This article discusses the potential challenges of introducing corporate
branding in public sector organizations. While the corporate branding ideal is
to seek a precise and coherent definition of the organizational identity and
achieve message consistency in the organization's self-presentation, public
organizations are often characterized by contradictory and inconsistent values
and multiple identities. This makes the ideal of consistency difficult to
achieve. It is argued that public organizations will benefit more from branding
on the basis of inconsistent values and multiple identities rather than trying
to promote one set of values and one identity at the expense of others.
Aaker, D.A.
(1991) Managing Brand Equity. New
York : Free Press.
2.
Aaker, D.A.
(2004)
`Leveraging the Corporate Brand'
, California Management Review46(3):
6-19.
3.
Aaker, D.A.
and
Joachimsthaler, E.
(2000) Brand Leadership. New
York: Free Press.
4.
Aaker, J.
(1997) `
Dimensions of Brand Personality
', Journal of Marketing Research34(August):
347-56.
5.
Aaker, J.
(1999) `
The Malleable Self: The Role of Self-Expression in Persuasion
', Journal of Marketing Research36(February):
45-57.
6.
Aberbach, J.D.
and
Christensen, T.
(2007)
`The Challenges of Modernizing Tax Administration'
, Public Policy and Administration22(2):
155-82.
7.
Albert, S.
and
Adams, E.
(2002) `The Hybrid Identity of Law Firms', in
B. Moingeon
and
G. Soenen
(eds) Corporate and Organizational Identities, pp.
35-50. London:
Routledge.
8.
Albert, S.
and
Whetten, C.
(1985) `
Organizational Identity
', Research in Organizational Behavior7: 263-95.
9.
Antorini, Y.M.
and
Schultz, M.
(2005a) `Corporate Branding and the Conformity Trap',
in
M. Schultz
,
Y.M. Antorini
and
F.F. Csaba
(eds) Corporate Branding. Purpose/ People/Processes, pp.
57-78. Copenhagen :
Copenhagen Business School Press.
10.
Antorini, Y.M.
and
Schultz, M.
(2005b) `Principles for the Second Wave of Corporate
Branding' , in
M. Schultz
,
Y.M. Antorini
and
F.F. Csaba
(eds) Corporate Branding. Purpose/People/Processes, pp.
219-32. Copenhagen :
Copenhagen Business School Press.
11.
Argenti, P.A.
and
Foreman, J.
(2002) The Power of Corporate Communication
(3rd edn.). New York:
McGraw-Hill.
12.
Ashworth, G.J.
and
Voogd, H.
(1990) Selling the City: Marketing Approaches in Public
Sector Urban Planning. London:
Belhaven Press.
13.
Bakan, J.
(2004) The Corporation. The Pathological Pursuit of Profit
and Power. New York: Free
Press .
14.
Balmer, J.M.T.
(2001)
`Corporate Identity, Corporate Branding and Corporate Marketing. Seeing
Through The Fog'
, European Journal of Marketing35(3/4):
248-91.
15.
Balmer, J.M.T.
and
Greyser, S.
(2002)
`Managing the Multiple Identities of the Corporation'
, California Management Review44(3):
72-86.
16.
Bickerton, D.
(2000)
`Corporate Reputation Versus Corporate Branding: The Realist Debate'
, Corporate Communications5(1):
42-8.
17.
Boston, J.
,
Martin, J.
,
Pallot, J.
and
Walsh, P.
(1996) Public Management: The New Zealand Model.
Auckland: Oxford University
Press.
18.
Brickson, S.
(2000)
`The Impact of Identity Orientation on Individual and Organizational
Outcomes in Demographically Diverse Settings'
, Academy of Management Journal25(1):
82-101.
19.
Brunsson, N.
(1989) The Organization of Hypocrisy: Talk, Decisions and
Actions in Organizations. Chichester:
Wiley.
20.
Buckley, W.
(1968) `Society as a Complex Adaptive System', in
W. Buckley
(ed.) Modern Systems Research for the Behavioral Scientist, pp.
490-513. Chicago, IL :
Aldine Publishing.
21.
Bulotaite, N.
(2003)
`University Heritage - An Institutional Tool for Branding and
Marketing'
, Higher Education in Europe28(4):
449-54.
22.
Butler, P.
and
Collins, N.
(1995)
`Marketing Public Sector Services: Concepts and Characteristics'
, Journal of Marketing Management11(1/3):
83-96.
23.
Byrkjeflot, S.
and
Angell, S.I.
(2007) `Dressing up Hospitals as Corporate Brands? The
Expansion and Managerialization of Communication in Norwegian Hospitals',
in
P. Kjær
and
T. Slaatta
(eds) The Media-Embedded Firm.
24.
Christensen, L.T.
,
Torp, S.
and
Firat, F.
(2005)
`Integrated Marketing Communication and Postmodernity: An Odd
Couple?'
, Corporate Communications: An International Journal10(2):
156-67.
25.
Christensen, T.
,
Lægreid, P.
,
Roness, P.G.
and
Røvik, K.A.
(eds) (2007) Organization Theory and the Public Sector.
Instrument, Culture and Myth. Oxford:
Routledge.
26.
Conant, R.C.
and
Ashby, R.
(1970)
`Every Good Regulator of a System Must Be a Model of that System'
, International Journal of System Science1(2):
89-97.
27.
Corley, K.G.
(2004)
`Defined by Our Strategy or Our Culture? Hierarchical Differences in
Perceptions of Organizational Identity and Change'
, Human Relations57(9):
1145-77.
28.
de Chernatony, L.
and
Dall'Olmo Riley, F.
(1999)
`Experts' Views About Defining Services Brands and the Principles of
Services Branding'
, Journal of Business Research46(2):
181-92.
29.
de Chernatony, L.
,
Drury, S.
and
Segal-Horn, S.
(2004) `
Identifying and Sustaining Services Brands' Values
', Journal of Marketing Communications10(June): 73-93.
30.
Eisenberg, E.
(1984)
`Ambiguity as Strategy in Organizational Communication'
, Communication Monographs51: 227-42.
31.
Fombrun, C.J.
(1996) Reputation: Realizing Value from the Corporate
Image. Boston, MA: Harvard Business
School Press.
32.
Fombrun, C.
and
Van Riel, C.
(2004) Fame and Fortune: How Successful Companies Build
Winning Reputations. Upper Saddle River,
NJ: Prentice Hall.
33.
Fournier, S.
(1998)
`Consumers and Their Brands: Developing Relationship Theory in Consumer
Research'
, Journal of Consumer Research24(4):
343-73.
34.
Gelders, D.
and
Van De Walle, S.
(2005) `
Marketing Government Reforms
', Journal of Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing14(1):
151-68.
35.
Goodsell, C.T.
(1989) `Balancing Competing Values', in
J.L. Perry
(ed.) Handbook of Public Administration , pp.
575-85. San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass.
36.
Golden-Biddle, K.
and
Rao, H.
(1997)
`Breaches in the Boardroom: Organizational Identity and Conflicts of
Commitment in a Nonprofit Organization'
, Organization Science8(6):
593-613.
37.
Gortner, H.F.
,
Mahler, J.
and
Nicholson, J.B.
(1997) Organization Theory: A Public Perspective.
Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace
College Publishers.
38.
Hatch, M.J.
and
Schultz, M.
(2003)
`Bringing the Corporation into Corporate Branding'
, European Journal of Marketing37(7/8):
1041-64.
39.
Heffron, F.
(1989) Organization Theory and Public Organizations: The
Political Connection. Englewood Cliffs,
NJ: Prentice Hall.
40.
Hoggett, P.
(2006) `
Conflict, Ambivalence, and the Contested Purpose of Public
Organizations
', Human Relations59(2):
175-94.
41.
Illia, L.
,
Schmid, E.
,
Fischbach, I.
,
Hangartner, R.
and
Rivola, R.
(2004)
`An Issues Management Perspective on Corporate Identity: The Case of a
Regulatory Agency'
, Corporate Reputation Review7(1):
10-21.
42.
Ind, N.
(1997) The Corporate Brand.
Houndmills :
Macmillan.
43.
Judson, K.
,
Aurand, T.
and
Gorchels, L.
(2006)
`Building a University Brand from Within'
, Journal of Marketing for Higher Education16(1):
97-114.
44.
Kearsey, A.
and
Varey, R.
(1998)
`Managerialist Thinking on Marketing for Public Services'
, Public Money & Management18(2):
51-60.
45.
Kitchen, P.J.
and
Schultz, D.
(2001) Raising the Corporate Umbrella: Corporate
Communication in the 21st Century.
Houndmills:
Palgrave.
46.
Kvåle, G.
and
Wæraas, A.
(2006) Organisasjon og identitet.
Oslo:
Samlaget.
47.
Laing, A.
(2003)
`Marketing in the Public Sector: Towards a Typology of Public
Services'
, Marketing Theory3(4):
427-45.
48.
Leitch, S.
and
Motion, J.
(1999) `
Multiplicity in Corporate Identity Strategy
', Corporate Communications: An International Journal4(4):
193-9.
49.
Leitch, S.
and
Richardson, N.
(2003)
`Corporate Branding in the New Economy'
, European Journal of Marketing37(7/8):
1065-79.
50.
Lilleker, D.G.
and
Lees-Marshment, J.
(2005) Political Marketing: A Comparative Perspective.
Manchester: Manchester University
Press.
51.
Maarek, P.J.
(1995) Political Marketing and Communication.
London: John
Libbey.
52.
McDonald, M.H.B.
,
de Chernatony, L.
and
Harris, F.
(2001) `
Corporate Marketing and Service Brands: Moving Beyond the Fast-Moving
Consumer Goods Model
', European Journal of Marketing35(3):
335-52.
53.
Marshall, K.
and
Fisher, C.
(2005)
`Marketing Military Service'
, Journal of Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing14(1):
247-67.
54.
Olins, W.
(1989) Corporate Identity: Making Business Strategy Visible
Through Design. London: Thames
and Hudson.
55.
Olins, W.
(2000) `How Brands are Taking Over the Corporation', in
M. Schultz
,
M.J. Hatch
and
M.H. Larsen
(eds) The Expressive Organization, pp.
51-65. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
56.
Park, C.W.
,
Jaworski, B.J.
and
MacInnis, D.J.
(1986)
`Strategic Brand Concept-Image Management'
, Journal of Marketing50(4):
135-45.
57.
Pratt, M.G.
and
Foreman, P.O.
(2000)
`Classifying Managerial Responses to Multiple Organizational
Identities'
, Academy of Management Review25(1):
18-42.
58.
Pratt, M.G.
and
Rafaeli, A.
(1997) `
Organizational Dress as a Symbol of Multilayered Social Identities
', Academy of Management Journal40(4):
862-98.
59.
Rainey, H.G.
(2003) Understanding and Managing Public Organizations
. San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass .
60.
Scheaff, R.
(1991) Marketing for Health Services.
Milton Keynes: Open University
Press.
61.
Schultz, M.
and
de Chernatony, L.
(2002)
`The Challenges of Corporate Branding'
, Corporate Reputation Review5(2/3):
105-12.
62.
Urde, M.
(2003)
`Core Value-Based Corporate Brand Building'
, European Journal of Marketing37(7/8):
1017-40.
63.
Van Rekom, J.
and
Van Riel, C.B.M.
(2000) `
Operational Measures of Organizational Identity: A Review of Existing
Methods
', Corporate Reputation Review3(4):
334-50.
64.
Van Riel, C.B.M.
(1995) Principles of Corporate Communication.
London: Prentice
Hall.
65.
Van Riel, C.B.M.
and
Balmer, J.M.T.
(1997) `
Corporate Identity: The Concept, its Measurement and Management
', European Journal of Marketing31(5/6):
340-55.
66.
Walsh, K.
(1994)
`Marketing and Public Sector Management'
, European Journal of Marketing28(3):
63-71.
67.
Weick, K.E.
(1979) Social Psychology of Organizing.
Reading, MA:
Addison-Wesley.
68.
Wæraas, A.
and
Solbakk, M.N.
(2006) `
Defining the Essence of a University
', paper presented at the NEON Conference, Norwegian
School of Management, 23-24 November.
