The influence of illumination level on prolonged work performance

Abstract

The paper discusses the effects of illumination ieveis on prolonged work performance. Measurements have been taken of speed, accuracy, fatigue, vigilance, critical flicker frequency, liminal brightness increment and subjective responses from subjects working for two-hour periods at fixed illumination levels. The results, from fourteen subjects, revealed that illumination level had little effect on accuracy or vigilance. The predominant effect was on the speed of working. It was found that after an initial practice period, a decrease in speed of working and an increase in the variability of speed of working occurred at low illumination levels. These fatigue effects on performance were supported by an adverse change in a physiological measurement, namely the liminal brightness increment, after work at the lowest illumination level. The subjective results were in reasonable agreement with the performance results. It is concluded that there existed an optimum range of target luminances (147-344 cd m^-2 ) over which superior prolonged performance of the experimental task could be obtained.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Simonson, E. , and Brozek, J. , J. Opt. Soc. Am., 38, 384 (1948).

Tinker, M.A. , Amer. J. Psychol., 65, 600 (1952).

Weston, H.C. , Med. Res. Council, Industrial Health Research Board, Report No. 87 (1954).

Grandjean, E. Von , and Battig, K. , Helv. Physiol. Acta, 13, 198 (1955).

Bills, A.C. , Amer. J. Psychol., 43, 230 (1931).

Bartiett, F. , Fatigue, p. I, H. K. Lewis, London (1953).

Welford, A.T. , Fatigue, p. 183, H. K. Lewis, London (1953).

Edholm, O.G. , The biology of work, p. I88, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London (1967).

Weston, H.C. , Sight, light and work, H. K. Lewis, London (1962).

10.

Weston, H.C. , Bridgers, D.J. , and Ledger, J. , Ergonomics, 6, 267 (1963).

11.

Muck, E. , and Bodmann, H.W. , Lichttechnik, 13, 502 (1961).

12.

Anon., Lichttechnik, 8, 296 (1956).

13.

Better industrial lighting, the economic case, British Lighting Council, London ( 1966).

14.

Eastmann, A.A. , and Delaney, W.B. , Illum. Engng, 61, 366 (1966).

15.

Muck, E. , and Bodmann, H.W. , Lichttechnik, 13, 512(1961).

16.

Söllner, G. , Report No I.I4/22, Philips Lighting Laboratory, Aachen (unpublished).

17.

Bodmann, H.W. ; Sollner, G. , and Voit, E. , Proc. CIE Vienna, C, 502 (1963).

18.

Balder, J.J. , Lichttechnik, 9, 455 (1957).

19.

Riemenschneider, W. , Bull. SEV 58 (1967).

20.

Westhoff, J.M. , and Horeman, H.W. , contribution

21.

to Bodmann, H.W. , Lichttechnik, 14, 24 (1963).

22.

Fischer, D. , Optimale Beteuchtungsniveaus in Arbeitsräumen, Lichttechnik (to be published).

23.

Poulton, E.C. , and Freeman, P.R. , Unwanted asymmetrical transfer effects with balanced experimental designs, Psychol. Bull., 66 (I), I (1966).

24.

Muck, E. , and Bodmann, H.W. , Die Bedeutung des Beleuchtungsniveaus bei praktischer Sehtatigkeit, Lichttechnik, 13, 502 (1961).

25.

Stone, P.T. , and Groves, S.D.P. , Discomfort glare and visual performance, Trans. Illum. Eng. Soc. (London), 33, I, 9 (1968).

26.

Simonson, E. , and Brozek, J. , The effect of spectral quality of light on visual performance and fatigue , J. Opt. Soc. Amer., 38 (10), 830 (1948).

27.

Lion, J.S. , Richardson, E. , and Browne, R.C. , A study of the performance of industrial inspectors under two kinds of lighting , Ergonomics, II (I), 23 (1968).

28.

Chernílovskaya, F.M. , The effect of flicker of fluorescent lamps on the state of the visual function and working efficiency of man, Svetotehhnika, 4 (12), 6 (1968).

29.

Masekene, K.S. , A study of the operating efficiency of workers under conditions of an industrial lighting installation supplied at an increased frequency, Svetotekhnika, 14 (8), 5 (1960).