The article studies the practice of one special form of closed accommodation: special care. The term suggests that this is a welfare-oriented response to norm-breaking behaviour of young people. The empirical example comes from Finland, where special care is defined as restrictive activity under the Child Welfare Act and aimed at, among other things, interrupting a vicious circle of crime in young people for the best interests of the child. A contradictory picture is drawn of special care. The article suggests that the contradictions should be understood — but not necessarily accepted — within the social context in which the institutional placements take place.
Allen R. ( 2006) From Punishment to Problem Solving: A New Approach to Children in Trouble. London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
2.
Allmän Sis-rapport ( 2006) Ungdomar som skrivits in på särskilda ungdomshem under år 2005 [Young People Registered in Special Youth Homes in 2005]. Annual report ADAD 05. Stockholm: Statens institutions styrelse Sis.
3.
Andreassen T. ( 2003) Institutionsbehandling av ungdomar: vad sager forskningen? [Residential Treatment of Young People: What is the Message from Research?] . Stockholm: Gothia.
4.
Beckley H. and O’Sullivan E. ( 2007) The interface between youth justice and child protection in Ireland. In: Hill M, Lockyer A and Stone F (eds) Youth Justice and Child Protection. London: Jessica Kingsley, 61-74.
5.
Bullock R. and Little M. ( 1991) Secure Accommodation for Children, Highlight No 103. London: National Children’s Bureau.
6.
Dahl T. ( 1985) Child Welfare and Social Defence. Oslo: Norwegian University Press.
7.
Eronen T., Laakso R. and Pösö T. ( 2010) Now you see them - now you don’t: institutions in child protection policy. In: Forsberg H and Kröger T (eds) Social Work and Child Welfare Politics through the Nordic Lenses. Bristol: Policy Press, 147-160.
8.
Forsberg H. and Kröger T. ( 2010) Social Work and Child Welfare Politics through the Nordic Lenses. Bristol: Policy Press.
9.
Francis J., Kendrick A. and Pösö T. ( 2007) On the margins? Residential care in Scotland and Finland . European Journal of Social Work10(3): 337-352.
10.
Goldson B. ( 2000) ‘Children in need’ or ‘young offenders’? Hardening ideology, organizational change and new challenges for social work with children in trouble. Child and Family Social Work5(3): 255-265.
11.
Goldson B. ( 2007) ‘Child protection’ and the ‘juvenile secure estate’ in England and Wales: Controversies, complexities and concerns. In: Hill M, Lockyer A, and Stone F (eds) Youth Justice and Child Protection. London: Jessica Kingsley, 104-119.
12.
Hammarberg T. ( 2008) A juvenile justice approach built on human rights principles . Youth Justice8(3): 193-196.
13.
Harrikari T. ( 2006) Rikos lasten suojelun kentässä. [Crime in the Field of Protecting Children ]. In: Honkatukia P and Kivivuori J (eds) Nuorisorikollisuus. Määrä, syyt ja kontrolli. [Youth criminality. Amount, reasons and control]. Helsinki: Oikeuspoliittinen tutkimuslaitos, 249-280.
14.
Harrikari T. ( 2008) Exploring risk governance in the Nordic context. Current Issues in Criminal Justice20(1): 29-42.
15.
Harris R. and Timms N. ( 1993) Secure accommodation in child care. Between hospital and prison or ‘thereabouts’?London: Routledge.
16.
Hearn J., Pösö T., Korpinen J., Smith C., and Whyte S. ( 2004) What is child protection/lastensuojelu? Historical and methodological issues in comparative research on lastensuojelu/child Protection . International Journal of Social Welfare13(1): 28-41.
17.
Hill M., Lockyer A., and Stone F. ( 2007) Introduction: The principles and practice of compulsory intervention when children are ‘at risk’ or engage in criminal behavior. In: Hill M, Lockyer A, and Stone F (eds) Youth Justice and Child Protection. London: Jessica Kingsley, 9-37.
18.
Hoikkala S. ( 2008) Researching history of restraining practices in children’s residential care: Methodological considerations. In: Canali C, Vecchiato T, and Whittaker J (eds) Assessing the ‘Evidence-base’ of Intervention for Vulnerable Children and their Families. Padova: Fondazione Emanuela Zancan onlus, 208-209.
19.
Hujala A. ( 2004) ‘Erityinen huolenpito’ [Special care]. In: Puonti A, Saarnio T, and Hujala A (eds) Lastensuojelu tänään [Child Welfare Today]. Helsinki: Tammi, 265-269.
20.
Kekoni T., Kitinoja M., and Pösö T. (2008) Erityinen huolenpito koulukodeissa [Special care in the Reform Schools], Report 36. Helsinki : Stakes.
21.
Kendrick A., Steckley L., and Lerpiniere J. ( 2008) Ethical issues, research and vulnerability: Gaining the views of childen and young people in residential care. Children’s Geographies6(1): 79-93.
22.
Kilkelly U. ( 2008) Youth justice and children’s rights: Measuring compliance with international standards. Youth Justice8(3): 187-192.
23.
King M. ( 1999) Moral Agendas for Children’s Welfare. London and New York: Routledge .
24.
Kitinoja M. ( 2005) Kujan päässä koulukoti. Tutkimus koulukoteihin sijoitettujen lasten lastensuojeluasiakkuudesta ja koulukotihistoriasta. [At the End of the Road, a Reform School. A Study of the Child Welfare Clienting and School History of Children Placed in Reform Schools]. Helsinki: Stakes.
25.
Kuula T., Pitts J., and Marttunen M. ( 2006) ‘Nuoret laitoksissa Suomessa ja Englannissa’ [Young people in residential institutions in Finland and England]. In: Honkatukia P and Kivivuori J (eds) Nuorisorikollisuus. Määrä, syyt ja kontrolli. [Youth criminality. Amount, reasons and control]. Helsinki: Oikeuspoliittinen tutkimuslaitos, 315-340.
26.
Lastensuojelu2007. [Child Welfare in 2007] Statistical report 23. Helsinki : Stakes & Suomen virallinen tilasto.
27.
Levin C. ( 1998) Uppfostringsanstalten. [Upbringing Institutions]. Eslöv: Arkiv förlag.
28.
McGhee J. and Waterhouse L. ( 2008) Classification in youth justice and child welfare: In search of ‘the child’. Youth Justice7(2): 107-120.
29.
Marttunen M. ( 2008) Nuorisorikosoikeus. Alaikäisten rikosten seuraamukset kriminaalipoliittisesta ja vertailevasta näkökulmasta. [Juvenile Crime Justice: Comparative and Criminal Policy Perspective on Sanctioning Juveniles.] Publication No. 236. Helsinki: Oikeuspoliittinen tutkimuslaitos.
30.
Milligan I. and Stevens I. ( 2006) Residential Child Care. Collaborative Practice. London, Thousand Oaks, CA and New Delhi: SAGE.
31.
Morris A. and McIsaac M. ( 1978) Juvenile Justice? The Practice of Social Welfare. London: Heinemann.
32.
Muncie J. (2004) Youth & Crime. London: SAGE .
33.
Muncie J. ( 2008) The ‘punitive turn’ in juvenile justice: Cultures of control and rights compliance in Western Europe and the USA. Youth Justice8(2): 107-121.
34.
O’Neill T. ( 2001) Children in Secure Accommodation. A Gendered Exploration of Locked Institutional Care for Children in Trouble. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
35.
Petrie P., Boddy J., Cameron C., Wigfall V., and Simon A. ( 2006) Working with Children in Care. European Perspectives. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
36.
Pitts J. and Kuula T. ( 2005) Incarcerating young people: An Anglo-Finnish comparsion . Youth Justice5(3): 147-164.
37.
Pösö T. ( 2004) The rights and wrongs of ethnographic research in youth residential setting. In: Eriksson T and Tjelflaat T (eds) Residential Care. Aldershot: Ashgate, 203-216.
38.
Pösö T., Honkatukia P., and Nyqvist L. ( 2008) The focus-group and the study of violence. Qualitative Research8(1): 91-113.
39.
Psykiatrian erikoisalan laitoshoito 2007 ( 2008) [The institutional care in psychiatry 2007]. Tilastotiedote 28. Helsinki: Stakes. Suomen virallinen tilasto.
40.
Sijaishuollon pakkotoimityöryhmän muistio ( 1998). [Memorandum of the working group of involuntary interventions in substitute care] Työryhmämuistio 22. Helsinki : Sosiaali- ja terveysministeriö.
41.
Smith M. and Milligan I. ( 2004) The expansion of secure education in Scotland In the best interest of the child?Youth Justice4(3): 178-191.
42.
Steckley L. and Kendrick A. ( 2008) Physical restraint in residentail childcare: The experiences of young people and residential workers. Childhood15(4): 552-569.
43.
Stein M. ( 1993) The uses and abuses of residential care. In: Ferguson H, Gilligan R and Torode R (eds) Surviving Childhood Adversity . Dublin: Social Studies Press, 234-244.
44.
Tervonen-Arnkil K. ( 2001) Lapsen eristäminen huolenpitona lastensuojelulaitoksessa [Isolation as a form of care in an institution for children]. In: Tervonen-Arnkil K (ed.) Vaikeahoitoisten lasten ja nuorten hoitomenetelmiä lastensuojelulaitoksissa [The treatment methods for difficult children in institutions for children]. Helsinki: Lastensuojelun keskusliitto, 28-34.
