violence in the United States and France: Comparing Los Angeles (1992) and Paris (2005). In: MossbergerKClarkeSEJohnP (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Urban Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
8.
CliftonHAllisonE (2011) Manchester and Salford: A tale of two riots. Guardian, 6thDecember.
9.
DruryJReicherSD (2009) Collective psychological empowerment as a model of social change: Researching crowds and power. Journal of Social Issues65(4): 707–725.
10.
FassinD (2013) Enforcing Order: An Ethnography of Urban Policing. Cambridge: Polity Press.
11.
GaddD (2015) In the aftermath of violence: What constitutes a responsive response?British Journal of Criminology55(6): 1031–1039.
12.
GarlandD (2013) Penality and the penal state. Criminology51(3): 475–517.
13.
HAC [House of Commons Home Affairs Committee] (2011) Policing Large-scale Disorder. London: House of Commons.
14.
HaineWS (2006) Culture and Customs of France. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
15.
HörnqvistM (2014) On the fluid legitimacy of the Husby riots. European Society of Criminology Newsletter13: 4–7.
16.
IPCC [Independent Police Complaints Commission] (2012) Report of the Investigation into a Complaint Made by the Family of Mark Duggan about Contact with them Immediately after his Death. Independent Investigation Final Report, London: IPCC.
17.
JobardF (2008) The 2005 French urban unrests: Data-based interpretations. Sociology Compass2(4): 1287–1302.
18.
KingMWaddingtonD (2006) Flashpoints revisited: a critical application to the policing of anti-globalization protest. Policing and Society15(3): 255–282
LagrangeH (2009) The French riots and urban segregation. In: WaddingtonDJobardFKingM (eds) Rioting in the UK and France: A Comparative Analysis. Cullompton: Willan.
21.
LewisPNewburnTTaylorMBallJ (2011) Blame the police: Why the rioters said they took part. Guardian, 5December.
22.
LightowlersCQuirkH (2015) The 2011 English riots: Prosecutorial zeal and judicial abandon. British Journal of Criminology55(1): 65–85.
23.
MalmbergBAnderssonEÖsthJ (2013) Segregation and urban unrest in Sweden. Urban Geography34(7): 1031–1046.
24.
MasonP (2012) Why It’s Still Kicking Off Everywhere: The New Global Revolutions. London: Verso.
25.
MPS [Metropolitan Police Service] (2012) Four Days in August: Strategic Review into the Disorder of August 2011. London: MPS.
26.
Ministry of Justice (2012) Statistical Bulletin on the Public Disorder of 6th and 9th August 2011 – February 2012 update. London: Ministry of Justice.
27.
NewburnT (2015a) The 2011 English riots in recent historical perspective. British Journal of Criminology55(1): 375–392.
NewburnTCooperKDeaconRDiskiR (2015) ‘Shopping for Free’? Looting, consumerism and the 2011 riots. British Journal of Criminology55(5): 987–1004.
30.
NewburnTDiskiRCooperKDeaconRBurchAGrantM (2016) ‘The biggest gang’? Police and people in the 2011 England riots. Policing and Society, doi: 10.1080/10439463.2016.1165220.
PhillipsFrost DSingletonA (2012) Researching the riots. Geographical Journal179(1): 3–10.
33.
Riots, Communities and Victims Panel (2012) After The Riots. London: Riots, Communities and Victims Panel.
34.
RochéS (2006) Le Frisson de l’Emeute, Violences Urbaines et Banlieues. Paris: Le Seuil.
35.
RochéS (2010) Riots. The nature of rioting. Comparative réflexions based on the French case study. In: Herzog-EvansM (ed.) Transnational Criminology Manual. Nijmegen: Wolf Legal Publishers.
36.
RochéSde MaillardJ (2009) Crisis in policing: The French rioting of 2005. Policing3(1): 34–40.
37.
SalaniéB (2006) The riots in France: An economist’s view. ‘Riots in France’, Social Science Research Council web essays, 11June. URL (accessed 18 February 2016): http://riotsfrance.ssrc.org/Salanie/
38.
SassenS (2010) The city: Its return as a lens for social theory. Theory, Culture and Society1: 3–10.
39.
SchierupC-UÅlundAKingsL (2014) Reading the Stockholm riots – a moment for social justice?Race and Class55(3): 1–21.
40.
SchneiderC (2014) Police Power and Race Riots: Urban Unrest in Paris and New York. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania Press.
41.
StensonK (2012) ‘Ealing calling’: Riot in the Queen of London’s suburbs. Criminal Justice Matters87(1): 12–13.
42.
ThriftN (2009) Space: The fundamental stuff of geography. In: CliffordNJHollowaySLRiceSPValentineG (eds) Key Concepts in Geography, 2nd edn.London: Sage.
43.
TonryM (2015) Is cross-national comparative research on the criminal justice system useful?European Journal of Criminology12(4): 505–516.
44.
WaddingtonDJonesKCritcherC (1989) Flashpoints: Studies in Public Disorder. London: Routledge.
45.
WarrenZJPowerSA (2015) It’s contagious: Rethinking a metaphor dialogically. Culture and Psychology21(3): 359–379.
