Pogge,poverty,and war

Abstract

According to Thomas Pogge, rich people do not simply violate a positive duty of assistance to help the global poor; rather, they violate a negative duty not to harm them. They do so by imposing an unjust global economic structure on poor people. Assuming that these claims are correct, it follows that, ceteris paribus, wars waged by the poor against the rich to resist this imposition are morally equivalent to wars waged in self-defense against military aggression. Hence, if self-defense against military aggression is just, then, ceteris paribus, so are defensive wars against the imposition of economic injustice. While I do not think Pogge’s analysis of the causes of global poverty is correct, I defend these inferences against various challenges.

Keywords

duties of assistance economic injustice global justice jus ad bellum just war poverty self-defense Thomas Pogge

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashford

(2009) The duties imposed by the human right to basic necessities. In: Pogge

(ed.) Freedom from Poverty as a Human Right: Who Owes What to the Very Poor? Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 183–218.

Barry

Øverland

(2012) The feasible alternatives thesis: kicking away the livelihoods of the global poor. Politics, Philosophy and Economics 11: 97–119.

Bazargan

(2004) Killing minimally responsible threats. Ethics 125(1): 114–136.

Beitz

(1975) Justice and international relations. Philosophy & Public Affairs 4(4): 360–389.

Croft

(2005) Human rights and positive duties. Ethics and International Affairs 19: 29–37.

de Vita Álvaro (2009) Inequality and poverty in global perspective. In: Pogge

(ed.) Freedom from Poverty as a Human Right. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 103–132.

Dill

Shue

(2012) Limiting the killing in war. Ethics and International Affairs 26(3): 311–333.

Fabre

(2009) Guns, food, and liability to attack. Ethics 120: 36–63.

Fabre

(2012) Cosmopolitan War. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

10.

Ferzan

(2012) Culpable aggression: the basis for moral liability to defensive killings. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 9: 669–697.

11.

Foot

(1977) Virtues and Vices and Other Essays in Moral Philosophy. Los Angeles: Berkeley University Press.

12.

Frowe

(2014) Defensive Killing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

13.

Frowe

(2011) The Ethics of War and Peace: An Introduction. London: Routledge.

14.

Jaggar

(2010) Thomas Pogge and His Critics. Cambridge: Polity Press.

15.

Haque

(2014) Law and morality at war. Criminal Law and Philosophy 8: 79–97.

16.

Hurka

(2005) Proportionality in the morality of war. Philosophy & Public Affairs 33: 34–66.

17.

Kagan

(1988) The additive fallacy. Ethics 99: 5–31.

18.

Kamm

(1983) Killing and letting die: methodological and substantive issues. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64: 297–312.

19.

Kamm

(2007) Intricate Ethics: Rights, Responsibilities, and Permissible Harm. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

20.

Lazar

(2015) Sparing Civilians. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

21.

Lazar

(2010) The responsibility dilemma for killing in war: a review essay. Philosophy and Public Affairs 38(2): 180–213.

22.

Lippert-Rasmussen

(2013a) Global injustice and redistributive wars. Law, Ethics and Philosophy 1(1): 65–86. Available at: http://www.raco.cat/index.php/LEAP/article/view/294761 (accessed 24 April 2017).

23.

Lippert-Rasmussen

(2013b) Noncombatants and liability to be targeted in wars. Public Affairs Quarterly 27(1): 25–47.

24.

Lippert-Rasmussen

(2015) Are enabling and allowing harm morally equivalent? Utilitas 27: 365–383.

25.

Luban

(1980) Just war and human rights. Philosophy & Public Affairs 9: 160–181.

26.

McMahan

(2009) Killing in War. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

27.

Miller

(2007) National Responsibility and Global Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

28.

Mills

(2010) Realizing (through racializing) Rawls. In: Jaggar

(ed.) Thomas Pogge and His Critics. Cambridge: Polity Press, pp. 151–174.

29.

Øverland

(2011) 602 and one dead: on contribution to global poverty and liability to defensive force. European Journal of Philosophy 21(2): 279–299.

30.

Patten

(2005) Should we stop thinking about poverty in terms of helping the poor? Ethics and International Affairs 19: 19–27.

31.

Pogge

(2008) World Poverty and Human Rights. Cambridge: Polity Press.

32.

Pogge

(2010) Politics as Usual. Cambridge: Polity Press.

33.

Pogge

(2013) Poverty and violence. Law, Ethics and Philosophy 1(1): 87–111. Available at: http://www.raco.cat/index.php/LEAP/article/view/294762/383297 (accessed 24 April 2017).

34.

Quinn

(1989) Actions, intentions, and consequences: the doctrine of the double effect. Philosophy and Public Affairs 18: 334–351.

35.

Quong

(2009) Killing in self-defense. Ethics 119(3): 507–537.

36.

Rachels

(1975) Active and passive euthanasia. The New England Journal of Medicine 292: 78–80.

37.

Raikkä

(2014) Redistributive wars and just war principles. RATIO.ru 12: 4–26.

38.

Risse

(2005a) Do we owe the global poor assistance or rectification. Ethics and International Affairs 19: 9–18.

39.

Risse

(2005b) How does the global order harm the poor? Philosophy and Public Affairs 33: 349–376.

40.

Singer

(1972) Famine, affluence, and morality. Philosophy and Public Affairs 1(3): 229–243.

41.

Singer

(2005) Ethics and intuitions. Journal of Ethics 9: 331–352.

42.

Tadros

(2011) The Ends of Harm: The Moral Foundations of Criminal Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

43.

Tadros

(2014) Resource wars. Law and Philosophy 33: 361–389.

44.

Vihvelin

Tomkow

(2005) The dif. Journal of Philosophy 102: 183–205.

45.

Walzer

(1977) Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations. New York: Basic Books.

46.

Wellman

(2012) Rights forfeiture theory of punishment. Ethics 122(2): 371–393.

47.

Wenar

(2006) Why rawls is not a cosmopolitan egalitarian. In: Martin

Reidy

(eds) Rawls’s Laws of Peoples: A Realistic Utopia. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, pp. 95–113.

48.

Wenar

(2010) Realistic reform of international trades in resources. In: Jaggar

(ed.) Thomas Pogge and His Critics. Cambridge: Polity Press, pp. 123–150.