This article examines Vietnam’s regulations and practices concerning the right to defence of juvenile offenders in comparison with international standards. I use mixed methods including statistics and analysis of case studies. Research findings indicate that Vietnam’s laws firmly state the right to defence of juvenile offenders but lack specific guarantees for appropriate legal support and protection of privacy. In the implementation of the law, we can see various issues, including a lack of understanding of their rights by offenders and their representatives, and failure to provide appropriate defence for juvenile offenders among responsible agencies.
Bo Tu Phap (2012) Bao Cao Tong Ket 5 Nam Thi Hanh Luat Luat Su [Summary report on the five-year implementation of the law on the lawyer]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Ministry of Justice.
2.
Bo Tu Phap and UNICEF (2012) Detailed Project Outline: Friendly Justice System for Minors Project 2012 – 2016. Hanoi, Vietnam: Ministry of Justice
3.
BoothN (2012) Implementing human rights in practice: Some observations. In: Proceedings of the conference on The 1st legal policy dialogue in 2012: Improvement of law on human rights, Hanoi, Vietnam, 23May2012, 31–35
4.
Children’s Legal Centre (2010) Bao Cao Danh Gia cac Quy Dinh cua Bo Luat Hinh Su Lien Quan Den Nguoi Chua Thanh Nien va Thuc Tien Thi Hanh [An assessment report on the provisions relating to Juveniles in the penal code and their practical implementation]. In: The Conference on Phap Luat To Tung Hinh Su ve Nguoi Chua Thanh Nien [Criminal procedural law concerning Juveniles], Hanoi, Vietnam, 15–16December.
5.
Dai Hoc Luat Ha Noi (2013) Hoan Thien Phap Luat To Tung Hinh Su nham Nang Cao Hieu Qua Hoat Dong Bao Chua cua Luat Su [The amendment of criminal procedural law in order to improve the effectiveness of lawyer professionals]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Hanoi Law University
6.
General Office for Population and Family Planning (2014) Tong Ket Cong Tac Dan So - Ke Hoach Hoa Gia Dinh nam 2013, Trien Khai Nhiem Vu nam 2014 [Reviewing the tasks of population and family planning in 2013, and implementing tasks in 2014]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Ministry of Health
7.
Lien Doan Luat Su Viet Nam (2011) Quy Tac Dao Duc va Ung Xu Nghe Nghiep Luat Su Viet Nam [The ethic conducts of Vietnamese lawyers]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Vietnam Bar Federation
8.
Lien Doan Luat Su Viet Nam (2012) Bao Cao Tong Ket Cong Tac nam 2011 va Phuong Huong Hoat Dong nam 2012 cua Lien Doan Luat Su Viet Nam [Summary report on implementing the tasks in 2011 and direction in 2012 of the Vietnam Bar Federation]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Vietnam Bar Federation .
9.
Lien Doan Luat Su Viet Nam (2013) Bao Cao ve Thuc Trang Hanh Nghe Luat Su trong Hoat Dong To Tung Hinh Su [Report on the current situation of lawyers’ professional performance in the criminal proceedings]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Vietnam Bar Federation .
10.
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2004) White Paper on Human Rights in Vietnam. Hanoi, Vietnam: Available at: www.mofa.gov.vn (accessed 10 January 2014).
11.
MowerAG (1997) The Convention on the Rights of the Child: International Law Support for Children. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
NguyenTD (2007) Dam Bao Quyen cua Nguoi Bi Tam Giu, Bi Can, Bi Cao trong To Tung Hinh Su Viet Nam [Ensuring the rights of persons held in custody, the accused and defendants in Vietnam’s criminal procedure]. The People’s Court Journal2007(11): 4–10.
NguyenVC (2011) Tham Luan Luat Luat Su sau 5 nam Thuc Hien: Kho Dhan, Vuong Mac cua Luat Su trong Qua Trinh Hanh Nghe [Memoir on the law on lawyers after 5 years of implementation: Difficulties and problems confronting lawyers in the course of practice]. Available at: http://liendoanluatsu.org.vn/ (accessed 29/9/2012).
16.
PhamHH (2006) Nhung diem moi ve Trach nhiem va Nghia vu cua Nguoi bao chua trong Bo luat to tung hinh su nam 2003 [New features of defence counsels’ responsibilities and obligations in the criminal procedure code 2003]. In: Proceedings of the conference on Quyen Con Nguoi trong To tung Hinh Su Viet Nam [Human rights in Vietnam’s criminal justice], Ho Chi Minh City, 15–18June, Vietnam: Ho Chi Minh City University of Law, 183–193.
17.
PhamMT (2007) Mot so Van De ve Bao Dam Quyen Bao Chua cua Nguoi Bi Tam Giu, Bi Can, Bi Cao trong Luat To Tung Hinh Su nam 2003 [Several issues concerning the right to defence of persons held in custody, the accused and defendants in criminal law of 2003]. The People’s Court Journal2007(21): 27–29.
18.
PhamTQ (2008) Trao Doi ve Che Dinh Quyen Bao Chua trong Phap Luat To Tung Hinh Su [Some discussion on the right to defence in criminal law]. The People’s Court Journal2008(24): 35–40.
19.
PhamTTN (2013) The establishment of Juvenile courts and the fulfillment of Vietnam’s obligations under the convention on the rights of the child. Australian Journal of Asian Law14: 1–19.
20.
PhanTH (2006) Thuc Trang va Dinh Huong Hoan Thien Phap Luat nham Bao Dam Quyen cua Luat Su Tham Gia Tranh Tung trong Vu An Hinh Su [The current situation and requirements to improve the law on ensuring lawyers’ rights in criminal proceedings]. In: Proceedings of the conference on Quyen Con Nguoi trong To tung Hinh Su Viet Nam [Human rights in Vietnam’s criminal justice], Ho Chi Minh City, 15–18 June, Vietnam: Ho Chi Minh City University of Law, 206–217.
21.
PhanTTM (2012) Mot so Y Kien ve viec Thanh Lap Toa An Gia Dinh va Nguoi Chua Thanh Nien o Vietnam [Several comments on the establishment of the Juvenile and family court in Vietnam]. In: Toa An Nhan Dan Toi Cao and UNICEF Vietnam (eds) Bao Cao Tong Quan ve Co so Ly Luan va Thuc Tien cua Su Can Thiet Thanh Lap Toa An Chuyen Trach doi voi Nguoi Chua Thanh Nien o Viet Nam [General Report on the Theoretical and Practical Rationale for Establishing Specialised Courts for Juveniles in Vietnam]. Hanoi, Vietnam: Thanh Nien, 173–182.
22.
Secretary-General of UN Security Council (2004) The rule of law and transitional justice in conflict and post-conflict societies. Available at: http://www.unrol.org/files/2004%20report.pdf
23.
Supreme People’s Court and UNICEF Vietnam (2007) Investigation and Court Proceedings Involving Children and Juveniles: An Assessment of Child-sensitive Procedures. Hanoi, Vietnam: Thanh Nien.
24.
Toa An Nhan Dan Toi Cao (1974) Trinh tu Xet xu So tham ve Hinh su [Procedures for first-instance trial] (dated 27 September 1974). In: He Thong Hoa cac Van ban ve Luat Le Hinh Su [The codification of criminal law]. Hanoi, Vietnam.
25.
Toa An Nhan Dan Toi Cao (2012) Bao Cao cua Chanh An Toa An Nhan Dan Toi Cao, nhiem ky 2007–2011 [The report of the chief judge of the supreme people’s court, term 2007–2011]. Hanoi, Vietnam: The Supreme People’s Court.
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) (2012) Report on the right to counsel in criminal law and practice in Vietnam. Available at: www.vn.undp.org (accessed 15 January 2014).
29.
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and Hoi Luat Gia Viet Nam (2012) Appointed counsels in Vietnamese criminal law and practices. Available at: www.vn.undp.org (accessed 15 January 2014).
30.
Vietnam (1999) National Report on the Implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child 1993–1998. Hanoi, Vietnam: Socialist Republic of Vietnam.
31.
Vietnam (2009) National report of socialist republic of Vietnam under the universal periodic review of the United Nations Human Rights Council. Hanoi, Vietnam: Socialist Republic of Vietnam. Available at: vietnamembassy-usa.org (accessed 15 September 2013).
32.
Vietnam Lawyers’ Association (2008). Tai Lieu Tap Huan cho cac Chuyen Gia Phap Ly o Viet Nam ve Tro Giup Phap Ly va Dai Dien, Bao Chua cho Nguoi Chua Thanh Nien/ Tre Em [Handbook for Legal Experts in Vietnam about Legal Assistance, Representative and Defence for Juveniles/ Children]. Hanoi, GTVT]
