Grounded in children’s rights, this article advances understanding of the affordances and constraints in implementing Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child in educational settings with young children – those under 7. It starts from the premise that if we are to foster democratic skills and understanding in children and young people, we need to develop practices that support this from the earliest age. The article presents the outcomes of a seminar series facilitating dialogue among international academics working in the field and a range of early years practitioners. This opportunity for extended dialogue led to the development of a rich and sophisticated conceptual clarity about the factors that need to be considered if Article 12 is to be realised with very young children. Eight factors were identified as pivotal for consideration when facilitating voices with this age group: definition; power; inclusivity; listening; time and space; approaches; processes; and purposes. This article explores each in turn and proposes a series of provocations and questions designed to support practitioners in their endeavour to elicit young children’s voices.
ArendtH (1958/1998) The Human Condition. 2nd ed.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
2.
ArnotMReayD (2007) A sociology of pedagogic voice: power, inequality and pupil consultation. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education28(3): 311–325.
3.
BaconKFrankelS (2014) Rethinking children’s citizenship: negotiating structure, shaping meanings. International Journal of Children’s Rights22(1): 21–42.
4.
BartelsROnstenkJVeugelersW (2016) Philosophy for democracy. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education46(5): 681–700.
5.
BiestaGLawyRKellyN (2009) Understanding young people’s citizenship learning in everyday life: the role of contexts, relationships and dispositions. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice4(5): 5–24.
6.
Black-HawkinsK (2010) The framework for participation: A research tool for exploring the relationship between achievement and inclusion in schools. International Journal of Research & Method in Education33(1): 21–40.
7.
BlackR (2011) Student participation and disadvantage: limitations in policy and practice. Journal of Youth Studies14(4): 463–474.
8.
BucknallS (2014) Doing qualitative research with children and young people. In: ClarkAFlewittRHammersleyM, et al. (eds) Understanding Research with Children and Young People. London: SAGE, pp. 69–84.
9.
CassidyC (2016) Promoting human rights through Philosophy with Children. International Journal of Children’s Rights24(3): 499–521.
10.
CassidyC (2017) Philosophy with Children: a rights-based approach to deliberative participation. International Journal of Children’s Rights25(2): 320–334.
11.
ClarkA (2005a) Listening to and involving young children: a review of research and practice. Early Child Development and Care175(6): 489–505.
12.
ClarkA (2005b) Ways of seeing: using the Mosaic approach to listen to young children’s perspectives. In: ClarkAMossPKjørholtA (eds) Beyond Listening: Children’s Perspectives on Early Childhood Services. Bristol: The Policy Press, pp. 29–49.
13.
ClarkA (2007) A hundred ways of listening: gathering children’s perspectives of their early childhood environment. Young Children62(3): 76–81.
14.
Cook-SatherA (2006) Sound, presence, and power: ‘Student voice’ in educational research and reform. Curriculum Inquiry36: 359–390.
15.
Cook-SatherA (2016) Creating brave spaces within and through student-faculty pedagogical partnerships. Teaching and Learning Together in Higher Education1(18): 1–5.
16.
DayLBPercy-SmithSRuxtonK, et al. (2015) Evaluation of Legislation, Policy and Practice on Child Participation in the European Union (EU): Final Report. Brussels: European Commission. Available at: http://publications.europa.eu
17.
DennerJBMeyerSBean (2005) Young women’s leadership alliance: youth–adult partnerships in an all-female after-school program. Journal of Community Psychology33(1): 87–100.
18.
Department of Children and Youth Affairs (2015) National Strategy on Children and Young People’s Participation in Decision-making, 2015 – 2020. Dublin: Government Publications. Available at: www.dcya.ie
19.
DeweyJ (1938/1991) Logic: The Theory of Enquiry: The Later Works of John Dewey, vol. 12 (ed BoydstonJA). Carbondale and Edwardsville, IL: Illinois University Press.
20.
FieldingM (2004) Transformative approaches to student voice: theoretical underpinnings, recalcitrant realities. British Educational Research Journal30(2): 295–311.
21.
GirouxH (1983) Theory and Resistance in Education: A Pedagogy for the Opposition. New York: Bergen and Garvey.
22.
GlazzardJ (2012) Tuning into children’s voices: exploring the perceptions of primary aged children about their education in one primary school in England. International Journal of Education4(3): 49–66.
23.
GündoğuKYildirimA (2010) Voices of home and school on democracy and human rights education at the primary level: a case study. Asia Pacific Education Review11(4): 525–532.
24.
HammersleyM (2017) Childhood Studies: a sustainable paradigm?Childhood24(1): 113–127.
25.
HarcourtDPerryBWallerT (eds) (2011) Researching Young Children’s Perspectives: Debating the Ethics and Dilemmas of Educational Research with Children. London: Routledge.
26.
HendrickH (2000) The child as social actor in historical sources: problems of identification and interpretation. In: ChristensenPJamesA (eds) Research with Children: Perspectives and Practices. London: Falmer Press.
27.
HigginsC (2010a) Labour, work and action: Arendt’s phenomenology of practical life. Journal of Philosophy of Education44(2-3): 275–300.
28.
HigginsC (2010b) Human conditions for teaching: the place of pedagogy in Arendt’s vita active. Teachers College Record112(2): 407–445.
29.
HodgkinRA (1988) Cognitive objects. Oxford Review of Education14(3): 353–362.
30.
HoldsworthR (2000) Schools that create real roles of value for young people. UNESCO International Prospect3: 349–362.
31.
HorganD (2017) Child participatory research methods: attempts to go deeper. Childhood24(2): 245–259.
KanyalMGibbsJ (2014) Participation: why and how?. In: KanyalM (ed.) Children’s Rights: Promoting Participation in Education and Care, 0–8. London: Routledge, pp. 45–62.
34.
KellettM (2014) Images of childhood and their influence on research. In: ClarkAFlewittRHammersleyM, et al. (eds) Understanding Research with Children and Young People. London: SAGE, pp.15–33.
35.
KomulainenS (2007) The ambiguity of the child’s ‘voice’ in social research. Childhood14(1): 11–28.
36.
LansdownG (2010) The realisation of childrens participation rights: critical reflections. In: Percy-SmithBThomasN (eds) A Handbook of Children and Young Peoples Participation: Perspectives from Theory and Practice.Oxford: Routledge, pp. 154–163.
37.
LundyL (2007) ‘Voice’ is not enough: conceptualising Article 12 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. British Educational Research Journal33(6): 927–942.
McLaughlinMW (1993) Embedded identities: enabling balance in urban contexts. In: HeathSBMcLaughlinMW (eds) Identity and Inner-city Youth. New York: Teachers College Press, pp. 36–68.
40.
MacNaughtonGHughesPSmithK (2007) Early childhood professionals and children’s rights: tensions and possibilities around the United Nations General Comment No. 7 on Children’s Rights. International Journal of Early Years Education15(2): 161–170.
41.
MannionG (2007) Going spatial, going relational: why ‘listening to children’ and children’s participation needs reframing. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education28(3): 405–420.
42.
MillsS (2017) Voice: sonic geographies of childhood. Children’s Geographies15(6): 664–677.
43.
MitraD (2003) Student voice in school reform: reframing student-teacher relationships. McGill Journal of Education/Revue des sciences de l’éducation de McGill38(2): 289–304.
44.
MitraDL (2008) Balancing power in communities of practice: an examination of increasing student voice through school-based youth–adult partnerships. Journal of Educational Change9(3): 221–242.
45.
MitraDL (2009) Strengthening student voice initiatives in high schools: an examination of the supports needed for school-based youth-adult partnerships. Youth & Society40(3): 311–335.
46.
MitraDLSandersFCPerkinsDF (2010) Providing spark and stability: the role of intermediary organizations in establishing school-based youth-adult partnerships. Applied Developmental Science14(2): 106–123.
47.
MitraDSerriereSKirshnerB (2014) Youth participation in U.S. contexts: student voice without a national mandate. Children & Society28(4): 292–304.
48.
PapathedorouT (2010) Being, belonging and becoming: some worldviews of early childhood in contemporary curricula. Forum on Public Policy Online2: 1–18.
49.
PascalCBertramT (2009) Listening to young citizens: the struggle to make real a participatory paradigm in research with young children. European Early Childhood Education Research Journal17(2): 249–262.
50.
RabyR (2014) Children’s participation as neo-liberal governance?Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education35(1): 77–89.
51.
RobertsH (2000) Listening to children: and hearing them. In: ChristensenPJamesA (eds) Research with Children. Perspectives and Practices. London: Falmer Press, pp. 260–275.
RobinsonC (2011) Children’s rights in student voice projects: where does the power lie?Education Inquiry2(3): 437–451.
54.
RudduckJ (2006) The past, the papers and the project. Educational Review58(2): 131–143.
55.
SerriereS (2010) Carpet-time democracy: digital photography and social consciousness in the early childhood classroom. The Social Studies101(2): 60–68.
56.
ShultzLGuimaraes-IosifR (2012) Citizenship education and the promise of democracy: a study of UNESCO associated schools in Brazil and Canada. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice7(3): 241–254.
57.
SmithAB (2011) Respecting children’s rights and agency: theoretical insights into ethical research procedures. In: HarcourtDPerryBWallerT (eds) Researching Young Children’s Perspectives. Debating the Ethics and Dilemmas of Educational Research with Children. London: Routledge, pp. 11–25.
58.
SmithAB (2016) Children’s Rights: Towards Social Justice. New York: Momentum Press Health.
59.
StruthersAEC (2015) Human Rights Education: Educating about, through and for human rights. The International Journal of Human Rights19(1): 53–73.
60.
TaylorCRobinsonC (2009) Student voice: theorising power and participation. Pedagogy, Culture & Society17(2): 161–175.
61.
UNESCO (1994) The Salamanca statement and framework for action of special needs education. In: Adopted by the World Conference on Special Needs Education: Access and Quality, Salamanca, 7-10 July 1994. Paris: UNESCO.
62.
United Nations (1989) United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Geneva: United Nations.
63.
VandenbroeckMBourverne-De BieM (2006) Children’s agency and educational norms: a tensed negotiation. Childhood13(1): 127–143.
64.
VygotskyL (1978) Mind in Society – The Development of Higher Psychological Processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
65.
WallK (2012) “It wasn’t too easy, which is good if you want to learn”: an exploration of pupil participation and Learning to Learn. The Curriculum Journal23(3): 283–305.
66.
WallK (2017) Exploring the ethical issues related to visual methodology when including young children’s voice in wider research samples. International Journal of Inclusive Education21(3): 316–331.
67.
WallKHallE (2016) Teachers as metacognitive role models. European Journal of Teacher Education39(4): 403–418.
68.
WallKHigginsS (2006) Facilitating and supporting talk with pupils about metacognition: a research and learning tool. International Journal of Research and Methods in Education29(1): 39–53.
69.
WallKArnottLCassidyC, et al. (2017) Look who’s talking: eliciting the voices of children from birth to seven. International Journal of Student Voice2(1).
70.
WallKHigginsS (2006) Facilitating metacognitive talk: a research and learning tool. Journal of Reearch and Methods in Education29(1): 39–53.
71.
WinnicottDW (1968) The Family and Individual Development. London: Tavistock.
ZeldinSCaminoLMookC (2005) The adoption of innovation in youth organizations: creating the conditions for youth–adult partnerships. Journal of Community Psychology33(1): 121–135.
74.
ZeldinSLCaminoMCalvertD, et al. (2002) Youth-adult Partnerships and Positive Youth Development: Some Lessons Learned from Research and Practice in Wisconsin. Madison: University of Wisconsin-Extension.
