‘Unsafe,Unjust and Harmful to Wider Society’: Grounds for Raising the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility in England and Wales

Abstract

This article assesses critically the means by which social (symbolic) and statutory (institutionalized) constructions of child ‘offenders’ in England and Wales intersect and underpin processes of responsibilization and adultification. It is argued that securing immunity from prosecution should be the principal driver for raising the minimum age of criminal responsibility. In this sense the analysis is less concerned with questions of capacity and mens rea and more interested in: compliance with international human rights standards; modelling a system of justice that is broadly compatible with law, policy and practice in Europe (and elsewhere); ensuring that criminal law coheres with civil law; minimizing social harm and obtaining the best outcomes for children in conflict with the law, the wider community and the general public in respect of crime prevention and community safety. Finally, the prospects for such progressive reform within a context of heightened politicization are considered.

Keywords

adultification capacity criminal responsibility evidence human rights immunity justice knowledge politicization

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

All Party Parliamentary Group for Children (2010) Children and Young People in the Youth Justice System: London, National Children’s Bureau.

All Party Parliamentary Group on Women in the Penal System (2012) Keeping Girls out of the Penal System. London: Howard League for Penal Reform.

Ariès

(1962) Centuries of Childhood. Harmondsworth: Penguin.

Atkinson

(2010) ‘Even Bulger killers were just children, says Maggie Atkinson, Children’s Commissioner’, The Times, 13 March. Available at: http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/life/families/article2464698.ece (accessed 12 February 2013).

Bandalli

(2000) Children, responsibility and the new youth justice. In: Goldson

(ed.) The New Youth Justice. Lyme Regis: Russell House Publishing.

Bateman

(2012a) Criminalising children for no good purpose: The age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales, National Association for Youth Justice Campaign Paper. Available at: http://thenayj.org.uk/wp-content/files_mf/criminalisingchildrennov12.pdf (accessed 12 February 2013).

Bateman

(2012b) Who pulled the plug? Towards an explanation of the fall in child imprisonment in England and Wales. Youth Justice: An International Journal 12(1): 36−52.

Bateman

Pitts

(2005) Conclusion: What the evidence tells us. In: Bateman

Pitts

(eds) The RHP Companion to Youth Justice. Lyme Regis: Russell House Publishing.

Becker

(1963) Outsiders: Studies in the Sociology of Deviance. London: Macmillan.

10.

Becroft

(2009) How to turn a child offender into an adult criminal - in 10 easy steps. Paper presented at Children and the Law International Conference, Prato, Italy. Available at: http://www.rethinking.org.nz/assets/Young_People_and_Crime/10_Easy_Steps.pdf (accessed 12 February 2013).

11.

Bernberg

Krohn

(2003) Labeling, life chances and adult crime: The direct and indirect effects of official intervention in adolescence on crime in early adulthood. Criminology 41(4): 1287−1318.

12.

Bottoms

(1974) On the decriminalisation of English juvenile courts. In: Hood

(ed.) Crime, Criminology and Public Policy. London: Heinemann.

13.

Brewer

Browne

Joyce

(2011) Child and Working Age Poverty from 2010 to 2020. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies.

14.

Brooks

(2011) An ugly totem for the abject failure of our criminal justice system. The Guardian, 18 March. Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/mar/18/justice-10-age-criminal-responsibility (accessed 12 February 2013).

15.

Centre for Social Justice (2012) Rules of Engagement: Changing the Heart of Youth Justice. London: Centre for Social Justice.

16.

Children’s Rights International Network (n.d.) Making children criminals…. Available at: http://www.crin.org/resources/infodetail.asp?id=27829 (accessed 12 February 2013)

17.

Children’s Rights International Network (2012) Juvenile justice: States lowering the minimum age of criminal responsibility. Available at: http://www.crin.org/resources/infodetail.asp?id=27826# (accessed 12 February 2013)

18.

Cipriani

(2009) Children’s Rights and the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: A Global Perspective. Aldershot: Ashgate.

19.

Coleman

(2011) The Nature of Adolescence. London: Routledge.

20.

Commission of the European Communities (2006) Towards an EU Strategy on the Rights of the Child. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.

21.

Corsaro

(1997) The Sociology of Childhood. California: Pine Forge Press.

22.

Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights (2009) Children and Juvenile Justice: Proposals for Improvements. Strasbourg: Council of Europe.

23.

Crofts

(2009) Catching up with Europe: Taking the age of criminal responsibility seriously in England. European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice 17(4): 267−291.

24.

Crook

(2012) 2000 under-12s arrested last year, says charity. The Guardian, 3 December. Accessible at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2012/dec/03/under-12s-arrested-children (accessed 12 February 2013).

25.

Davis

Bourhill

(1997) ‘Crisis’: The demonization of children and young people. In: Scraton

(ed.) Childhood’ in ‘Crisis’? London: UCL Press.

26.

Department for Work and Pensions (2012) Households Below Average Income: An Analysis of the Income Distribution 1994/95 – 2010/11. London: Department for Work and Pensions.

27.

Douglas

(1998) The child’s right to make mistakes: Criminal responsibility and the immature minor. In: Douglas

Sebba

(eds) Children’s Rights and Traditional Values. Aldershot: Ashgate.

28.

Dünkel

(1996) Current directions in criminal policy. In: McCarney

(ed.) Juvenile Delinquents and Young People in Danger in an Open Environment. Winchester: Waterside Books.

29.

Erikson

(1966) Wayward Puritans: A Study in the Sociology of Deviance. New York: Wiley.

30.

Farmer

(2011) The age of criminal responsibility: Developmental science and human rights perspectives. Journal of Children’s Services 6(2): 86−95.

31.

Franklin

Petley

(1996) Killing the age of innocence: Newspaper reporting of the death of James Bulger. In: Pilcher

Wagg

(eds) Thatcher’s Children: Politics, Childhood and Society in the 1980s and 1990s. London: RoutledgeFalmer.

32.

Gabbatt

(2010) Balls rejects call to raise age of criminal responsibility. The Guardian, 15 March. Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2010/mar/15/balls-rejects-bulger-killers-call (accessed 12 February 2013).

33.

Gatti

Tremblay

Vitaro

(2009) Iatrogenic effect of juvenile justice. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 50(8): 991−998.

34.

Gelsthorpe

Sharpe

(2006) Gender, youth crime and justice. In: Goldson

Muncie

(eds) Youth Crime and Justice. London: Sage Publications.

35.

Gillen

(2006) The Age of Criminal Responsibility: ‘The Frontier between Care and Justice’. Child Care in Practice 12(2): 129−139.

36.

Glover

Hibbert

(2009) Locking Up or Giving Up ? London: Barnardo’s.

37.

Goldson

(1997a) ‘Childhood’: An introduction to historical and theoretical analyses. In: Scraton

(ed.) ‘Childhood’ in ‘Crisis’? London: UCL Press.

38.

Goldson

(1997b) Children in trouble: State responses to juvenile crime. In: Scraton

(ed.) ‘Childhood’ in ‘Crisis’? London: UCL Press.

39.

Goldson

(2000) Wither diversion? Interventionism and the new youth justice. In: Goldson

(ed.) The New Youth Justice. Lyme Regis: Russell House Publishing.

40.

Goldson

(2001) The demonisation of children: From the symbolic to the institutional. In: Foley

Roche

Tucker

(eds) Children in Society: Contemporary Theory, Policy and Practice. Basingstoke: Palgrave.

41.

Goldson

(2002) New Labour, social justice and children: political calculation and the deserving-undeserving schism. British Journal of Social Work 32(6): 683−695.

42.

Goldson

(2008) Early intervention in the youth justice sphere: A knowledge-based critique. In: Blyth

Solomon

(eds) Prevention and Youth Crime, Researching Criminal Justice Series. Bristol: The Policy Press.

43.

Goldson

(2009a) Child incarceration: Institutional abuse, the violent state and the politics of impunity. In: Scraton

McCulloch

(eds) The Violence of Incarceration. London: Routledge.

44.

Goldson

(2009b) ‘Difficult to understand or defend’: A reasoned case for raising the age of criminal responsibility. Howard Journal of Criminal Justice 48(5): 514−521.

45.

Goldson

(2010) The sleep of (criminological) reason: Knowledge-policy rupture and New Labour’s youth justice legacy. Criminology and Criminal Justice 10(2): 155−178

46.

Goldson

(ed.) (2011) Youth in Crisis? ‘Gangs’, Territoriality and Violence. London: Routledge.

47.

Goldson

Muncie

(2006) Critical anatomy: Towards a principled youth justice. In: Goldson

Muncie

(eds) Youth Crime and Justice: Critical issues. London: Sage Publications.

48.

Goldson

Peters

(2000) Tough Justice: Responding to Children in Trouble. London: The Children’s Society.

49.

Graham

Perrott

Marshall

(2011) A Review of the Youth Justice System in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Department of Justice.

50.

Hay

(1995) Mobilisation through interpellation: James Bulger, juvenile crime and the construction of a moral panic. Social and Legal Studies 4(2): 197−223.

51.

Haydon

Scraton

(2000) ‘Condemn a little more, understand a little less’: The political context and rights implications of the domestic and European rulings in the Venables-Thompson case. Journal of Law and Society 27(3): 416−448.

52.

Hazel

(2008) Cross-national Comparison of Youth Justice. London: Youth Justice Board.

53.

Hendrick

(1994) Child Welfare: England 1872−1989. London: Routledge.

54.

Hill

(2011) Fourteen: The age of responsibility? The Argentina Independent, 9 March. Available at: http://www.argentinaindependent.com/currentaffairs/newsfromargentina/fourteen-the-age-of-responsibility/ (accessed 12 February 2013).

55.

Home Office (1997) No More Excuses: A New Approach to Tackling Youth Crime. London: Home Office.

56.

House of Lords House of Commons Joint Committee on Human Rights (2003) The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Tenth Report of Session 2002−03. London: HMSO.

57.

Howard League for Penal Reform (2008) Punishing Children: A Survey of Criminal Responsibility and Approaches across Europe. London: The Howard League for Penal Reform.

58.

James

Prout

(1997) Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood. London: Falmer Press.

59.

Jeffs

Smith

(1996) ‘Getting the Dirt-Bags off the Street’: Curfews and Other Solutions to Juvenile Crime. Youth and Policy 53: 1−14.

60.

Jenks

(1996) Childhood. London: Routledge.

61.

Kitsuse

(1962) Societal reaction to deviant behavior. Social Problems 9: 247−256.

62.

Lemert

(1967) Human Deviance, Social Problems and Social Control. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

63.

Lib Dem Lords (2013) Lib Dem Lord bids to increase age of criminal responsibility. Available at: http://libdemlords.wordpress.com/2013/01/17/lib-dem-lord-bids-to-increase-age-of-criminal-responsibility/ (accessed 12 February 2013).

64.

Liberal Democrats (2011) Taking Responsibility: Policies on Youth Justice, Policy Paper 99. London: Liberal Democrats. Available at: http://www.libdems.org.uk/siteFiles/resources/PDF/conference/Spr11%20Youth%20Justice%20PP99%20CLEAR%20PRINT.pdf (accessed 12 February 2013).

65.

Lipscombe

(2012) The age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales, Standard Note SN/HA/3001, 18 April. London: House of Commons Library.

66.

McAra

McVie

(2007) Youth justice? The impact of system contact on patterns of desistance from offending. European Journal of Criminology 4(3): 315−345.

67.

Magistrates Association (2012) Should the age of criminal responsibility be raised to 14? Press Notice November. Available at: http://www.magistrates-association.org.uk/dox/Press%20Statements/1352997061_should_the_age_of_criminal_responsibility_be_raised_to_14_-_15_november_2012.pdf (accessed 29 January 2013).

68.

Maher

(2005) Age and criminal responsibility. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 2(2): 493−512.

69.

Muncie

(1999) Institutionalised intolerance: Youth justice and the 1998 Crime and Disorder Act. Critical Social Policy 19(2):147−175.

70.

Muncie

(2009) Youth and Crime, 3rd Edition. London: Sage Publications.

71.

National Association for Youth Justice (2012) 6^th December… Our letter to youth justice minister Jeremy Wright MP. Available at: http://thenayj.org.uk/news-events-and-information/ (accessed 12 February 2013).

72.

Northern Ireland Assembly (2012) Official Report (Hansard), Session 2011/12, Thursday, 28 June 2012. Available at: http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/Assembly-Business/Official-Report/Committee-Minutes-of-Evidence/Session-2011-2012/June-2012/Review-of-Youth-Justice–Ministerial-Briefing/ (accessed 12 February 2013).

73.

Pickett

Wilkinson

(2009) Child wellbeing and income inequality in rich countries. Poverty 133: 6−9.

74.

Pilkington

(1993) Boys guilty of Bulger murder - Detention without limit for ‘unparalleled evil’, The Guardian, 25 November. Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/1993/nov/25/bulger1 (accessed 30 January 2013).

75.

Prior

Farrow

Hughes

Kelly

Manders

White

Wilkinson

(2011) Maturity, Young Adults and Criminal Justice: A Literature Review. Birmingham: University of Birmingham Institute of Applied Social Studies.

76.

Richards

(2011) What makes juvenile offenders different from adult offenders? Trends & Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice, No. 409. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.

77.

Royal Society (2011) Brain Waves Module 4: Neuroscience and the Law. London: The Royal Society Science Policy Centre.

78.

Rutherford

(1992) Growing Out of Crime: The New Era. Winchester: Waterside Press.

79.

Sampson

Laub

(2004) A life course theory of cumulative disadvantage and the stability of delinquency. In: Thornberry

(ed.) Developmental Theories of Crime and Delinquency. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.

80.

Schur

(1971) Labelling Deviant Behaviour: Its Sociological Implications. New York: Harper and Row.

81.

Schur

(1973) Radical Nonintervention: Rethinking the Delinquency Problem. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

82.

Scottish Government (2009) Criminal age to be raised to 12. Available at: http://www.scotland.gov.uk/News/Releases/2009/03/27140804 (accessed 30 January 2013).

83.

Scottish Law Commission (2002) Report on Age of Criminal Responsibility. Edinburgh: The Stationery Office.

84.

Scraton

(ed.) (1997) ‘Childhood’ in ‘Crisis’? London: UCL Press.

85.

Shecaira

(2004) Brazil / Criminal responsibility of minors in national and international legal orders. Revue Internationale de Droit Penal 75: 201−212.

86.

Unicef (2007) Child Poverty in Perspective: An Overview of Child Well-being in Rich Countries. Florence: Unicef.

87.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (1995) Eighth Session: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties under Article 44 of the Convention − Concluding Observations of the Committee on the Rights of the Child: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Geneva: United Nations.

88.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2002) Thirty-first Session: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties under Article 44 of the Convention − Concluding observations: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Geneva: United Nations.

89.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2007) General Comment No. 10: Children’s Rights in Juvenile Justice. Geneva: United Nations.

90.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2008) Forty-ninth Session: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties under Article 44 of the Convention − Concluding observations: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Geneva: United Nations.

91.

United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (2012) Sixty-seventh Session, Supplement No. 41: Report of the Committee on the Rights of the Child (A/67/41). New York: United Nations.

92.

United Nations General Assembly (1985) United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice. New York: United Nations.

93.

United Nations General Assembly (1989) United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. New York: United Nations.

94.

Vizard

(2006) Child Defendants, Occasional Paper OP56. London: Royal College of Psychiatrists.

95.

Webster

(2006) ‘Race’, youth crime and justice. In: Goldson

Muncie

(eds) Youth Crime and Justice. London: Sage Publications.

96.

White

Cunneen

(2006) Social class, youth crime and justice. In: Goldson

Muncie

(eds) Youth Crime and Justice. London: Sage Publications.

97.

Wright

(2012) Letter to Pam Hibbert, Chairperson of the National Association for Youth Justice’, dated 14 December, unpublished.

98.

Zimring

(2005) American Juvenile Justice. New York: Oxford University Press.