One of the major concerns when analysing incomplete longitudinal data is the fact
that models necessarily rest on strong assumptions, unverifiable from the data. In
response to these concerns, there is growing awareness of the usefulness of
sensitivity analysis. In this paper we will focus on repeated ordinal data.
Specifically, we implement a formal approach to such a sensitivity assessment, based
on local influence, in the presence of multivariate categorical data. We explore the
influence of perturbing a MAR dropout model in the direction of non-random dropout,
and apply the proposed method to data from a longitudinal multicentre psychiatric study.
Bahadur RR
(1961) A representation of the joint distribution of
responses to n dichotomous items. In:
Solomon H
, ed. Studies in item analysis and prediction. Stanford Mathematical
Studies in the Social Sciences VI,
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
3.
Beckman RJ
,
Nachtsheim, Cook RD
(1987)
Diagnostics for mixed-model analysis of variance
. Technometrics29,
413-426
.
4.
Breslow NE
,
Clayton DG
(1993)
Approximate inference in generalized linear mixed models
. Journal of the American Statistical Association88,
9-25
.
5.
Cook RD
(1986)
Assessment of local influence
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B48,
133-169
.
6.
Cook RD
,
Weisberg S
(1982) Residuals and influence in regression.
London: Chapman and Hall
.
7.
Cox DR
(1972)
The analysis of multivariate binary data
. Applied Statistics21,
113-120
.
8.
Dale JR
(1986)
Global cross-ratio models for bivariate, discrete, ordered responses
. Biometrics42,
909-917
.
Fahrmeir L
,
Tutz G
(1994) Multivariate statistical modelling based on
generalized linear models.
Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag
.
11.
Fitzmaurice GM
,
Laird NM
(1993)
A Likelihood-based method for analysing longitudinal binary responses
. Biometrika80,
141-151
.
12.
Fitzmaurice GM
,
Laird NM
,
Rotnitzky A
(1993)
Regression models for discrete longitudinal responses
. Statistical Science8,
284-309
.
13.
Geys H
,
Molenberghs G
,
Ryan LM
(1997)
Pseudo-likelihood inference for clustered binary data
. Communications in Statistics: Theory and Methods26,
2743-2767
.
14.
Geys H
,
Molenberghs G
,
Ryan L
(1999)
Pseudolikelihood modelling of multivariate outcomes in developmental toxicology
. Journal of the American Statistical Association94,
734-745
.
15.
Glynn RJ
,
Laird NM
,
Rubin DB
(1986) Selection modelling versus mixture modelling with
non-ignorable nonresponse. In:
Wainer H
, ed. Drawing inferences from self selected samples.
New York: Springer-Verlag
, 115-142.
16.
Hogan JW
,
Laird NM
(1997)
Mixture models for the joint distribution of repeated measures and event times
. Statistics in Medicine16,
239-258
.
17.
Kenward MG
,
Molenberghs G
,
Lesaffre E
(1994)
An application of maximum likelihood and estimating equations to the
analysis of ordinal data from a longitudinal study with cases missing at random
. Biometrics50,
945-953
.
18.
Lesaffre E
,
Verbeke G
(1998)
Local influence in linear mixed models
. Biometrics54,
570-582
.
19.
Liang K-Y
,
Zeger SL
(1986)
Longitudinal data analysis using generalized linear models
. Biometrika73,
13-22
.
20.
Little RJA
,
Rubin DB
(1987) Statistical analysis with missing data.
New York: Wiley
.
21.
Little RJA
(1993)
Pattern-mixture models for multivariate incomplete data
. Journal of the American Statistical Association88,
125-134
.
22.
Little RJA
(1994)
A class of pattern-mixture models for normal incomplete data
. Biometrika81,
471-483
.
23.
McCullagh P
,
Nelder JA
(1989) Generalized linear models.
London: Chapman and Hall
.
24.
Molenberghs G
,
Goetghebeur E
,
Kenward MG
(2001)
Sensitivity analysis for incomplete contingency tables. The Slovenian
plebiscite case
. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society - Series C Applied Statistics50,
15-30
.
25.
Molenberghs G
,
Goetghebeur E
,
Lipsitz SR
,
Kenward MG
,
Lesaffre E
,
Michiels B
(1999)
Missing data perspectives of the fluvoxamine data set: a review
. Statistics in Medicine18,
2449-2464
.
26.
Molenberghs G
,
Kenward MG
,
Lesaffre E
(1997)
The analysis of longitudinal ordinal data with nonrandom dropout
. Biometrika84,
33-44
.
27.
Molenberghs G
,
Lesaffre E
(1994)
Marginal modelling of correlated ordinal data using a multivariate Plackett distribution
. Journal of the American Statistical Association89,
633-644
.
28.
Molenberghs G
,
Lesaffre E
(1999)
Marginal modelling of multivariate categorical data
. Statistics in Medicine18,
2237-2255
.
29.
Molenberghs G
,
Ryan LM
(1999)
Likelihood inference for clustered multivariate binary data
. Environmetrics10,
279-300
.
30.
Pendergast JF
,
Gange SJ
,
Newton MA
,
Lindstrom MJ
,
Palta M
,
Fisher MR
(1996)
A survey of methods for analyzing clustered binary response data
. International Statistical Review64,
89-118
.
31.
Plackett RL
(1965)
A class of bivariate distributions
. Journal of the American Statistical Association60,
516-522
.
32.
Prentice RL
(1988)
Correlated binary regression with covariates specific to each binary observation
. Biometrics44,
1033-1048
.
33.
Rosner B
(1984)
Multivariate methods in ophtalmology with applications to other paired-data situations
. Biometrics40,
1025-1035
.
34.
Rubin DB
(1976)
Inference and missing data
. Biometrika63,
581-592
.
35.
Ryan LM
,
Molenberghs G
(1999)
Statistical methods for developmental toxicity: analysis of clustered
multivariate binary data
. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences895,
196-211
.
36.
Scharfstein DO
,
Rotnitzky A
,
Robins JM
(1999)
Adjusting for non-ignorable drop-out using semiparametric nonresponde
models (with discussion)
. Journal of the American Statistical Association94,
1096-1146
.
37.
Stiratelli R
,
Laird N
,
Ware J
(1984)
Random effects models for serial observations with dichotomous response
. Biometrics40,
961-972
.
38.
Thijs H
,
Molenberghs G
,
Michiels B
,
Verbeke G
,
Curran D
(2000) Strategies to fit pattern-mixture models. (Submitted).
39.
Thompson R
,
Baker, RJ
(1981)
Composite link functions in generalized linear models
. Applied Statistics30,
125-131
.
40.
Verbeke G
,
Molenberghs G
(2000) Linear mixed models for longitudinal data.
New York: Springer-Verlag
.
41.
Verbeke G
,
Molenberghs G
,
Thijs H
,
Lesaffre E
,
Kenward MG
(2001)
Sensitivity analysis for non-random dropout: a local influence approach
. Biometrics57,
7-14
.
42.
Wolfinger R
,
O’Connell M
(1993)
Generalized linear mixed models: a pseudo-likelihood approach
. Journal of Statistical Computation and Simulation48,
233-243
.
43.
Zeger SC
,
Liang K-Y
,
Albert PS
(1988)
Models for longitudinal data: a generalized estimating equation approach
. Biometrics44,
1049-1060
.
