In the years since the publication of Robert Carroll’s ‘Surplus Meaning and the Conflict of Interpretations: A Dodecade of Jeremiah Studies (1984—95)’, in Currents 4 in 1996, major paradigm shifts in biblical studies have resulted in an unprecedented level of innovation. Increased engagements with the element of chaos in the text and the resultant innovative encounters with this problematic scriptural material include influential contributions from philosophy, cultural and literary theories. The present review surveys the current state of the field of Jeremiah studies by tracing the impact of post-structuralist methodologies of decentring on ways of thinking about and engaging with Jeremiah. It argues that in the aftermath of the widely acknowledged end of the hegemony of historical-criticism as the dominant paradigm of biblical interpretation articulated by Perdue as ‘the collapse of history’, Jeremiah studies has taken on the shape and nature of a dialectic between the principles of order and chaos.
Auld, A.G.1983‘Prophets Through the Looking Glass: Between Writings and Moses’, JSOT27: 3-23.
2.
1984 ‘Prophets and Prophecy in Jeremiah and Kings’ , ZAW96: 66-82.
3.
1990 ‘Prophecy in Books: A Rejoinder’, JSOT48: 31-32.
4.
Bakhtin, M.M.1981The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays (trans. C. Emerson and M. Holquist;Austin: University of Texas Press ).
5.
1984 Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics (trans. C. Emerson; Minneapolis: University of Minnesota).
6.
Barry, P.2002Beginning Theory: An Introduction to Literary and Cultural Theory ( Manchester: Manchester University Press).
7.
Bauer, A.2002‘Death, Grief, Agony, and a New Creation: Re-reading Gender in Jeremiah after September 11’, W&W22.4: 378-86.
8.
Belsey, C.2002Poststructuralism: A Very Short Introduction ( Oxford: Oxford University Press).
9.
Ben Zvi, and E.M. Floyd (eds.) 2000Writings and Speech in Israelite and Ancient Near Eastern Prophecy (SBLSymS, 10; Atlanta: SBL ).
10.
Bible & Culture Collective1997The Postmodern Bible (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
11.
Biddle, M.E.1990A Redaction History of Jeremiah (AThANT , 77; Zurich: TVZ ).
12.
1991 ‘The Figure of Lady Jerusalem: Identification, Deification and Personification of Cities in the Ancient Near East’, in K.L. Younger, B. Batto and W. Hallo (eds.), Biblical Canon in Comparative Perspective (Ancient Near Eastern Texts and Studies, 11; Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press): 173-94.
13.
1996 Polyphony and Symphony in Prophetic Literature: Rereading Jeremiah 7-20 (Studies in Old Testament Interpretation, 2; Macon: Mercer University Press).
14.
Boadt, L.1999‘The Book of Jeremiah and the Power of Historical Recitation’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 339-49.
15.
Boase, E.2006The Fulfilment of Doom? The Dialogic Interaction between the Book of Lamentations and the Pre-Exilic/Early Prophetic Literature (JSOTSup, 437; New York and London : T&T Clark).
16.
Bright, J.1965Jeremiah: Anchor Bible Commentary (AB, 21;Garden City, NY: Doubleday).
17.
1981A History of Israel (Philadelphia: Westminster Press).
18.
1983 ‘Jeremiah’s Complaints: Liturgy, or Expressions of Personal Distress?’, in J. Durham and J. Porter (eds.), Proclamation and Presence: Old Testament Essays in Honor of Gwynne Henton Davies (London: SCM Press): 189-214.
19.
Brueggemann, W.1983‘The Book of Jeremiah: Portrait of the Prophet’ , Int37: 130-45.
20.
1985 ‘A Second Reading of Jeremiah After the Dismantling’ , Ex Auditu1: 156-68.
21.
1986Hopeful Imagination: Prophetic Voices in Exile ( Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
1988b To Pluck Up, To Tear Down: A Commentary on Jeremiah 1-25 (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans; Edinburgh: Handsel Press).
24.
1991To Build, To Plant: A Commentary on Jeremiah 26-52 ( Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans).
25.
1995‘A Shattered Transcendence? Exile and Restoration’ , in S.J. Kraftchick et al. (eds.), Biblical Theology: Problems and Perspectives, in Honor of J. Christiaan Beker (Nashville: Abingdon Press ): 169-82.
26.
1999‘Next Steps in Jeremiah Studies?’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 404-22.
27.
2002‘Meditation upon the Abyss: The Book of Jeremiah’ , W&W22.4: 340-50.
28.
Carroll, C.E.2008‘That’s What She Said: Jeremiah, Six Voices and Counting’ (Paper delivered at the Second Annual Conference on Graduate Interdisciplinary Approaches to the Biblical World, Trinity College, Dublin).
29.
Carroll, R.P.1979When Prophecy Failed: Reactions and Responses to Failure in the Old Testament Prophetic Traditions (London : SCM Press).
30.
1981From Chaos to Covenant: Uses of Prophecy in the Book of Jeremiah (London: SCM Press).
31.
1983 ‘Poets Not Prophets: A Response to "Prophets through the Looking Glass"’, JSOT27: 25-31.
32.
1984 a ‘Prophecy, Dissonance and Jeremiah xxvi’, in Perdue and Kovacs (eds.) 1984: 389-91.
33.
1984 b ‘Theodicy and the Community: The Text and Subtext of Jeremiah V 1-6’, in A.S. Van der Woude (ed.), Prophets, Worship, and Theodicy: Studies in Prophetism, Biblical Theology and Structural and Rhetorical Analysis on the Place of Music in Worship (OTS, 23; Leiden: Brill ): 19-38.
34.
1986 Jeremiah: A Commentary (OTL; London: SCM Press).
35.
1988a ‘Dismantling the Book of Jeremiah and Deconstructing the Prophet’, in M. Augustin and K.D. Schunck (eds.), ‘Wunschet Jerusalem Frieden’: Collected Communications to the XIIth Congress of the International Organisation for the Study of the Old Testament, Jerusalem 1996 (BEATAJ, 13; Frankfurt: Peter Lang): 291-302.
36.
1988b ‘Inventing the Prophets’, IBS 10: 24-36.
37.
1989a Jeremiah (OTG; Sheffield: JSOT Press).
38.
1989b ‘Prophecy and Society’, in R.E. Clements (ed.), The World of Ancient Israel: Sociological, Anthropological and Political Perspectives (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 203-25.
39.
1989c ‘Radical Clashes of Will and Style: Recent Commentary Writing on the Book of Jeremiah’, JSOT45: 99-114.
40.
1990 a ‘Jeremiah’, in R.J. Coggins and J.L. Houlden (eds.), A Dictionary of Biblical Interpretation (London : SCM Press): 331-33.
41.
1990b ‘Whose Prophet? Whose History? Whose Social Reality? Troubling the Interpretive Community Again: Notes Towards a Response to T. W. Overholt’s Critique’, JSOT48: 33-49.
42.
1991‘Arguing about Jeremiah: Recent Studies and the Nature of a Prophetic Book’, in J. Emerton (ed.), Congress Volume: Leuven 1989 (VTSup, 43; Leiden: Brill): 222-35.
43.
1992 a ‘The Discombobulations of Time and the Diversities of the Text: Note on the Rezeptionsgeschichte of the Bible’, in R.P. Carroll (ed.), Text as Pretext: Essays in Honour of Robert Davidson (JSOTSup, 138; Sheffield: JSOT Press): 61-80.
44.
1992 b ‘The Myth of the Empty Land’, in D. Jobling and T. Pippin (eds.), Ideological Criticism of Biblical Texts ( Semeia, 59; Atlanta : Scholars Press): 79-93.
45.
1993 a ‘Inscribing the Covenant: Writing and the Written in Jeremiah’, in A.G. Auld (ed.), Understanding Poets and Prophets: Essays in Honour of George Wishart Anderson (JSOTSup, 152; Sheffield: JSOT Press): 61-76.
46.
1993 b ‘Intertextuality and the Book of Jeremiah: Animadversions on Text and Theory’, in J.C. Exum and D.J.A. Clines (eds.), The New Literary Criticism and the Hebrew Bible ( JSOTSup, 143; Sheffield: JSOT Press): 55-78.
47.
1995‘Synchronic Deconstruction of Jeremiah: Diachrony to the Rescue? Reflections on Some Reading Strategies for Understanding Certain Problems in the Book of Jeremiah’, in J.C. De Moor (ed.), Synchronic or Diachronic? A Debate on Method in Old Testament Exegesis (OTS, 34; Leiden: Brill): 39-51.
48.
1996a ‘Jeremiah, Intertextuality and Ideologiekritik’ , JNSL22.1: 15-34.
49.
1996 b ‘Manuscripts Don’t Burn-Inscribing the Prophetic Tradition: Reflections on Jeremiah 36’, in M. Augustin et al. (eds.), Dort Ziehen Schiffe Dahin ( Frankfurt: Peter Lang): 31-42.
50.
1996c ‘Surplus Meaning and the Conflict of Interpretations: A Dodecade of Jeremiah Studies (1984-1995)’, CR:BS4: 115-59.
51.
1997 a ‘Deportation and Diasporic Discourses in the Prophetic Literature’, in J.M. Scott (ed.), Exile: Old Testament, Jewish, and Christian Conceptions ( Leiden: Brill): 63-87.
52.
1997 b ‘Jeremiah’ in R.P. Carroll and S. Prickett (eds.), The Bible: Authorised King James Version (Oxford : Oxford University Press): 363-65.
53.
1998‘Biblical Ideolatry, Ideologiekritik, Biblical Studies and the Problematics of Ideology’, JNSL24.1: 101-14.
54.
1999 a ‘The Book of J: Intertextuality and Ideological Criticism’ , in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 220-43.
55.
1999 b ‘Halfway Through a Dark Wood: Reflections on Jeremiah 25’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 73-86.
56.
1999c ‘Review of McKane, Jeremiah 2’, JTS50.1: 188-91.
57.
1999 d ‘Something Rich and Strange: Imagining a Future for Jeremiah Studies’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 423-43.
58.
2000 ‘Century’s End: Jeremiah Studies at the Beginning of the Third Millennium’, CR:BS8: 18-58.
59.
Childs, B.S.1979Introduction to the Old Testament as Scripture ( Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
60.
1985Old Testament Theology in a Canonical Context ( London: SCM Press).
61.
Chilton-Callaway, M.1996‘Exegesis as Banquet: Reading Jeremiah with the Rabbis’ , in R.D. Weiss and D.M. Carr (eds.), A Gift of God in Due Season: Essays on Scripture and Community in Honor of James A. Sanders (JSOTSup, 225; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ): 219-30.
62.
1999‘Black Fire on White Fire: Historical Context and Literary Subtext in Jeremiah 37-38’, in Diamond , O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 171-78.
63.
2004‘The Lamenting Prophet and the Modern Self: On the Origins of Contemporary Readings of Jeremiah’, in Kaltner and Stulman (eds.) 2004: 48-62.
64.
Claassens, J.L.M.2003‘Biblical Theology as Dialogue: Continuing the Conversation on Mikhail Bakhtin and Biblical Theology’, JBL122: 127-44.
65.
Diamond, A.R.P.1987The Confessions of Jeremiah in Context: Scenes of Prophetic Drama (JSOTSup, 45;Sheffield: JSOT Press).
66.
1993 ‘Portraying Prophecy: Of Doublets, Variants and Analogies in the Narrative Representation of Jeremiah’s Oracles-Reconstructing the Hermeneutics of Prophecy’, JSOT57: 99-119.
67.
1999‘Introduction’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 15-32.
68.
2008a ‘Interlocutions: The Poetics of Voice in the Figuration of YHWH and His Oracular Agent Jeremiah’, Int62.1: 48-65.
69.
2008 b ‘The Jeremiah Guild in the Twenty-First Century: Variety Reigns Supreme’, in A.J. Hauser (ed.), Recent Research on the Major Prophets ( Sheffield: Sheffield Phoenix Press): 232-48.
70.
Diamond, A.R.P.,K.M. O’Connor and L. Stulman (eds.) 1999 Troubling Jeremiah (JSOTSup, 260; Sheffield : Sheffield Academic Press).
71.
Exum, J.C., and S.D. Moore (eds.) 1998Biblical Studies/Cultural Studies: The Third Sheffield Colloquium (JSOTSup, 266;Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press).
72.
Exum, J.C., and H.G.M. Williamson (eds.) 2003Reading from Right to Left: Essays on the Hebrew Bible in Honour of David J.A. Clines (JSOTSup, 373; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ).
73.
Freitheim, T.E.2002‘Caught in the Middle: Jeremiah’s Vocational Crisis’, W&W22.4: 351-60.
74.
Freud, S.2004‘The Uncanny’, in Rivkin and Ryan (eds.) 2004: 418-30.
75.
Gitay, Y. (ed.) 1997Prophecy and Prophets: The Diversity of Contemporary Issues in Scholarship (SBLSS;Atlanta: Scholars Press).
76.
Grabbe, L.L.1995Priests, Prophets, Diviners, Sages: A Socio-Historical Study of Religious Specialists in Ancient Israel (Valley Forge: Trinity Press International).
77.
2000‘Ancient Near Eastern Prophecy from an Anthropological Perspective’, in Nissinen (ed.) 2000: 13-32.
78.
Grabbe, L.L., and R.D. Haak (eds.) 2003Knowing the End from the Beginning: The Prophetic, the Apocalyptic, and their Relationship (JSPSup, 46; London and New York: T&T Clark International).
79.
Hegel, G.W.F.2004‘Dialectics’, in Rivkin and Ryan (eds.) 2004: 647-92.
80.
Holladay, W.L.1986Jeremiah 1: A Commentary on the Book of the Prophet Jeremiah, Chapters 1-25 (Hermeneia;Philadelphia: Fortress ).
81.
1989 Jeremiah 2: A Commentary on the Book of the Prophet Jeremiah, Chapters 26-52 (Hermeneia; Philadelphia: Fortress).
82.
Joyce, J.A.2000Finnegan’s Wake (repr.; London : Penguin Classics/Faber and Faber [ 1939]).
83.
Kaltner, J., and L. Stulman (eds.) 2004Inspired Speech: Prophecy in the Ancient Near East; Essays in Honour of Herbert B. Huffmon (JSOTSup, 378; London and New York: T&T Clark International).
84.
Kohanski, A.S.1984The Greek Mode of Thought in Western Philosophy ( Madison, NJ: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press).
85.
Kristeva, J.1969Semotiké (Paris: Editions de Seuil).
86.
Lawlor, J.I.2004‘Word Event in Jeremiah: A Look at the Composition’s Introductory Formulas’, in Kaltner and Stulman (eds.) 2004: 231-43.
87.
Lohfink, N.F.1999‘Was there a Deuteronomistic Movement?’ , in McKenzie and Schearing (eds.) 1999: 36-66.
88.
Lundbom, J.1999Jeremiah 1-20 (AB, 21A;Garden City, NY: Doubleday).
89.
2004 a Jeremiah 21-36 (AB, 21B; Garden City, NY : Doubleday).
90.
2004 b Jeremiah 37-52 (AB, 21C; Garden City, NY : Doubleday).
91.
McConville, J.G.1993Judgement and Promise: An Interpretation of the Book of Jeremiah (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns ).
92.
McKane, W.1983Prophets and Wisemen (London : SCM Press).
93.
1986A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Jeremiah. I. Introduction and Commentary on Jeremiah I-XXV (ICC, 1; Edinburgh: T&T Clark).
94.
1995A Late Harvest: Reflections on the Old Testament ( Edinburgh: T&T Clark).
95.
1996A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Jeremiah. II. Introduction and Commentary on Jeremiah XXVI-LII (ICC, 2; Edinburgh : T&T Clark).
96.
Maier, C.M.2008‘Jeremiah as Teacher of Torah’, Int62.1: 22-32.
97.
McKenzie, S.L., and L.S. Schearing (eds.) 1999Those Elusive Deuteronomists: The Phenomenon of Pan Deuteronomism (JSOTSup, 268;Sheffield : Sheffield Academic Press).
98.
Nations, A.L.1983‘Historical Criticism and the Current Methodological Crisis’, Scottish Journal of Theology36: 59-71.
99.
Newsom, C.A.1996‘Bakhtin, the Bible, and Dialogic Truth’ , JR76: 290-306.
100.
2002 ‘The Book of Job as Polyphonic Text’, JSOT97: 87-108.
101.
Nissinen, M.2000a Prophecy in its Ancient Near Eastern Context ( Atlanta: SBL ).
102.
2000 b ‘Spoken, Written, Quoted and Invented: Orality and Writtenness in Ancient Near Eastern Prophecy’, in Ben Zvi and Floyd (eds.) 2000: 235-71.
103.
2004‘What is Prophecy? An Ancient Near Eastern Perspective’ , in Kaltner and Stulman (eds.) 2004: 17-46.
104.
Nissinen, M. (ed.) 2000Prophecy in its Ancient Near Eastern Context: Mesopotamian, Biblical, and Arabian Perspectives (SBLSymS, 13; Atlanta: SBL).
105.
O’Connor, K.M.1999‘The Tears of God and Divine Character in Jeremiah 2-9’ , in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 387-401.
106.
2002 a Lamentations and the Tears of the World ( New York: Orbis).
107.
2002b ‘Surviving Disaster in the Book of Jeremiah’ , W&W22.4: 369-77.
108.
2008‘Lamenting Back to Life’, Int62.1: 34-47.
109.
Olson, D.T.1999‘Between the Tower of Unity and the Babel of Pluralism: Biblical Theology and Leo Perdue’s The Collapse of History’ , in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999 : 350-58.
110.
Overholt, T.W.1999‘What Shall We Do About Pluralism? A Response to Leo Perdue’s The Collapse of History’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 359-66.
111.
Perdue, L.G.1984‘Jeremiah in Modern Research: Approaches and Issues’ , in Perdue and Kovacs (eds.) 1984: 1-32.
112.
1994The Collapse of History: Reconstructing Old Testament Theology (Minneapolis: Fortress Press ).
113.
1999‘The Book of Jeremiah in Old Testament Theology’ , in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 320-49.
114.
2005Reconstructing Old Testament Theology: After the Collapse of History (Philadelphia: Fortress ).
115.
Perdue, L.G., and B.W. Kovacs (eds.) 1984A Prophet to the Nations: Essays in Jeremiah Studies (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns).
116.
Petersen, D.L.1997‘Rethinking the Nature of Prophetic Literature’ , in Gitay (ed.) 1997: 23-40.
117.
2000‘Defining Prophetic Literature’, in Nissinen (ed.) 2000: 33-44.
118.
Rivkin, J., and M. Ryan (eds.) 2004Literary Theory: An Anthology (Oxford: Blackwell).
119.
Römer, T.C.1999‘How did Jeremiah Become a Convert to Deuteronomistic Ideology?’, in McKenzie and Schearing (eds.) 1999: 189-99.
120.
Saussure, F.2004‘Course in General Linguistics’, in Rivkin and Ryan (eds.) 2004: 59-71.
121.
Sharp, C.J.2003Prophecy and Ideology in Jeremiah: Struggles for Authority in the Deutero-Jeremianic Prose (London and New York: T&T Clark International).
122.
Shead, A.G.2002The Open Book and the Sealed Book: Jeremiah 32 in its Hebrew and Greek Recensions (JSOTSup, 347;Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press).
123.
Smith, J.K.A.2006Who’s Afraid of Postmodernism? Taking Derrida, Lyotard, and Foucault to Church (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic).
124.
Sommer, B.D.1996‘Did Prophecy Cease? Evaluating a Reevaluation’ , JBL115: 31-47.
125.
Stulman, L.1995‘Insiders and Outsiders in the Book of Jeremiah: Shifts in Symbolic Arrangements’, JSOT66: 65-86.
1999‘The Prose Sermons as Hermeneutical Guide to Jeremiah 1-25: The Deconstruction of Judah’s Symbolic World’, in Diamond, O’Connor and Stulman (eds.) 1999: 34-63.
128.
2004‘Jeremiah as a Polyphonic Response to Suffering’ , in Kaltner and Stulman (eds.) 2004: 302-318.
129.
2008‘Jeremiah as a Messenger of Hope in Crisis’ , Int6.1: 5-20.
130.
Thompson, J.A.1980The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT;Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans).
131.
Van der Toorn, K.2000‘From the Oral to the Written: The Case of Old Babylonian Prophecy’, in Ben Zvi and Floyd (eds.) 2000: 219-34.
132.
2004‘From the Mouth of the Prophet: The Literary Fixation of Jeremiah’s Prophecies in the Context of the Ancient Near East’ , in Kaltner and Stulman (eds.) 2004: 191-202.
