Visual fatigue has become a public health issue, while the relevant retinal mechanism and characteristics of blue light that induce visual fatigue have been rarely studied. In the retina, both short wavelength-sensitive (S) cones and melanopsin-containing intrinsically photoreceptive retinal ganglion cells (ipRGCs) are sensitive to blue light, and their responses are opposite in pupil mediation. Thus, effects of blue-enriched white light with different S-cone-opic Equivalent Daylight Illuminance (EDI) on visual fatigue was investigated, maintaining the same melanopic EDI to avoid interferences of melanopsin-containing ipRGCs. Two white illuminants (one with low S-cone-opic EDI, the other with high S-cone-opic EDI) were characterized based on α-opic EDI with the same correlated colour temperature and illuminance. Melanopic EDI was lower than S-cone-opic EDI of these two illuminants. Psychological, visual, physiological and cognitive performances were measured to investigate visual fatigue. Results showed that blue-enriched white light with high S-cone-opic EDI can induce visual fatigue. Participants felt more discomfort in their eyes under high S-cone-opic EDI along with the decline of tear film stability and changes of heart rhythm. Furthermore, the reaction time in a memory task increased significantly under high S-cone-opic EDI. The findings provide new insights into the optimization of indoor lighting environments for human health.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
LambooijMIjsselsteijnWFortuinMHeynderickxI. Visual discomfort and visual vatigue of stereoscopic displays: a review. Journal of Imaging Science and Technology2009; 53: 1–14.
2.
HanCCLiuRLiuRRZhuZHYuRBMaL. Prevalence of asthenopia and its risk factors in Chinese college students. International Journal of Ophthalmology2013; 6: 718–722.
3.
WangYZhongXZhangYTuYWangLChenY, et al. Visual fatigue following long-term visual display terminal work under different light sources. Lighting Research and Technology2017; 49: 1034–1051.
4.
LinCJFengWYChaoCJTsengFY. Effects of VDT workstation lighting conditions on operator visual workload. Industrial Health2008; 46: 105–111.
5.
LinYHChenCYLuSYLinYC. Visual fatigue during VDT work: effects of time-based and environment-based conditions. Displays2008; 29: 487–492.
6.
YuHAkitaT. Influence of ambient-tablet PC luminance ratio on legibility and visual fatigue during long-term reading in low lighting environment. Displays2020; 62: 101943.
7.
TsubotaK. Short tear film breakup time-type dry eye. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science2018; 59: DES64–DES70.
8.
AryalAGhahramaniABecerik-GerberB. Monitoring fatigue in construction workers using physiological measurements. Automation in Construction2017; 82: 154–165.
9.
ParkSWonMMunSLeeEWhangM. Does visual fatigue from 3D displays affect autonomic regulation and heart rhythm?International Journal of Psychophysiology2014; 92: 42–48.
10.
KimHGCheonEJBaiDSLeeYHKooBH. Stress and heart rate variability: a meta-analysis and review of the literature. Psychiatry Investigation2018; 15: 235–245.
11.
ParkSJOhSBSubramaniyamMLimHK. Human impact assessment of watching 3D television by electrocardiogram and subjective evaluation. Proceedings of the XX IMEKO World Congress-Metrology for Green Growth, Busan, Korea, 9–14 September 2012: 1–4.
12.
ZhaoCZhaoMLiuJZhengC. Electroencephalogram and electrocardiograph assessment of mental fatigue in a driving simulator. Accident Analysis and Prevention2012; 45: 83–90.
13.
MizunoKTanakaMYamagutiKKajimotoOKuratsuneHWatanabeY. Mental fatigue caused by prolonged cognitive load associated with sympathetic hyperactivity. Behavioral and Brain Functions2011; 7: 1–7.
14.
TranYWijesuriyaNTarvainenMKarjalainenPCraigA. The relationship between spectral changes in heart rate variability and fatigue. Journal of Psychophysiology2009; 23: 143–151.
15.
SmoldersKCde KortYACluitmansPJ. A higher illuminance induces alertness even during office hours: findings on subjective measures, task performance and heart rate measures. Physiology and Behavior2012; 107: 7–16.
16.
SoumanJLTingaAMTe PasSFVan EeRVlaskampBN. Acute alerting effects of light: a systematic literature review. Behavioural Brain Research2018; 337: 228–239.
17.
ToftumJThorsethAMarkvartJLogadóttirÁ. Occupant response to different correlated colour temperatures of white LED lighting. Building and Environment2018; 143: 258–268.
18.
FiskASTamSKBrownLAVyazovskiyVVBannermanDMPeirsonSN. Light and cognition: roles for circadian rhythms, sleep, and arousal. Frontiers in Neurology2018; 9: 1–18.
19.
de KortYAW. Tutorial: theoretical considerations when planning research on human factors in lighting. Leukos2019; 15: 85–96.
20.
CajochenCFreyburgerMBasishviliTGarbazzaCRudzikFRenzC, et al. Effect of daylight LED on visual comfort, melatonin, mood, waking performance and sleep. Lighting Research and Technology2019; 51: 1044–1062.
21.
BurattiniCPiccardiLCurcioGFerlazzoFGianniniAMBisegnaF. Cold LED lighting affects visual but not acoustic vigilance. Building and Environment2019; 151: 148–155.
22.
ChellappaSLSteinerRBlattnerPOelhafenPGotzTCajochenC. Non-visual effects of light on melatonin, alertness and cognitive performance: can blue-enriched light keep us alert?Plos One2011; 6: e16429.
23.
ViolaAUJamesLMSchlangenLJDijkDJ. Blue-enriched white light in the workplace improves self-reported alertness, performance and sleep quality. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health2008; 34: 297–306.
24.
te KulveMSchlangenLSchellenLSoumanJLvan Marken LichtenbeltW. Correlated colour temperature of morning light influences alertness and body temperature. Physiology and Behavior2018; 185: 1–13.
25.
LasauskaiteRCajochenC. Influence of lighting color temperature on effort-related cardiac response. Biological Psychology2018; 132: 64–70.
26.
Zielinska-DabkowskaKM. Make lighting healthier. Nature2018; 553: 274–276.
27.
SoumanJLBorraTde GoijerISchlangenLJVlaskampBNLucassenMP. Spectral tuning of white light allows for strong reduction in melatonin suppression without changing illumination level or color temperature. Journal of Biological Rhythms2018; 33: 420–431.
28.
LucasRJPeirsonSNBersonDMBrownTMCooperHMCzeislerCA, et al. Measuring and using light in the melanopsin age. Trends in Neurosciences2014; 37: 1–9.
29.
SpitschanMGardasevicMMartialFPLucasRJAllenAE. Pupil responses to hidden photoreceptor-specific modulations in movies. Plos One2019; 14: e0216307.
30.
WoeldersTLeenheersTGordijnMCHutRABeersmaDGWamsEJ. Melanopsin- and L-cone-induced pupil constriction is inhibited by S- and M-cones in humans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences2018; 115: 792–797.
31.
YamakawaMTsujimuraSOkajimaK. A quantitative analysis of the contribution of melanopsin to brightness perception. Scientific Reports2019; 9: 7568.
32.
AllenAEMartialFPLucasRJ. Form vision from melanopsin in humans. Nature Communications2019; 10: 2274.
33.
MoulandJWMartialFWatsonALucasRJBrownTM. Cones support alignment to an inconsistent world by suppressing mouse circadian responses to the blue colors associated with twilight. Current Biology2019; 29: 4260–4267.
34.
AllenAEHazelhoffEMMartialFPCajochenCLucasRJ. Exploiting metamerism to regulate the impact of a visual display on alertness and melatonin suppression independent of visual appearance. Sleep2018; 41: zsy100.
35.
Commission International de l’Éclairage. System for Metrology of Optical Radiation for ipRGC-Influenced Responses to Light. CIE S 026/E:2018. Vienna: CIE, 2018.
36.
MotamedzadehMGolmohammadiRKazemiRHeidarimoghadamR. The effect of blue-enriched white light on cognitive performances and sleepiness of night-shift workers: a field study. Physiology and Behavior2017; 177: 208–214.
37.
IsonoHKumarAKamimuraTNoguchiYYaguchiH. The effect of blue light on visual fatigue when reading on LED-backlit tablet LCDs. Proceedings of International Display Workshops, Sapporo, Japan, p. VHFp2-9L, 2013.
38.
LinJBGerrattBWBassiCJApteRS. Short-wavelength light-blocking eyeglasses attenuate symptoms of eye fatigue. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science2017; 58: 442–447.
39.
SpitschanMWoeldersT. The method of silent substitution for examining melanopsin contributions to pupil control. Frontiers in Neurology2018; 9: 941.
40.
Commission International de l’Éclairage. Lighting of Work Places. Part 1: Indoor. CIE S 008/E:2001. Vienna: CIE, 2001.
41.
BaliJNeerajNBaliR. Computer vision syndrome: a review. Journal of Clinical Ophthalmology and Research2014; 2: 61–68.
42.
KennedyRSLaneNEBerbaumKSLilienthalMG. Simulator sickness questionnaire: an enhanced method for quantifying simulator sickness. The International Journal of Aviation Psychology1993; 3: 203–220.
43.
BorstingERouseMWMitchellGLScheimanMCotterSACooperJ, et al. Validity and reliability of the revised convergence insufficiency symptom survey in children aged 9 to 18 years. Optometry and Vision Science2003; 80: 832–838.
44.
FoulksGNLempMA. Report of the international dry eye workshop (DEWS). Ocular Surface2007; 5: 65–204.
45.
BaileyILLovie-KitchinJE. Visual acuity testing. From the laboratory to the clinic. Vision Research2013; 90: 2–9.
46.
HansenALJohnsenBHThayerJF. Vagal influence on working memory and attention. International Journal of Psychophysiology2003; 48: 263–274.
47.
OsakaN. The effect of VDU colour on visual fatigue in the fovea and periphery of the visual field. Displays1985; 6: 138–140.
48.
FaulFErdfelderEBuchnerALangAG. Statistical power analyses using G*Power 3.1: tests for correlation and regression analyses. Behavior Research Methods2009; 41: 1149–1160.
49.
LiuCYLiLPZhaoLZhengDCLiPLiuCC. A combination method of improved impulse rejection filter and template matching for identification of anomalous intervals in RR sequences. Journal of Medical and Biological Engineering2012; 32: 245–249.
50.
MangiaficoSS. Summary and analysis of extension program evaluation in R, version 1.20.01. 2016 from http://rcompanion.org/handbook/
51.
CohenJ. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. New York: Routledge, 2013.
52.
LokRJoyceDSZeitzerJM. Impact of daytime spectral tuning on cognitive function. Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology B: Biology2022; 230: 112439.
53.
SchatzAFischerMDSchommerKZrennerEBartz-SchmidtKUGekelerF, et al. Attenuation of S-cone function at high altitude assessed by electroretinography. Vision Research2014; 97: 59–64.
54.
GreensteinVCHoodDCRitchRSteinbergerDCarrRE. S (blue) cone pathway vulnerability in retinitis pigmentosa, diabetes and glaucoma. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science1989; 30: 1732–1737.
55.
SwansonWHBirchDGAndersonJL. S-cone function in patients with retinitis pigmentosa. Investigative Ophthalmology and Visual Science1993; 34: 3045–3055.
56.
ShafferFGinsbergJ. An overview of heart rate variability metrics and norms. Frontiers in Public Health2017; 5: 258.
57.
YudaEOgasawaraHYoshidaYHayanoJ. Suppression of vagal cardiac modulation by blue light in healthy subjects. Journal of Physiological Anthropology2016; 35: 1–9.
58.
AraujoJRodriguesMJPostolacheOCercasFMartínFFMartínezAL. Heart rate variability analysis in healthy subjects under different colored lighting conditions. 2020 IEEE International Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference (I2MTC), Dubrovnik, Croatia. IEEE, 2020: 1–5.
59.
Iskra-GolecIWaznaASmithL. Effects of blue-enriched light on the daily course of mood, sleepiness and light perception: a field experiment. Lighting Research and Technology2012; 44: 506–513.
60.
ChoiSChoiASungM. Cloud-based lighting control systems: fatigue analysis and recommended luminous environments. Building and Environment2022; 214: 108947.
61.
Luque-CasadoAPeralesJCCardenasDSanabriaD. Heart rate variability and cognitive processing: the autonomic response to task demands. Biological Psychology2016; 113: 83–90.
62.
ThayerJFHansenALSaus-RoseEJohnsenBH. Heart rate variability, prefrontal neural function, and cognitive performance: the neurovisceral integration perspective on self-regulation, adaptation, and health. Annals of Behavioral Medicine2009; 37: 141–153.
63.
CammAJMalikMBiggerJTBreithardtGCeruttiSCohenRJ, et al. Heart rate variability: standards of measurement, physiological interpretation and clinical use. European Heart Journal1996; 17: 354–381.
64.
RamirezEOrtegaARDel PasoGAR. Anxiety, attention, and decision making: the moderating role of heart rate variability. International Journal of Psychophysiology2015; 98: 490–496.
65.
SouchetADPhilippeSLourdeauxDLeroyL. Measuring visual fatigue and cognitive load via eye tracking while learning with virtual reality head-mounted displays: a review. International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction2022; 38: 801–824.
66.
DuschekSMuckenthalerMWernerNDel PasoGAR. Relationships between features of autonomic cardiovascular control and cognitive performance. Biological Psychology2009; 81: 110–117.
67.
KimCJParkSWonMJWhangMLeeEC. Autonomic nervous system responses can reveal visual fatigue induced by 3D displays. Sensors2013; 13: 13054–13062.
68.
LiuPForteJSewellDCarterO. Cognitive load effects on early visual perceptual processing. Attention Perception and Psychophysics2018; 80: 929–950.
69.
WangDXieYYangXLuYGuoA. Subjective and objective evaluation of visual fatigue on viewing 3D display continuously. Stereoscopic Displays and Applications XXVI2015; 9391: 238–246.
70.
SpitschanMLazarRYetikECajochenC. No evidence for an S cone contribution to acute neuroendocrine and alerting responses to light. Current Biology2019; 29: R1297–R1298.
71.
VandewalleGMaquetPDijkDJ. Light as a modulator of cognitive brain function. Trends in Cognitive Sciences2009; 13: 429–438.
72.
DaceyDMLiaoHWPetersonBBRobinsonFRSmithVCPokornyJ, et al. Melanopsin-expressing ganglion cells in primate retina signal colour and irradiance and project to the LGN. Nature2005; 433: 749–754.
73.
RuTde KortYASmoldersKCChenQZhouG. Non-image forming effects of illuminance and correlated color temperature of office light on alertness, mood, and performance across cognitive domains. Building and Environment2019; 149: 253–263.
