In response to a swirling controversy over high costs, wastes and inefficiencies in marketing, Wroe Alderson (1948) proposed a novel formula to measure the productivity (or efficiency) of the marketing system. His dual input—output formulation represented a significant conceptual advance over marketing efficiency measures that had gone before or have come after. Alderson’s main contribution was to add a measure of household purchasing productivity to the standard economic formulation of the aggregate marketing productivity of business firms. There were, however, conceptual, operational and empirical problems with the formula, particularly with Alderson’s inclusion of household buying behavior. Because the conceptual challenges appeared so intractable and also because the difficulties of measurement seemed so insurmountable, the formula has long been relegated to the scrapheap of marketing history.
Conceptual advances in marketing theory, particularly in light of Alderson’s later theoretical work, along with the availability of data sources hitherto unavailable, now make empirically testing the efficiency formula a realistic possibility. Consequently, it is worth revisiting the formula and reexamining the conceptual challenges so that one of Alderson’s most brilliant theoretical contributions to marketing thought may finally be conceptually resurrected and empirically tested.
Alderson, W. ( 1941) ‘A Critical Analysis of Recent Literature Dealing with Marketing Efficiency: Discussion’, Journal of Marketing5(April): 365-70.
2.
Alderson, W. ( 1948) ‘A Formula for Measuring Productivity in Distribution’ , Journal of Marketing12(April): 442-8.
3.
Alderson, W. ( 1951) ‘A Systemics for Problems of Action’, Philosophy of Science18(January): 16-25.
4.
Alderson, W. ( 1954) ‘Factors Governing the Development of Marketing Channels’, in R. M. Clewett (ed.) Marketing Channels for Manufactured Goods, pp. 7-8. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
5.
Alderson, W. ( 1957) Marketing Behavior and Executive Action. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
6.
Alderson, W. ( 1958) ‘The Analytical Framework for Marketing’, in D. J. Duncan (ed.) Proceedings of the Conference of Marketing Teachers from Far Western States , pp.15-25. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
7.
Alderson, W. ( 1965) Dynamic Marketing Behavior: A Functionalist Theory of Marketing. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
8.
Anderson, W.T., Challagalla, G.N. and McFarland, R.G. ( 1999) ‘Anatomy of Exchange,’Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice7(Fall): 8-19.
9.
Ardnt, J. ( 1983) ‘A Critique of Marketing and Broadened Marketing’ , in P.D. White and C. Slater (eds) Macromarketing: Distributive Processes from a Social Perspective, pp. 7-28. Boulder, CO: University of Colorado Business Research Division.
10.
Barksdale, H.C. ( 1980) ‘Wroe Alderson’s Contributions to Marketing Theory’, in C.W. Lamb, Jr and P.M. Dunne (eds) Theoretical Developments in Marketing, pp. 1-3. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
11.
Bartels, R. ( 1968) ‘The General Theory of Marketing’, Journal of Marketing15(3): 319-28.
12.
Bartels, R. ( 1970) Marketing Theory and Metatheory. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
13.
Beckman, T.N. ( 1940) ‘Criteria of Marketing Efficiency’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science209(May): 133-40.
14.
Beckman, T.N. ( 1958a) ‘The Value Added Concept as a Measurement of Output’ , in E. J. Kelley and W. Lazer (eds) Managerial Marketing: Perspectives and Viewpoints’ A Source Book, pp. 451-9. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
15.
Beckman, T.N. ( 1958b) ‘The Evolution of Marketing and Marketing Concepts’ , in D. J. Duncan (ed.) Proceedings of the Conference of Marketing Teachers from Far Western States, pp.1-11. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
16.
Beckman, T.N. ( 1965) ‘Marketing Productivity - Appraisal and Challenge’ , in J. L. Heskett (ed.) Productivity in Marketing, pp.59-72. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University.
17.
Bender, W.C. ( 1964) ‘Consumer Purchase Costs - Do Retailers Recognize Them?’, Journal of Retailing40(Spring): 1-8.
18.
Black, J.D. and Houston, N.T. ( 1950) Resource-use Efficiency in the Marketing of Farm Products . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
19.
Blankertz, D.F. ( 1950) ‘Consumer Actions and Consumer Nonprofit Co-operation’ , in R. Cox and W. Alderson (eds) Theory in Marketing, pp.163-78. Chicago, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
20.
Breyer, R.F. ( 1934) The Marketing Institution. NY: McGraw-Hill.
21.
Breyer, R.F. ( 1949) Quantitative Systemic Analysis and Control: Study No. 1. Philadelphia, PA: Published by the author.
22.
Brown, S. ( 2005) Writing Marketing. London: Sage Publications.
23.
Bucklin, L.P. ( 1975) ‘A Synthetic Index of Marketing Productivity’ , in E. Mazze (ed.) Proceedings of the American Marketing Association Educators Conference , pp. 556-60. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
24.
Bucklin, L.P. ( 1978) Productivity in Marketing. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
25.
Cassels, J.M. ( 1936) ‘The Significance of Early Economic Thought on Marketing’ , Journal of Marketing1(October): 129-33.
26.
Claque, E. ( 1965) ‘An Evaluation of Current Productivity Measures for Trade’, in J. L. Heskett (ed.) Papers of the Theodore N. Beckman Symposium on Marketing Productivity, pp. 11-24. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University.
27.
Clark, F.E. ( 1922) Principles of Marketing. NYMacmillan .
28.
Clark, F.E. and Clark, C.P. ( 1942) Principles of Marketing. NYMacmillan .
29.
Committee on Marketing (1961) Principles of Marketing. NY: Pitman Publishing.
30.
Commons, J.R. ( 1924) Legal Foundations of Capitalism. NYMacmillan.
Converse, P.D. ( 1940) ‘Employment, Wages, and Labor Relations in Marketing’ , The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science209(May): 149-57.
33.
Converse, P.D. and Huegy, H.W. ( 1940) The Elements of Marketing. NYPrentice Hall.
34.
Cox, R., Goodman, C.S. and Fichandler, T.C. ( 1965) Distribution in a High-level Economy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
35.
Dixon, D.F. ( 1967) ‘A Social Systems Approach to Marketing’, Social Science Quarterly48(September): 164-73.
36.
Dixon, D.F. and Wilkinson, I.F. ( 1989) The Marketing System. Melbourne, VIC : Longman Cheshire.
37.
Downs, A. ( 1961) ‘A Theory of Consumer Efficiency’, Journal of Retailing37(Spring): 6-12.
Editors (2001) ‘Welcome to Marketing Theory’, Marketing Theory1(1): 1-8.
40.
Engle, N.H. ( 1940) ‘Costs and Profits in Marketing’, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science209(May): 122-32.
41.
Engle, N.H. ( 1941) ‘Measurement of Economic and Marketing Efficiency’ , Journal of Marketing5(April): 335-49.
42.
Fisk, G. ( 1967) Marketing Systems: An Introductory Analysis. NYHarper and Row.
43.
Fisk, G. and Dixon, D.F. ( 1967) Theories for Marketing Systems Analysis. NYHarper and Row.
44.
Florence, P.S. ( 1933) The Logic of Industrial Organizations. London: Routledge and Keegan Paul.
45.
Grabner, J.R. and Layton, R.A. ( 1973) ‘Problems and Challenges in Marketing Performance Measurement’, in F. C. Alvine (ed.) Proceedings of the AMA Workshop on Public Policy and Marketing Practices, pp.163-82. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
46.
Holbrook, M. ( 2001) ‘Wroe Alderson’s Marketing Behavior and Executive Action’, Association for Consumer Research News Winter : 37.
47.
Homans, G.C. ( 1958) ‘Social Behavior as Exchange’, American Journal of Sociology63(May): 597-606.
48.
Hostiuk, T.K. and Kurtz, D.L. ( 1973) ‘Alderson’s Functionalism and the Development of Marketing Theory’, Journal of Business Research1(2): 141-56.
49.
Huegy, H.W. ( 1941) ‘A Critical Analysis of Recent Literature Dealing with Marketing Efficiency: Discussion’, Journal of Marketing5(April): 371-3.
50.
Hunt, S.D. ( 1976) Marketing Theory: Conceptual Foundations of Research in Marketing. Columbus, OH: Grid.
51.
Hunt, S.D. ( 1979) ‘Panel Discussion on the Graduate Marketing Theory Course’, in O. C. Ferrell, S. Brown and C. W. Lamb, Jr (eds) Conceptual and Theoretical Developments in Marketing, pp. 665-78. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
52.
Hunt, S.D. ( 1983) ‘General Theories and the Fundamental Explanada of Marketing’, Journal of Marketing47(Fall): 9-17.
53.
Hunt, S.D. ( 2002) Foundations of Marketing Theory: Toward a General Theory of Marketing. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe .
54.
Hunt, S.D., Muncy, J.A. and Ray, N.M. ( 1981) ‘Alderson’s General Theory of Marketing: A Formalization’, in B. M. Enis and K. J. Roering (eds) Review of Marketing, pp. 267-72. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
55.
Jones, D.G.B. and Shaw, E. ( 2002) ‘A History of Marketing Thought’, in B. A. Weitz and R. Wensly (eds) Handbook of Marketing, pp. 39-66. London : Sage.
56.
Kendrik, J.W. ( 1973) Postwar Productivity Trends in the United States, 1948-1968. NY: National Bureau of Economic Research and Columbia University.
57.
Kerin, R.A., Hartley, S.W., Berkowitz, E.N. and Rudelius, W. ( 2006) Marketing, pp. 396-8. NY: McGraw-Hill Irwin.
58.
Kotler, P. ( 1972a) ‘A Generic Concept of Marketing’, Journal of Marketing36(April): 46-54.
59.
Kotler, P. ( 1972b) Marketing Management (2nd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall .
60.
Kotler, P. ( 2003) Marketing Management (11th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall .
61.
Kotler, P. and G Armstrong, . G. ( 2010) Principles of Marketing. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
62.
Kotler. P. and Levy, S. ( 1969) ‘Broadening the Concept of Marketing’, Journal of Marketing33(January): 10-15.
63.
Kotler, P. and Levy, S.J. ( 1973) ‘Buying is Marketing Too!’, Journal of Marketing37(January): 54-9.
64.
Lamb, C.W., Hair, J.F. and McDaniel, C. ( 2006) Marketing, pp. 394-6. Mason, OH: Thomson South-Western.
65.
McCarthy, E.J. ( 1960) Basic Marketing. New York: McGraw-Hill.
66.
McGarry, E.D. ( 1950) ‘Some Functions of Marketing Reconsidered’ , in R. Cox and W. Alderson (eds) Theory in Marketing, pp. 263-79. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
67.
McInnes, W. ( 1964) ‘A Conceptual Approach to Marketing’, in R. Cox, W. Alderson and S. Shapiro (eds) Theory in Marketing (2nd ed.), pp. 51-67. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
68.
Maynard, H.H. and Beckman, T.N. ( 1946) Principles of Marketing. NYRonald Press Company.
Narver, J.C. and Savitt, R. ( 1971) The Marketing Economy. NYHolt, Rinehart, and Winston.
71.
Nervik, O. and Black, J.D. ( 1951) Research in Selling and Buying. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
72.
Newman, P. ( 1965) The Theory of Exchange. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
73.
Nickels, W.G. ( 1974) ‘Conceptual Conflicts in Marketing’, Journal of Economics and Business26(Winter): 140-3.
74.
Perreault, W.D., Jr and McCarthy, E.J. (2005) Basic Marketing: A Global-Managerial Approach. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill .
75.
Phillips, C.F. ( 1941) ‘A Critical Analysis of Recent Literature Dealing with Marketing Efficiency’, Journal of Marketing5(April): 360-5.
76.
Phillips, C.F. and Duncan, D.J. ( 1948) Marketing Principles and Methods. Chicago, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
77.
Polanyi, K.( 1957) ‘The Economy as Instituted Process’, in K. Polanyi, C. M. Aronsberg and H. W. Pearson (eds) Trade and Market in Early Empires, pp. 243-70. New York: Free Press.
Sevin, C.H., Cox, R., Hawkins, E.R. and Clewett, R.M. ( 1951) ‘An Outline of Distribution Costs’, Journal of Marketing16(July): 51-5.
80.
Shaw, A.W. ( 1912) ‘Some Problems in Market Distribution’, Quarterly Journal of Economics26(August): 706-65.
81.
Shaw, E.H. ( 1990) ‘A Review of Empirical Studies of Aggregate Marketing Costs and Productivity in the United States’, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science18(4): 285-92.
82.
Shaw, E.H. ( 1995) ‘The First Dialogue on Macromarketing’, Journal of Macromarketing15(Spring): 7-20.
83.
Shaw, E.H. ( 2009) ‘A General Theory of Systems Performance Criteria’ , International Journal of General Systems38(8): 851-69.
84.
Shaw, E.H. and Dixon, D.F. ( 1980) ‘Exchange: A Conceptualization’, in C. W. Lamb and P. M. Dunne (eds) Theoretical Developments in Marketing, pp. 150-3. Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.
85.
Shaw, E.H. and Jones, D.G.B. ( 2005) ‘A History of Schools of Marketing Thought’ , Marketing Theory5(3): 239-81.
86.
Shaw, E.H. and Pirog, S.F. ( 1997) ‘A Systems Model of Household Behavior’, Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice5(3): 17-30.
87.
Sheth, J.N. and Garrett, D.E. ( 1986) ‘Part One: Theoretical Foundations’, in J. N. Sheth and D. E. Garrett (eds) Marketing Theory: Classical and Contemporary Readings, pp. 1-2. Cincinnati, OH: South-Western.
88.
Smith, A. ( 1776 [1937]) An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, reprinted. New York: Modern Library.
89.
Smith, W.R. ( 1965) ‘The Study of Productivity in Marketing - Conception and Measurement’, in J. L. Heskett (ed.) Productivity in Marketing, pp. 1-10. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University.
90.
Stewart, P.W. and Dewhurst, J.F. ( 1939) Does Distribution Cost Too Much?New York: Twentieth Century Fund.
91.
Thibaut, J.W. and Kelley, H.H. ( 1959) The Social Psychology of Groups. New York: Wiley.
92.
Tousley, R.D., Clark, E. and Clark, F.E. ( 1962) Principles of Marketing. New York: Macmillan.
93.
Vaile, R.S. ( 1941) ‘Efficiency within the Marketing Structure’ , Journal of Marketing5(4): 350-9.
94.
Vaile, R.S., Grether, E.T. and Cox, R. ( 1952) Marketing in the American Economy. New York: Ronald Press.
