When one size does not fit all: Using participatory action research to co-create preventive healthcare services

Abstract

Organized screening programs have proved effective at reducing cervical cancer in Sweden by offering early detection of precancerous cells. However, participation rates vary across groups of women. The purpose of this paper is to explore how participatory action research contributes to (re)designing cervical cancer screening programs to better meet local residents’ needs and expectations. The paper examines the Pap smear testing barriers encountered by foreign-born women. It is also reported how different actors within the healthcare system as well as civil society can work together to address these barriers and improve healthcare services. Moreover, the paper contributes to action research methodology by demonstrating how participatory inquiries benefit from quantitative monitoring of improvement initiatives.

Keywords

Participatory action research foreign-born cervical cancer screening

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aaron

Markovic

Danielson

(2001) Behavioral risk factors for disease and preventive health practices among lesbians. American Journal of Public Health 91: 972–975.

Abdullahi

Copping

Kessel

Luck

Bonell

(2009) Cervical screening: Perceptions and barriers to uptake among Somali women in Camden. Public Health 123: 680–685.

Anderson

J. O.

Mullins

R. M.

Siahpush

Spittal

M. J.

Wakefield

(2009) Mass media campaign improves cervical screening across all socio-economic groups. Health Education Research 24: 867–875.

Andrae

Andersson

Lambert

Kemetli

Silfverdal

Strander

Sparén

(2012) Screening and cervical cancer cure: Population based cohort study. British Medical Journal 344: 1–11.

Ataöv

Brøgger

Hildrum

J. M.

(2010) An action research approach to the inclusion of immigrants in work life and local community life: Preparation of a participatory realm. Action Research 3: 237–265.

Azerkan

Sparén

Sandin

Tillgren

Faxelid

Zendehdel

(2011) Cervical screening participation and risk among Swedish-born and immigrant women in Sweden. International Journal of Cancer 130: 937–947.

Azerkan

Zendehdel

Tillgren

Faxelid

Sparén

(2008) Risk of cervical cancer among immigrants by age at immigration and follow-up time in Sweden, from 1968 to 2004. International Journal of Cancer 123: 2664–2670.

Bargal

(2008) Action research: A paradigm for achieving social change. Small Group Research 1: 17–27.

Beiki

Allebeck

Nordqvist

Moradi

(2009) Cervical, endometrial and ovarian cancers among immigrants in Sweden: Importance of age at migration and duration of residence. European Journal of Cancer 45: 107–118.

10.

Bergman

Klefsjö

(2010) Quality from customer needs to customer satisfaction, Lund, Sweden: Studentlitteratur AB.

11.

Blomberg

Ternestedt

B. M.

Törnberg

Tishelman

(2008) How do women who choose not to participate in population-based cervical cancer screening reason about their decision? Psycho-Oncology 17: 561–569.

12.

Bradbury

Reason

(2003) Action research: An opportunity for revitalizing research purpose and practices. Qualitative Social Work 2: 155–175.

13.

Carroll

Epstein

Fiscella

Volpe

Diaz

Omar

(2007) Knowledge and beliefs about health promotion and preventive healthcare among Somali women in the United States. Healthcare for Women International 28: 360–380.

14.

Castillo-Burguete

M. T.

Viga de Alva

M. D.

Dickinson

(2008) Changing the culture of dependency to allow for successful outcomes in participatory research: Fourteen years of experience in Yucatan, Mexico. In: Reason

Bradbury

(eds) The Sage handbook of action research: Participative inquiry and practice, 2nd ed. London, UK: Sage, pp. 522–533.

15.

Chiu

L. F.

(2004) Minority ethnic women and cervical screening: A matter of action or research? Primary Health Care Research and Development 5: 104–116.

16.

Chiu

L. F.

(2008) Health promotion and participatory action research: The significance of participatory praxis in developing participatory health intervention. In: Reason

Bradbury

(eds) The Sage handbook of action research: Participative inquiry and practice, 2nd ed. London, UK: Sage, pp. 534–549.

17.

Coghlan

Brannick

(2010) Doing action research in your own organization, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

18.

Comerasamy

Read

Francis

Cullings

Gordon

(2003) The acceptability and use of contraception: A prospective study of Somalian women’s attitude. Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 23: 412–415.

19.

Eaker

Adami

Sparén

(2001) Reasons women do not attend screening for cervical cancer: A population-based study in Sweden. Preventive Medicine 32: 482–491.

20.

Emami

Tishelman

(2004) Reflections on cancer in the context of women’s health: Focus group discussions with Iranian immigrant women in Sweden. Women & Health 39: 75–94.

21.

Fagerberg, P. (2012). Besökspunkter i nordöstra Göteborg. Visioner och behov för utveckling av attraktiviteten i Angered och Östra Göteborg (Visiting points in the northeast of Gothenburg. Visions and needs for development of attractiveness of Angered and Eastern Gothenburg). Retrieved from http://www.utvecklingnordost.se/Bilder/Vision/utredning.pdf.

22.

Forss

Tishelman

Widmark

Lundgren

E. L.

Sachs

Törnberg

(2001) “I got a letter…” A qualitative study of women’s reasoning about attendance in cervical cancer screening-programme in urban Sweden. Psycho-Oncology 10: 76–87.

23.

Göteborgs stadskansli. (2010). Befolkningsdata och sociala indikatorer. Göteborgs stads 10 nya stadsdelsnämnder (Population data and social indicators. City of Gothenburg’s 10 new districts). Retrieved from http://medborgarkraften.org/Kartorstadsdelarna/Statistisk%20beskrivning%20av%2010%20nya%20SDN.pdf.

24.

Göteborgs stadsledningskontor. (2013). Göteborgsbladet 2013 – områdesfakta (Gothenburg 2013 – area information). Retrieved from http://www4.goteborg.se/prod/G-info/statistik.nsf/3a1ad6102b0c4f0ac1256cdf004881c0/e1c973e615de8e87c1257b98004632cb/$FILE/G%C3%B6teborg%20+%20SDN%202013.pdf.

25.

Gregory

Lester

O’Neill

Gray

(2005) Widening participation for black and ethnic minority women: A pilot educational intervention using action research. Health Educational Journal 1: 43–50.

26.

Hok-Bun Ku

(2011) “Happiness being like a blooming flower”: An action research of rural social work in an ethnic minority community of Yunnan Province, PRC. Action Research 4: 344–369.

27.

Israel

B. A.

Schulz

A. J.

Parker

E. A.

Becker

A. B.

(1998) Review of community-based research: Assessing partnership approaches to improve public health. Annual Review of Public Health 19: 173–202.

28.

Kiger

(2003) Outreach to multiethnic, multicultural, and multilingual women for breast cancer and cervical cancer education and screening. Family & Community Health 26: 307–318.

29.

Krishnaswamy

(2004) Participatory research: Strategies and tools. Practitioner: Newsletter of the National Network of Forest Practitioners 22: 17–22.

30.

Letiecq

Schmalzbauer

(2012) Community-based participatory research with Mexican migrants in a new rural destination: A good fit? Action Research 3: 244–259.

31.

Lockwood-Rayermann

(2004) Characteristics of participation in cervical cancer screening. Cancer Nursing 27: 353–363.

32.

Matin

LeBaron

(2004) Attitudes toward cervical cancer screening among Muslim women: A pilot study. Women & Health 39: 63–77.

33.

McNiff

Whitehead

(2009) Doing and writing action research, London, UK: Sage.

34.

Naish

Brown

Denton

(1994) Intercultural consultations: Investigation of factors that deter non-English speaking women from attending their general practitioners for cervical screening. British Medical Journal 309: 1126–1128.

35.

Okigbo

Reierson

Stowman

(2009) Leveraging acculturation through action research: A case study of refugee and immigrant women in the United States. Action Research 2: 127–142.

36.

Olsson, M. (2011). Behovsanalys för Angereds Närsjukhus – ur ett befolkningsperspektiv, 3:e upplagan (Necessity analysis for Angereds Local Hospital – from the perspective of the citizens, 3rd ed.). Retrieved from http://www.angeredsnarsjukhus.se/upload/Angereds%20n%C3%A4rsjukhus/Behovsanalys%203.pdf?epslanguage=sv.

37.

Olsson, M., & Panifilova, O. (2009). Behovsanalys för Angereds Närsjukhus – ur ett befolkningsperspektiv (Necessity analysis for angered local hospital – from the perspective of the citizens). Retrieved from http://www.angeredsnarsjukhus.se/upload/Angereds%20n%C3%A4rsjukhus/Behovsanalys%20del%202.pdf.

38.

Samuel

P. S.

Pringle

J. P.

James

N. W.

Fielding

S. J.

Fairfield

K. M.

(2009) Breast, cervical, and colorectal cancer screening rates amongst female Cambodian, Somali, and Vietnamese immigrants in the USA. International Journal for Equity in Health 8: 1–5.

39.

Scientific Assessment of Health Technology. (2008). General childhood vaccination against HPV 16 and 18 aimed at preventing cervical cancer. SBU Alert no. 2008-1. Stockholm: Statens beredning för medicinsk utvärdering.

40.

Socialstyrelsen. (2012). Modell för införande av nationella screeningprogram på cancerområdet (A model to introduce national screening programs in cancer care). Retrieved from http://www.socialstyrelsen.se/Lists/Artikelkatalog/Attachments/18634/2012-2-36.pdf.

41.

SOU 2006:78. Hälsa, vård och strukturell diskriminering (Health, care and structural discrimination). Statens offentliga utredningar. Stockholm: Fritzes offentliga publikationer.

42.

Statistiska centralbyrån. (2014). Den utrikes födda befolkningen ökar (An increase of the foreign-born population). Retrieved from http://www.scb.se/Statistik/BE/BE0101/2011A01C/Den%20utrikes%20f%C3%B6dda%20befolkningen%20%C3%B6kar.pdf.

43.

Strander, B., Holtenman, M., & Westlund, M. (2011). Sammanställning av några kvalitetsdata från 2010 gällande cervixcancerprevention i västra Sverige (Compilation of quality data from 2010 regarding cervical cancer prevention in western Sweden). Onkologiskt centrum, Västra sjukvårdsregionen. Retrieved from http://www.cancercentrum.se/PageFiles/3464/kommunbilaga%20tanum%202010%20Omsl.pdf.

44.

Swedish Association of Local Authorities and Regions. (2005). Swedish health care in an international context – A comparison of care needs, costs, and outcomes. Retrieved from http://www.skl.se/MediaBinaryLoader.axd?MediaArchive_FileID=6b25ef48-5afa-43a4-9800-911324bc42f3.

45.

Västra Götalandsregionen. (2009). Utvärdering av projektet Utlandsfödda kvinnor som doulor och kulturtolkar (Evaluation of the project foreign-born women as doulas and culture interpreters). Folkhälsokommittén.

46.

Västra Götalandsregionen. (2010). Kommunikationsplan – vidareutveckling av cervixcancerprevention i Västra Götalandsregionen 2010–2011 (Communication plan – development of cervical cancer prevention in the Western Region of Sweden 2010–2011).

47.

Västra Götalandsregionen. (2014). Vårdprogram för gynekologisk cellprovskontroll – förslag (Program for Pap smear tests – proposal). Retrieved from http://www.cancercentrum.se/sv/vast/Screening/Cervixcancerprevention-forebyggande-av-livmoderhalscancer/ROCK/Styrdokument-VP-PM-/.

48.

Whyte

W. F.

Greenwood

D. J.

Lazes

(1991) Participatory action research: Through practice to science in social research. In: Whyte

W. F.

(ed.) Participatory action research, Newbury Park, CA: Sage, pp. 19–55.