Caucasus edition: Decentralized transnational network as a pivotal structure for peacebuilding in non-democratic environments

Abstract

In 2021, only a few locally led peacebuilding institutions worked to build bridges across the Armenian–Azerbaijani conflict that had divided the two societies for over three decades. This stood in sharp contrast with the recent past, when the environment was saturated by civil society institutions promoting peace and cross-border co-operation. The reasons for the dissipation of the once-vibrant scene of institutionalized peacebuilding included the decreased European and US support for democratization and civil society, the crackdown on and stigmatization of peacebuilding, military escalation, and the Second Karabakh War. The collapse of the professionalized scene, however, was not the end of peacebuilding. As institutions retreated, decentralized online networks connecting Armenians and Azerbaijanis sprang into existence. The article explores the journey of Caucasus Edition, a peacebuilding journal, whose ongoing reflection and action cycle process led it to transform from a professional institution into a decentralized transnational network. It highlights the relative effectiveness of decentralized structures, particularly their resiliency and adaptability, compared to professionalized civil society institutions susceptible to cooptation or crackdown in non-democratic political environments.

Keywords

transnational networks post-liberal peace de-institutionalization Caucasus activism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abasov

Haroutiun

(2002). Variants for a solution of the Karabakh conflicts: Concepts and reality. Yeni Nesil.

Abrahamyan

(1991). Arc’axyan goyamart : 1917–1991t’t’. iradarjowt’yownnerë arc’axowm [artsakhs struggle for survival: The events of 1917-1991 in artsakh]. Giteliq.

Altstadt

A. L.

(1992). The azerbaijani turks: Power and identity under Russian rule. Hoover Institution Press, Stanford University.

Avetisyan

(2021 June 2021). Robert kocharyan proposes Armenia ‘Foreign agent’ law. OC Media.

Aydin

Sargsyan

(2018). Meet the New Normal: Community-Driven Clean Energy Partnership and Regional Cooperation between Turkey and Armenia. In Gamaghelyan

(Ed.), Challenging gender norms, dealing with the past, and protecting the environment: Community-driven conflict transformation in the South Caucasus (3, pp. 141-156).

Baghdasarian

(2006). A Karabakh Armenian perspective. In Broers

(Ed.), The limits of leadership Elites and societies in the Nagorny Karabakh peace process (pp. 22-25). Conciliation Resources.

Balayan

(1997). Between hell and Heaven: The struggle for Karabakh. Aramas.

Broers

(2019). Armenia and Azerbaijan: Anatomy of a rivalry. Edinburgh University Press.

Broers

(2021a). Analysing the second Karabakh War. Conciliation Resources (blog). https://www.c-r.org/news-and-insight/analysing-second-karabakh-war

10.

Broers

(2021b). Armenia’s snap election Preserves precarious democracy. Chatham House (blog). https://www.chathamhouse.org/2021/06/armenias-snap-election-preserves-precarious-democracy?fbclid=IwAR3HUqC7_B33tl3AEeBH54Xe4IWj9DOwI9YnExRAsIZ3CVM-foSPQIY0bkw

11.

Bunyatyan

(2003). Aryownot òrer [Bloody days]. Asoghik.

12.

Conca

Dabelko

G. D.

(Eds.). (2002). Environmental Peacemaking. Woodrow Wilson Center Press with Johns Hopkins University Press.

13.

De Waal

(2013). Black garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War (10th-year anniversary edition revised and updated ed.). New York University Press.

14.

De Waal

(2016). Prisoners of the Caucasus: Resolving the Karabakh security dilemma. Carnegie Europe (blog). https://carnegieeurope.eu/2016/06/16/prisoners-of-caucasus-resolving-karabakh-security-dilemma-pub-63825

15.

Dilanyan

Beraia

Yavuz

(2018). Beyond NGOs: Decolonizing peacebuilding and human rights. In Gamaghelyan

(Ed.), Challenging gender norms, dealing with the past, and protecting the environment: Community-driven conflict transformation in the South Caucasus (Vol. 3, pp. 157-173). Caucasus Edition.

16.

Dilanyan

Gamaghelyan

Rumyansev

Sayan

(2018). Political transitions and conflicts in the South Caucasus. Caucasus Edition, 3(2).

17.

Fatyllayev

(2017). Antiazerbaydzhanskoye podpol’ye v Tbilisi: Yavki, den’gi, instruktsii [the Azerbaijani underworld in Tbilisi: Secret gatherings, money, and instructions]. Haqqin.az Electronic Journal. https://haqqin.az/comics/99120.

18.

Galtung

(1969). Violence, peace, and peace research. Journal of Peace Research, 6(3), 167–191. https://doi.org/10.1177/002234336900600301

19.

Galtung

(1990). Cultural violence. Journal of Peace Research, 27(3), 291–305.

20.

Gamaghelyan

Rumyansev

(2013a). Armenia and Azerbaijan: The Nagorny Karabakh conflict and the reinterpretation of narratives in history textbooks. In Javakhishvili

J. D.

Kvarchelia

(Eds.), Myths and Conflicts in the South Caucasus: Instrumentalization of historical narratives (Vol. 1, pp. 166–188). International Alert.

21.

Gamaghelyan

Huseynova

Karapetyan

Rumyansev

(Eds.). (2016). The South Caucasus and its neighborhood. Form politics and economics to group rights (1st ed., 1, p. 2). Journal of Conflict Transformation: Caucasus Edition.

22.

Gamaghelyan

Karapetyan

Rumyansev

Sayan

(2017). Visions and strategies for conflict transformation: Dominant and alternative discourses on gender, militarism, and peace processes. Journal of Conflict Transformation Caucasus Edition, 2.

23.

Gamaghelyan

Huseynova

Sayan

Dilanyan

(Eds), (2019a). Exploring post-liberal approaches to peace in the South Caucasus (Vol. 4).

24.

Gamaghelyan

Huseynova

Soloyan

Tskhvariashvili

(Eds.). (2019b). Activism and peace in the South Caucasus (Vol. 4, pp. 160). Caucasus Edition.

25.

Hashimov

(2013). Comparative analysis of ethnic cleansing: The case of Kosovo and Nagorno-Karabakh. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2283749.

26.

Human Rights Watch (2017). Georgia/Azerbaijan: journalist kidnapped across border. Afgan Mukhtarli is facing politically motivated prosecution in Azerbaijan. https://www.hrw.org/news/2017/05/31/georgia/azerbaijan-journalist-kidnapped-across-border

27.

Huseynov

(2006). A Karabakh Azeri perspective. In Broers

(Ed.), The limits of leadership Elites and societies in the Nagorny Karabakh peace process (pp. 25-28). Conciliation Resources.

28.

Huseynov

(2015). Azerbaijan and the Armenian question in the Caucasus. National Academy of Sciences of Azerbaijan.

29.

Keck

M. E.

Sikkink

(1998). Activists beyond borders: Advocacy networks in international Politics. Cornell University Press.

30.

Keck

M. E.

Sikkink

(2018). Transnational advocacy networks in international and regional politics. International Social Science Journal, 68(227–228), 65–76. https://doi.org/10.1111/issj.12187

31.

Kostanyan

(2015). “The Rocky Road to an EU-Armenia Agreement: From U-Turn to Detour.”CEPS commentary (blog). https://www.ceps.eu/ceps-publications/rocky-road-eu-armenia-agreement-u-turn-detour/

32.

Lejava

(2014 August). Human rights in Azerbaijan: Chronicles of a crackdown. Henrich Boll Foundation. https://www.boell.de/en/2014/08/25/human-rights-azerbaijan-chronicles-crackdown

33.

Mahmudov

(2009). Historical facts of Armenia’s actions in Azerbaijan land. Azerbaijan National Academy of Science.

34.

Mammadov

Musayev

T. F.

(2015). Il conflittotra Armenia e azerbaigian: Storia, diritto, mediazione. Passigli.

35.

Manasyan

(2005). Karabahskij konflikt: klûčevye ponâtiâ i hronika [Karabakh conflict: key terms and timeline]. Noravank. http://www.noravank.am/upload/pdf/37_ru.pdf

36.

Nan

S. A.

(2008a). Conflict resolution in a network society. International Negotiation, 13(1), 111–131. https://doi.org/10.1163/138234008X297995

37.

Nan

S. A.

(2008b). Social capital in exclusive and inclusive networks. In Cox

(Ed.), In social capital and peace-building (pp. 172). Routledge. http://www.crcnetbase.com/doi/abs/10.4324/9780203887837.ch11

38.

Nikoghosyan

(2010). International court of Justice Ruling on Kosovo and the Ultimate Power of Precedence. Caucasus Edition. https://caucasusedition.net/old/analysis/international-court-of-justice-ruling-on-kosovo-and-the-ultimate-power-of-precedence/

39.

Ohanyan

Broers

(2021). Armenia’s velvet revolution: Authoritarian decline and civil resistance in a multipolar world. I.B. Tauris.

40.

Oskanian

(2013). Fear, weakness and Power in the Post-soviet South Caucasus: A theoretical and empirical analysis. HoundmillsPalgrave Macmillan.

41.

Papyan

(2009). Hayoc pahanjatirowt’yan iravakan himownqnery’ [Legal Bases for Armenian Claims]. Modus Vivendi. https://web.archive.org/web/20110419123829/http://www.wilsonforarmenia.org/Articles/EastArm.pdf

42.

Reason

Bradbury

(2006). Handbook of action research: The concise paperback edition. SAGE.

43.

Richmond

O. P.

(2006). The problem of peace: Understanding the ‘liberal peace. Conflict, Security & Development, 6(3), 291–314. https://doi.org/10.1080/14678800600933480

44.

Romashov

Guliyeva

Yavuz

(2018). A communitarian peace Agenda for the South Caucasus: Supporting everyday peace practices. In Gamaghelyan

Huseynova

Karapetyan

Sayan

(Eds.), Challenging gender norms, dealing with the past, and protecting the environment: Community-driven conflict transformation in the South Caucasus (Vol. 3, pp. 157–173). Caucasus Edition

45.

Rubenstein

R. E.

(2017). Resolving structural conflicts: How violent systems can be transformed. In Romano

(Ed.), Routledge studies in Peace and conflict resolution. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group.

46.

Sookiasian

P V.

(2021). Bright garden voices opens communications between Azerbaijanis and Armenians. Mirror Spectator. https://mirrorspectator.com/2021/04/08/bright-garden-voices-opens-communications-between-azerbaijanis-and-armenians/

47.

Suny

R. G.

(1994). The making of the Georgian nation (2nd ed.). Indiana University Press.

48.

Suny

R. G.

(1993). Looking toward ararat: Armenia in modern History. Indiana University Press.

49.

Torosyan

(2013). To the resolution of intractable conflicts: Nagorno-Karabakh and Kosovo. IRAN and the CAUCASUS, 17(4), 427–441. https://doi.org/10.1163/1573384X-20130407

50.

Tudor

(2017). Dimensions of transnationalism. Federal Register, 117(1), 20–40. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41305-017-0092-5

51.

Zerynalov

(2010). Nagorno-Karabakh and Kosovo: Politically precedent, legally different. Caucasus Edition. https://caucasusedition.net/old/analysis/nagorno-karabakh-and-kosovo-politically-precedent-legally-different/