It is generally acknowledged that a certain amount of state intervention in health and health care is needed to address the significant market failures in these sectors; however, it is also thought that the primary rationale for state involvement in health must lie elsewhere, for example in an egalitarian commitment to equalizing access to health care for all citizens. This paper argues that a complete theory of justice in health can be derived from a commitment to correcting market failure, or in other words promoting Pareto-efficiency, in the domain of health. This approach can address familiar problems around access to care, as well as problems related to resource allocation and rationing (including resource allocation between generations), the control of health care costs, and the foundations of public health. Egalitarian theories of justice in health cannot make sense of the depth and pervasiveness of state involvement in health and health care; only a theory rooted in the need to correct market failure can.
AkerlofGA (1970) The market for "lemons": quality uncertainty and the market mechanism. Quarterly Journal of Economics84(3): 488–500.
2.
AlemayehuBWarnerKE (2004) Lifetime distribution of health care costs. Health Services Research39(3): 627–642.
3.
AnomalyJ (2011) Public health and public goods. Public Health Ethics4(3): 251–259.
4.
AnomalyJ (2015) Public goods and government action. Politics, Philosophy, and Economics14(2): 109–128.
5.
ArrowK (1963) Uncertainty and the welfare economics of medical care. American Economic Review53(5): 941–973.
6.
BarrN (1989) Social insurance as efficiency device. Journal of Public Policy9(1): 59–82.
7.
BaylisFKennyNPSherwinS (2008) A relational account of public health ethics. Public Health Ethics1(3): 196–209.
8.
BernsteinJRandallP (2020) Against the public goods conception of public health. Public Health Ethics13(3): 225–233.
9.
BognarGHiroseI (2014) The Ethics of Health Care Rationing: An Introduction. New York: Routledge.
10.
BraunS (2012) Mandatory health insurance, liberalism, and freedom. Public Affairs Quarterly26(3): 179–197.
11.
BrockD (2000) Broadening the bioethics agenda. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal10(1): 21–38.
12.
BrownRMaslenHSavulescuJ (2019) Against moral responsibilization of health: Prudential responsibility and health promotion. Public Health Ethics12(2): 114–129.
13.
CappelenAWNorheimOF (2005) Responsibility in health care: A liberal egalitarian approach. Journal of Medical Ethics31(8): 476–480.
14.
CarpenterD (2010) Reputation and Power. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
15.
ChandlerA (1977) The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in Modern Business. Cambridge, MA: Belknap.
CoaseRH (1937) The nature of the firm. Economica New Series4(16): 386–405.
18.
CutlerDMMillerG (2005) The role of public health advances in health advances: the twentieth-century United States. Demography42: 1–22.
19.
CutlerDMZeckhauserRJ (1998) Adverse selection in health insurance. In: GarberA (ed) Frontiers in Health Policy Research, Volume 7. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp.1–31.
20.
DanielsN (1988) Am I My Parents’ Keeper?Oxford: Oxford University Press.
21.
DanielsN (1994) Four unsolved rationing problems: A challenge. Hastings Center Report24(4): 27–29.
22.
DanielsN (2008) Just Health. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23.
DanielsN (2009) Is there a right to health care and, if so, what does it encompass? In: KuhseHSingerP (eds) A Companion to Bioethics, 2nd edition. Oxford: Blackwell, pp.362–372.
24.
DaviesB (2018) Ageing and terminal illness: Problems for rawlsian justice. Journal of Applied Philosophy35(4): 775–789.
25.
DworkinR (1993) Justice in the distribution of health care. McGill Law Journal38(4): 883–898.
26.
EpsteinR (2004) In defense of the “old” public health. Brooklyn Law Review69(4): 1421–1470.
27.
EwaldF (1986) L’Etat Providence. Paris: Bernard Grasset.
28.
FishmanJMacKayD (2019) Rawlsian justice and the social determinants of health. Journal of Applied Philosophy36(4): 608–625.
29.
GawandeA (2009) The Cost Conundrum. The New Yorker, June 1, 2009.
30.
GibbardA (1984) The prospective pareto principle and equity of access to health care. Ethics94(2): 261–282.
31.
HackingI (2001) An Introduction to Probability and Inductive Logic. New York: Cambridge University Press.
32.
HeathJ (2001) The Efficient Society. Toronto: Penguin.
33.
HeathJ (2003) Les Soins de Santé Comme Marchandises. Ethique Publique5(1): 84–90.
34.
HeathJ (2006) The benefits of cooperation. Philosophy & Public Affairs34(4): 313–351.
35.
HeathJ (2011) Three normative models of the welfare state. Public Reason3(1): 13–43.
36.
HeathJ (2013) The structure of intergenerational cooperation. Philosophy & Public Affairs41(1): 31–66.
37.
HeathJ (2020) The Machinery of Government. New York: Oxford University Press.
38.
HorneLC (2016) Medical need, equality, and uncertainty. Bioethics30(8): 588–596.
39.
HorneLC (2017) What makes health care special?Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal27(4): 561–587.
40.
HorneLC (2019) Public health, public goods, and market failure. Public Health Ethics12(3): 287–292.
41.
LazenbyH (2011) Is age special? Justice, complete lives, and the prudential lifespan account. Journal of Applied Philosophy28(4): 327–340.
42.
Mas-ColellAWhinstonMDGreenJR (1995) Microeconomic Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
43.
MenzelP (2012) Justice and fairness: A critical element in US health reform. Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics40(3): 582–597.
44.
MillerG (1992) Managerial Dilemmas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
45.
MitchellEM (2019) Concentration of health expenditures and selected characteristics of high spenders. Report for Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Statistical Brief #521 Maryland: AHRQ. Available at https://meps.ahrq.gov/data_files/publications/st521/stat521.shtml (accessed 4 March 2022).
46.
MossDA (2004) When All Else Fails. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
47.
MuntheC (2008) The goals of public health: An integrated, multidimensional model. Public Health Ethics1(1): 39–52.
SreenivasanG (2007) Health care and equality of opportunity. Hastings Center Report37(2): 21–31.
57.
TaylorM (1987) The Possibility of Cooperation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
58.
TemkinL (2000) Equality, priority, and the leveling down objection. In: ClaytonMWilliamsA (eds) The Ideal of Equality. New York: Macmillan, pp.126–161.
59.
TemkinL (2017) Equality as comparative fairness. Journal of Applied Philosophy34(1): 43–60.
60.
VoightK (2013) Appeals to individual responsibility for health: reconsidering the luck egalitarian perspective. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics22(2): 146–158.
61.
VoorhoeveA (2018) May a government mandate more expensive insurance than citizens want for themselves? In: SobelDVallentynePWallS (eds) Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy, Volume 4. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.167–191.
62.
WalzerM (1983) Spheres of Justice. New York: Basic.
63.
WilkinsonRMarmotM (Eds) (2003) Social Determinants of Health: The Solid Facts, 2nd editionDenmark: World Health Organization.
64.
WilliamsB (2005) The idea of equality. In: HawthornG (ed) In the Beginning Was the Deed. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp.97–114.
65.
WoolhandlerSCampbellTHimmelsteinDU (2003) Costs of health care administration in the United States and Canada. New England Journal of Medicine349(8): 768–775.
