This study explores the history of the Red Gate Student Consumer Cooperative at Tokyo Imperial University, an elite university in Japan, to consider its accomplishment and limitation as redistribution machine. While its elite founders successfully provided commodities inexpensively to its members, its staff were exposed to the potential exploitation for its competitive edge in prices and small-sized shops in the neighborhood were endangered as they could not compete with it. Based on this case study, I seek to explore the social basis for elite consumers’ challenges to the market and the inherent limitation of a market-based institution for economic redistribution.
BourdieuP (1984) Translated by Richard Nice. Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste. Harvard University Press.
2.
Bunbōgurui wa kumiai ga motto mo yasui, nōto, pen wa takai kōnai baiten. (1930, June 30). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
3.
CulverAA (2024) Democratizing Luxury: Name Brands, Advertising, and Consumption in Modern Japan. University of Hawaii Press.
4.
Daiichi shokudō ga futatabi sanshoku zenbu nesage: Asa jūsen, hiru jūgosen, yū nijūsen ni raishun hayabaya kara jisshi. (1930, December 22). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
5.
EndōS (1979) Toshohyōron sōkan no koro. Toshohyōron fukkokuban kankō iinkai (ed) Toshohyōron bessatsu: omoide no shuki, watashitachi no ayunda michi. Kasumigaseki shuppan kabushikigaisha, 3–4.
6.
FranksP (2009) The Japanese Consumers: An Alternative Economic History of Modern Japan. Cambridge University Press.
7.
Gakunai no kaku baiten ga heikin ichiwari wo nesage: kinshuku nesage jidai wo han’eishite jihatsuteki ni mōshidasu. (1930, January 13). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
8.
Gakushō no shinshutsu ni nokinami shoten no nayami: Purinto waribiki mondai ni karande hanmoku yōyaku hyōmenka. (1934, November 12). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
9.
GaronS (2012) Beyond Our Means: Why America Spends while the World Saves. Princeton University Press.
KurimotoA (2017) Building Consumer Democracy: the Trajectory of Consumer Co-operation in Japan. In: HilsonM, et al. (ed) A Global History of Consumer Co-operation since 1850: Movements and Business. Leiden, 668–697.
20.
Kutsugawa mo daiyōhin: Kyōsai Iinkai de Kyoka. (1939, October 2). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
21.
Midorikai no sasshinpa gakuseika e oshikaku nijūyokka totsujo taikai wo hiraite gakubukai no sasshin undō. (1930, May 26). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
22.
Midorikai no zeniin jūninichi totsujo kainin kiru funkyū tuzuku daiichi shokudō jiken. (1931, June 15). Teikoku Daigaku Shinbun.
23.
MinamiH, et al. (1987) (ed)Taishō bunka. Keisō shobō.
YoungL (1999) Marketing the modern: department stores, consumer culture, and the new middle class in modern Japan. International Labor and Working Class History55: 52–70. https://doi.org/10.1017/s014754799900318x
