This paper examines the treatment of paradigm incommensurability in marketing
theory. It is not the first to tackle the issue, although I will argue that
existing attempts to negotiate the incommensurability thesis fail on their
misunderstanding of Kuhn's work. I then highlight Kuhn's own shifting position
regarding the incommensurability thesis. Despite Kuhn's proposal that
incommensurability can be overcome, such a strategy would be risky in an
environment where cognitive bias indicates a continued subscription to logical
empiricism and behavioural scientific modes of inquiry.
Alderson, W.
(1965) Dynamic Marketing Behavior: A Functionalist Theory of
Marketing. Homewood: Richard D.
Irwin.
2.
Alderson, W.
and
Cox, R.
(1948)
`Towards a Theory of Marketing'
, The Journal of Marketing13(2):
137-52.
3.
Anderson, P.F.
(1986)
`On Method in Consumer Research: A Critical Relativist Perspective'
, Journal of Consumer Research13(2):
155-73.
4.
Bagozzi, R.P.
(1976) `Science, Politics, and the Social Construction of
Marketing', in
K. L. Bernhardt
(ed.) Marketing 1776-1976 and Beyond, pp.
586-92. Chicago, IL:
American Marketing Association.
5.
Bagozzi, R.P.
(1992)
`Acrimony in the Ivory Tower: Stagnation or Evolution?'
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science20(4):
355-9.
6.
Belk, R.W.
(1995) `Studies in the New Consumer Behaviour', in
D. Miller
(ed.) Acknowledging Consumption: A Review of New Studies, pp.
58-95. London:
Routledge.
7.
Böhm, S.
(2006) Repositioning Organization Theory: Impossibilities and
Strategies. Basingstoke:
Palgrave Macmillan.
8.
Brown, S.
(1995a)
`Nightmare on IMR Street'
, Irish Marketing Review8: 157-60.
9.
Brown, S.
(1995b)
`The Eunuch's Tale: Reviewing Reviewed'
, Journal of Marketing Management11(7):
681-706.
10.
Brown, S.
(1998) Postmodern Marketing 2.
London : International Thompson
Business Press.
11.
Brown, S.
(2000)
`Going Bananas in Paradise: From McDonaldisation to Fyffefication'
, Marketing Intelligence and Planning18(6/7):
356-67.
12.
Burrell, G.
(1997) `Organization Paradigms', in
A. Sorge
and
M. Warner
(eds) The IEBM Handbook of Organizational Behavior, pp.
33-47. London:
International Thompson Business
Press.
13.
Burrell, G.
and
Morgan, G.
(1992[1979]) Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis.
Oxford:
Ashgate.
14.
Burton, D.
(2001)
`Critical Marketing Theory: The Blueprint?'
, European Journal of Marketing35(5/6):
722-43.
15.
Calder, B.J.
and
Tybout, A.M.
(1987)
`What Consumer Research Is
. . . ', Journal of Consumer Research14(1):
136-40.
16.
Churchill, G.A.
(1988)
`Comments on the AMA Task Force Study'
, Journal of Marketing52(4):
26-31.
17.
Davidson, D.
(2001) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation
(2nd ed.). Oxford:
Clarendon.
18.
Davies, A.
and
Fitchett, J.A.
(2001)
`Interpretivist and Positivist Insights into Museum Consumption: An
Empirical Inquiry into Paradigm Comparability'
, European Advances in Consumer Research1: 234-9.
19.
Davies, A.
and
Fitchett, J.A.
(2005)
`Beyond Incommensurability? Empirical Expansion on Diversity in
Research'
, European Journal of Marketing39(3):
272-93.
20.
De Cock, C.
and
Jeanes, E.L.
(2006)
`Questioning Consensus, Cultivating Conflict'
, Journal of Management Inquiry15(1):
18-30.
21.
De Grazia, A.
(1978) The Velikovsky Affair.
London :
Sphere.
22.
Deetz, S.
(1996)
`Describing Differences in Approaches to Organization Science: Rethinking
Burrell and Morgan and their Legacy'
, Organization Science7(2):
191-207.
23.
Deetz, S.
(2000)
`Putting the Community into Organizational Science: Exploring the
Construction of Knowledge Claims'
, Organization Science11(6):
732-8.
24.
Deighton, J.
(2005)
`From the Editor-Elect'
, Journal of Consumer Research32(1).
25.
Easley, R.W.
,
Madden, C.S.
and
Dunn, M.G.
(2000)
`Conducting Marketing Science: The Role of Replication in the Research
Process'
, Journal of Business Research48(1):
83-92.
26.
Easton, G.
(1995) `Methodology and Industrial Networks', in
K. Möller
and
D. Wilson
(eds) Business Marketing: An Interaction and Network Perspective,
pp. 411-92. Boston, MA:
Kluwer .
27.
Feyerabend, P.
(1975) Against Method.
London: New Left
Books.
28.
Feyerabend, P.
(1978) Science in a Free Society.
London: New Left
Books.
29.
Feyerabend, P.
(1999a) Conquest of Abundance.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
Press.
30.
Feyerabend, P.K.
(1999b) `How to Defend Society Against Science', in
P. K. Feyerabend Knowledge, Science and Relativism: Philosophical Papers
Vol. 3, ed.
J. Preston
, pp. 181- 91.
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
31.
Fuller, S.
(2005a)
`You Call Yourself an Intellectual'
, Times Higher Education Supplement February 18th:
14
.
32.
Fuller, S.
(2005b) The Intellectual.
London:
Icon.
33.
Gioia, D.A.
and
Pitre, E.
(1990)
`Multiparadigm Perspectives on Theory Building'
, Academy of Management Review15(4):
584-602.
34.
Gioia, D.A.
,
Donnellon, A.
and
Sims, H.P.
(1989)
`Communication and Cognition in Appraisal: A Tale of Two Paradigms'
, Organization Studies10(4):
503-30.
35.
Gould, S.
(1991)
`The Self-Manipulation of My Pervasive Perceived Vital Energy through
Product Use: An Introspective-Praxis Perspective'
, Journal of Consumer Research18(2):
194-207.
36.
Hassard, J.
(1990) `An Alternative to Paradigm Incommensurability in
Organization Theory', in
J. Hassard
and
D. Pym
(eds) The Theory and Philosophy of Organizations, pp.
219-30. London:
Routledge.
37.
Hirschman, E.C.
(1986)
`Humanistic Inquiry in Marketing Research: Philosophy, Method and
Criteria'
, Journal of Marketing Research23(3):
237-49.
38.
Hirschman, E.C.
(1989) `Afterword', in
E.C. Hirschman
(ed.) Interpretive Consumer Research, p. 209.
Provo, UT : Association for
Consumer Research.
39.
Hirschman, E.C.
(1993)
`Ideology in Consumer Research, 1980 and 1990: A Marxist and Feminist
Critique'
, Journal of Consumer Research19(4):
537-55.
40.
Holbrook, M.B.
(1995) Consumer Research: Introspective Essays on the Study
of Consumption. London:
Sage .
41.
Holbrook, M.B.
(1997)
`Romanticism, Introspection, and the Roots of Experiential
Consumption'
, Consumption, Markets and Culture1(2):
97-164.
42.
Holbrook, M.B.
and
Hirschman, E.C.
(1993) The Semiotics of Consumption: Interpreting Symbolic
Consumer Behavior in Popular Culture and Works of Art.
Berlin: Mouton de
Gruyter.
43.
Holbrook, M.B.
and
O'Shaughnessy, J.
(1988)
`On The Scientific Status of Consumer Research and the Need for an
Interpretive Approach to Studying Consumption Behavior'
, Journal of Consumer Research15(3):
398-402.
44.
Horrobin, D.F.
(1982)
`Peer Review: A Philosophically Faulty Concept which is Disastrous for
Science'
, The Behavioral and Brain Sciences5(2):
217-18.
45.
Hoyningen-Huene, P.
(1995)
`Two Letters of Paul Feyerabend to Thomas S. Kuhn on a Draft of The
Structure of Scientific Revolutions'
, Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science26(3):
353-87.
46.
Hoyningen-Huene, P.
and
Schaber, P.
(2003) `Incommensurability of Knowledge: Theories and
Values', URL (consulted June 2007):
http://www.unics.uni-hannover.de/zeww/pub.phh.eng.html
47.
Hunt, S.D.
(1971)
`The Morphology of Theory and the General Theory of Marketing'
, Journal of Marketing53(2):
65-8.
48.
Hunt, S.D.
(1976)
`The Nature and Scope of Marketing'
, Journal of Marketing40(3):
17-26.
49.
Hunt, S.D.
(1991)
`Positivism and Paradigm Dominance in Consumer Research'
, Journal of Consumer Research18(2):
32-44.
50.
Hunt, S.D.
(2003) Controversy in Marketing Theory: For Reason, Realism,
Truth and Objectivity. Armonk, NY:
M.E. Sharpe.
51.
Kelemen, M.
and
Hassard, J.
(2003) `Paradigm Plurality: Exploring Past, Present and
Future Trends', in
R. Westwood
and
S. Clegg
(eds) Debating Organization: Point-Counterpoint in Organization
Studies, pp. 73-82.
Oxford :
Blackwell.
52.
Kernan, J.B.
(1995)
`Declaring a Discipline: Reflections on ACR's Silver Anniversary'
, Advances in Consumer Research22: 543-60.
53.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1962) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
Press .
54.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1970a) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
(2nd ed.). Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
55.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1970b) `Reflections on My Critics', in
I. Lakatos
and
A. Musgrave
(eds) Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, pp.
231-78. Cambridge :
Cambridge University Press.
56.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1977) `Objectivity, Value Judgment, and Theory Choice'
, in
T. S. Kuhn
, The Essential Tension: Selected Studies in Scientific Tradition and
Change, pp. 320-39.
Chicago: University of Chicago
Press.
57.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1983)
`Commensurability, Comparability, Communicability'
, in P. D. Asquith and T. Nickles (eds) PSA1982 Vol. 2, pp.
2-13. East
Lansing: Philosophy of Science
Association.
58.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1987) `What are Scientific Revolutions?', in
L. Kruger.,L. J. Daston
and
M. Heidelberger
(eds) The Probabilistic Revolution, pp.
7-22. Cambridge, MA:
MIT Press.
59.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1989)
`Possible Worlds in History of Science'
, in S. Allén (ed.)
Possible Worlds in Humanities
, Arts and Sciences: Proceedings of Novel Symposium65, pp. 9-32.
Berlin: Walter de
Gruyter.
60.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1990) `Dubbing and Redubbing: The Vulnerability of Rigid
Designation', in
C. W. Smith
(ed.) Scientific Theories, pp. 298-318.
Minneapolis, MN: University of
Minnesota Press.
61.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1991a)
`The Road Since Structure'
, in A. Fine, M. Forbes and L. Wessels (eds) PSA1990 Vol. 2, pp.
2-13. East
Lansing: Philosophy of Science
Association.
62.
Kuhn, T.S.
(1991b) `The Natural and the Human Sciences', in
D.R. Hiley
,
J.F. Bohman
and
R. S. Schusterman
(eds) The Interpretive Turn: Philosophy, Science and Culture, pp.
17-24. Ithaca, NY:
Cornell University Press.
63.
Leone, R.P.
and
Schultz, R.L.
(1980)
`A Study of Marketing Generalizations'
, Journal of Marketing44(4)
10-18.
64.
Lewis, M.W.
and
Grimes, A.
(1999)
`Metatriangulation: Building Theory from Multiple Paradigms'
, Academy of Management Review24(4):
673-90.
65.
Lewis, M.W.
and
Kelemen, M.L.
(2002)
`Multiparadigm Inquiry: Exploring Organizational Pluralism and
Paradox'
, Human Relations55(2):
251-75.
66.
Lowe, S.
,
Carr, A.N.
and
Thomas, M.
(2004)
`Paradigmapping Marketing Theory'
, European Journal of Marketing,
38(9/10):
1057-64.
67.
Lowe, S.
,
Carr, A.N.
,
Thomas, M.
and
Watkins-Mathys, L.
(2005)
`The Fourth Hermeneutic in Marketing Theory'
, Marketing Theory5(2):
185-203.
McAlister, L.
(2005)
`Unleashing Potential'
, Journal of Marketing69(4):
16-17.
70.
McDonagh, P.
(1995)
`Radical Change through Rigorous Review? A Commentary on the
Commodification of Marketing Knowledge'
, Journal of Marketing Management11(7):
675-9.
71.
MacInnis, D.
(2003)
`Responsibilities of a Good Reviewer: Lessons Learned from
Kindergarten'
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science31(3):
344-5.
72.
MacInnis, D.J.
(2005)
`Them versus Us: Woes on the Bifurcation of the Academic Marketing
Discipline'
, Journal of Marketing69(4):
14-16.
73.
MacIntyre, A.
(1989) `Relativism, Power, and Philosophy', in
M. Krausz
(ed.) Relativism: Interpretation and Confrontation, pp.
182-204. Indiana, IN:
University of Notre Dame Press.
74.
McKelvey, B.
(1997)
`Quasi-Natural Organization Science'
, Organization Science8(4):
352-80.
75.
McKelvey, B.
(1999) `Toward a Campbellian Realist Organization
Science' , in
J. A. C. Baum
and
B. McKelvey
(eds) Variations in Organization Science: In Honor of Donald T.
Campbell, pp. 383-411. Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage.
76.
McKelvey, B.
(2003a) `Postmodernism versus Truth in Management
Theory' , in
E. A. Locke
(ed.) Postmodernism and Management: Pros, Cons and the
Alternative, pp. 113-68.
Amsterdam : JAI
Press.
77.
McKelvey, B.
(2003b) `From Fields to Science: Can Organization Studies
Make the Transition?', in
R. Westwood
and
S. Clegg
(eds.) Debating Organization: Point-Counterpoint in Organization
Studies, pp. 47-73.
Oxford :
Blackwell.
78.
Mahoney, M.J.
(1977)
`Publication Prejudices: An Experimental Study of Confirmatory Bias in the
Peer Review System'
, Cognitive Therapy and Research1(2):
161-75.
79.
Marsden, D.
and
Littler, D.
(1998)
`Positioning Alternative Perspectives of Consumer Behaviour'
, Journal of Marketing Management14(1/3):
3-29.
80.
Mauws, M.K.
and
Phillips, N.
(1995)
`Understanding Language Games'
, Organization Science6(3):
322-34.
81.
Morgan, G.
(2003) `Marketing and Critique: Prospects and Problems'
, in
M. Alvesson
and
H. Willmott
(eds) Studying Management Critically , pp.
111-31. London:
Sage.
82.
Murray, J.B.
and
Ozanne, J.L.
(1991)
`The Critical Imagination: Emancipatory Interests in Consumer
Research'
, Journal of Consumer Research18(2):
129-44.
83.
Murray, J.B.
and
Ozanne, J.L.
(1997) `A Critical-Emancipatory Sociology of Knowledge:
Reflections on the Social Construction of Consumer Research', in
R. Belk
(ed.) Research in Consumer Behavior , pp.
57-92. Greenwich, CT:
JAI Press.
84.
Nola, R.
and
Sankey, H.
(2001) `A Selective Survey of Theories of Scientific
Method' , in
R. Nola
and
H. Sankey
(eds) After Popper, Kuhn and Feyerabend: Recent Issues in Theories of
Scientific Method, pp. 1-65.
Dordrecht
, MA:
Kluwer
.
85.
Nola, R.
and
Sankey, H.
(2007) Theories of Scientific Method.
Stocksfield:
Acumen.
86.
O'Shaughnessy, J.
(1997)
`Temerarious Directions for Marketing'
, European Journal of Marketing31(9/10):
677-705.
87.
O'Shaughnessy, J.
and
O'Shaughnessy, N.
(2002)
`Ways of Knowing and their Applicability'
, Marketing Theory2(2):
147-64.
88.
Ozanne, J.L.
and
Hudson, L.A.
(1989) `Exploring Diversity in Consumer Research', in
E.C. Hirschman
(ed.) Interpretive Consumer Research, pp.
1-9. Provo, UT:
Association for Consumer Research.
89.
Parker, M.
and
McHugh, G.
(1991)
`Five Texts in Search of an Author: A Response to John Hassard's Multiple
Paradigms and Organizational Analysis'
, Organization Studies12(3):
451-6.
90.
Phillips, D.L.
(1977) Wittgenstein and Scientific Knowledge: A Sociological
Perspective. London:
Macmillan.
91.
Popper, K.R.
(1976) `The Logic of the Social Sciences', in
T. W. Adorno
,
H. Albert
,
R. Dahrendorf
,
J. Habermas
,
H. Pilot
and
K. R. Popper
( 1976) The Positivist Dispute in German Sociology, pp.
87-104. Trans. G. Adey and D. Firsby.
London:
Heinemann.
Pronin, E.
,
Lin, D.Y.
and
Ross, L.
(2002)
`The Bias Blind Spot: Perceptions of Bias in Self versus Others'
, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin28(3):
369-81.
94.
Ravetz, J.R.
(1990) The Merger of Knowledge with Power: Essays in Critical
Science. London:
Mansell.
95.
Sankey, H.
(1994) The Incommensurability Thesis.
Aldershot:
Avebury.
96.
Sankey, H.
(1997) Rationality, Relativism and Incommensurability .
Aldershot:
Avebury.
97.
Sankey, H.
and
Hoyningen-Huene, P.
(2001) `Introduction', in
H. Sankey
and
P. Hoyningen-Huene
(eds) Incommensurability and Related Matters, pp.
vii-xxxiv. Dordrecht, MA:
Kluwer.
98.
Scherer, A.G.
(1998)
`Pluralism and Incommensurability in Strategic Management and Organization
Theory'
, Organization5(2):
147-68.
99.
Schroeder, J.E.
(2007) `Critical Marketing: Insights for Informed Research
and Teaching', in
M. Saren
,
R. Elliott
,
P. Maclaran
,
C. Goulding
,
M. Caterall
and
A. Shankar
(eds) Critical Marketing: Defining the Field.
London:
Elsevier.
100.
Schultz, M.
and
Hatch, M.J.
(1996)
`Living with Multiple Paradigms: The Case of Paradigm Interplay in
Organization Culture Studies'
, Academy of Management Review21(2):
529-57.
101.
Scott, L.M.
(2007) `Critical Research in Marketing: An Armchair
Report' , in
M. Saren
,
R. Elliott
,
P. Maclaran
,
C. Goulding
,
M. Caterall
and
A. Shankar
(eds) Critical Marketing: Defining the Field.
London:
Elsevier.
102.
Shah, J.Y.
,
Kruglanski, A.W.
and
Thompson, E.P.
(1998)
`Membership has its (Epistemic) Rewards: Need for Closure Effects on
In-Group Bias'
, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology75(2):
383-93.
103.
Shankar, A.
and
Patterson, M.
(2001)
`Interpreting the Past, Writing the Future'
, Journal of Marketing Management17(5/6):
481-501.
104.
Shapin, S.
(1995)
`Here and Everywhere: Sociology of Scientific Knowledge'
, Annual Review of Sociology21: 289-321.
105.
Sharrock, W.
and
Read, R.
(2002) Kuhn: Philosopher of Scientific Revolution.
Cambridge:
Polity.
106.
Sheth, J.N.
(1992)
`Acrimony in the Ivory Tower: A Retrospective on Consumer Research'
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science20(4):
345-53.
107.
Singh, J.
(2003)
`A Reviewer's Gold'
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science31(3):
331-6.
108.
Staelin, R.
(2005)
`Influencing the Practice through Big New Ideas'
, Journal of Marketing69(4):
21-2.
109.
Stern, R.N.
and
Barley, S.R.
(1996)
`Organizations and Social Systems: Organization Theory's Neglected
Mandate'
, Administrative Science Quarterly41(1):
146-162.
110.
Summers, J.O.
(2001)
`Guidelines for Conducting Research and Publishing in Marketing: From
Conceputalization through the Review Process'
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science29(4):
405-15.
111.
Svensson, G.
(2005)
`Ethnocentricity in Top Marketing Journals'
, Marketing Intelligence and Planning23(5):
422-34.
112.
Svensson, G.
(2006)
`The Paradoxnoia of Top Journal(s) in Marketing'
, European Journal of Marketing40(11/12):
1153-68.
113.
Svensson, G.
and
Wood, G.
(2006)
`The Pareto Plus Syndrome in Top Marketing Journals: Research and Journal
Criteria'
, European Business Review18(6):
457-67.
114.
Tadajewski, M.
(2005)
`Confrontations of Philosophy, Management and Politics'
, Ephemera: Theory and Politics in Organization5(3):
499-518.
115.
Tadajewski, M.
(2006a)
`The Ordering of Marketing Theory: The Role of McCarthyism and the Cold
War'
, Marketing Theory6(2):
163-200.
116.
Tadajewski, M.
(2006b)
`Remembering Motivation Research: Toward an Alternative Genealogy of
Interpretive Consumer Research'
, Marketing Theory6(4):
429-66.
117.
Thompson, C.J.
(1991)
`May the Circle be Unbroken: A Hermeneutic Consideration of how
Interpretive Approaches to Consumer Research are Understood by Consumer
Researchers'
, Advances in Consumer Research18(1):
63-9.
118.
Thompson, C.J.
(1993)
`Modern Truth and Postmodern Incredulity: A Hermeneutic Deconstruction of
the Metanarrative of "Scientific Truth" in Marketing Research'
, International Journal of Research in Marketing10: 325-38.
119.
Thompson, C.J.
(2002)
`A Re-Inquiry on Re-Inquiries: A Postmodern Proposal for a
Critical-Reflexive Approach'
, Journal of Consumer Research29(1):
142-5.
120.
Toulmin, S.
(1972) Human Understanding, Vol. 1.
Oxford:
Clarendon.
121.
Von Dietz, E.
(2001) Paradigms Explained: Rethinking Thomas Kuhn's
Philosophy of Science. Westport, CT:
Praeger .
122.
Weaver, G.R.
and
Gioia, D.A.
(1994)
`Paradigms Lost: Incommensurability vs Structurationist Inquiry'
, Organization Studies15(4):
565-90.
123.
Whetten, D.A.
(1989)
`What Constitutes a Theoretical Contribution
? ' Academy of Management Review14(4):
490-6.
124.
Wilkie, W.L.
(2005)
`Needed: A Large Sense of Marketing and Scholarship'
, Journal of Marketing69(4):
8-10.
125.
Willmott, H.
(1999) `On the Idolization of Markets and the Denigration of
Marketers: Some Critical Reflections on a Professional Paradox', in
D. Brownlie
,
M. Saren
,
R. Wensley
and
R. Whittington
(eds) Rethinking Marketing: Towards Critical Marketing
Accountings, pp. 205-22.
London:
Sage.
126.
Wittnick, D.R.
(2004)
`Journal of Marketing Research: 2 Ps'
, Journal of Marketing ResearchXLI(February):
1-6.
127.
Woodruff, R.B.
(2003)
`Serving the Marketing Discipline Through Journal Reviews'
, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science31(3):
327-30.
