Anthropologizing and indigenizing heritage: The origins of the UNESCO Global Strategy for a representative,balanced and credible World Heritage List

Abstract

This article analyzes the origins of the 1994 Global Strategy for a Representative, Balanced and Credible World Heritage List as a lens through which to view the process of constructing and re-elaborating a global heritage discourse. Using untapped archival records, it shows that the Global Strategy crystallized after lengthy prior discussions reaching to the early 1980s. Most important, it demonstrates that the novel element in 1994 was the influence of new actors, although not from the Global South that was intended to be the beneficiary of change. The contributors to the Global Strategy were rather from regions (Australia) or disciplines (anthropology) that had hitherto failed to claim their share of influence in shaping international cultural heritage concepts despite being firmly situated within the North. By highlighting such influences, this article resonates with the efforts of anthropologists and other scholars to eschew a reductive center-periphery framework in conceptualizing global cultural flows.

Keywords

World Heritage UNESCO culture global culture heritage discourse Australia anthropology indigenous rights

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Appadurai

(1990) Disjuncture and difference in the global cultural economy. Theory Culture Society 7: 295–310.

Atalay

(2006) Indigenous archaeology as decolonizing practice. American Indian Quarterly 30: 280–310.

Australian Archaeological Association (2003) Rhys Jones medal for outstanding contribution to Australian archaeology 2003: Isabel McBryde. Available at: http://australianarchaeology.com/rhys-jones-medal/isabel-mcbryde/ (accessed 2 June 2015).

Bertacchini

Saccone

Santagata

(2010) Embracing diversity, correcting inequalities: Towards a new global governance for the UNESCO World Heritage. International Journal of Cultural Policy 17: 278–288.

Bortolotto

(2007) From objects to processes: UNESCO's ‘intangible cultural heritage’. Journal of Museum Ethnography 19: 21–33.

Bortolotto

(2010) Globalising intangible cultural heritage? Between international arenas and local appropriations. In: Long

Labadi

(eds) Heritage and Globalisation, London and New York: Routledge, pp. 95–112.

Bortolotto

(2011) Le trouble du patrimoine culturel immateriel [The ambiguities of intangible cultural heritage]. In: Bortolotto

(ed.) Le Patrimoine culturel immatériel. Enjeux d'une nouvelle catégorie [Intangible cultural heritage. What is at stake in this new category], Paris: Maison des sciences de l'homme, pp. 21–43.

Bortolotto

(2013) L'UNESCO comme arène de traduction. La fabrique globale du patrimoine immatériel [UNESCO as an arena for translation. The global making of intangible cultural heritage]. In: Berliner

Bortolotto

(eds) Le monde selon l'UNESCO [The world according to UNESCO], Paris: Musée du Quai Branly, pp. 50–73.

Brattain

(2007) Race, racism, and antiracism: UNESCO and the politics of presenting science to the postwar public. The American Historical Review 112: 1386–1413.

10.

Bromberger

Zonabend

(2012) Isac Chiva (1925--2012). Terrain 2: 168–171.

11.

Brumann

(2011) Unser aller Kulturgut: Eine ethnologische Annäherung an das UNESCO-Welterbe [Our common cultural heritage: An ethnographic exploration of the UNESCO World Heritage]. Sociologus 61: 19–43.

12.

Brumann C (2012) Multilateral ethnography: Entering the World Heritage arena. Working Papers. Halle/Saale: Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology.

13.

Brumann

(2014) Shifting tides of world-making in the UNESCO World Heritage Convention: Cosmopolitanisms colliding. Ethnic and Racial Studies 37: 2176–2192.

14.

Cameron

Rössler

(2013) Many Voices, One Vision: The Early Years of the World Heritage Convention, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon, UK: Ashgate.

15.

Cassimatis M, Cleere H and Cliver B (1992) World Heritage Committee: A framework for preparing a global study for cultural properties. In: Sixteenth meeting of World Heritage Committee, Santa Fe, December 1992, unpublished. Paris: ICOMOS Archives, unboxed, folder Etude globale.

16.

Chiva

(1987a) Compte rendu des débats de la table-ronde ‘L'architecture rurale: De la connaissance à la sauvegarde’ [Proceedings of the roundtable ‘rural architecture: From knowledge to preservation’]. In: Ministère de la culture et de la communication, Direction du patrimoine (ed.) Les Monuments Historiques Demain [Historical monuments tomorrow], Paris: Ministère de la culture et de la communication, Direction du patrimoine, pp. 45–48.

17.

Chiva

(1987b) La maison: Le noyau du fruit, l'arbre, l'avenir [The house: The stone of the fruit, the tree, the future]. Terrain 9: 5–9.

18.

Chiva

(1990) Le patrimoine ethnologique. L’exemple de la France [Anthropological heritage. The example of France]. Encyclopædia Universalis 24: 229–241.

19.

Chiva

Dubost

(1990) L'architecture sans architectes. Une esthétique involontaire? [Architecture without architects. An unintentional aesthetics?]. Etudes rurales [Rural studies] 117: 9–38.

20.

Cleere H (1992) World Heritage Convention: Framework for a global study. In: Sixteenth meeting of World Heritage Bureau, Paris, July 1992, unpublished. Paris: ICOMOS Archives, unboxed, folder Etude globale.

21.

Cleere

(1993) The World Heritage Convention 1972: Framework for a Global Study (Cultural Properties), 23 November 1993, Unpublished, Paris: ICOMOS Archives, unboxed, folder Etude globale.

22.

Cleere

(1994) Tableau des sites [An analysis of sites], Unpublished, Paris: ICOMOS Archives, unboxed, folder Stratégie globale 1994.

23.

Cleere

(1996) The concept of ‘outstanding universal value’ in the World Heritage Convention. Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites 1: 227–233.

24.

Cleere

(2011) The 1972 UNESCO World Heritage Convention: A success or a failure? Heritage and Society 4: 173–185.

25.

Domicelj J (1995) A question of authenticity: Cultural diversity. In: Larsen KE (ed) Nara Conference on Authenticity in Relation to the World Heritage Convention, Nara, Japan, 1–6 November 1994: Proceedings / Conférence de Nara sur l'authenticité dans le cadre de la Convention du Patrimoine Mondial, Nara, Japon, 1–6 novembre 1994 : compte-rendu. Paris and Tokyo: UNESCO World Heritage Centre and Agency for Cultural Affairs, pp. 301–304.

26.

Domicelj

Marshall

(1994) Diversity, Place and the Ethics of Conservation: A Discussion Paper Prepared for the Australian Heritage Commission on Behalf of Australia ICOMOS, Canberra: Australia Heritage Commission.

27.

Duedahl

(2011) Selling mankind: UNESCO and the invention of global history, 1945–1976. Journal of World History 22: 101–133.

28.

Eriksen

(2001) Between universalism and relativism: A critique of the UNESCO concepts of culture. In: Cowan

Dembour

M-B

Wilson

(eds) Culture and Rights: Anthropological Perspectives, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 127–148.

29.

Ferguson

(2011) Civilization: The West and the Rest, London and New York: Allen Lane.

30.

Gfeller

(2013) Negotiating the meaning of global heritage: ‘Cultural landscapes’ in the UNESCO World Heritage Convention, 1972–1992. Journal of Global History 8: 483–503.

31.

Gfeller

(2015) Preserving cultural heritage across the iron curtain: The International Council on Monuments and Sites from Venice to Warsaw, 1964–1978. In: Schädler-Saub

Weyer

(eds) Geteilt – Vereint! Denkmalpflege in Mitteleuropa zur Zeit des Eisernen Vorhangs und heute [Divided – United! Historical monuments in central Europe at the time of the Iron Curtain and today], Petersberg: Michael Imhof Verlag, pp. 115–121.

32.

Gfeller

Eisenberg

(in print) Scaling the local: Canada’s Rideau Canal and shifting World Heritage norms. Journal of World History.

33.

Hafstein

(2009) Intangible heritage as a list: From masterpieces to representation. In: Smith

Akagawa

(eds) Intangible Heritage, London and New York: Routledge, pp. 93–111.

34.

Hannerz

(1987) The world in creolisation. Africa 57: 546–559.

35.

Hannerz

(1989a) Culture between center and periphery: Toward a macroanthropology. Ethnos 54: 200–216.

36.

Hannerz

(1989b) Notes on the global ecumene. Public Culture 1: 66–75.

37.

Harrison

(2013) Heritage: Critical Approaches, London and New York: Routledge.

38.

Heinich

(2009) La fabrique du patrimoine. De la cathédrale à la petite cuillère [The making of heritage. From the cathedral to the teaspoon], Paris: Maison des sciences de l'homme.

39.

ICOMOS (1984) Expert meeting on World Heritage cultural criteria, handwritten notes of meeting in French, 20–21 February 1984, unpublished, Paris: ICOMOS Archives, box Réunion critères 1984.

40.

ICOMOS (1986) Expert meeting on the implementation of the World Heritage Convention in sub-Saharan Africa, handwritten notes of meeting in French, 23 October 1986, unpublished, Paris: ICOMOS Archives, box Réunion Bamako 1987.

41.

ICOMOS (1994) Expert meeting on the Global Strategy and thematic studies for a representative World Heritage List, handwritten notes of meeting in French and English, 20–22 June 1994, Paris: ICOMOS Archives, unboxed, folder Stratégie globale 1994.

42.

IUCN (1983) Monitoring Natural World Heritage Sites, 11 April 1983. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1983/sc-83-conf009-6e.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

43.

Kearney

(1996) Reconceptualizing the Peasantry: Anthropology in Global Perspective, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

44.

Labadi

(2005) A review of the Global Strategy for a Balanced, Representative and Credible World Heritage List 1994–2004. Conservation and Management of Archaeological Site 7: 89–102.

45.

Labadi

(2012) Cultural Heritage, and Outstanding Universal Value: Value-Based Analyses of the World Heritage and Intangible Cultural Heritage Conventions, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

46.

Langford

(1983) Our heritage - Your playground. Australian Archaeology 16: 1–6.

47.

Laqua

(2011) Transnational intellectual cooperation, the league of nations, and the problem of order. Journal of Global History 6: 223–247.

48.

Lebovics

(2005) On the origins of the mission du patrimoine ethnologique. Ethnologies Comparées. Available at: http://recherche.univ-montp3.fr/cerce/r8/h.l.htm.

49.

Lévi-Strauss

(1952) Race et histoire [Race and history], Paris: UNESCO.

50.

Lévi-Strauss

(2001 [1971]) Race et culture [Race and culture], Paris: Albin Michel.

51.

Logan

(2007) Closing Pandora’s box: Human rights: Conundrums in cultural heritage protection. In: Silverman

Ruggles

(eds) Cultural Heritage and Human Rights, New York: Springer, pp. 33–52.

52.

Logan

(2012) States, governance and the politics of culture: World Heritage in Asia. In: Daly

Winter

(eds) Routledge Handbook of Heritage in Asia, New York: Routledge, pp. 113–128.

53.

McBryde

(1985) Who Owns the Past? Papers from the Annual Symposium of the Australian Academy of the Humanities, Melbourne and New York: Oxford University Press.

54.

McBryde

(1990) ‘Those Truly Outstanding Examples…’: Kakadu in the context of Australia’s World Heritage properties – A response. In: Domicelji

Domicelj

(eds) A Sense of Place: A Conversation in Three Cultures, Canberra: Australian Heritage Commission, pp. 15–19. 46–52.

55.

McBryde

(1995) Dream the impossible dream? Shared heritage, shared values, or shared understanding of disparate values. Historic Environment 11: 8–14.

56.

McBryde

(1997) The cultural landscapes of aboriginal long distance exchange systems: Can they be confined within our heritage registers? Historic Environment 13: 6–14.

57.

Meskell

(2011) From Paris to Pontdrift: UNESCO meetings, mapungubwe and mining. Journal of South African Archaeology 66: 149–156.

58.

Meskell

(2012) The rush to inscribe: Reflections on the 35th session of the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO Paris, 2011. Journal of Field Archaeology 37: 145–151.

59.

Meskell

(2013) UNESCO’s World Heritage Convention at 40: Challenging the economic and political order of international heritage conservation. Current Anthropology 54: 483–494.

60.

Murray

(2011) Archaeologists and indigenous people: A maturing relationship? Annual Review of Anthropology 40: 363–378.

61.

Nara Conference on Authenticity (1994) The Nara document on authenticity, November 1994. Available at: http://www.icomos.org/charters/nara-e.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

62.

Nicholas

(2008) Native peoples and archaeology. In: Pearsall

(ed.) Encyclopedia of Archaeology, San Diego, CA: Elsevier/Academic Press, pp. 1660–1669.

63.

Nielsen

(2011) UNESCO and the ‘right’ kind of culture: Bureaucratic production and articulation. Critique of Anthropology 31: 273–292.

64.

Palmer

Neaverson

(1998) Industrial Archaeology: Principles and Practice, London and New York: Routledge.

65.

Parent M (1979) Examen comparatif des propositions d’inscription et des critères du patrimoine culturel mondial, CC-79/CONF.003/11 Annexe, 20 September 1979. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1979/cc-79-conf003-11f.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

66.

Parent

(1983) Intervention de M. Michel Parent, Président de l'ICOMOS, lors de la septième session du Bureau du Comité du Patrimoine mondial [Speech of Mr. Michel Parent, president of ICOMOS, at the 7th meeting of the World Heritage Bureau], 27–30 June 1983, unpublished, Paris: ICOMOS Archives, box Réunion critères 1984.

67.

Renoliet

J-J

(1999) L'UNESCO oubliée. La Société des Nations et la coopération intellectuelle [The forgotten UNESCO: the League of Nations and intellectual cooperation] (1919–1946), Paris: Publications de la Sorbonne.

68.

Rothschild

(2008) The archives of universal history. Journal of World History 19: 375–401.

69.

Rudolff

(2010) ‘Intangible’ and ‘Tangible’ Heritage. A Topology of Culture in Contexts of Faith, Bonn: Scientia Bonnensis.

70.

Schmitt

(2009) Global cultural governance: Decision-making concerning World Heritage between politics and science. Erdkunde 63: 103–121.

71.

Schmitt

(2011) Cultural Governance. Zur Kulturgeographie des UNESCO-Welterberegimes, Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag.

72.

Shepard

(2011) Algeria, France, Mexico, UNESCO: A transnational history of anti-racism and decolonization, 1932–1962. Journal of Global History 6: 273–297.

73.

Singh

(2011) United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO): Creating Norms for a Complex World, New York and London: Routledge.

74.

Slatyer

(1984) The origin and development of the World Heritage Convention. Monumentum, Special Issue. 3–16.

75.

Sluga

(2010) UNESCO and the (one) world of Julian Huxley. Journal of World History 21: 393–418.

76.

Smith

(2006) Uses of Heritage, London and New York: Routledge.

77.

Stoczkowski

(2009) UNESCO's doctrine of human diversity: A secular soteriology. Anthropology Today 25: 7–11.

78.

Stott

(2011) The World Heritage Convention and the National Park Service, 1962–1972. The George Wright Forum 28: 279–290.

79.

Sullivan

(2005) Out of the box: Isabel McBryde’s radical contribution to the shaping of Australian archaeological practice. In: Macfarlane

Mountain

M-J

Paton

(eds) Many Exchanges: Archaeology, History, Community and the Work of Isabel McBryde, Canberra: Aboriginal History Incorporated, pp. 83–94.

80.

Tornatore

J-L

(2004) La difficile politisation du patrimoine ethnologique [The difficult politicization of anthropological heritage]. Terrain 42: 149–160.

81.

Tsing

(2000) The global situation. Cultural Anthropology 15: 327–360.

82.

UNESCO (1945) UNESCO constitution, 16 November 1945. Available at: http://portal.unesco.org/en/ev.php-URL_ID=15244&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html (accessed 2 June 2015).

83.

UNESCO (1972) Convention concerning the protection of the world cultural and natural heritage, 23 November 1972. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/en/conventiontext/ (accessed 2 June 2015).

84.

UNESCO (1981) List of reports and studies published by the division of human settlements and socio-cultural environments, sector of social sciences and their applications, SS-81/WS/65, September 1981. Available at: http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0004/000457/045703mo.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

85.

UNESCO (1982a) Mexico City declaration on cultural policies, World Conference on Cultural Policies, Mexico City, 26 July–6 August 1982. Available at: http://portal.unesco.org/culture/en/files/12762/11295421661mexico_en.pdf/mexico_en.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

86.

UNESCO (1982b) Nominations to the World Heritage List and to the List of World Heritage in Danger, CLT-82/CONF.015/3, 15 November 1982. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1982/clt-82-conf015-3e.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

87.

UNESCO (1983) World Heritage Committee, seventh session, December 1983, address by outgoing chairman, Professor Ralph Slatyer, SC/83/CONF.009/8/Annex II. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1983/sc-83-conf009-8e.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

88.

UNESCO (1988a) Item 6 of the provisional agenda: Report of the working group established by the Committee at its eleventh session, SC-88/CONF.001/02, 19 October 1988. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1988/sc-88-conf001-2e.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

89.

UNESCO (1988b) Report of the working group established by the Committee at its eleventh session, CONF 001 VII.12-19, December 1988. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/3656/ (accessed 2 June 2015).

90.

UNESCO (1993) Item 16 of the provisional agenda: Global study, WHC/93/CONF.002/8, 20 October 1993. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/1993/whc-93-conf002-8e.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

91.

UNESCO (1994a) Expert meeting on the ‘Global Strategy’ and thematic studies for a representative World Heritage List, UNESCO Headquarters, 20–22 June 1994, WHC-94/CONF.003/INF.6. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/global94.htm (accessed 2 June 2015).

92.

UNESCO (1994b) Operational guidelines for the implementation of the World Heritage Convention, WHC/2/Revised, February 1994. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/opguide94.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

93.

UNESCO (2015) World Heritage List. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/ (accessed 2 June 2015).

94.

UNESCO Office of the External Auditor (2011) INF.9A: Final report of the audit of the Global Strategy and the PACT initiative, WHC-11/35.COM/INF.9A, 27 May 2011. Available at: http://whc.unesco.org/archive/2011/whc11-35com-INF9Ae.pdf (accessed 2 June 2015).

95.

Watkins

(2005) Through wary eyes: Indigenous perspectives on archaeology. Annual Review of Anthropology 34: 429–449.

96.

Wong

(2008) Relocating East and West: UNESCO's major project on the mutual appreciation of Eastern and Western cultural values. Journal of World History 19: 349–374.