Working Practices Employed within and across Hospital and Community Service Provision for Adults with an Intellectual Disability and Additional Needs

Abstract

This study documented the perceptions of 98 front-line staff of 42 adult residential and day care facilities regarding the working practices employed within and across 38 community and hospital units, using the Working Method Scale. This scale was designed to measure whether the service units adopted any systematic approaches in their practices with regard to client planning, assessment and staff training. Results indicated that systematic approaches were reported to be employed in terms of how staff planned client care. Inconsistencies were found between service settings regarding the involvement of the client and professional input (i.e. psychology). Furthermore, this study found a distinct shortage of `good' practices in relation to person-centred plans and assessment tools for measuring challenging behaviours and mental health problems. The results highlight that these services are adopting a `minding' model in contrast to an `active support' model. Consequently, this study challenges service providers to ensure that all service units adopt what are considered `good' working practices.

Keywords

challenging behaviours placement breakdown service providers staff perceptions working practices

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ALLEN, D. (1999) `Success and Failure in Community Placements for People with Learning Disabilities and Challenging Behaviours: An Analysis of Key Variables', Journal of Mental Health 8 (3): 307-320.

AMAN, M. G. & SINGH, N. N. (1986) Aberrant Behaviour Checklist Manual. New York: Shossom Publications.

BOURAS, N. (1999) Psychiatric and Behavioural Disorders in Development Disabilities and Mental Retardation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH (1998) Signposts for Success. London: NHS Executive.

EMERSON, E. & HATTON, C. (1994) Moving Out: The Impact of Relocation from Hospital to Community on the Quality of Life of People with Learning Disabilities. London: HMSO.

EMERSON, E. , ROBERTSON, J. , GREGORY, N. ET AL. (1999) A Comparative Analysis of Quality and Costs in Village Communities, Residential Campuses and Dispersed Housing Schemes. Manchester: Hester Adrian Centre.

FELCE, D. (1996) `Changing Residential Services: From Institutions to Ordinary Living', in P. MILTER & V. SINASON (eds) Changing Policy and Practice for People with Learning Disabilities, Chapter 11. London: Cassell.

FELCE, D. & PERRY, J. (1995) `The Extent of Support for Ordinary Living Provided in Staffed Housing: The Relationship between Staffing Levels, Resident Dependency, Staff-Resident Interactions and Resident Activity Patterns', Social Science and Medicine 40 (6): 799-810.

HATTON, C. , EMERSON, E. , RIVERS, M. ET AL. (1999) `Factors Associated with Staff Stress and Work Satisfaction in Services for People with Intellectual Disability', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 43 (4): 253-267.

10.

JONES, E. , PERRY, J. , LOWE, K. ET AL. (1999) `Opportunity and the Promotion of Activity among Adults with Severe Intellectual Disability Living in Community Residences: The Impact of Training Staff in Active Support', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research 43: 164-178.

11.

LOWE, K. & DE PAVIA, S. (1991) `Clients' Community and Social Contacts: Results of a Five Year Longitudinal Study', Journal of Mental Deficiency Research 35: 308-323.

12.

LOWE, C. , FELCE, D. , PERRY, J. , BAXTER, H. ET AL. (1997) Changing Behaviour: Residential Situations, Service Processes, Costs and Outcomes. Wales: University of Wales College of Medicine.

13.

MANSELL, J. , MCGILL, P. & EMERSON, E. (1994) `Conceptualising Service Provision', in E. EMERSON , P. MCGILL & J. MANSELL Severe Learning Disabilities and Challenging Behaviour, Designing High Quality Services. London: Chapman & Hall.

14.

MORGAN, C. L. , ZAHIR, A. & KERR, M. P. (2000) `Health Care Provision for People with a Learning Disability', British Journal of Psychiatry 176: 37-41.

15.

O'BRIEN, J. (1987) `A Guide to Lifestyle Planning: Using the Activities Catalogue to Integrate Services and Natural Support Systems', in B. WILCOX & G. T. BELLAMY (eds) Comprehensive Guide to the Activity Catalogue: An Alternative Curriculum for Youth and Adults with Severe Disabilities. Baltimore, MD: Brookes.

16.

PSYCHOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF IRELAND (1998) Responding to Behaviour that Challenges: A Policy Document of the Psychological Society of Ireland Prepared by the Learning Disability Group. Dublin: PSI.

17.

ROPER, N. , LOGAN, W. W. & TEIRNEY, A. (1986) Elements of Nursing. London: Churchill Livingstone.

18.

ROYAL COLLEGE OF PSYCHIATRISTS (1999) Meeting the Mental Health Needs of People with Learning Disability: Council Report. London: Royal College of Psychiatrists.

19.

SANDERSON, H. & SMULL, M. (2001) Implementing Essential Lifestyle Planning: Training Programme. Manchester: Northwest Training and Development Team.

20.

SCHOPLER, E. (1986) `A New Approach to Autism', Social Science 71 (2-3): 183-185.

21.

WHITWORTH, D. , HARRIS, P. & JONES, J. (1999) `Staff Culture and the Management of Challenging Behaviours in People with Learning Disabilities', Mental Health Care 2 (11): 376-378.