For the last few decades the growing assumption has been that a community exists behind each of the four canonical Gospels. Elaborate reconstructions and reading techniques have been employed to draw out the characteristics of these communities, with the assumption that if we can see ‘behind the text’, we could better interpret the text itself. Recently the scholarly reconstruction of the communities behind the Gospels has been challenged by The Gospels for All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences, edited by Richard Bauckham. Since the publication of The Gospels for All Christians, several discussions have begun concerning the nature of the Gospel communities, as well as the overall methods for reading the Gospels. This article attempts to place the Gospel community debate in the current discussion and direct it toward future resolve.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexander, L.1998‘Ancient Book Production and the Circulation of the Gospels’, in R. Bauckham (ed.), The Gospels for All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences ( Grand Rapids: Eerdmans ): 71-111.
2.
Allison, D.1988‘Was There a “Lukan Community?” ’ , IRB10: 62-70 .
3.
Ashton, J.1991Understanding the Fourth Gospel ( Oxford: Clarendon Press ).
4.
Balch, D. (ed.) 1991The Social History of the Matthean Community ( Minneapolis: Fortress Press ).
5.
2000‘Christian Community in the Light of the Gospel of John’, in D.G. Horrell and C. M. Tuckett (eds.), Christology, Controversy, and Community: New Testament Essays in Honour of David R. Catchpole (NovTSup, 99; Leiden: E.J. Brill ): 279-301.
6.
2001‘The Audience of the Fourth Gospel’, in R. T. Fortna and T. Thatcher (eds.), Jesus in Johannine Tradition ( Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox ): 101-111.
7.
Bauckham, R. (ed.) 1998The Gospels for All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences ( Grand Rapids: Eerdmans ).
8.
Baxter, T.2001Review of The Gospels For All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences , edited by Richard Bauckham, in Evangel19: 55 .
9.
2001The Historical Reliability of John’s Gospel: Issues and Commentary ( Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press ).
10.
Bowe, B. E.2000Review of The Gospels For All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences , edited by Richard Bauckham, in CTM27: 295 .
11.
Brodie, T. L.1993The Quest for the Origin of John’s Gospel: A Source-Oriented Approach ( New York: Oxford University Press ).
12.
1984The Churches the Apostles Left Behind ( London: Geoffrey Chapman ).
13.
Burge, G. M.2001‘Situating John’s Gospel in History’, in R. T. Fortna and T. Thatcher (eds.), Jesus in Johannine Tradition ( Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press ): 35-46.
14.
2000‘Gospel Genre, Christological Controversy and the Absence of Rabbinic Biography: Some Implications of the Biographical Hypothesis’, in D. G. Horrell and C. M. Tuckett (eds.), Christology, Controversy, and Community: New Testament Essays in Honour of David R. Catchpole (NovTSup, 99; Leiden: E.J. Brill ): 137-156.
15.
Casson, L.1974Travel in the Ancient World ( London: Allen & Unwin ).
16.
Cohen, A.1985The Symbolic Construction of Community ( London: Routledge ).
17.
1976The Johannine Circle (trans. J. Bowden; London: SCM Press ).
18.
1983Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel: A Study in Literary Design ( Philadelphia: Fortress Press ).
Duff, J.1999Review of The Gospels For All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences , edited by Richard Bauckham, in Anvil16: 134-135 .
21.
Eco, U.1981The Role of the Reader: Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts ( London: Hutchinson ).
22.
Ellingworth, P.1999Review of The Gospels For All Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences , edited by Richard Bauckham, in EvQ71: 273-275 .
23.
Esler, P. F.1998‘Community and Gospel in Early Christianity: A Response to Richard Bauckham’s Gospels for All Christians’ , SJT51: 235-248 .
24.
Filson, F. V.1939‘The Significance of Early House Churches’ , JBL58: 105-112 .
25.
Gamble, H. F.1995Books and Readers in the Early Church ( New Haven: Yale University Press ).
26.
Gusfield, J. R.1975Community: A Critical Response (KCSS; Oxford: Basil Blackwell ).
27.
Hägerland, T.2003‘John’s Gospel: A Two-Level Drama?’ , JSNT25: 309-322 .
28.
2000The Four Gospels and the One Gospel of Jesus Christ (trans. J. Bowden; London: SCM Press ).
29.
Holmberg, B.1990Sociology and the New Testament: An Appraisal ( Minneapolis: Fortress Press ).
30.
Hurtado, L. W.2003Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity ( Grand Rapids: Eerdmans ).
31.
Johnson, L. T.1979‘On Finding Lukan Community: A Cautious Cautionary Essay’ , SBLSP: 87-100 .
32.
Judge, E.1980‘The Social Identity of the First Christians: A Question of Method in Religious History’ , JRH11: 201-217 .
33.
1995Who are the People of God? Early Christian Models of Community ( New Haven: Yale University Press ).
34.
1979Mark’s Story of Jesus ( Philadelphia: Fortress Press ).
35.
Kingsbury, J. D.1991‘Conclusion: Analysis of a Conversation’, in D. Balch (ed.), Social History of the Matthean Community ( Minneapolis: Fortress Press ): 259-269.
36.
Klauck, H.-J. 2003 ‘Community, History, and Text(s)—a Response’ (paper delivered at Life in Abundance: An International Conference on the Gospel of John: A Tribute to Raymond E. Brown, Baltimore, Maryland, 16-18 October).
37.
Kügler, J.1984‘Das Johannesevangelium und seine Gemeinde—kein Thema für Science Fiction’ , BN23: 48-62 .
38.
2003 ‘The Whence and Whither of the Johannine Community’ (paper delivered at Life in Abundance: An International Conference on the Gospel of John: A Tribute to Raymond E. Brown, Baltimore, Maryland, 16-18 October).
39.
Lincoln, A. T.2000Truth on Trial: The Lawsuit Motif in the Fourth Gospel ( Peabody, MA: Hendrickson ).
40.
Malherbe, A. J.1977Social Aspects of Early Christianity ( Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press ).
41.
Malina, B. J.1994‘John’s [sic]: The Maverick Christian Group: The Evidence of Sociolinguistics’ , BTB24: 167-182 .
42.
Marcus, J.2000Mark 1-8 (AB, 27; New York: Doubleday ).
43.
2003History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel ( Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press , 3rd edn [1st edn, 1968]).
44.
Marxsen, W.1969Mark the Evangelist: Studies on the Redactional History of the Gospel (trans. J. Boyce, D. Juel and W. Poehlmann; Nashville: Abingdon Press ).
45.
Matson, M. A. 2003 ‘Interactive Rhetoric in Matthew: An Exploration of Audience Knowledge Competency’ (paper delivered at the Annual Meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature in Atlanta, 22-25 November).
46.
1985‘Breaking Away: Three New Testament Pictures of Christianity’s Separation from the Jewish Communities’, in J. Neusner and E. S. Frerichs (eds.), ‘To See Ourselves as Others See Us.’ Christians, Jews, ‘Others’ in Late Antiquity ( Chico, CA: Scholars Press ): 93-115.
47.
Mitchell, M. M. 2003 ‘Patristic Counter-evidence to the Claim that “The Gospels Were Written for All Christians” ’ (paper delivered at the annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature in Atlanta, 22-25 November).
48.
1981The Birth of the New Testament (BNTC, 1; London: Continuum , 3rd edn [1st edn, 1962]).
49.
Moxnes, H.1999‘The Social Context of Luke’s Community’ , Int48: 379-389 .
50.
Myers, C.1988Binding the Strong Man: A Political Reading of Mark’s Story of Jesus ( Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books ).
51.
Neyrey, J. H.1988An Ideology of Revolt: John’s Christology in Social-Science Perspective ( Philadelphia: Fortress Press ).
52.
O’Day, G. R. 2002 ‘Response: “The Expulsion from the Synagogue: A Tale of a Theory” ’ (paper delivered at the annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature in Toronto, 23-26 November).
53.
Painter, J.1993The Quest for the Messiah: The History, Literature and Theology of the Johannine Community ( Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark , 2nd edn [1st edn, 1991]).
54.
Peterson, D. N.2000The Origins of Mark: The Markan Community in Current Debate (BIS, 48; Leiden: E.J. Brill ).
55.
Rensberger, D.1988Johannine Faith and Liberating Community ( Philadelphia: Westminster Press ).
56.
Riches, J. K.1993‘The Synoptic Evangelists and their Communities’, in J. Becker (ed.), Christian Beginnings: Word and Community from Jesus to Post-Apostolic Times ( Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press ): 213-241.
57.
Rodd, C. S.1981‘On Applying a Sociological Theory to Biblical Studies’ , JSOT19: 95-106 .
58.
Saldarini, A. J.1994Matthew’s Christian-Jewish Community ( Chicago: University of Chicago Press ).
59.
1980‘The Sociological Interpretation of the New Testament: The Present State of Research’ , NTS26: 164-179 .
60.
2001‘The Gospels for All Christians: A Response to Richard Bauckham’ , JSNT84: 3-27 .
61.
2002 ‘Response to Robert Kysar, “The Expulsion from the Synagogue: The Tale of the Theory” ’ (paper delivered at the annual meeting of the Society of Biblical Literature in Toronto, 23-26 November).
62.
Sproston North, W. E.2003‘John for Readers of Mark? A Response to Richard Bauckham’s Proposal’ , JSNT25: 449-468 .
63.
Staley, J. L.2001‘What Can a Postmodern Approach to the Fourth Gospel Add to Contemporary Debates about its Historical Situation?’, in R. T. Fortna and T. Thatcher (eds.), Jesus in Johannine Tradition ( Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press ): 47-57.
64.
1997‘The Fourfold Gospel’ , NTS43: 317-346 .
65.
Stendahl, K.1954The School of St. Matthew (ASNU, 20; Lund: C.W.K. Gleerup ).
66.
Streeter, B. H.1924The Four Gospels: A Study of Origins ( London: Macmillan ).
67.
Thompson, M. B.1998‘The Holy Internet: Communication between Churches in the First Christian Generation’, in Bauckham (ed.) 1998: 49-70.
68.
Twelftree, G. H.1999Jesus the Miracle Worker ( Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press ).
69.
Via, D. O.1988The Ethics of Mark’s Gospel: In the Middle of Time ( Philadelphia: Fortress Press ).
70.
Wansbrough, H.2000‘The New Israel: The Community of Matthew and the Community of Qumran’ , SNTU25: 8-22 .
71.
Watson, F.1998‘Toward a Literal Reading of the Gospels’, in Bauckham (ed.) 1998: 195-217.
72.
Weiss, H.1979‘Footwashing in the Johannine Community’ , NovT41: 298-325 .
73.
Wisse, F.1992‘Historical Method and the Johannine Community’ , Arc20: 35-42 .
