The event of meaning making in fine art studio pedagogy is explored in this paper through the enquiry into the practice of critique (colloquially known as ‘crit’). It will seek to understand the role of consensus (in the Kantian sense) and judgement in formative group critique feedback exchanges and how these concepts interplay with the concept of dissensus as developed by Rancière. It argues that joint inquiry into what an artwork does within a specific context provides insights into the creation of meaning for the developing artist as an individual and within a learning community.
AtkinsonD (2021) Inheritance, disobedience and speculation in pedagogic practice. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education43(5): 749–765.
2.
BarrettT (1988) A comparison of the goals of studio professors conducting critiques and art education goals for teaching criticism. Studies in Art Education30(1): 22–27.
3.
BarrettT (2004a) Improving student dialogue about art. Teaching Artist Journal2(2): 87–94.
4.
BarrettT (2004b) Investigating art criticism in education: an autobiographical narrative. In: EisnerEWDayMD (eds) Handbook of Research and Policy in Art Education. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers, 725–749.
BiestaG (2017) In: VosM (ed) Letting Art Teach: Art Education after Joseph Beuys. Arnhem, Netherlands: ArtEZ Press.
7.
BlairB (2006) ‘At the end of a huge crit in the summer, it was “crap” – I’d worked really hard but all she said was “fine” and I was gutted. Art, Design and Communication in Higher Education5(2): 83–95.
8.
BoerKSondereggerR (2012) Conceptions of critique. In: BoerKSondereggerR (eds) Modern and Contemporary Philosophy. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
9.
ClementV (2019) Beyond the sham of the emancipatory enlightenment: rethinking the relationship of indigenous epistemologies, knowledges, and geography through decolonizing paths. Progress in Human Geography43(2): 276–294.
10.
DeweyJ (1997) How We Think. Mississauga, ON: Dover Publications, Inc. (Original work published 1910).
11.
ElkinsJ (1992) Art school critiques as seductions. Journal of Aesthetic Education26(1): 105–107.
12.
ElkinsJ (2001) Why Art Cannot Be Taught. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
13.
Gaztambide-FernándezRA (2013) Why the arts don’t do anything: toward a new vision for cultural production in education. Harvard Educational Review83(1): 211–237.
14.
HalversonERSaplanKStoiberA, et al. (2020) The role of critique in the development of student-artists’ metacognitive practices. In: Multidisciplinary Approaches to Art Learning and Creativity. New York, NY: Routledge, 167–189.
15.
HealyJP (2016) The components of the ‘crit’ in art and design education. Irish Journal of Academic Practice5(1): 17.
16.
HetlandLWinnerEVeenemaS, et al. (2013) Studio Thinking: The Real Benefits of Visual Arts Education. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
17.
JohnsonH (2015) Painting Is a Critical Form. Digital edition. Sydney, NSW: 3-Ply and Minerva.
KantIMeredithJC (2007) Critique of Judgement. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
20.
LuckettKBhattI (2024) Getting critical about critique in higher education: provocations on the meanings of ‘critical perspectives’. Teaching in Higher Education29(6): 1690–1703.
21.
McphersonMJ (2018) Subjectivity, Agency and Affect in the Undergraduate University Art Studio Crit. PhD, Monash University, Melbourne, VIC.
22.
MirandaP (2013) The crit lab: critical ethical art. Available at: https://thecritlab.com/about (accessed 26 November 2024).
23.
MunariBSantanaD (2006) Design e Comunicação Visual: Contribuição Para Uma Metodologia Didática. Sao Paulo, Brazil: Martins Fontes.
24.
MurrayJAHBradleyHCraigieWA, et al. (1989) The Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd edition. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press, Vol. 4.
25.
NewallM (2018) Crits, consensus and criticality: making artists in the contemporary art school. In: The Routledge Companion to Criticality in Art, Architecture and Design. London, UK: Routledge, 14–31. Available at: https://www.routledgehandbooks.com/doi/10.4324/9781315623412-3.
26.
OrrS (2011) ‘Being an artist you kind of, I mean, you get used to excellence’: identity, values and fine art assessment practices. International Journal of Art and Design Education30(1): 37–44.
27.
OrrSShreeveA (2018) Art and Design Pedagogy in Higher Education: Knowledge, Values and Ambiguity in the Creative Curriculum. Oxon, UK: Routledge.
28.
OrrSYorkeMBlairB (2014) ‘The answer is brought about from within you’: a student-centred perspective on pedagogy in art and design. International Journal of Art and Design Education33(1): 32–45.
29.
PercyC (2004) Critical absence versus critical engagement. Problematics of the crit in design learning and teaching. Art, Design and Communication in Higher Education2(3): 143–154.
30.
RancièreJCorcoranS (2010) Dissensus: On Politics and Aesthetics. London, UK: Continuum Books.
31.
RanciereJElliotG (2009) The Emancipated Spectator. London, UK: Verso.
32.
RancièreJRockhillG (2000) The Politcs of Aesthetics: The Distribution of the Sensible. London, UK: Continuum Books.
33.
SawyerRK (2017) Teaching creativity in art and design studio classes: a systematic literature review. Educational Research Review22: 99–113.
34.
SimsEShreeveA (2012) Signature pedagogies in art and design. In: ChickNLHaynieAGurungRAR (eds) Exploring More Signature Pedagogies: Approaches to Teaching Disciplinary Habits of Mind. New York, NY: Routledge, 55–67.
35.
SoepE (2000) To Make Things with Words: Critique and the Art of Production. PhD Thesis, Stanford University, Stanford, CA.
36.
SoepE (2006) Critique: assessment and the production of learning. Teachers College Record108(4): 748–777.
37.
SoulelesN (2013) The evolution of art and design pedagogies in England: influences of the past, challenges for the future. International Journal of Art and Design Education32(2): 243–255.
TravisS (2020) Flashpoints of artist identity formation. Art Education73(5): 16–25.
40.
UnkeferENSCurtisCAndradeL, et al. (2023) “Out of my element”: the experiences of black art students in critique. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education16(1): 40–52.
41.
WongHLH (2011) Critique: a communicative event in design education. Visible Language45(3): 221–247.
