This article reviews policy developments in Scotland concerning ‘persistent young offenders’ and then describes the design of a study intended to assist a local planning group in developing its response. The key findings of a review of casefiles of young people involved in persistent offending are reported. It emerges that youth crime and young people involved in offending are more complex and heterogeneous than is sometimes assumed. This, along with a review of some literature about desistance from offending, reaffirms the need for properly individualised interventions. Studies of ‘desisters’ suggest the centrality of effective and engaging working relationships in this process. However, these studies also re-assert the significance of the social contexts of workers’ efforts to bring ‘change’ out of ‘chaos’. We conclude therefore that the ‘new correctionalism’ must be tempered with appreciation of the social exclusion of young people who offend.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, S. (1999) Crime Statistics and the ‘Problem’ of Crime in Scotland, in Duff, P. and Hutton, N. (Eds.) Criminal Justice in Scotland. Aldershot, Dartmouth .
2.
Asquith, S. and Docherty, M. (1999) Preventing Offending by Children and Young People in Scotland, in Duff, P. and Hutton, N. (Eds.) Criminal Justice in Scotland. Aldershot, Dartmouth .
3.
Audit Scotland (2001) Youth Justice in Scotland: A Baseline Report. Edinburgh, Audit Scotland . (Available on-line at: http://www.audit-scotland.gov.uk/publications/pdf/01pf01ag.pdf)
4.
Blumstein, A. , Farrington, D. P. and Moitra, S. (1985) Delinquency Careers: Innocents, Desisters, and Persisters, in Tonry, M. and Morris, N. (Eds.) Crime and Justice 6: 187-220. Chicago, University of Chicago Press .
5.
Blumstein, A. , Cohen, J. , Roth, J. A. and Vischer, C. A. (Eds.) (1986) Criminal Careers and Career Criminals. Washington DC, National Academy Press .
6.
Burnett, R. (2000) Understanding Criminal Careers Through a Series of In-depth Interviews . Offender Programs Report4: 1, 1-16 .
7.
Chapman, T. and Hough, M. (1998) Evidence Based Practice: A Guide to Effective Practice. London, Home Office .
8.
Currie, E. (1985) Confronting Crime. New York, Pantheon Books .
9.
Ditton, J. and Ford, R. (1994) The Reality of Probation: A Formal Ethnography of Process and Practice. Aldershot, Avebury .
10.
Dowden, C. and Andrews, D.A. (1999) What Works in Young Offender Treatment: A Meta-analysis . Forum on Corrections Research11: 2, 21-24 .
11.
Farrell, S. (2001) Probation, Social Context and Desistance From Crime, unpublished D.Phil thesis, St Catherine’s College, Oxford.
12.
Farrell, S. and Bowling, B. (1999) Structuration, Human Development and Desistance from Crime . British Journal of Criminology17: 2, 252-267 .
13.
Farrington, D. P. (1996) Understanding and Preventing Youth Crime (Social Policy Research 93). York, Joseph Rowntree Foundation .
14.
Farrington, D. P. and West, D. J. (1993) Criminal, Penal and Life Histories of Chronic Offenders: Risk and Protective Factors and Early Identification . Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health3: 492-523 .
15.
Flood-Page, C. , Campbell, S. , Harrington, V. and Miller, J. (2000) Youth Crime: Findings from the 1998/99 Youth Lifestyles Survey (Home Office Research Study 209). London, Home Office .
16.
Garland, D. (2001), The Culture of Control. Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Oxford, Oxford University Press .
17.
Goldson, B. (2000) ‘Children in Need’ or ‘Young Offenders’? Hardening Ideology, Organizational Change and New Challenges for Social Work with Children in Trouble . Child and Family Social Work, 5: 255-265 .
18.
Goldson, B. (2001) A Rational Youth Justice? Some Critical Reflections on the Research, Policy and Practice Relation . Probation Journal48: 2, 76-85 .
19.
Goldson, B. and Peters, E. (2000) Tough Justice: Responding to Children in Trouble. London, The Children’s Society .
20.
Graham, J. and Bowling, B. (1995) Young People and Crime (Home Office Research Study 145). London, Home Office .
21.
Hagell, A. and Newburn, T. (1994) Persistent Young Offenders. London, Policy Studies Institute .
22.
Hoge, R. D. and Andrews, D. A. (2001) The Youth Level of Service/Case Management Inventory: Intake Manual and Item Scoring Key. Cardiff, The Cognitive Centre Foundation .
23.
Jamieson, J.McIvor, G. and Murray, C. (1999) Understanding Offending Among Young Offenders. Edinburgh, Scottish Executive .
24.
Jones, C. (2001) Voices from the Front Line: State Social Workers and New Labour . British Journal of Social Work, 31: 547-562 .
25.
Lipsey, M. W. (1992) Juvenile Delinquency Treatment: A Meta-analytic Inquiry into the Variability of Effects, in Cook, T. D. , Cooper, H. , Cordray, D. S. , Hartmann, H. , Hedges, L. V. , Light, R. J. , Louis, T. A. and Mosteller, F. (Eds.) Meta-analysis for Explanation: A Casebook. New York, Russell Sage Foundation .
26.
Lobley, D. , Smith, D. and Stern, C. (2001) Freagarrach: An Evaluation of a Project for Persistent Juvenile Offenders. Edinburgh, The Scottish Executive Central Research Unit .
27.
Loeber, R. and Stouthamer-Loeber, M. (1986) Family Factors as Correlates and Predictors of Juvenile Conduct Problems and Delinquency, in, Tonry, M. and Morris, N. (Eds.) Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research Vol. 7: Chicago, The University of Chicago Press .
28.
Maruna, S. (2000) Desistance From Crime and Offender Rehabilitation: A Tale of Two Research Literatures . Offender Programs Report, 4:1, 1-13 .
29.
McGuire, J. (Ed.) (1995) What Works: Reducing Reoffending - Guidelines from Research and Practice. Chichester, Wiley .
30.
McIvor, G. , Jamieson, J. and Murray, C. (2000) Study Examines Gender Differences in Desistance From Crime . Offender Programs Report4: 1, 5-9 .
31.
McNeill, F. (2001) Developing Effectiveness: Frontline Perspectives . Journal of Social Work Education, 20: 6, 671-687 .
32.
Pawson, R. and Tilley, N. (1997) Realistic Evaluation. London, Sage .
33.
Pitts, J. (2001) The New Correctionalism: Young People, Youth Justice and New Labour, in Matthews, R. and Pitts, J. (Eds.) Crime, Disorder and Community Safety. London, Routledge .
34.
Rex, S. (1999) Desistance from Offending: Experiences of Probation . Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, 38: 4, 366-383 .
35.
Roberts, C. , Baker, K. , Merrington, S. and Jones, S. (2001) Validity and Reliability of ASSET: Interim Report to the Youth Justice Board. Centre for Criminological Research, Oxford, University of Oxford .
36.
Rutherford, A. (1986), Growing Out of Crime: Society and Young People in Trouble. Harmondsworth, Penguin .
37.
Rutter, M. , Giller, H. and Hagell, A. (1998) Anti Social Behaviour by Young People. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press .
38.
Scottish Executive (2000a) It’s a Criminal Waste: Stop Youth Crime Now: the Report of the Advisory Group on Youth Crime. Edinburgh, The Scottish Executive .
39.
Scottish Executive (2000b) The Scottish Executive’s Response to the Advisory Group Report on Youth Crime. Edinburgh, The Scottish Executive .
40.
Smith, D. (2000) Learning from the Scottish Juvenile Justice System . Probation Journal, 47: 1, 12-17 .
41.
Trotter, C. (1996) The Impact of Different Supervision Practices on Community Corrections . Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 28: 2, 29-46 .
42.
Trotter, C. (1999) Working with Involuntary Clients: A guide to practice. London, Sage .
43.
Trotter, C , (2000) Social Work Education, Pro-Social Orientation and Effective Probation Practice . Probation Journal, 47: 4, 256-261 .
44.
Utting, D. and Vennard, J. (2000) What Works with Young Offenders in the Community?Ilford, Barnardo’s .
45.
Whyte, B. (2000) Between Two Stools: Youth Justice in Scotland . Probation Journal, 47: 2, 119-125 .
