Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This paper introduces the idea of ‘foil comparisons’, ones where the overriding goal is to change given practices in the light of what are claimed to be better (or, sometimes, worse) practices elsewhere. Using as an example a recent blog about what can be learned from Italian juvenile justice, it shows the potential weaknesses of such comparisons in terms of understanding other people’s practices. But it also warns that they are becoming ever more common.

Keywords

Comparative criminal justice comparative criminology foil comparisons Italian juvenile justice

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aebi

Delgrande

(2010) Council of Europe Annual Penal Statistics – SPACE I. Survey 2008. Strasbourg: Council of Europe and University of Lausanne.

Aromaa

Heiskanen

(eds) (2008) Crime and Criminal Justice Systems in Europe and North America 1995–2004. HEUNI Helsinki Publication 55.

Audit Commission (1996) Misspent Youth: The Challenge for Youth Justice. London.

Braithwaite

(1989) Crime, Shame and Integration. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Brauzzi

Ciuffo

Viggiani

(2013) Studio sull-applicazione degli articoli 20, 21 D.P.R. 448/88. Ministero della Giustizia. URL (accessed 26 March 2015): http://www.giustiziaminorile.it/rsi/studi/art20e21.pdf.

Case

Haines

(2009) Understanding Youth Offending: Risk Factor Research, Policy and Practice. Cullompton: Willan.

Cavallo

(2002) Ragazzi senza: Disagio, devianza e delinquenza. Milan: Mondadori.

Chessa

Gasparini

Poli

(2008) La messa alla prova nella esperienza del Giudice per l’udienza preliminare presso il Tribunale per i minorenni di Milano. Minori giustizia 4: 102–118.

Colamussi

Mestitz

(2012) Devianza minorile e recidiva. Prosciogliere, punire o responsabilizzare? Milan: Franco Angeli.

10.

Downes

(1988) Contrasts in Tolerance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

11.

Farrington

(1996) The explanation and prevention of youthful offending. In: Hawkins

(ed.) Delinquency and Crime: Current Theories. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 68–148.

12.

Field

Nelken

(2007) Youth justice: A comparison of Italy and Wales. In: Gessner

Nelken

(eds) European Ways of Law. Oxford: Hart, 349–374.

13.

Field

Nelken

(2010) Reading and writing youth justice in Italy and Wales. Punishment and Society 12: 287–308.

14.

Franke

(1990) Dutch tolerance: Facts and fables. British Journal of Criminology 130: 81–93.

15.

Gatti

(2002) La delinquenza giovanile. In: Barbagli

Gatti

(eds) La Criminalità in Italia. Bologna: Il Mulino, 159–170.

16.

Gatti

Verde

(2002) Comparative juvenile justice: An overview on Italy. In: Winterdyk

(ed.) Juvenile Justice Systems: International Perspectives, 2nd edn. Toronto: Canadian Scholars Press, 297–320.

17.

Gili

Pieroni

(2013) L’applicazione della messa alla prova nella riduzione del tasso di recidiva: Primi risultati. In: Gili

Zanghi

Mastropasqua

Leogrande

Pieroni

Totaro

(eds) La recidiva nei percorsi penali dei minori autori di reato. Rome: Gangemi Editore, 89.

18.

Gili

Zanghi

Mastropasqua

Leogrande

Pieroni

Totaro

(eds) (2013) La recidiva nei percorsi penali dei minori autori di reato. Rome: Gangemi Editore.

19.

Giostra

(ed.) (2001) Il processo penale minorile. Milan: Giuffrè.

20.

Goldson

(2011) The 2011 Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour. ‘Time for a Fresh Start’, but is this it? Youth Justice 11: 3–27.

21.

Goldson

Hughes

(2010) Academic intervention and sociological criminology and youth justice: Comparative policy analysis. Criminology and Criminal Justice 10.

22.

Green

(2008) When Children Kill Children: Penal Populism and Political Culture. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

23.

Hazel

(2008) Cross-national Comparison of Youth Justice. London: Youth Justice Board.

24.

Howard League (2009) Custody panels: Impact of a pilot on juvenile sentencing rates. London: The Howard League for Penal Reform.

25.

Janes

(2008) Criminal liability of minors and severity of penalties: European trends and developments. London: The Howard League for Penal Reform (England and Wales).

26.

Johnson

(2000) Prosecutor culture in Japan and the USA. In: Nelken

(ed.) Contrasting Criminal Justice. Aldershot: Ashgate, 157–204.

27.

Lappi-Seppälä

(2007) Penal policy in Scandinavia. Crime and Justice 36: 217–295.

28.

Loader

Sparks

(2010) Public Criminology. London: Routledge.

29.

McAra

McVie

(2007) Youth justice? The impact of system contact on patterns of desistance from offending. European Journal of Criminology 4: 315–345.

30.

Maggiolini

Ciceri

Macchi

Marchesi

Pisa

(2008) La valutazione del rischio di recidiva nei servizi della giustizia minorile. Rassegna Italiana di Criminologia 3: 481–495.

31.

Mastropasqua

Bracalenti

Leogrande

(eds) (2013) ‘Seconda Chance’: Prevenzione del rischio di recidiva per i minori stranieri presenti nel circuito penale. Fondo Europeo per l’integrazione dei cittadini di paesi terzi 2007–2013 azione 2. Istituto Psicoanalytico per le Ricerche Sociali.

32.

Muncie

(2008) The ‘punitive turn’ in juvenile justice: Cultures of control and rights compliance in Western Europe and the USA. Youth Justice 8: 107–121.

33.

Nelken

(2001) Introduction. In: Nelken

Feest

(eds) Adapting Legal Cultures. Aldershot: Ashgate, 1–52.

34.

Nelken

(2005) When is a society non-punitive? A case-study of Italy. In: Pratt

. (eds) The New Punitiveness: Current Trends, Theories, Perspectives. Cullompton: Willan Books, 218–238.

35.

Nelken

(2006a) Italian juvenile justice: Tolerance, leniency or indulgence? Youth Justice 6: 107–128.

36.

Nelken

(2006b) Italy: A lesson in tolerance? In: Muncie

Goldson

(eds) Comparative Youth Justice: Critical Issues. London: Sage, 159–176.

37.

Nelken

(2010) Comparative Criminal Justice: Making Sense of Difference. London: SAGE Publications.

38.

Nelken

(2014) The changing roles of social indicators: From explanation to governance. In: Alldridge

Cheliotis

Mitsilegas

(eds) Globalisation, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice: Theoretical, Comparative and Transnational Perspectives. Oxford: Hart.

39.

Pitts

(2001) The New Politics of Youth Crime. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

40.

Pratt

Eriksson

(2013) Contrasts in Punishment: An Explanation of Anglophone Excess and Nordic Exceptionalism. London: Routledge.

41.

Ricciotti

(2001) La giustizia penale minorile, 2nd edn. CEDAM.

42.

Savelsberg

(2011) Globalization and states of punishment. In: Nelken

(ed.) Comparative Criminal Justice and Globalization. Aldershot: Ashgate, 69–86.

43.

Scalia

Mannoia

(2008) I minori sono cosa nostra? Criminalità organizzata, devianza minorile e sistema giudiziario a Palermo e a Catania. Sociologia del diritto 3: 113–138.

44.

Scardaccione

(1997) Gli studi sul recidivismo: Vecchi e nuovi modelli. Rassegna Penitenziaria e criminologica 1(1–2): 9–28.

45.

Scatolera

(2004) Devianza minorile e coercizione personale. Questione Giustizia 2–3: 397–411.

46.

Scivoletto

(1999.) C’è Tempo per Punire. Percorsi di Probation. Milan: Franco Angeli.

47.

Sherman

Gottfredson

MacKenzie

Eck

Reuter

Bushway

(1998) Preventing crime: What works, what doesn’t, what’s promising. National Institute of Justice, Research in Brief, July. URL (accessed 26 March 2015): https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/171676.PDF.

48.

Ugelvik

(2012) The dark side of a culture of equality: Reimagining communities in a Norwegian remand prison. In: Ugelvik

Dullum

(eds) Penal Exceptionalism? Nordic Prison Policy and Practice. London: Routledge, 121–138.

49.

Von Hofer

(2003) Prison populations as political constructs: The case of Finland, Holland and Sweden. Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention 4(1): 2003: 21–38.

50.

Watson

(1974) Legal Transplants. Athens: University of Georgia Press.

Foil comparisons or foiled comparisons? Learning from Italian juvenile justice

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References