In 2010, the Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour published a major report entitled Time for a Fresh Start (Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour, 2010). The Commission’s report exposes the youth justice system in England and Wales to critical scrutiny. During the course of its inquiries the Commission consulted with, and/or received ‘evidence’ from, over 170 individuals and organizations. At the conclusion of the same inquiries, the report was published alongside a companion volume entitled A New Response to Youth Crime (Smith, 2010). The titles of the report and its accompanying book leave little to the imagination; the Commission clearly believes that a ‘fresh start’ and/or a ‘new response’ to youth crime and youth justice are needed in England and Wales. Informed by a long-term research project centred on national and international youth justice theory, law, policy and practice, this article focuses exclusively upon the Commission’s report and subjects it to critical assessment. Whilst endorsing the Commission’s perceived need for change, the article presents a detailed critique of its ‘alternative’ vision. It concludes by raising core questions pertaining to youth justice policy formation and the politics of policy influence.
Becker H. ( 1963) Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance. New York: Free Press.
2.
Bell A., Hodgson M., and Pragnell S. ( 1999) Diverting children and young people from crime and the criminal justice system. In Goldson B (ed.) Youth Justice: Contemporary policy and practice. Aldershot : Ashgate.
3.
Blumer H. ( 1969) Symbolic interactionism. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
4.
Blunt C. ( 2010) Address to the 7th Annual Victims and Witnesses conference, London, 20 October. Extracts provided in personal communication from David Utting.
5.
Campbell C., Devlin R., O’Mahony D., Doak J., Jackson J., Corrigan T., and McEvoy K. ( 2006) Evaluation of the Northern Ireland Youth Conference Service . Belfast: Statistics and Research Branch, Northern Ireland Office.
6.
Carlile, Lord ( 2006) The Lord Carlile of Berriew QC: An Independent Inquiry into the Use of Physical Restraint, Solitary Confinement and Forcible Strip Searching of Children in Prisons, Secure Training Centres and Local Authority Secure Children’s Homes. London: The Howard League for Penal Reform.
7.
Case S., Haines K. ( 2009) Understanding Youth Offending: Risk factor research, policy and practice. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
8.
Cipriani D. ( 2009) Children’s Rights and the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: A global perspective. Aldershot: Ashgate.
9.
Commission of the European Communities (2006 ) Towards an EU Strategy on the Rights of the Child. Brussels: Commission of the European Communities.
10.
Cook K. ( 2006) Doing difference and accountability in restorative justice conferences. Theoretical Criminology10(1): 107-124.
11.
Cook K., Daly K., and Stubbs J. ( 2006) Introduction. Theoretical Criminology10(1), Special Issue: ‘Gender, Race and Restorative Justice’ .
12.
Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights ( 2009) Children and Juvenile Justice: Proposals for improvements . Strasbourg: Council of Europe .
13.
Crawford A.(2009) Criminalizing sociability through anti-social behaviour legislation: Dispersal powers, young people and the police. Youth Justice9(1): 5-26.
14.
Cunneen C. ( 2010) The limitations of restorative justice. In: Cunneen C and Hoyle C Debating Restorative Justice. Oxford : Hart.
15.
Daly K. ( 2002) Restorative justice: The real story. Punishment and Society4(1): 55-79.
16.
Dunkel F. ( 1996) Current directions in criminal policy. In: McCarney W (ed.) Juvenile Delinquents and Young People in Danger in an Open Environment. Winchester : Waterside Books.
17.
Erikson K. ( 1966) Wayward Puritans: A study in the sociology of deviance . New York: Wiley.
18.
Evans R. ( 2008) Diversion. In: Goldson B (ed.) Dictionary of Youth Justice. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
19.
Glover J., Hibbert P. ( 2009) Locking Up or Giving Up?London: Barnardo’s.
20.
Goldson B (ed.) (2000) The New Youth Justice. Lyme Regis: Russell House Publishing.
21.
Goldson B. ( 2005) Taking liberties: Policy and the punitive turn. In: Hendrick H (ed.) Children and Social Policy: An essential reader. Bristol: The Policy Press.
22.
Goldson B. ( 2008) Early Intervention in the Youth Justice Sphere: A knowledge-based critique. In: Blyth M and Solomon E (eds) Prevention and Youth Crime, Researching Criminal Justice Series. Bristol: The Policy Press.
23.
Goldson, B. ( 2009) Child incarceration: Institutional abuse, the violent state and the politics of impunity. In: Scraton P and McCulloch J (eds) The Violence of Incarceration. London: Routledge.
24.
Goldson B.(2010) The sleep of (criminological) reason: Knowledge-policy rupture and New Labour’s youth justice legacy. Criminology and Criminal Justice10(2): 155-178.
25.
Goldson B., Coles D. ( 2005) In the Care of the State? Child deaths in penal custody . London: Inquest.
26.
Goldson B., Hughes G.(2010) Sociological criminology and youth justice: Comparative policy analysis and academic intervention. Criminology and Criminal Justice10(2): 211-230.
27.
Goldson B., Muncie J. ( 2006) Critical anatomy: Towards a principled youth justice. In: Goldson B and Muncie J (eds) Youth Crime and Justice: Critical issues . London: SAGE.
28.
Goldson B., Muncie J. ( 2007) Youth justice with integrity: Beyond Allen’s ‘New Approach’. In: Davies Z and McMahon W (eds) Debating Youth Justice: From punishment to problem solving?London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
29.
Haines K., Drakeford M. ( 1998) Young People and Youth Justice. Basingstoke : Macmillan.
30.
Haydon D. ( 2009) Developing a Manifesto for Youth Justice in Northern Ireland: Background Paper. Belfast: Include Youth.
31.
Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Prisons ( 2008) Report on an Announced Inspection of the Management, Care and Control of Young People at Oakhill Secure Training Centre. London: HM Inspectorate of Prisons.
32.
House of Lords / House of Commons Joint Committee on Human Rights (2003) The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, Tenth Report of Session 2002-2003 . London: The Stationery Office .
33.
Howard League for Penal Reform (2008) Punishing Children: A survey of criminal responsibility and approaches across Europe. London: The Howard League for Penal Reform.
34.
Hughes G. ( 2007) The Politics of Crime and Community. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
35.
Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour (2010) Time for a Fresh Start: The report of the Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour. London: The Police Foundation.
36.
Jacobson J., Gibbs P. ( 2009) Out of Trouble: Making amends - restorative youth justice in Northern Ireland. London: Prison Reform Trust.
37.
Jones T., Newburn T. ( 2006) Policy Transfer and Criminal Justice. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
38.
Kemp V., Sorsby A., Liddle M., and Merrington S. ( 2002) Assessing Responses to Youth Offending in Northamptonshire , Research Briefing2. London: Nacro.
39.
Kempf-Leonard K., Peterson E. ( 2000) Expanding realms of the new penology: The advent of actuarial justice for juveniles. Punishment and Society2: 66-97.
40.
Kitsuse J. ( 1962) Societal reaction to deviant behaviour. Social Problems9: 247-256.
41.
Lemert E. ( 1951) Social Pathology. New York: McGraw Hill.
42.
Lemert E. ( 1967) Human Deviance, Social Problems and Social Control. Englewood Cliffs New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
43.
McAlister S., Scraton P., and Haydon D. ( 2009) Childhood in Transition: Experiencing marginalization and conflict in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Queen’s University, Prince’s Trust Northern Ireland and Save the Children.
44.
McAlister S., Scraton P., and Haydon D. ( 2011) Place, territory and young people’s identity in the ‘new’ Northern Ireland. In: Goldson B (ed.) Youth in Crisis? ‘Gangs’, territoriality and violence. Abingdon: Routledge .
45.
McAra L., McVie S. ( 2007) Youth justice? The impact of system contact on patterns of desistance from offending. European Journal of Criminology4: 315-345.
46.
McAra L., McVie S.(2010) Youth crime and justice: Key messages from the Edinburgh Study of Youth Transitions and Crime. Criminology and Criminal Justice10(2): 179-209.
47.
Maruna S., Wright S., Brown J., van Merle F., Devlin R., and Liddle M. ( 2007) Youth Conferencing as Shame Management: Results of a long-term follow-up study. Cambridge: ARCS (UK) Ltd.
48.
Matza D. ( 1964) Delinquency and Drift. New York: Wiley.
49.
Matza D. ( 1969) Becoming Deviant. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
50.
Mead GH ( 1934) Mind, Self and Society. IllinoisUniversity of Chicago Press.
51.
Miller J. ( 1991) Last One Over the Wall: The Massachusetts experiment in closing reform schools. Ohio: Ohio State University Press.
52.
Ministry of Justice (2010) News Release: Reform of public bodies announced (14 October). London: Ministry of Justice. Available at: http://www.justice.gov.uk/announcement141010a.htm
53.
Morris N. ( 2006) Blair’s ‘frenzied law making’: A new offence for every day spent in office. The Independent , 16 August.
54.
Muncie J. ( 2001) Policy transfers and ‘what works’: Some reflections on comparative youth justice. Youth Justice1(3) 27-35.
55.
Muncie J. ( 2005) The globalization of crime control - The case of youth and juvenile justice: Neo-liberalism, policy convergence and international conventions. Theoretical Criminology9(1): 35-64.
56.
Muncie J. ( 2009) Youth and Crime, 3rd Edition. London: SAGE.
57.
Munro E. ( 2004) A simpler way to understand the results of risk assessment instruments. Children and Youth Services Review26: 877-887.
58.
Munro E. ( 2007) Confidentiality in a preventive child welfare system. Ethics and Social Welfare1: 41-55.
59.
Parton N. ( 2006) Safeguarding Childhood: Early intervention and surveillance in a late modern society. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
60.
Peters R., Barlow J. ( 2003) Systematic review of instruments designed to predict child maltreatment during the antenatal and postnatal periods. Child Abuse Review12: 416-439.
61.
Pople L., Utting D. ( 2010) Consultation Responses: An overview of submissions to the Independent Commission in response to its consultation paper. Available at: http://www.youthcrimecommission.org.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=75&Itemid=84
62.
Rutherford A. ( 1986) Growing Out of Crime. London: Penguin.
63.
Salz A. ( 2010) Chair’s introduction. In: Time for a Fresh Start: The report of the Independent Commission on Youth Crime and Antisocial Behaviour. London: The Police Foundation and Nuffield Foundation.
64.
Scraton P. ( 2004) From deceit to disclosure: The politics of official inquiries in the United Kingdom. In: Gilligan G and Pratt J (eds) Crime, Truth and Justice: Official inquiry, discourse, knowledge. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
65.
Scraton P., Moore L. ( 2005) The Hurt Inside: The imprisonment of women and girls in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission.
66.
Sherman L., Strang H. ( 2007) Restorative Justice: The evidence. London: The Smith Institute.
67.
Smith R. ( 2006) Actuarialism and early intervention in contemporary youth justice. In: Goldson B and Muncie J (eds) Youth Crime and Justice: Critical issues. London: SAGE.
68.
Smith D (ed.) (2010) A New Response to Youth Crime. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
69.
Stubbs J. (forthcoming). Relations of domination and subordination: Challenges for restorative justice in responding to domestic violence. University of New South Wales Law Journal16(2).
70.
Thorpe D., Smith D., Green C., and Paley J. ( 1980) Out of Care: The community support of juvenile offenders . London: George Allen & Unwin .
71.
United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child ( 1995) Eighth session: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties Under Article 44 of the Convention - Concluding observations of the Committee on the Rights of the Child: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Geneva: United Nations.
72.
United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child ( 2002) Thirty-first session: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties Under Article 44 of the Convention - Concluding observations: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Geneva: United Nations.
73.
United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child ( 2007) General Comment No. 10: Children’s rights in juvenile justice. Geneva: United Nations .
74.
United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child ( 2008) Forty-ninth session: Consideration of Reports Submitted by States Parties Under Article 44 of the Convention - Concluding observations: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Geneva: United Nations.
75.
Walklate S. ( 2006) Imagining the Victim of Crime. Maidenhead : Open University Press.
