Judge John Jelderks found that Kennewick Man cannot be defined as Native American
under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act. A recent
amicus brief in the legal case regarding repatriation of materials from
Spirit Cave, Nevada, suggests that the Kennewick case should be used as legal
precedent, and that the remains of Spirit Cave Man are also not Native American. We
suggest that a precedent in cases of Paleoindian human remains is inappropriate and
unnecessary. We provide bioarchaeological, human variation, archaeological, social,
and cultural contexts of the Spirit Cave Man remains. These contexts indicate that
this case, and likely all of the few Paleoindian cases, is unique. Determinations of
repatriation of Paleoindians should be handled on a case-by-case basis.
Adovasio, J. M.
(1970)
‘The Origin, Development and Distribution of Western Archaic Textiles’
, Tebiwa13(2):
1-40
.
2.
Adovasio, J. M.
(1974) ‘Prehistoric North American
Basketry’, in
D. R. Tuohy
and
D. L. Rendall
(eds) Collected Papers on Aboriginal Basketry, pp.
98-148. Anthropological Papers 16.
Carson City: Nevada State Museum
.
3.
Adovasio, J. M.
(1977) Basketry Technology: A Guide to Identification and
Analysis.
Chicago, IL: Aldine Publishing Company
.
4.
Adovasio, J. M.
(1986a) ‘Artifacts and Ethnicity: Basketry as an
Indicator of Territoriality and Population Movements in the Prehistoric Great
Basin (with R.L. Andrews)’, in
C. J. Condie
and
D. D. Fowler
(eds) Anthropology of the Desert West: Essays in Honor of Jesse D.
Jennings, pp. 43-89. University of Utah Anthropological
Papers No. 110.
Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
.
5.
Adovasio, J. M.
(1986b) ‘Prehistoric
Basketry’, in
W. L. d’Azevedo
(ed.) and
W. C. Sturtevant
(general ed.) Handbook of North American Indians, Vol. 11, Great
Basin, pp. 194-205.
Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution
.
6.
Adovasio, J. M.
and
D. R. Pedler
(1994) ‘A Tisket, a Tasket: Looking at Numic
Speakers Through the “Lens” of a Basket’,
in
D. B. Madsen
and
D. H. Rhode
(eds) Across the West: Human Population Movement and the Expansion of
the Numa, pp. 114-123.
Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
.
7.
Andrews, R. L.
,
J. M. Adovasio
and
R. C. Carlisle
(1986) Perishable Industries from Dirty Shame Rockshelter,
Malheur County, Oregon. University of Oregon Anthropological Papers 34,
issued jointly as Ethnology Monographs 9.
Pittsburgh, PA: Department of Anthropology,
University of Pittsburgh
.
8.
Associated Press
(2005) ‘Scientists Protest Bill to Change Indian
Graves Law’, (consulted Oct. 2006): http://www.kennewick-man.com/kman/news/story/6378014p-6256277c.html
9.
Barker, P.
,
C. Ellis
and
S. Damadio
(2000) Determination of Cultural Affiliation of Ancient Human
Remains from Spirit Cave, Nevada.
Reno: Bureau of Land Management Nevada State Office
.
10.
Blumenbach, J. F.
(1795/1969) On the Natural Varieties of Mankind,
3rd edn. (trans. T. Bendyshe).
New York: Bergmann
. Originally published by the Anthropological Society of London, 1865.
11.
Brace, C. L.
and
D. P. Tracer
(1998) ‘Craniofacial Continuity and Change: A
Comparison of Late Pleistocene and Recent Europe and Asia’,
in
T. Akazawa
,
K. Akoi
and
T. Kimura
(eds) The Evolution and Dispersal of Modern Humans, pp.
439-471.
Tokyo: Housem-Sha
.
12.
Bradley, B.
and
D. Stanford
(2004)
‘The North Atlantic Ice-edge Corridor: A Possible Paleolithic
Route to the New World’
, World Archaeology36(4):
459-478
.
13.
Buikstra, J. E.
and
D. H. Ubelaker
(1994) Standards for Data Collection from Human Skeletal
Remains.
Fayetteville: Arkansas Archaeological Survey
.
14.
Connolly, T. J.
and
J. P. Barker
(2004) ‘Basketry Chronology of the Early
Holocene in the Northern Great Basin’, in
D. J. Jenkins
,
T. J. Connolly
and
C. M. Aikens
(eds) Early and Middle Holocene Archaeology of the Northern Great Basin,
Oregon, pp. 241-250. University of Oregon
Anthropological Papers 62.
Eugene: University of Oregon
.
15.
Coon, C. S.
(1954) The Story of Man.
New York: Knopf
.
16.
Cressman, L. S.
(1942) Archaeological Researches in the Northern Great
Basin. Carnegie Institution Publication 538.
Washington, DC: Carnegie Institution of Washington
.
17.
Dansie, A.
(1997)
‘Early Holocene Burials in Nevada: Overview of Localities,
Research, and Legal Issues’
, Nevada Historical Quarterly40(1):
4-14
.
18.
D’Errico, P.
(2000) ‘Sovereignty: A Brief History in the
Context of U.S. “Indian Law”’, in
J. D. Schultz
,
K. L. Haynie
,
A. M. McCulloch
and
A. L. Aoki
(eds) The Encyclopedia of Minorities in American Politics, pp.
691-693.
Phoenix, AZ: Oryx Press
, (consulted May 2006): http://www.umass.edu/legal/derrico/sovereignty.html
19.
Dongoske, K.
,
M. Aldenderfer
and
K. Doehner
, eds (2000) Working Together: Native Americans and
Archaeologists.
Washington, DC: Society for American Archaeology
.
20.
Edgar, H. J. H.
(1997)
‘Paleopathology of the Wizard’s Beach Man (AHUR 2023)
and the Spirit Cave Mummy (AHUR 2064)’
, Nevada Historical Quarterly40(1):
57-61
.
21.
Emery, I.
(1995) The Primary Structures of Fabrics: An Illustrated
Classification. Revised 1980.
Washington, DC: The Textile Museum
. Reprinted in Washington, DC: Watson-Guptil Publications, the Whitney
Library of Design, and the Textile Museum.
Fladmark, K. R.
(1983) ‘Times and Places: Environmental
Correlates of Mid-to-Late Wisconsin Human Population Expansion in the
Americas’, in
R. Shutler
(ed.) Early Man in the New World, pp. 13-42.
Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE Publications
.
24.
Fowler, C. S.
(1994) ‘Material Culture and the Proposed Numic
Expansion’, in
D. B. Madsen
and
D. H. Rhode
(eds) Across the West: Human Population Movement and the Expansion of
the Numa, pp. 103-113.
Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
.
25.
Fowler, C. S.
and
L. E. Dawson
(1986) ‘Ethnographic
Basketry’, in
W. L. d’Azevedo
(ed.) and
W. C. Sturtevant
(general ed.) Handbook of North American Indians, Vol. 11, Great
Basin, pp. 705-737.
Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution
.
26.
Fowler, C. S.
,
E. M. Hattori
and
A. J. Dansie
(2000) ‘Ancient Matting from Spirit Cave,
Nevada: Technical Implications’, in
P. B. Drooker
and
L. D. Webster
(eds) Beyond Cloth and Cordage: Archaeological Textile Research in the
Americas, pp. 119-139.
Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
.
27.
Friends of America’s Past
(2005) ‘Brief of Amicus Friends of
America’s Past’, Fallon Paiute-Shoshone Tribe
v. United States Bureau of Land Management, No. CV-N-04-466-LRH [U.S. Dist
Nev. 28 Oct. 2005]).
28.
Goodman, A. H.
(1995) ‘The Problematics of
“Race” in Contemporary Biological
Anthropology’, in
N. T. Boaz
and
L. D. Wolfe
(eds) Biological Anthropology: the State of the Science, pp.
221-243.
Bend, OR: International Institute for Human
Evolutionary Research
.
29.
Goodman, A. H.
(1997)
‘Racializing Kennewick Man’
, Anthropology NewsletterOctober:
3-5
.
30.
Goodman, A. H.
(1998)
‘Archaeology and Human Biological Variation’
, Conference on New England Archaeology Newsletter17:
1-8
.
31.
Hattori, E. M.
(1982) The Archaeology of Falcon Hill, Winnemucca Lake,
Washoe County, Nevada. Nevada State Museum Anthropological Papers No. 18.
Carson City: Nevada State Museum
.
32.
Hattori, E. M.
and
C. S. Fowler
(2005)
‘Early Fiber Technologies and Fiber Research in the Western Great Basin’
, paper presented at the 70th Annual Meeting of the Society for
American Archaeology, Salt Lake City, Utah.
33.
Hedges, K.
(1973) A Rabbitskin Blanket from San Diego County.
Ethnic Technology Notes No. 10.
San Diego, CA: San Diego Museum of Man
.
34.
Heizer, R. F.
and
A. D. Krieger
(1956)
‘The Archaeology of Humboldt Cave, Churchill County, Nevada’
, University of California Publications in American Archaeology and Ethnology47(1).
35.
Heyerdahl, T.
(1950) Kon-Tiki: Across the Pacific by Raft.
New York: Rand McNally
.
36.
Howells, W. W.
(1989) Skull Shapes and the Map. Papers of the Peabody
Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Vol. 82.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
.
37.
Jantz, R. L.
and
D. W. Owsley
(1997)
‘Pathology, Taphonomy, and Cranial Morpho-metrics of the Spirit
Cave Mummy (AHUR 2064)’
, Nevada Historical Society Quarterly40(1):
62-84
.
38.
Jelderks, J.
(2002) ‘Opinion and Order’, Civil
No. 96-1481-JE (consulted May 2004): http://www.friendsofpast.org
39.
Jolie, E.A. (2004) ‘Coiled Basketry from Charlie Brown Cave,
Western Nevada’, unpublished MA thesis, University of Nevada, Reno.
40.
Jones, G. T.
and
C. Beck
(1999) ‘Paleoarchaic Archaeology in the Great
Basin’, in
C. Beck
(ed.) Models for the Millennium: Great Basin Anthropology Today,
pp. 83-95.
Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
.
41.
Kent, K. P.
(1983) Prehistoric Textiles of the Southwest.
Santa Fe, NM: School of American Research Press
.
42.
King A.
(2006)
‘Kennewick Man Was Buried After He Died’
, Tri-City Herald 24 February, (consulted Oct. 2006): http://www.kennewick-man.com/kman/news/story/7476501p-7385959c.html
43.
Kroeber, T.
(1962) Ishi in Two Worlds: A Biography of the Last Wild
Indian in North America.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
44.
Lee, M.
(1998)
‘Bones Likely Deposited by River’
, Tri-City Herald 3 January 1998, (consulted Oct. 2006): http://www.kennewick-man.com/kman/news/story/2883343p-2919352c.html
45.
Loud, L. L.
and
M. R. Harrington
(1929)
‘Lovelock Cave’
, University of California Publications in American Archaeology and Ethnology25(1).
46.
Madsen, D. B.
and
D. Rhode
, eds (1994) Across the West: Human Population Movement and
the Expansion of the Numa.
Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press
.
47.
Mason, O. T.
(1904) ‘Aboriginal American Basketry: Studies in
a Textile Art without Machinery’, Annual Report of the
U.S. National Museum for 1901-1902, pp. 171-548.
Washington, DC: Government Printing Office
.
48.
Morris, E. H.
and
R. F. Burgh
(1941) Anasazi Basketry: Basket Maker II Through Pueblo III:
A Study Based on Specimens from the San Juan River Country. Carnegie
Institution of Washington, Publication 533.
Washington, DC: Carnegie Institution
.
49.
National Park Service
(1978) ‘Indian Land Areas Judicially Established
1978’, (consulted May 2006): http://www.cr.nps.gov/nagpra/documents/judicial.pdf
50.
Neves, W. A.
and
H. M. Pucciarelli
(1991)
‘Morphological Affinities of the First Americans: An Exploratory
Analysis Based on Early South American Human Remains’
, Journal of Human Evolution21:
261-273
.
51.
Owsley, D. W.
and
R. L. Jantz
(2001)
‘Archaeological Politics and Public Interest in Paleoamerican
Studies: Lessons from Gordon Creek Woman and Kennewick Man’
, American Antiquity66:
565-575
.
52.
Owsley, D.
and
R. Jantz
(2002) ‘Kennewick Man - A Kin? Too
Distant’, in
E. Barkan
and
R. Bush
(eds) Claiming the Stones, Naming the Bones: Cultural Property and the
Negotiation of National and Ethnic Identity, pp.
141-161.
Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute
.
53.
Owsley, D. W.
,
H. E. Berryman
,
K. S. Bruwelheide
,
D. Hunt
,
T. W. Stafford
,
C. W. Smith
and
J. C. Chatters
(2006)
‘Kennewick Man: Nowhere Near the Last Word’
, Proceedings from the American Academy of Forensic Sciences Annual Meeting12:
371-371
.
54.
Powell, J. F.
(2005) The First Americans: Race, Evolution and the Origin of
Native Americans.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
55.
Powell, J. F.
and
W. A. Neves
(1999)
‘Craniofacial Morphology of the First Americans: Pattern and
Process in the Peopling of the Americas’
, Yearbook of Physical Anthropology42:
153-188
.
56.
Rose, J. C.
,
T. J. Green
and
V. D. Green
(1996)
‘NAGPRA is Forever: The Future of Osteology and the Repatriation
of Skeletons’
, Annual Review of Anthropology25:
81-103
.
57.
Starn, O.
(2004) Ishi’s Brain: In Search of
America’s Last ‘Wild’ Indian.
New York: W.W. Norton and Company
.
58.
Steele, D. G.
and
J. F. Powell
(2002) ‘Facing the Past: A View of the North
American Human Fossil Record’, in
N. G. Jablonski
(ed.) The First Americans: The Pleistocene Colonization of the New
World, pp. 93-122.
San Francisco
: Memoirs of the California Academy of Sciences, No. 27.
59.
Sutton, M. Q.
(1993)
‘The Numic Expansion in Great Basin Oral Tradition’
, Journal of California and Great Basin Anthropology15(1):
111-128
.
60.
Swidler, N.
,
K. E. Dongoske
,
R. Anyon
and
A. S. Downer
, eds (1997) Native Americans and Archaeologists: Stepping
Stones to Common Ground.
Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press
.
61.
Tuohy, D. R.
and
A. J. Dansie
(1997)
‘New Information Regarding Early Holocene Manifestations in the
Western Great Basin’
, Nevada Historical Society Quarterly40(1):
24-53
.
62.
Watkins, J. E.
(2004)
‘Becoming American or Becoming Indian? NAGPRA, Kennewick and
Cultural Affiliation’
, Journal of Social Archaeology4(1):
60-80
.
63.
Wheeler, S. M.
(1997)
‘Cave Burials Near Fallon, Nevada’
, Nevada Historical Quarterly40(1):
15-23
.
64.
Wheeler, S. M.
and
G. N. Wheeler
(1969) ‘Cave Burials Near Fallon,
Nevada’, in
D. L. Rendall
and
D. R. Tuohy
(eds) Miscellaneous Papers on Nevada Archaeology 1-8, pp.
70-78.
Carson City: Nevada State Museum
Anthropological Papers
.
65.
Wolpoff, M.
and
R. Caspari
(1997) Race and Human Evolution: A Fatal Attraction.
New York: Simon and Schuster
.
