Discussion about the reconstruction of the history of ancient Israel seldom interacts with theoretical literature on the nature of history. Modern attempts to write Israel’s history, however, have been shaped by their theoretical underpinnings for the past two centuries. This essay explores the epistemological underpinnings of the historical criticism of the Hebrew Bible, outlines trends in historiographical theory, and assesses the impact newer theories of intellectual cultural history can have on studies of the history of the social world of ancient Israel.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ahlström, G.1991‘The Role of Archaeological and Literary Remains in Reconstructing Israel’s History’, in Edelman (ed.) 1991: 116-142.
2.
1964History, Archaeology, and Christian Humanism ( New York: McGraw-Hill ).
3.
Alt, A. 1953 Kleine Schriften zur Geschichte des Volkes Israel (3 vols.; Münich: Beck’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung).
4.
Barr, J.2000History and Ideology in the Old Testament ( Oxford: Oxford University Press ).
5.
1998‘The Strange Fear of the Bible’, in L.L. Grabbe (ed.), Leading Captivity Captive (European Seminar in Historical Methodology, 2; JSOTSup, 278; Shef-field: Sheffield Academic Press ): 120-127.
6.
2000‘No More Grapes from the Vineyard?’, in Lemaire and Sæbø (eds.) 2000: 123-141.
7.
Berge, K.1994‘Comments’ , SJOT8: 198-205 .
8.
Braudel, F.1980On History (trans. S. Matthews; Chicago: University of Chicago Press ).
9.
The Creation of History in Ancient Israel ( New York: Routledge [1995]): 2-6.
10.
Bright, J.1972A History of Israel ( Philadelphia: Westminster Press , 2nd edn [1959]).
11.
Burckhardt, J.1992The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy ( New York: Barnes & Noble [1890]).
12.
1997Varieties of Cultural History ( Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press ).
13.
Carroll, D. (ed.) 1990The States of ‘Theory’ (Irvine Studies in the Humanities, 4; New York: Columbia University Press ).
14.
1997On the Edge of the Cliff (trans. L.G. Cochrane; Parallax Re-visions of Culture and Society; Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press ).
15.
Cheyne, T.K.1893Founders of Old Testament Criticism ( London: Methuen & Co .).
16.
Collingwood, R.G.1951The Idea of History ( Oxford: Clarendon Press [1946]).
17.
1990The Kiss of Lamourette ( New York: W.W. Norton ).
18.
2001‘The Intellectual, the Archaeologist, and the Bible’, in J.A. Dearman and M.P. Graham (eds.), The Land That I Will Show You (JSOTSup, 343; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ): 239-254.
19.
De Wette, W.M.L.2001Critical and Historical Introduction to the Canonical Scriptures of the Old Testament ( Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press [1805]).
20.
Deist, F.E.1990‘Biblical and Modern Historiography’ , OTE3: 7-22 .
21.
1990‘Some Statements and Truisms about Neo-logisms, Newisms, Postisms, Parasitisms, and Other Small Seismisms’ (trans. A. Tomiche), in Carroll (ed.) 1990: 63-94.
22.
2001bWhat Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It? ( Grand Rapids: Eerdmans ).
23.
Dilthey, W.1976The Development of Hermeneutics: Selected Writings By Dilthey (ed. and trans. H.P. Rickman ; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press ).
24.
Edelman, D.V. (ed.) 1991The Fabric of History (JSOTSup, 127; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ).
25.
Eichhorn, J.G.1780Einleitung in das Altes Testaments ( Leipzig: Leipzig Universitatsverlag ).
26.
1947 Geschichtliches und Übergeschichtliches im Alten Testament (Beiträge zur Theologie und Religionswissenschaft, 109.2; Berlin: Evang. Verlagsanst).
27.
Ewald, H.G.A.2004Antiquities of Israel ( Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock [1841]).
28.
1996‘Ethnicity and Origin of the Iron I Settlers in the Highlands of Canaan’ , BA59: 198-212 .
29.
1995‘Finding the Arrow of Time’ , CR:BS3: 37-62 .
30.
Foucault, M.1977Language, Counter-Memory, Practice (trans. D.F. Bouchard and S. Simon; Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press ).
31.
Freedman, D.N.1963‘On Method in Biblical Studies. The Old Testament’ , Int17: 308-318 .
Gay, P.1974Style in History ( New York: W.W. Norton ).
34.
1999bThe Judge and the Historian (trans. A. Shugaar; New York: Verso ).
35.
Glock, A.E.1985‘Tradition and Change in Two Archaeologies’ , American Antiquity50: 464-477 .
36.
1999‘Response: Twenty-Five Years and Counting’ , Semeia87: 255-265 .
37.
1997c‘Reflections on the Discussion’, in Grabbe (ed.) 1997: 188-196.
38.
Grabbe, L.L. (ed.) 1997Can a ‘History of Israel’ Be Written? (JSOTSup, 245; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ).
39.
Greenblatt, S.1989‘Towards a Poetics of Culture’, in Veeser (ed.) 1989: 1-13.
40.
Gressmann, H.1905Der Ursprung der israelitisch-jüdischen Eschatologie [‘The Source of Israelite-Jewish Eschatology’] ( Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht ).
41.
Gunkel, H.1964The Legends of Genesis ( New York: Schocken Books , rev. edn [1901]).
42.
Hallo, W.1990‘The Limits of Skepticism’ , JAOS110: 187-199 .
43.
Bible Review11.6 (1995): 26-35, 47 .
44.
= ET of ‘Die Abwertung des Alten Testaments als Geschichtsquelle’, in H.H. Schmid and J. Mehlhausen (eds.), Sola Scriptura (Gütersloh: Mohn, 1993): 156-65.
45.
Himmelfarb, G.1989‘Some Reflections on the New History’ , American Historical Review94: 661-670 .
46.
Hobsbawm, E.J.1984Worlds of Labour ( London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson ).
47.
Huddlestun, J.R.1994‘ “Who is this that rises like the Nile?” Some Egyptian Texts on the Inundation and a Prophetic Trope’, in A.H. Bartlettet al. (eds.), Fortunate the Eyes that See ( Grand Rapids: Eerdmans ): 338-363.
48.
1990‘History Beyond Social Theory’, in Carroll (ed.) 1990: 95-111.
49.
Iggers, G.G.1988The German Conception of History ( Middletown, CN: Wesleyan University Press , rev. edn [1983]).
50.
Isabell, C.2003‘ “History” and “Writing”’ , The Bible and Interpretation, http://www.bibleinterp.com.
51.
Isenberg, S.R. , and G.R. Thursby1985‘A Perennial Philosophy Perspective on Richard Rorty’s Neo-Pragmatism’ , International Journal for the Philosophy of Religion17: 41-65 .
Jobling, D.et al. (eds) 1991The Bible and the Politics of Exegesis ( Cleveland, OH: Pilgrim Press ).
54.
Kamm, A.1999The Israelites ( London: Routledge ).
55.
Kirkpatrick, P.1988The Old Testament and Folklore Study (JSOTSup, 62; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ).
56.
Kittel, R. 1932 Geschichte des Volkes Israel (3 vols.; Stuttgart: Kohlhammer Verlag).
57.
Knauf, E.A.1991‘From History to Interpretation’, in Edelman (ed.) 1991: 26-64.
58.
Kofoed, J.B.2002‘Epistemology, Historiographical Method, and the “Copenhagen School”’, in V.P. Long , D. Baker and G. Wenham (eds.), Windows into Old Testament History ( Grand Rapids: Eerdmans ): 23-43.
59.
1985History and Criticism ( Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press ).
60.
LaCapra, D. , and S. Kaplan (eds.) 1982Modern Intellectual History ( Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press ).
61.
Lemaire, A. , and M. Sæbø (eds.) 2000Congress Volume Oslo (VTSup, 80; Leiden: Brill ).
62.
2000‘On the Problems of Reconstructing Pre-Hellenistic Israelite (Palestinian) History’ , Journal of Hebrew Scriptures, October, http://www.jhsonline.org.
63.
Lentricchia, F.1989‘Foucault’s Legacy—A New Historicism?’, in Veeser (ed.) 1989: 231-242.
64.
1988Review of The Origin Tradition of Ancient Israel, vol. I, by T.L. Thompson , JBL107: 327-330 .
65.
Long, V.P.1999‘The Future of Israel’s Past’, in Long (ed.) 1999: 580-592.
66.
Long, V.P. (ed.) 1999Israel’s Past in Present Research (Sources for Biblical and Theological Study, 7; Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns ).
67.
1994‘Outsiders or Insiders: The Biblical View of Emergent Israel and Its Contexts’, in L.J. Silberman and R.L. Cohn (eds.), The Other in Jewish Thought and History ( New York: New York University Press ): 35-60.
68.
= ET of ‘Wahrheit und Wirklichkeit im Geschichtesverständis des Alten Testaments’, in G. Maier (ed.), Israel in Geschichte und Gegenwart (Basel: Brunnen, 1996): 9-23.
69.
Marcus, G.E.1994‘What Comes (Just) After “Post”? The Case of Ethnography’, in N.K. Denzin and Y.S. Lincoln (eds.), Handbook of Qualitative Research ( Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications ): 563-574.
1993‘Reading the Bible Historically’, in S.L. McKenzie and S.R. Haynes (eds.), To Each Its Own Meaning ( Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press ): 11-28.
72.
1982‘Biblical Studies and Classical Studies—Simple Reflections about Historical Method’ , BA45: 224-228 .
73.
Moore, S.D.1997‘History after Theory?’ , BibInt5: 289-299 .
74.
Neusner, J.1981‘Beyond Historicism, After Structuralism’ , Henoch3: 171-196 .
75.
Noth, M.1958The History of Israel (trans. P.R. Ackroyd; New York: Harper & Row , 2nd edn).
76.
Oden, A., Jr.1987The Bible Without Theology (New Voices in Biblical Studies, 4; San Francisco: Harper & Row ).
77.
Popper, K.2002Unended Quest ( London and New York: Routledge , rev. edn [1974]).
78.
2000‘In the Stable with the Dwarves’, in Lemaire and Sæbø (eds.) 2000: 281-319.
79.
Putnam, H.1981Reason, Truth, and History ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press ).
80.
Ranke, L. von 1824 Zur Kritik Neuerer Geschichtschreiber (Leipzig: G. Reimer).
81.
Reisch, G.1995‘Scientism without Tears’ , HT34: 45-58 .
82.
Rendsburg, G.A.1997‘Early History of Israel’, in G.D. Young , M.W. Chavalas and R.E. Averbeck (eds.), Crossing Boundaries and Linking Horizons ( Bethesda, MD: CDL Press ): 433-453.
83.
Rogerson, J.1985Old Testament Criticism in the Nineteenth Century ( Minneapolis: Fortress Press , rev. edn [1984]).
84.
Rorty, R.1982Consequences of Pragmatism: Essays, 1972-1980 ( Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press ).
85.
Sasson, J.1981‘Models for Recreating Israelite History’ , JSOT21: 3-24 .
86.
Saussure, F. de1966Course in General Linguistics (ed. C. Bally and A. Sechehaye , in collaboration with A. Riedlinger ; trans. W. Baskin; New York: McGraw-Hill ).
87.
Schwartz, R.1991‘Adultery in the House of David’ , Semeia54: 35-55 .
Silberman, N.A. , and D. Small (eds.) 1997The Archaeology of Israel (JSOTSup, 237; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press ).
90.
Smelik, K.A.D.1992Converting the Past (OTS, 28; Leiden: Brill ).
91.
Soggin, J.A.1993An Introduction to the History of Israel and Judah ( Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press , 2nd edn [1983]).
92.
Thompson, E.P.1975The Making of the English Working Class ( Harmondsworth, Middlesex: Penguin Books [1963]).
93.
2000‘A View From Copenhagen: Israel and the History of Palestine’ , The Bible and Interpretation, http://www.bibleinterp.com/articles/copenhagen.htm.
94.
Toynbee, A.J.1947-57A Study of History (2 vols.; ed. D.C. Somervell ; New York: Oxford University Press , 1st American edn).
95.
Veeser, H.A.1997‘Christianity, Wild Turkey, and Syphilis’ , BibInt5: 465-481 .
96.
Veeser, H.A. (ed.) 1989The New Historicism ( New York: Routledge ).
97.
Waddell, W.G.1980Manetho (repr.; LCL; Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press [1930]).
98.
Weber, M.1952Ancient Judaism ( Glencoe, IL: The Free Press ).
99.
Wellhausen, J.1957Prolegomena to the History of Ancient Israel ( New York: Meridian Books [1883]).
100.
1999Figural Realism ( Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press ).
101.
1998‘The Search for Early Israel’ , Beer-sheva12: 41-64 .
102.
Williamson, H.G.M.1998‘The Origins of Israel’ , Beer-sheva12: 141-151 .
103.
Yoffee, N.1995‘Conclusion: A Mass in Celebration of the Conference’, in T.E. Levy (ed.), The Archaeology of Society in the Holy Land ( London: Leicester University Press ): 542-548.
