In a remarkably frank paper, Professor Andrew Burrows has shed some light on the process by which awards for non-pecuniary loss in personal injury cases were uplifted in Heil v Rankin, a process in which he played a leading role as a Law Commissioner. In apparent disregard of the criticisms to which this process has been subjected, Burrows regards it as an example of a valuable ‘methodology’ of common law law reform. These criticisms are reviewed in this paper and to them is added a criticism of the concept of ‘normal decision-making’ by the courts that is the basis of Burrows’ views. Heil v Rankin was far from normal decision-making, but in this it was merely of a piece with all awards of damages for non-pecuniary loss, for such damages have no grounding in the common law adjudication of awards of compensation. The further development in Simmons v Castle of the judicial legislation effected in Heil v Rankin is also considered.
AllenDKBourneCJHolyoakJH (eds.) (1979) Accident Compensation After Pearson. London: Sweet and Maxwell.
2.
Anon (2012) Increase in general damages: Quid pro quo for loss of success fees. Civil Procedure News9(October): 6–8.
3.
ArvindTTSteeleJ (eds.) (2012) Tort Law and the Legislature. Oxford: Hart.
4.
AtiyahPS (1997) The Damages Lottery. Oxford: Hart.
5.
BeeverA (2011) Our most fundamental rights. In: NolanDRobertsonA (eds.) Rights and Private Law. Oxford: Hart, pp.63–87.
6.
BeeverA (2016) A Theory of Tort Liability. Oxford: Hart.
7.
BennettC (2000) Personal injuries: General damages—minor increases only. Journal of Personal Injuries Law2/3: 129–136.
8.
BeveridgeW (1942) Social Insurance and Allied Services. Cmd 6404.
9.
BurrowsA (1998a) Improving contract and tort: The view from the law commission. In: Understanding the Law of Obligations. Oxford: Hart, pp.164–121.
10.
BurrowsA (1998b) In defence of tort. In: Understanding the Law of Obligations. Oxford: Hart, pp.120–134.
11.
BurrowsA (1998c) Restitution: Where do we go from here? In: Understanding the Law of Obligations. Oxford: Hart, pp.99–119.
12.
BurrowsA (2015) Alternatives to legislation: Restatements and judicial law reform. In: GulliferLVogenauerS (eds.) English and European Perspectives on Contract and Commercial Law. Oxford: Hart, pp.37–50.
13.
CampbellD (2010) Gathering the water: Abuse of rights after the recognition of government failure. The Journal Jurisprudence7: 487–534.
14.
CampbellD (2015) Interpersonal justice and actual choice as ways of determining personal injury law and policy. Legal Studies35(3): 430–442.
15.
CoaseRH (1950) British Broadcasting. London: Longmans, Green and Co.
16.
CoaseRHWangN (2012) How China became capitalist. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
17.
Departmental Committee on Alternative Remedies (Chair: Sir Walter Monckton) (1946) Final Report. Cmd 6860.
18.
HarlowC (2002) Public law and popular justice. Modern Law Review65(1): 1–18.
19.
HarrisD (1984) Compensation and Support for Illness and Injury. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
20.
HarrisDCampbellDHalsonR (2002) Remedies in Contract and Tort. 2nd edn. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
21.
JacksonR (2009a) Review of Civil Litigation Costs: Final Report. Norwich: The Stationery Office.
22.
JacksonR (2009b) Review of Civil Litigation Costs: Preliminary Report. Norwich: The Stationery Office.
Judicial College (2015) Guidelines for the Assessment of General Damages in Personal Injury Cases. 13th edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
26.
Judicial Studies Board (1992) Guidelines for the Assessment of General Damages in Personal Injury Cases. London: Blackstone Press.
27.
Judicial Studies Board (2000) Guidelines for The Assessment of General Damages in Personal Injury Cases. 5th edn. London: Blackstone Press.
28.
KempDAKempMS (1954–56) The Quantum of Damages in Personal Injury Claims. London: Sweet and Maxwell.
29.
Law Commission (1994a) Personal injury compensation: How much is enough?EWLC 225.
30.
Law Commission (1994b) Structured settlements and interim and provisional damages. EWLC 224.
31.
Law Commission (1995a) Damages for personal injury: Non-pecuniary loss. EWLC C140.
32.
Law Commission (1995b) Sixth Programme of Law Reform. EWLC 234.
33.
Law Commission (1998a) Damages for personal injury: Non-pecuniary loss. EWLC 257.
34.
Law Commission (1998b) Liability for Psychiatric Illness. EWLC 249.
35.
Law Commission (1999a) Claims for Wrongful Death. EWLC 263.
36.
Law Commission (1999b) Damages for personal injury: Medical, nursing and other expenses; collateral benefits. EWLC 262.
37.
Law Commission (2000) Thirty Fourth Annual Report 1999. EWLC 265.
38.
LewisR (2001) Increasing the price of pain: Damages, the Law Commission and Heil v Rankin. Modern Law Review64(1): 100–111.
39.
LewisR (2012) Recovery of state benefits from tort damages: Legislating for or against the welfare state. In ArvindTTSteeleJ (eds.) Tort Law and the Legislature. Oxford: Hart, pp.285–301.
40.
LewisR (2016) Structural factors affecting the number and cost of personal injury claims in the tort system. In: QuillEFrielRJ (eds.) Damages and Compensation Culture: Comparative Perspectives. Oxford: Hart, pp.37–59.
41.
LewisRMorrisA (2012) Tort law culture: Image and reality. Journal of Law and Society39(4): 562–592.
42.
Ministry of Justice (2010) Proposals for Reform of Civil Litigation Funding and Costs in England and Wales. CP13/10. Cm 7947.
43.
Ministry of Justice (2011) Reforming Civil Litigation Funding and Costs in England and Wales: Implementation of Lord Justice Jackson’s Recommendations—The Government Response. Cm 8041.
44.
RamseyV (2013) Implementation of the costs reforms. Civil Justice Quarterly32(2): 112–122.
45.
Royal Commission on Civil Liability and Compensation for Personal Injury (Chair: Lord Pearson) (1978) Report. Cmnd 7054.
46.
Transport Committee (2011) Fourth Report: The Cost of Motor Insurance(2010–12) HC 591.
47.
Transport Committee (2012) Twelfth Report: Cost of Motor Insurance—Follow Up(2010–12) HC 1451.
48.
Transport Committee (2013) Fourth Report: Cost of Motor Insurance—Whiplash(2013–14) HC 117.
49.
Transport Committee (2014) First Report: Driving Premiums Down—Fraud and the Cost of Motor Insurance(2014–15) HC 285.
50.
WeirT (2000) A Casebook on Contract. 9th edn. London: Sweet and Maxwell.
51.
WeirT (2004) A Casebook on Contract. 10th edn. London: Sweet and Maxwell.
