In this article we examine the role of informal settlements inhabited by Europeans, Africans and, potentially, indigenous people in the eighteenth-century insular Caribbean. Rather than simply being frontier settlements established in anticipation of formal colonization, in many cases settlements on and beyond the margins of colonies represent alternative possibilities and facilitate ways of life, modes of production, and means of trade and exchange that are at odds with expected norms of colonial society. We view such settlements as holdouts, practicing what James Scott refers to as the ‘art of not being governed’. To make this argument we compare ethnohistorical data related to settlement patterns in St John and Dominica and archaeological data retrieved from household excavations of plantation settlements dating to the eighteenth century. Examining such settlements allows us to map the range of variation in colonial life during the apogee of plantation-based slavery.
AgorsahEK(2006) The other side of freedom: The Maroon trail in Suriname. In: HaviserJBMacDonaldKC (eds). African Re-genesis: Confronting Social Issues in the Diaspora, New York: University College London Press, pp. 191–203.
2.
ArmstrongDKellyKG (2000) Settlement patterns and the origins of African Jamaican society: Seville Plantation, St. Ann’s Bay, Jamaica. Ethnohistory7(2): 369–397.
3.
BoroméJ (1972) Aspects of Dominica History, Roseau, Dominica: Government Printing Office.
4.
BraudelF (1972) The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II. Vol. 1892/93, New York: Harper & Row.
5.
ByresJ (1776) Plan of the Island of Dominica Laid Down by Actual Survey under the Direction of the Honourable Commissioners for the Sale of Lands in the Ceded Islands, London: S. Hooper.
6.
ByresJ (1777) References to the Plan of the Island of Dominica, as Surveyed from the Year 1765 to 1773, London: S. Hooper.
7.
CoronilF (2001) Review essays: Seeing like a state – smelling like a market. American Historical Review106(1): 119–129.
DietlerM (2010) Archaeologies of Colonialism: Consumption, Entanglement, and Violence in Ancient Mediterranean France, Berkeley: University of California Press.
10.
FergusonJ (2005) In focus: Moral economies, state spaces, and categorical violence: Anthropological engagements with the work of James Scott – seeing like an oil company: Space, security, and global capital in neoliberal Africa. American Anthropologist107(3): 377–382.
11.
FinamoreD(2006) A mariner’s utopia: Pirates and logwood in the Bay of Honduras. In: EwenCR (ed.) X Marks the Spot: The Archaeology of PiracyNew Perspectives on Maritime History and Nautical Archaeology. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, pp. 64–78.
12.
GoucherCAgorsahKE(2011) Excavating the roots of resistance: The significance of Maroons in Jamaican archaeology. In: DelleJAHauserMWArmstrongDV (eds). Out of Many, One People: The Historical Archaeology of Colonial Jamaica, Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, pp. 144–162.
13.
GreeneJP (2000) The American Revolution. American History Cooperative105(1): 93–102.
14.
GreeneJP(2001) South Carolina: An introduction. In: GreeneJPBrana-ShuteRSparksRJ (eds). Money, Trade, and Power: The Evolution of Colonial South Carolina’s Plantation Society, Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, pp. vii–xiii.
15.
HallNAT (1985) The Danish West Indies: Empire without Dominion 1671–1848, United States Virgin Islands: Division of Libraries, Museums and Archaeological Services.
16.
HauserMW (2008) An Archaeology of Black Markets: Local Ceramics and Economies in Eighteenth-century Jamaica, Gainesville: University Press of Florida.
17.
HauserMW (2011) Routes and roots of empire: Pots, power, and slavery in the eighteenth-century British Caribbean. American Anthropologist113(3): 17–17.
18.
HauserMWKellyKG(2011) Colonies without frontiers: Inter-island trade in the eighteenth and nineteenth century Caribbean. In: CuretLAHauserMW (eds). Islands at the Crossroads: Migration, Seafaring, and Interaction in the Caribbean, Tuscaloosa: University of Albama Press.
19.
HerzfeldM (2005) Moral economies, state spaces, and categorical violence: Anthropological engagements with the work of James Scott – Political optics and the occlusion of intimate knowledge. American Anthropologist107(3): 369–376.
20.
HicksD (2007) The Garden of the World: An Historical Archaeology of Sugar Landscapes in the Eastern CaribbeanVol. 3, British Archaeological Reports International Series. London: Archaeopress.
21.
HigmanBW (2000) The sugar revolution. Economic History Review53(2): 213–236.
22.
HigmanBW (2005) Plantation Jamaica, 1750–1850: Capital and Control in a Colonial Economy, Kingston: University of the West Indies Press.
23.
HonychurchL (1995) The Dominica Story: A History of the Island, London: Macmillan Education.
24.
HonychurchL (1997) Crossroads in the Caribbean: A site of encounter and exchange on Dominica. World Archaeology28(3): 291–304.
25.
KellyKG(2011) ‘La Vie Quotidienne’: Historical archaeological approaches to plantation slavery in Guadeloupe, French West Indies. In: KellyKGHardyM (eds). French Colonial Archaeology in the Southeast and Caribbean, Gainesville: University Press of Florida, pp. 189–205.
26.
KellyKGHauserMWDesCantesCGlascockM (2008) Cabotage or contraband: Compositional analysis of French colonial ceramics. Journal of Caribbean Archaeology8: 1–23.
27.
KnightD (1999) A Documentary History of Cinnamon Bay 1718–1917, Compiled for the Cinnamon Bay Archaeological Project. St Thomas, USVI: Virgin Islands Historical and Genealogical Research Center.
28.
KnoxJP (1852) A Historical Account of St. Thomas in the Danish West Indies, New York: Charles Scribner.
29.
LarsenLC (1991) The Danish Colonization of St. John, 1718–1733, St Thomas, USVI: Virgin Islands Resource Management Cooperative.
30.
LenikS (2011) Frontier Landscapes, Missions, and Power: A French Jesuit Plantation and Church at Grand Bay, Dominica (1747–1763), New York: Syracuse University Press.
31.
McBrideJD(2006) Contraband traders, lawless vagabonds, and the British settlement and occupation of Roatan, Bay Islands, Honduras. In: EwenCR (ed.) X Marks the Spot: The Archaeology of PiracyNew Perspectives on Maritime History and Nautical Archaeology. Gainesville: University Press of Florida, pp. 44–63.
32.
ParesR (1936) War and Trade in the West Indies, 1739–1763, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
33.
ParesR (1956) Yankees and Creoles: The Trade between North America and the West Indies before the American Revolution, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
34.
Pérotin-DumonA(1991) Cabotage, contraband, and corsairs: The port cities of Guadeloupe and their inhabitants, 1650–1800. In: KnightFWLissPK (eds). Atlantic Port Cities: Economy, Culture, and Society in the Atlantic World, 1650–1850, Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, pp. 58–86.
35.
PriceR (1976) The Guiana Maroons: A Historical and Bibliographical Introduction, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
36.
PriceRPriceS (2001) Maroons under assault in Suriname and French Guiana. Cultural Survival Quarterly25(4): 38–45.
37.
RosenJ (1995) La faience dans la France du XIVe au XIXe siècle: Histoire et technique, Paris: Éditions Errance.
38.
RosenJ (2009) La Faïence de Nevers, Dijon: Faton.
39.
ScottJC (2009) The Art of not Being Governed: An Anarchist History of Upland Southeast Asia, New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
40.
ShepherdV (2002) Slavery without Sugar: Diversity in Caribbean Economy and Society Since the Seventeenth Century, Gainesville: University Press of Florida.
41.
SouthS (1977) Method and Theory in Historical Archaeology, New York: Academic Press.
42.
TrouillotMR (1988) Peasants and Capital: Dominica in the World Economy, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
43.
WalthallJA (1991a) Faience in French Colonial Illinois. Historical Archaeology25(1): 80–105.
44.
WalthallJA (1991b) French Colonial Archaeology: The Illinois Country and Western Great Lakes, Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
45.
WaselkovGAWalthallJA (2002) Faience styles in French North America: A revised classification. Historical Archaeology36(1): 62–78.
46.
WestergaardWC (1917) The Danish West Indies under Company Rule (1671–1754): With a Supplementary Chapter, 1755–1917, New York: Macmillan.
47.
WolfER (1982) Europe and the People without History, Berkeley: University of California Press.
48.
WoodwardRP(2006) Taino artifacts from post-contact Jamaica. In: AtkinsonLG (ed.) The Earliest Inhabitants: The Dynamics of the Jamaican Taino, Kingston: UWI Press.
49.
WoodwardRP(2011) Feudalism or agrarian capitalism? The archaeology of the early sixteenth-century Spanish sugar industry. In: DelleJAHauserMWArmstrongDV (eds). Out of Many, One People: The Historical Archaeology of Colonial Jamaica, Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, pp. 23–40.
50.
DBOD – Dominica Book of Deeds 1763–1817 (Dominica National Archives, Roseau, Dominica).
