Literature on the psychological reaction to environments with and without windows is reviewed. It is concluded that acceptance of a windowless space is governed by the characteristics of the space itself. Beneficial qualities of windows include view, sunshine, daylight, and spaciousness. View appears critical in determining preferred size and shape of windows. The paper is an extended summary of NBS Building Science series publication 70.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Langdon, F.J. , and Loudon, A.G., Discomfort in schools from overheating in summer, J. Instn Heat. Vent. Engnrs, 37, 265-274 (1970).
Arnold, C.J. , Take out the windows, Educ. Screen & Audio-Visual Guide , 40, 280-296 (1961).
4.
McDonald, E.G. , Opinions differ on windowless classrooms, Nat. Educ. Assoc. J., 50, 12-14 (1961).
5.
Brown, S.W. and Hult, E.E., New York's first windowless air-conditioned school, ASHRAE J., 47-51 (Jan. 1967).
6.
Nimnicht, G.P. , Windows and school design, Phi Delta Kappan, 47, 305-307 (1966).
7.
Burts,E., Windowless classrooms: windows help to promote better classroom learning , NEA J., 50,13-14 (Oct. 1961 ).
8.
Perkins, L.B. , Windows and learning, US Glass Met. & Glazing, 11-14 (Oct. 1966).
9.
Demos, G.D., Controlled physical classroom environments and their effect upon elementary school children (windowless classroom study), Riverside County, California, Palm Springs School District (1965).
10.
Demos, G.D. , Davis, S., and Zuwaylif, F.F., Controlled physical environments, Building Res., 4, 60-62 (1967).
11.
Larson, C. T. (ed.), The effect of windowless classrooms on elementary school children, Architectural Research Laboratory, Department of Architecture, University of Michigan (1965).
12.
Chambers, J.A. , A study of attitudes and feelings toward windowless classrooms, EdD dissertation, University of Tennessee (1963). [Dissertation Abstracts24, 4498 (1963- 1964)].
13.
Gingold, W. , The effects of physical environments on children's behavior in the classroom, PhD thesis, University of Wisconsin (1971). [Dissertation Abstracts32, 2947 (1971)].
14.
Tikkanen, K.T. , Significance of windows in classrooms, MA thesis , University of California at Berkeley ( 1970).
15.
Tikkanen, K.T. , Significance of windows in classrooms, Evaluation of built-in environments by a comparative method (1 Nov. 1972 ).
16.
Karmel, L.J. , Effects of windowless classroom environments on high school students, Percep. & Motor Skills, 20, 277-278 (1965).
17.
Tognoli, J. , The effect of windowless rooms and unembellished surroundings on attitudes and retention, Environ. Behavior , 5, 191-201 (1973).
18.
Industrial lighting in windowless factories, Light Ltg, 57, 265-269 (1964).
19.
Hollister, F.D. , A report on the problems of windowless environments , Greater London Council (1968).
20.
Plant, C.G.H. , The light of day, Light Ltg , 63, 292-296 (1970).
21.
Carlier, R. , Design of windowless factories in Belgium, Inst. Technique du Batiment et des Travaux Publics, Annales , 22 (262), 1441-1483 (1969 ).
22.
Hopkinson, R.G., and Collins, J.B., The ergonomics of lighting, MacDonald (1970).
23.
Ruys, Windowless offices , MA thesis, University of Washington ( 1970).
24.
Sommer, R., Tight spaces: hard architecture and how to humanize it, Prentice Hall, New Jersey (1974).
25.
Manning, P. , Lighting in relation to other components of the total environment, Trans. Ilium. Engng Soc. (London) , 33, 159-168 (1968).
26.
Kornfeld, D.S. , Psychiatric view of the intensive care unit, Br. Med. J., 1, 108 -110 (1969).
27.
Margolis, G.J. , Postoperative psychosis on the intensive care unit, Comprehensive Psychiatry, 8, 227-232 (1967).
28.
Wilson, L.M. , Intensive care delirium; the effect of outside deprivation in a windowless unit, Arch. Internal Medicine , 130, 225-226 (1972).
29.
Abram, H.S. , and Gill, B.F., Predictions of postoperative psychiatric complications, New EnglandJ. Medicine, 265, 1123-1128 (1961).
30.
Morse, R.M. , and Litin, E.M., Postoperative delirium: a study of etiologic factors, Am. J. Psychiatry, 126, 388-395 (1969).
31.
Vaisrub, S. , Windows for the soul, Arch. Internal Medicine, 130, 297 (1972).
32.
Griffith, J.W., Design of windows, Proc. Building Research Institute conference on Solar effects on building design, 95-101 (1962).
33.
Juillerat, E.E., Fire hazards of windowless buildings, Nat. Fire Protection Assoc. Q., 22-30 (July 1964).
Markus, T.A. , The function of windows: a reappraisal, Building Sci., 2, 97-121 (1967).
36.
Markus, T.A. , The significance of sunshine and view for office workers, in Sunlight in buildings, Proc. CIE conference, Rotterdam, 59-93 (1967).
37.
Cooper, J.R. , Wiltshire, T., and Hardy, A.C., Attitudes toward the use of heat rejecting/low light transmission glasses in office buildings, Proc. CIE conference, Istanbul, on Windows and their function in architectural design (1973).
38.
Ludlow, A.M. , The broad classification of the visual scene: A preliminary study, Vision and lighting, Report3 (GIB) (Nov. 1972).
39.
Ludlow, A.M. , Perceptual concepts of tne view and their influence on the design of windows , talk given at BRE conference on Perception of the external world, London ·(Oct. 1974 ).
40.
Ludlow, A.M. , The visual amenity of the window. Luterg report 170, sponsored by Glass in Building (March 1975).
41.
Kaplan, S., and Wendt, J.S., Preference and the visual environment: complexity and some alternatives , Proc. EDRA 3/ar 8 conference, University of California at Los Angeles, 1, paper 6. 8 (1972).
42.
Ne' eman, E. , and Hopkinson, R.G., Critical minimum acceptable window size, a study of window design and provision of a view, Ltg Res. & Technol., 2, 17-27 (1970).
43.
Keighley, E.C. , Visual requirements and reduced fenestration in offices-A study of multiple apertures and window area, J. Building Sci., 8, 321-331 (1973).
44.
Keighley, E.C. , Visual requirements and reduced fenestration in office buildings-a study of window shape, J. Building Sci. , 8, 311-320 (1973).
Wurtman, R.J. , Effects of light and visual stimuli on endocrine function, in Ganong, W. F. (ed.), Neuroendocrinology, 19-59, Academic Press , New York (1967).
48.
Ott, J.N. , Effects of wavelengths of light on physiological functions of plants and animals, Illum. Engng,60, 254-261 (1965).
49.
Ott, J.N. , Health and light, Devon-Adair, Old Greenwich (1973).
50.
Thorington, L. , Cunningham, L., and Parascandola , J., The illuminant in the prevention and photo-therapy of hyperbilirubinemia, Illum. Engng, 66, 240-249 (1971).
51.
O'Sullivan, P.E., Integrated environmental design of buildings, Proc. EDRA 3/ar 8 conference, University of California at Los Angeles, 2, paper 25.2 (Jan. 1972).
52.
Lowson, J.C. , Combined use of natural and artificial light in offices, IES Ltg Rev., 9-13 (Feb. 1970).
53.
Button, D.A. , Control of daylight, noise and heat by the building structure, LtgRes. & Technol., 2, 225-231 (1970).
54.
Jackson, G.K. , and Holmes, J.G., Let's keep it simple (11)-daylight design , Light Ltg, 66, 59-60 (1973).
55.
Jackson, G.K. , and Holmes, J.G., Let's keep it simple (12)-what we want from daylight, Light Ltg, 66, 80-82 (1973).
56.
Wells, B.W.P. , Subjective responses to the lighting installation in a modern office building and their design implications, Building Sci., 1, 57-68 (1965).
57.
Manning, P. (ed.), Office design: a study of environment, Pilkington Research Unit, Liverpool University Department of Building Science (1965 ).
58.
Bitter, C., and van Ierland, J.F.A.A. , Appreciation of sunlight in the home. Proc. CIE conference, Rotterdam, 27-37 (1967).
59.
Hopkinson, R.G. , The psychophysics of sunlighting, Proc. CIE conference, Rotterdam, 13-19 (1967).
60.
Grandjean, E. , Gilgen, A., and Barrier, A., Etude sur 1'ensoleillement d'habitations , Proc. international conference on The sun in the service of mankind, Paris (1973).
61.
Ne'eman, E. , Visual aspects of sunlight in buildings, LtgRes. & Technol., 6, 159-164 (1974).
62.
Longmore, J. , and Ne'eman, E., The availability of sunshine and human requirements for sunlight in building, presented at conference on Environmental research in real buildings, NIC Committee TC 3. 3, Cardiff (1973).
63.
Goromosov, S.M. , The physiological basis of health standards for dwellings-World Health Organization, chapters 1,2,3 and 5 ( 1963).
64.
Leposky, G. , There's more to light than meets the eye, Inland Archit., 20-22 (Feb. 1974).
65.
Richards, S.J. , Sunlight and buildings, South African Archit. Record, 52, (12) (1967).
66.
Morgan, C.J. , Sunlight and its effect on human behavior and performance, Proc. CIE conference, Rotterdam, 21-26 (1967).
67.
Brierly, E.S. , Sunshine, daylight, visual privacy and view in housing, Building, 11,119-123 (1971).
68.
Markus, T.A. and Gray, A., Windows in low rise, high density housing-The psychological significance of sunshine, daylight, view and visual privacy , Proc. CIE conference on Windows and their function in architectural design, Istanbul ( 1973).
69.
Hopkinson, R.G., Glare from daylighting in buildings, Appl . Ergonomics, 34, 206-215 (1972).
70.
Inui, M., and Miyata, T., Spaciousness in interiors, LtgRes. & Technol. , 5, 103-111 (1973).
71.
Collingro, C. , and Roessler, G., Influence of window width on the communication with the external environment in a room with PSALI, Proc. CIE Study Group A symposium, Varna ( 1972).
72.
Mercer, J.C. , On measuring the effect of a window, Archit. Res. & Teaching, 2, 53-55 (Nov. 1971 ).
73.
Imamoglu, V., and Markus, T.A., The effect of window size, room proportion and window position on spaciousness evaluation of rooms, Proc. CIE conference on Windows and their function in architectural design, Istanbul (1973).
74.
Aldworth, R.C. , and Bridgers, D.J., Design for variety in lighting, LtgRes. & Technol., 3, 8-20 (1971).
75.
Windowless building best for research project, Engng News Record, 166, 28 (9 Fab. 1961).
so Baker, G., and Funaro, B., Windows in modern architecture, Architectural Book Publishing Co., New York (1948).
81.
Beckett, H.E. , and Godfrey, J.A., Windows: performance, design and installation , Crosby Lock-wood Staples/ R,IBA , London (1974).
82.
Bell, J.A.M. , Development and practice in the daylighting of buildings, LtgRes. & Technol., 5, 173-185 (1973).
83.
Bennett, I. , Natural daylight illumination-its relation to isolation, Illum. Engng, 57, 145-149 (1962).
84.
Button, D.A. , Research into performance requirements for windows and window glass products . Paper presented at 6th CIB Congress, Budapest (1974 ).
85.
Catlin, G., The growing case for the daylighted school, Tech. Service Memo, Pittsburgh Plate Glass (9 Sept. 1966).
86.
Cockram, A.H. , and Collins, J.B., Permanent supplementary artificial lighting of deep hospital wards, LtgRes. & Technol., 2, 174-185 (1970).
87.
Cockram, A.H. , and Collins, J.B., Lighting of hospital circulation spaces which are open to bed bays, LtgRes. & Technol. , 6, 69-79 (1974).
88.
Collins, J.B. , and Plant, C.G.H., Preferred luminance distribution in windowless spaces, LtgRes. & Technol., 3, 219-231 (1971).
89.
Cooper, J.R. , Wiltshire, T.J., and Warren, B., Glazing considerations for buildings (sponsored by Glass in Buildings, date unknown).
90.
Croghan, D. , Daylight study; daylight and the form of office buildings, Archit. J., 142, 1502-1508 (1965 ).
91.
Croghan, D. , and Hawkes, D., Daylighting in dwellings ; analysis of a questionnaire, Archit. J., 149, 585-589 (1969).
92.
Cuttle, C., The sharpness and the flow of light in Küller, R. (ed.), Architectural psychology, Studentlitteratur ab Sweden (1973).
93.
Daytime lighting of buildings: Report of an IES symposium, Ltg Res. & Technol., 6, 104-111 (1974).
94.
Ferguson, R.S. , The requirement for windows, Building Use Note 29, Division of Building Research, National Research Council of Canada (1968).
95.
Grandjean, E. , Ergonomics of the home, Halstead Press, New York, 198-207, 230-244 (1973).
96.
Grimm, C.T., Jones, J.W., Vliet, G.C., and Pyhrr, S.A., Relative thermal and economic performance of masonry and glass building enclosures . Texas State Building Materials and Systems Testing Laboratory. Texas Department of Community Affairs ( 1975).
97.
Griffith, J.W., Design of windows. Solar effects on building design. Building Research Institute conference (1962).
98.
Hardy, A.C., and O'Sullivan, P., Insolation and fenestration, Oriel Press, London (1967).
99.
Hill, A.R., Vision through meshes: a summary report, LtgRes. & Technol. , 1, 54-56 (1969).
100.
gohm, W., and Roessler, G., Sunlight in dwellings, Proc. CIE Study Group A symposium, Varna, (1972).
Hopkinson, R.G. , Daylight as a cause of glare, Light Ltg, 56, 222-226 (1963).
103.
Hopkinson, R.G., and Longmore , J., The permanent supplementary artificial lighting of interiors, Trans. Illum. Engng Soc. (London), 24, 121-148 (1959).
104.
Krochmann, J. , On the physical and psychophysiological meaning of windows for the environment in interiors, Proc. international conference on The sun in the service of mankind, Paris (1973).
105.
Logan, H.L., How long will you live ?Proc. 5th annual meeting, AIA architect-researcher's conference, 295-315 (1968).
106.
Longmore,J. ,Daylighting: a current view. Light Ltg, 113-119 (1975).
107.
Loudon, A.G. , Summertime temperatures in buildings without air-conditioning, Paper presented at IHVE/BRS symposium on Thermal environment in modern buildings-aspects affecting the design team (1968).
108.
Malarky, J.T. , Architectural economics related to comfort, productivity and glass, NBS Special Publication 361, vol. 1, Performance concept in buildings, Proc. joint RILEM-ASTM-CIB symposium , Philadelphia, USA (1972).
109.
Manning, P. , Daylighted or windowless design for single-story factories ? Light Ltg, 56, 188-192 (1963).
110.
Markus, T.A. , Window design in Europe: a review of recent research for solar effects on building design, Conference of Building Research Institute, 119-140 (1962).
111.
Markus, T.A. , Architectural aspects of windows.Economic aspects of daylighting. The real cost of a window-an exercise in cost benefit study in building design, Proc. CIE conference on Windows and their function in architectural design , Istanbul (1973).
Markus, T.A. , Window requirements in housing.Talk given at BRE conference on Perception of the external world, London (1974 ).
114.
Morisseau, J.J., Peak preview of windowless school experience , Am. School Board J., June 27-30, year unknown.
115.
Ne'eman, E., Visual aspects of sunlight in buildings, Proc. international conference on The sun in the service of mankind, Paris (1973).
116.
Ne'eman, E., and Hopkinson, R.G., The design of windows in relation to outside view, interior form, sunshine and activity. Paper presented at BRE conference on Perception of the external world, London (1974).
117.
Ne'eman, E., and Longmore, J., Physical aspects of windows: Integration of daylight with artificial light , Proc. CIE conference on Windows and their function in architectural design, Istanbul (1973 ).
118.
Platzker, J. , The first 100 windowless schools in the USA , Paper presented at educational workshop, 28th annual convention of National Association of Architectural Metal Manufacturers (1966).
119.
privacy, Building Res. & Practice, 30-31 (Jan/ Feb. 1973).
120.
Sandström, C.I. , The shortcomings of psychophysics in determining architectural spaces, Proc. CIE Study Group A, symposium, Varna (1972).
121.
Schwartz, B. , The social psychology of privacy, in Gutman, R. (ed.), People and buildings, Basic Books, New York , 152-169 (1972).
122.
Smith, K.C. , The science of photobiology, Bioscience, 24, 45-48 (1974).
123.
S611ner,G. , Glare from luminous ceilings, Lichttechnik,24 (11) (1972). [Library translation 1760 of BRE,Garston ( 1973)].
124.
Sommer, R., Personal space; the behavioral basis of design, Prentice Hall, New Jersey (1969), esp. pp. 98-119.
125.
Tikkanen,K.T. , Window factors in schools. Part 2, Overhead natural lighting, Helsinki University of Technology (Feb. 1974).
126.
Tikkanen, K.T., A study of the emotional reactions to light and colour in a school, environment, Ltg Res.& Technol. , 8, 27-30 (1976).
127.
Tourtelot, E.M., Glass and academics, US Glass, Metal & Glazing (April 1967).
128.
Turner, D. P. (ed), Windows and environment. McCorquodale/Pilkington Environmental Advisory Service (1969).
129.
Wenzler, O.F. , How to relate daylighting requirements to building design, US Glass Metal & Glazing, 18-21 (Jan. 1967 ).
130.
Woodford, G.P. , Innovation and continuity, planning for sunlight in housing, Proc. international conference on The sun in the service of mankind, Paris ( 1973).
131.
Wotton, E. , Some considerations affecting the inclusion of windows in office facades, Ltg Des. & Applic., 6, 32-40 (1976).
132.
Wright, H., Environmental technology as a design determinant, Presented at American Standards symposium on Man and his environment , Toronto (1966).
