Tourism commercialisation and the frontstage-backstage metaphor in intangible cultural heritage tourism

Abstract

Resolving tensions between tourism commercialisation and intangible cultural heritage (ICH) safeguarding is an important objective. Using the frontstage-backstage metaphor as an analytical lens, we investigate how tourism promotes ICH safeguarding and how detrimental aspects of tourism commercialisation can be handled in Miao silverware tourism in Fenghuang, China. Results show that tourism commercialisation is beneficial because it provides new possibilities and promotes the transformation of ICH. However, fake ICH products are detrimental, prioritising commercial value over ICH value. ICH inheritors create two separate commercial spaces to handle the segmented tourism market. The frontstage-backstage metaphor helps to investigate the transformational process of ICH in tourism and socio-psychological dilemmas of cultural practitioners in dealing with the multiplying realities of ICH.

Keywords

China frontstage-backstage ICH value intangible cultural heritage tourism commercialisation value

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

P. M.

Varga

(2007) ‘Complexity: The Co-evolution of Epistemology, Axiology and Ontology’, Nonlinear Dynamics, Psychology, and Life Sciences 11(1): 19–50.

Avrami

Mason

(2019) ‘Mapping the Issue of Values’, pp. 9–33 in Avrami

Macdonald

Mason

Myers

(eds) Values in Heritage Management: Emerging Approaches and Research Directions. Los Angles: The Getty Conservation Institute.

Bortolotto

Ubertazzi

(2018) ‘Editorial: Foodways as Intangible Cultural Heritage’, International Journal of Cultural Property 25(4): 409–18.

Broude

(2018) ‘Mapping the Potential Interactions Between UNESCO’s Intangible Cultural Heritage Regime and World Trade Law’, International Journal of Cultural Property 25(4): 419–48.

Campbell

Greenwood

Prior

, et al. (2020) ‘Purposive Sampling: Complex or Simple? Research Case Examples’, Journal of Research in Nursing 25(8): 652–61.

Chronis

(2006) ‘Heritage of the Senses: Collective Remembering as an Embodied Praxis’, Tourist Studies 6(3): 267–96.

Chronis

(2012) ‘Tourists as Story-Builders: Narrative Construction at a Heritage Museum’, Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing 29(5): 444–59.

Daugstad

Kirchengast

(2013) ‘Authenticity and the Pseudo-backstage of Agri-tourism’, Annals of Tourism Research 43: 170–91.

De La Torre

Mason

(2002) Assessing the Values of Cultural Heritage. Los Angeles, CA: The Getty Conservation Institute.

10.

Edelheim

Joppe

Flaherty

(2022) Teaching Tourism: Innovative, Values-based Learning Experiences for Transformative Practices. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

11.

Everett

(2012) ‘Production Places or Consumption Spaces? The Place-making Agency of Food Tourism in Ireland and Scotland’, Tourism Geographies 14(4): 535–54.

12.

Francis-Lindsay

(2009) ‘The Intrinsic Value of Cultural Heritage and its Relationship to Sustainable Tourism Development: The Contrasting Experiences of Jamaica and Japan’, Caribbean Quarterly 55(2): 151–68.

13.

Kim

Zhou

(2015) ‘Staging the “Authenticity” of Intangible Heritage from the Production Perspective: The Case of Craftsmanship Museum Cluster in Hangzhou, China’, Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change 13: 285–300.

14.

Ghanem

M. M.

Saad

S. K.

(2015) ‘Enhancing Sustainable Heritage Tourism in Egypt: Challenges and Framework of Action’, Journal of Heritage Tourism 10(4): 357–77.

15.

Goffman

(1959) The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York, NY: Anchor Books.

16.

Gong

(2011) ‘An Old Town in Recession: A Case Study of the Cultural Circle of the Old Lijiang City’, Journal of Guizhou University for Nationalities (Philosophy and Social Science) (3): 159–63.

17.

Halewood

Hannam

(2001) ‘Viking Heritage Tourism: Authenticity and Commodification’, Annals of Tourism Research 28(3): 565–80.

18.

Hartman

R. S.

(2019) Five Lectures on Formal Axiology. Salt Lake City: Izzard Ink.

19.

Kim

Whitford

Arcodia

(2019) ‘Development of Intangible Cultural Heritage as a Sustainable Tourism Resource: The Intangible Cultural Heritage Practitioners’ Perspectives’, Journal of Heritage Tourism 14(5–6): 422–35.

20.

Logan

(2012) ‘Cultural Diversity, Cultural Heritage and Human Rights: Towards Heritage Management as Human Rights-based Cultural Practice’, International Journal of Heritage Studies 18(3): 231–44.

21.

Luo

(2021) ‘Safeguarding Intangible Heritage Through Edutainment in China’s Creative Urban Environments’, International Journal of Heritage Studies 27(2): 170–85.

22.

Maags

(2021) ‘Common, Luxury, and Fake Commodities: Intangible Cultural Heritage Markets in China’, China Perspectives 3: 7–17.

23.

MacCannell

(1976) The Tourist: A New Theory of the Leisure Class. London: University of California Press.

24.

Nute

(2019) ‘Toward a Test of Cultural Misappropriation’, International Journal of Critical Cultural Studies 17(2): 67–82.

25.

Pardo Abad

C. J.

(2016) ‘The Post-industrial Landscapes of Riotinto and Almadén, Spain: Scenic Value, Heritage and Sustainable Tourism’, Journal of Heritage Tourism 12(4): 331–46.

26.

Poulios

(2014) ‘Discussing Strategy in Heritage Conservation: Living Heritage Approach as an Example of Strategic Innovation’, Journal of Cultural Heritage Management and Sustainable Development 4(1): 16–34.

27.

Richards

Munsters

(2010) Cultural Tourism Research Methods. Oxfordshire: CAB International.

28.

Schäfer

(2015) ‘From Geisha Girls to the Atomic Bomb Dome: Dark Tourism and the Formation of Hiroshima Memory’, Tourist Studies 16(4): 351–66.

29.

Schein

(2000) Minority Rules: The Miao and the Feminine in China’s Cultural Politics. London: Duke University Press.

30.

Shi

(1995) ‘Five Migrations in the History of Miao People’, Journal Guizhou Ethnic Studies 61(1): 120–8.

31.

Smith

Akagawa

(2009) Intangible Heritage. London: Routledge.

32.

Smith

Campbell

(2018) ‘The Tautology of “Intangible Values” and the Misrecognition of Intangible Cultural Heritage’, Heritage & Society 10(1): 26–44.

33.

State Council of China (2005) ‘Opinions of the General Office of the State Council on Strengthening the Protective Work of China’s Intangible Cultural Heritage’, The State Council of People’s Republic of China. Available at: https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2005/content_63227.htm

34.

(2018a) ‘Conceptualising the Subjective Authenticity of Intangible Cultural Heritage’, International Journal of Heritage Studies 24(9): 919–937.

35.

(2019) ‘Understanding the Changing Intangible Cultural Heritage in Tourism Commodification: The Music Players’ Perspective from Lijiang, China’, Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change 17(3): 247–68.

36.

M. M.

Dong

Wall

, et al. (2020) ‘A Value-based Analysis of the Tourism Use of Agricultural Heritage Systems: Duotian Agrosystem, Jiangsu Province, China’, Journal of Sustainable Tourism 28(12): 2136–55.

37.

(2018b) ‘Reconstructing Tradition: Heritage Authentication and Tourism-related Commodification of the Ancient City of Pingyao’, Sustainability (Switzerland) 10(3): 670.

38.

Timm Knudsen

. (2011) ‘Thanatourism: Witnessing Difficult Pasts’, Tourist Studies 11(1): 55–72.

39.

Ubertazzi

(2023) ‘Intellectual Property, and Ethics’, pp. 89-105 in Bortolotto

Skounti

(eds) Intangible Cultural Heritage and Sustainable Development: Inside a UNESCO Convention. London: Routledge.

40.

UNESCO (2003) ‘Convention for the Safeguarding of the Intangible Cultural Heritage’. Available at: https://ich.unesco.org/doc/src/01852-EN.pdf (accessed 2 April).

41.

Walby

Piché

(2015) ‘Staged Authenticity in Penal History Sites across Canada’, Tourist Studies 15(3): 231–47.

42.

Walter

(2017) ‘Culinary Tourism as Living History: Staging, Tourist Performance and Perceptions of Authenticity in a Thai Cooking School’, Journal of Heritage Tourism 12(4): 365–79.

43.

Wang

Xiang

(2021) ‘Research on Space Production of Real-scene Performing Art: A Case Study on “The Peach Colony”’, Scientia Geographica Sinica 41(2): 310–18.

44.

Wang

(2020) Sustainment and Changes of Ethnicity Under the Background of Modernization: Research on the Miao’s Culture Changes in Fenghuang. Kunming: Yunnan University.

45.

Wang

(2012) ‘Research on the Great Wall Culture from the Perspective of Ethnocultural Geography’, Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities 10: 22–7.

46.

World Heritage Committee (2002) ‘Budapest Declaration on World Heritage’. Available at: https://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/1217/ (accessed 3rd April).

47.

Xie

(2019) ‘The Misuse of the Theory of “Stage Authenticity” in the Ethnic Tourism Culture Protection: Rethinking on the Development Model of “Front Stage, Curtain and Backstage”’, Social Sciences in Yunnan 4: 96–104+186.

48.

Yan

Zhu

(2013) ‘Commodification of Chinese Heritage Villages’, Annals of Tourism Research 40(1): 415–19.

49.

Yang

Hou

(2022) National Intangible Cultural Heritage in Fenghuang County, Xiangxi, China: Miao Silverware Forging Skills. Fenghuang: Fenghuang County’s Bureau of Culture and Tourism.

50.

Yang

(2006) ‘The Front Stage, Curtain and Back Stage: An Exploration of Ethnic Culture Conservation and Tourism Development’, Ethno-National Studies 48(2): 39–46+108.

51.

Zhang

Yang

(2015) ‘Application of “Front and Back Stages” Theory on Conservation of Traditional Villages and Towns in China’, South Architecture 3: 65–70.

52.

Zhang

(2010) ‘The Chinese Writing of Miao Nationality’s Identity in Western Guizhou and Ethnic Identity in Modern China’, Journal of Southwest University of Nationalities (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition) 3: 1–11.

53.

Zhou

(2019) Evolution of Miao Nationality Silver Ornaments Cultural Function in Tourism Context: Taking Debang Village in Fenghuang County as an Example. Jishou: Jishou University.

54.

Zhu

(2018) ‘Uses of the Past: Negotiating Heritage in Xi’an’, International Journal of Heritage Studies 24(2): 181–92.

55.

Zhu

Maags

(2020) Heritage Politics in China: The Power of the Past. London: Routledge.