Deephouse raised an important question as to whether firms should be different or should be the same. The strategic balance perspective proposed by him suggests that by balancing the competing pressures of conformity and differentiation, a moderate degree of similarity is what contributes most to firm performance. This perspective has been widely accepted by scholars but follow-up studies are few and have achieved mixed results, leaving the knowledge base in this stream on shaky ground. This study conducted multiple replications of Deephouse’s seminal work across 155 manufacturing industries in China and across two methods to examine its replicability, generalizability, and robustness to methods and to provide additional and cumulative information. The results show that strategic balance perspective was replicable, but with context limitations. Our exploratory analyses indicate several possible boundary conditions and promising topics for furthering the development of strategic balance perspective. Theoretical and methodological implications are discussed.
AcarWKeatingRJAupperleKE, et al. (2003) Peering at the past century’s corporate strategy through the looking glass of time-series analysis: Extrapolating from Chandler’s classic mid-century American firms?Journal of Management Studies40(5): 1225–1254.
2.
AgrawalAKnoeberCR (2001) Do some outside directors play a political role?The Journal of Law and Economics44(1): 179–198.
3.
AngSH (2008) Competitive intensity and collaboration: Impact on firm growth across technological environments. Strategic Management Journal29(10): 1057–1075.
4.
AngristJDPischkeJS (2009) Mostly Harmless Econometrics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
5.
BasdeoDKSmithKGGrimmCM, et al. (2006) The impact of market actions on firm reputation. Strategic Management Journal27(2): 1205–1219.
6.
BaumJACHavemanHA (1997) Love thy neighbor? Differentiation and agglomeration in the Manhattan hotel industry, 1898-1990. Administrative Science Quarterly42(2): 304–338.
7.
BaumJACMeziasSJ (1992) Localized competition and organizational failure in the Manhattan hotel industry, 1898–1990. Administrative Science Quarterly37: 580–604.
8.
BaumJACSinghJV (1994) Organizational niche overlap and the dynamics of organizational mortality. American Journal of Sociology100: 346–380.
BaysingerBHoskissonRE (1989) Diversification strategy and R&D intensity in multiproduct firms. Academy of Management Journal32(2): 310–332.
11.
BerghDDSharpBMAguinisH, et al. (2017) Is there a credibility crisis in strategic management research? Evidence on the reproducibility of study findings. Strategic Organization15(3): 423–436.
12.
BettisRAHelfatCEShaverJM (2016) The necessity, logic, and forms of replication. Strategic Management Journal37(11): 2193–2203.
13.
BuchkoA (2011) Institutionalization, coercive isomorphism, and the homogeneity of strategy. Advances in Business Research2(1): 27–45.
14.
CaiHLiuQ (2009) Competition and corporate tax avoidance: Evidence from Chinese industrial firms. The Economic Journal119: 764–795.
15.
Campbell-HuntC (2000) What have we learned about generic competitive strategy? A meta-analysis. Strategic Management Journal21(2): 127–154.
16.
CarrollGRSwaminathanA (2000) Why the microbrewery movement? Organizational dynamics of resource partitioning in the U.S. brewing industry. American Journal of Sociology106: 715–762.
17.
CartonRBHoferCW (2006) Measuring Organizational Performance: Metrics for Entrepreneurship and Strategic Management Research. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
18.
CastrogiovanniGJ (1991) Environmental munificence: A theoretical assessment. Academy of Management Review16(3): 542–565.
ChenC (1999) Local institutions and the transformation of property rights in Southern Fujian. In: OiJWalderA (eds) Property Rights and Economic Reform in China. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, pp. 40–70.
21.
ChenMJ (1996) Competitor analysis and interfirm rivalry: Toward a theoretical integration. Academy of Management Review21: 100–134.
22.
ChenWRMillerKD (2007) Situational and institutional determinants of firms’ R&D search intensity. Strategic Management Journal28: 369–381.
23.
ClarkeD (2007) Legislating for a market economy in China. China Quarterly191: 567–585.
DiMaggioPJPowellWW (1983) The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review48: 147–160.
31.
DowellG (2006) Product line strategies of new entrants in an established industry: Evidence from the US bicycle industry. Strategic Management Journal27(10): 959–979.
32.
DriscollJCKraayAC (1998) Consistent covariance matrix estimation with spatially dependent panel data. The Review of Economics and Statistics80: 549–560.
33.
EapenAKrishnanR (2009) Conform or rebel: Who does keeping to the rules enhance firm performance?Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences26: 95–108.
34.
FaccioM (2006) Politically connected firms. American Economic Review96(1): 369–386.
35.
FarjounMLaiL (1997) Similarity judgments in strategy formulation: Role, process and implications. Strategic Management Journal18(4): 255–273.
36.
FiegenbaumAThomasH (1995) Strategic groups as reference groups: Theory, modeling and empirical examination of industry and competitive strategy. Strategic Management Journal16(6): 461–476.
37.
FinkelsteinSHambrickDC (1990) Top management team tenure and organizational outcomes: The moderating role of managerial discretion. Administrative Science Quarterly35(3): 484–503.
38.
GaoGYMurrayJYKotabeM, et al. (2010) A “strategy tripod” perspective on export behaviors: Evidence from domestic and foreign firms based in an emerging economy. Journal of International Business Studies41(3): 377–396.
39.
GranovetterM (1985) Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology91(3): 481–510.
HaansRFJPietersCHeZ (2015) Thinking about U: Theorizing and testing U- and inverted U-shaped relationships in strategy research. Strategic Management Journal37(7): 1177–1195.
42.
HambrickDC (2007) Upper echelons theory: An update. Academy of Management Review32(2): 334–343.
43.
HamiltonBHNickersonJA (2003) Correcting for endogeneity in strategic management research. Strategic Organization1(1): 51–78.
44.
HannanMT (1997) Inertia, density and the structure of organizational populations: Entries in European automobile industries, 1886-1981. Organization Studies18(2): 193–228.
45.
HarrisRJ (1985) A Primer of Multivariate Statistics, 2nd edn.New York: Academic Press.
46.
HarrisonJSBanksGCPollackJM, et al. (2017) Publication bias in strategic management research. Journal of Management43(2): 400–425.
47.
HaunschildPR (1993) Interorganizational imitation: The impact of interlocks on corporate acquisition activity. Administrative Science Quarterly38: 564–592.
48.
HavemanHA (1993) Follow the leader: Mimetic isomorphism and entry into new markets. Administrative Science Quarterly38: 593–627.
49.
HavemanHAJiaNShiJ, et al. (2017) The dynamics of political embeddedness in China. Administrative Science Quarterly62(1): 67–104.
50.
HoechleD (2007) Robust standard errors for panel regressions with cross-sectional dependence. Stata Journal7: 281–298.
51.
HubbardRVetterDE (1996) An empirical comparison of published replication research in accounting, economics, finance, management, and marketing. Journal of Business Research35: 153–164.
52.
HubbardRVetterDELittleEL (1998) Replication in strategic management: Scientific testing for validity, generalizability, and usefulness. Strategic Management Journal19(3): 243–254.
53.
HuffAS (1982) Industry influences on strategy reformulation. Strategic Management Journal3(2): 119–131.
54.
HymerSH (1976) The International Operations of National Firms: A Study of Direct Foreign Investment. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
55.
ItoKPucikV (1993) R&D spending, domestic competition, and export performance of Japanese manufacturing firms. Strategic Management Journal14(1): 61–75.
56.
JeffersonGHSuJ (2006) Privatization and restructuring in China: Evidence from shareholding ownership, 1995–2001. Journal of Comparative Economics34(1): 146–166.
57.
KaleSArditiD (2003) Differentiation, conformity, and construction firm performance. Journal of Management in Engineering19(2): 52–59.
58.
KochMJMcGrathRG (1996) Improving labor productivity: Human resource management policies do matter. Strategic Management Journal17(5): 335–354.
59.
KothaSRajgopalSRindovaV (2001) Reputation building and performance: An empirical analysis of the top-50 pure internet firms. European Management Journal19(6): 571–586.
60.
LamertzKHeugensPPMARCalmetL (2005) The configuration of organizational images among firms in the Canadian beer brewing industry. Journal of Management Studies42(4): 817–843.
61.
LeibleinMJMillerDJ (2003) An empirical examination of transaction- and firm-level influences on the vertical boundaries of the firm. Strategic Management Journal24: 839–859.
62.
LemelinA (1982) Relatedness in the patterns of interindustry diversification. The Review of Economics and Statistics64(4): 646–657.
63.
LiJYangJYYueDR (2007) Identity, community, and audience: How wholly owned foreign subsidiaries gain legitimacy in China. Academy of Management Journal50(1): 175–190.
64.
LiYPengMWMacaulayCD (2013) Market–political ambidexterity during institutional transitions. Strategic Organization11(2): 205–213.
65.
LiebermanMBAsabaS (2006) Why do firms imitate each other?Academy of Management Review31(2): 366–385.
66.
LindJTMehlumH (2010) With or without U? The appropriate test for a U-shaped relationship. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics72(1): 109–118.
67.
LounsburyMGlynnMA (2001) Cultural entrepreneurship: Stories, legitimacy, and the acquisition of resources. Strategic Management Journal22(6–7): 545–564.
68.
LustigMWAndersenPA (1990) Generalizing about communication apprehension and avoidance: Multiple replications and meta-analyses. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality5(4): 309–340.
69.
MeyerJWRowanB (1977) Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology83(2): 340–363.
70.
MeziasSJRegnierMO (2007) Walking the walk as well as talking the talk: Replication and the normal science paradigm in strategic management research. Strategic Organization5(3): 283–296.
71.
MillerDChenMJ (1996) Nonconformity in competitive repertoires: A sociological view of markets. Social Forces74(4): 1209–1234.
72.
MillerDLe Breton-MillerILesterRH (2013) Family firm governance, strategic conformity, and performance: Institutional vs. strategic perspectives. Organization Science24: 189–209.
73.
MillerSREdenL (2006) Local density and foreign subsidiary performance. Academy of Management Journal49(2): 341–355.
74.
MintzbergH (1987) The strategy concept I: Five Ps for strategy. California Management Review30(1): 11–24.
75.
NatividadG (2013) Financial slack, strategy, and competition in movie distribution. Organization Science24(3): 846–864.
76.
NewbertSL (2007) Empirical research on the resource-based view of the firm: An assessment and suggestions for future research. Strategic Management Journal28(2): 121–146.
77.
NewbertSLDavidRJHanSK (2014) Rarely pure and never simple: Assessing cumulative evidence in strategic management. Strategic Organization12(2): 142–154.
78.
NewportELHauserMDSpaepenG, et al. (2004) Learning at a distance II. Statistical learning of non-adjacent dependencies in a non-human primate. Cognitive Psychology49(2): 85–117.
79.
OcasioW (1997) Towards an attention-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal18(S1): 187–206.
80.
OerlemansLAGMeeusMTH (2005) Do organizational and spatial proximity impact on firm performance?Regional Studies39(1): 89–104.
81.
OliverC (1997) The influence of institutional and task environment relationships on organizational performance: The Canadian construction industry. Journal of Management Studies34(1): 99–124.
82.
PalepuK (1985) Diversification strategy, profit performance and the entropy measure. Strategic Management Journal6(3): 239–255.
83.
PengMW (2003) Institutional transitions and strategic choices. Academy of Management Review28(2): 275–296.
84.
PoracJFThomasHBaden-FullerC (1989) Competitive groups as cognitive communities: The case of Scottish knitwear manufacturers. Journal of Management Studies26: 397–416.
85.
RamaswamyK (2001) Organizational ownership, competitive intensity, and firm performance: An empirical study of the Indian manufacturing sector. Strategic Management Journal22(10): 989–998.
86.
RaoHMoninPDurandR (2003) Institutional change in Toque Ville: Nouvelle cuisine as an identity movement in French gastronomy. American Journal of Sociology108(4): 795–843.
RichardPJDevinneyTMYipGS, et al. (2009) Measuring organizational performance: Towards methodological best practice. Journal of Management35(3): 718–804.
89.
RobinsonKCMcDougallPP (2001) Entry barriers and new venture performance: A comparison of universal and contingency approaches. Strategic Management Journal22: 659–685.
90.
RosenthalR (1979) The “file drawer problem” and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin86: 638–641.
91.
RosenthalR (1991) Applied Social Research Methods: Meta-analytic Procedures for Social Research. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
92.
RuefMScottW (1998) A multidimensional model of organizational legitimacy: Hospital survival in changing institutional environments. Administrative Science Quarterly43(4): 877–904.
93.
RussoMVFoutsPA (1997) A resource-based perspective on corporate environmental performance and profitability. Academy of Management Journal40(3): 534–559.
94.
SidaniYAl ArissA (2014) Institutional and corporate drivers of global talent management: Evidence from the Arab Gulf region. Journal of World Business49: 215–224.
95.
SinghKAngSHLeongSM (2003) Increasing replication for knowledge accumulation in strategy research. Journal of Management29(4): 533–549.
96.
SloneRE (2004) Leading a supply chain turnaround. Harvard Business Review82(10): 114–121.
97.
SunQTongWH (2003) China share issue privatization: The extent of its success. Journal of Financial Economics70(2): 183–222.
98.
TanJ (2002) Impact of ownership type on environment, strategy, and performance: Evidence from China. Journal of Management Studies39(3): 333–354.
99.
TatarynowiczASytchMGulatiR (2016) Environmental demands and the emergence of social structure: Technological dynamism and interorganizational network forms. Administrative Science Quarterly61(1): 52–86.
100.
TianX (2007) Accounting for sources of FDI technology spillovers: Evidence from China. Journal of International Business Studies38: 147–159.
101.
TjosvoldDPengACChenYF, et al. (2008) Business and government interdependence in China: Cooperative goals to develop industries and the marketplace. Asia Pacific Journal of Management25(2): 225–249.
102.
TsangEKwanK (1999) Replication and theory development in organizational science: A critical realist perspective. Academy of Management Review24(4): 759–780.
103.
Vicente-LorenteJD (2001) Specificity and opacity as resource-based determinants of capital structure: Evidence for Spanish manufacturing firms. Strategic Management Journal22(2): 157–177.
104.
WernerfeltB (1984) A resource-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal5(2): 171–180.
105.
WhitingSH (1999) The regional evolution of ownership forms: Shareholding cooperatives and rural industry in Shanghai and Wenzhou. In: OiJWalderA (eds) Property Rights and Economic Reform in China. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, pp. 171–200.
106.
WooldridgeJ (2002) Econometric Analysis of Cross-Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
107.
ZajacEJWestphalJD (1994) The costs and benefits of managerial incentives and monitoring in large US corporations: When is more not better?Strategic Management Journal15(S1): 121–142.
108.
ZhaoEYFisherGLounsburyM, et al. (2017) Optimal distinctiveness revisited: Broadening the interface between institutional theory and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal38: 93–113.
109.
ZhengWSinghKChungCN (2017) Ties to unbind: Political ties and firm sell-offs during institutional transition. Journal of Management43(7): 2005–2036.
110.
ZhouW (2009) Bank financing in China’s private sector: The payoffs of political capital. World Development37(4): 787–799.
111.
ZuckermanEW (1999) The categorical imperative: Securities analysts and the illegitimacy discount. American Journal of Sociology104: 1398–1438.
112.
ZuckermanEW (2016) Optimal distinctiveness revisited: An integrative framework for understanding the balance between differentiation and conformity in individual and organizational identities. In: PrattMGSchultzMAshforthBE, et al (eds) Handbook of Organizational Identity. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 183–199.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
