This article proposes a (critical) realist agenda for tourist studies, centred around
the question, ‘What makes tourism possible?’. In asserting
realism as the philosophy of social science most likely to advance tourism theory,
it offers a critique of prevailing epistemologies, notably positivism and
constructivism (and critical theory), with a view to provoking engagement by the
tourism research community with ontological and epistemological arguments, which we
would contend is the hallmark of a mature subject area that is not derivative of
disciplines. In the furtherance of this cause a critical assessment is made of the
ontological, epistemological and methodological assumptions underpinning an idea or
assemblage of ideas within tourist studies that might be construed as
‘orthodox’, here represented by the tourist-area life cycle and
subsequent applications, and also of radical reactions to that orthodoxy. We follow
this with a case study of seaside resort decline (Rhyl, North Wales), which
demonstrates how a realist philosophy of social science may permit a more
satisfactory understanding of, in this instance, tourism destination development
than that afforded by actualism or non-realism.
Ackroyd, S.
and
S. Fleetwood
(2000) ‘Realism in Contemporary Organisation and
Management Studies’, pp. 3–25
in
S.Ackroyd
and
S. Fleetwood
(eds) Realist Perspectives on Management and Organisations.
London: Routledge
.
2.
Agarwal, S.
(1997a)
‘The Resort Cycle and Seaside Tourism:An Assessment of Its
Applicability and Validity’
, Tourism Management18(2):
65–73
.
3.
Agarwal, S.
(1997b) ‘The Public Sector: Planning for
Renewal?’, pp. 137–158 in
G. Shaw
and
A. M.Williams
(eds) The Rise and Fall of British Coastal Resorts.
London: Pinter
.
4.
Archer, M.
(1995) Realist Social Theory:The Morphogenic Approach.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
5.
Barker, C.
(2000) Cultural Studies:Theory and Practice.
London: SAGE Publications
.
6.
Baum, T.
(1998)
‘Taking the Exit Route: Extending the Tourism Area Life Cycle Model’
, Current Issues in Tourism1:
167–175
.
7.
Bauman, Z.
(1987) Legislators and Interpreters.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
8.
Bhaskar, R.
(1978) A Realist Theory of Science.
Brighton: Harvester
.
9.
Bhaskar, R.
(1979) The Possibility of Naturalism.
Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf
.
10.
Bhaskar, R.
and
A. Callinicos
(2000)
‘Marxism and Critical Realism:A Debate’
, Journal of Critical Realism1(2):
89–114
.
11.
Botterill, D.
(2001)
‘The Epistemology of a Set of Tourism Studies’
, Leisure Studies20:
199–214
.
12.
Botterill, D.
(2003)
‘An Autoethnographic Narrative on Tourism Research Epistemologies’
, Society and Leisure26(1):
97–110
.
13.
Botterill, D.
and
T. Gale
(2005) ‘Postgraduate and Ph.D.
Education’, in
D.Airey
and
J. Tribe
(eds) An International Handbook of Tourism Education.
Oxford: Elsevier
.
14.
Botterill, D.
and
M. Klemm
(2006)
‘Introduction:Tourism and Social Inclusion’
, Tourism, Culture and Communication6(1):
1–5
.
15.
Botterill, D.
,
C. Haven
and
T. Gale
(2002)
‘A Survey of Doctoral Theses Accepted by Universities in the UK
and Ireland for Studies of Tourism, 1990–1999’
, Tourist Studies2(3):
283–311
.
16.
Burns, D.
and
L. Murphy
(1998) ‘An Analysis of the Promotion of Marine
Tourism in Queensland, Australia’, pp.
415–430 in
E. Laws
,
B. Faulkner
and
G. Moscardo
(eds) Embracing and Managing Change in Tourism: International Case
Studies.
London: Routledge
.
17.
Butler, R.W.
(1980)
‘The Concept of a Tourism Area Cycle of Evolution: Implications
for Resources’
, Canadian Geographer24(1):
5–12
.
18.
Butler, R.W.
(1994) ‘Introduction’, pp.
1–11 in
R.W. Butler
and
D. Pearce
(eds) Change in Tourism: People, Places, Processes.
London: Routledge
.
19.
Butler, R.W.
(2004) ‘The Tourism Area Life Cycle in the
Twenty first Century’, pp.
159–169 in
A.A. Lew
,
C. M. Hall
and
A. M.Williams
(eds) A Companion to Tourism.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
20.
Butler, R.W.
(2005a) The TALC:Applications and Modifications.
Clevedon: Channel View
.
21.
Butler, R.W.
(2005b) The TALC: Conceptual and Theoretical Issues.
Clevedon: Channel View
.
22.
Byrne, D.
(1998) Complexity Theory and the Social Sciences.
London: Routledge
.
23.
Carter, B.
and
C. New
(2004) ‘Introduction: Realist Social Theory and
Empirical Research’, pp. 1–20
in
B. Carter
and
C. New
(eds) Making Realism Work: Realist Social Theory and Empirical
Research.
London: Routledge
.
24.
Christaller, W.
(1963)
‘Some Considerations of Tourism Location in Europe:The Peripheral
Regions – Underdeveloped Countries – Recreation Areas’
, Regional Science Association Papers12:
95–105
.
25.
Cohen, E.
(1972)
‘Toward a Sociology of International Tourism’
, Social Research39(1):
164–182
.
26.
Cohen, E.
(1979)
‘Rethinking the Sociology of Tourism’
, Annals of Tourism Research6(1):
18–35
.
27.
Collier, A.
(1994) Critical Realism:An Introduction to Roy
Bhaskar's Philosophy.
London: Verso
.
28.
Collier, A.
(1998) ‘Critical Realism’, in
E. Craig
(ed.) Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
London: Routledge
.Available at: http:www.rep.routledge.com/article/R003
29.
Cooke, P.
(1987)
‘The Changing Urban and Regional Systems in the UK’
, Regional Studies20:
243–251
.
30.
Cooper, C.
(2003) ‘Progress in Tourism
Research’, pp. 1–8 in
C. Cooper
(ed.) Classic Reviews in Tourism.
Clevedon: Channel View
.
31.
Delanty, G.
(1997) Social Science: Beyond Constructivism and
Realism.
Buckingham: Open University Press
.
32.
Doxey, G.V.
(1976)
‘When Enough's Enough:The Natives are Restless in Old Niagara’
, Heritage Canada2:
26–27
.
33.
Fleetwood, S.
and
S.Ackroyd
(eds) (2004) Critical Realist Applications in Organization
and Management Studies.
London: Routledge
.
34.
Gale, T. (2001) Late Twentieth Century Cultural Change and the Decline and
Attempted Rejuvenation of the British Seaside Resort as a Long Holiday Destination:A
Case Study of Rhyl, North Wales. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Wales.
35.
Gale, T.
(2005)
‘Modernism, Postmodernism and the Decline of British Seaside
Resorts as Long Holiday Destinations:A Case Study of Rhyl, North Wales’
, Tourism Geographies7(1):
86–112
.
36.
Gale, T. (forthcoming) ‘Urban Beaches, Cyber-worlds and
“the End of Tourism”’, Mobilities.
37.
Giddens, A.
(1984) The Constitution of Society.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
38.
Gonçalves, V. F. da C.
and
P. M. R.Aguas
(1997)
‘The Concept of Life Cycle:An Application to the Tourist Product’
, Journal of Travel Research36(2):
12–22
.
39.
Gordon, I.
and
B. Goodall
(1992)
‘Resort Cycles and Development Processes’
, Built Environment18(1):
41–56
.
40.
Gordon, I.
and
B. Goodall
(2000)
‘Localities and Tourism’
, Tourism Geographies2(3):
290–311
.
41.
Gormsen, E.
(1997)
‘The Impact of Tourism on Coastal Areas’
, Geo Journal42(1):
39–54
.
42.
Gregory, D.
(1982)
‘A Realist Construction of the Social’
, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers7:
254–256
.
43.
Gregory, D.
(1986) ‘Realism’, pp.
387–390 in
R. J. Johnston
,
D. Gregory
and
D. M. Smith
(eds) The Dictionary of Human Geography.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
44.
Guba, E.
(ed.) (1990) The Paradigm Dialogue.
Newbury Park, CA: SAGE Publications
.
45.
Guba, E. G.
and
Y. S. Lincoln
(1981) Effective Evaluation: Improving the Usefulness of
Evaluative Results Through Responsive and Naturalistic Approaches.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
46.
Holliday, A.
(2002) Doing and Writing Qualitative Research.
London: SAGE Publications
.
47.
Hollinshead, K.
(2004) ‘A Primer in Ontological
Craft’, pp. 63–82 in
J. Phillimore
and
L. Goodson
(eds) Qualitative Research in Tourism.
London: Routledge
.
48.
Howie, F.
(2003) Managing the Tourist Destination.
London: Continuum
.
49.
Ioannides, D.
and
K. Debbage
(1997)
‘Post-Fordism and Flexibility:The Travel Industry Polyglot’
, Tourism Management18(4):
229–241
.
50.
Jamal, T. B.
and
J. Everett
(2004)
‘Resisting Rationalisation in the Natural and Academic
Life-world: Critical Tourism Research or Hermeneutic Charity?’
, Current Issues in Tourism7(1):
1–19
.
51.
Johnston, C. S.
(2001)
‘Shoring the Foundations of the Destination Life Cycle Model,
Part 1: Ontological and Epistemological Considerations’
, Tourism Geographies3(1):
2–28
.
52.
Kuhn, T.
(1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
53.
Laclau, E.
and
R. Bhaskar
(1998)
‘Discourse Theory vs Critical Realism’
, Alethia1(2):
9–14
.
54.
Lawson, A.
(1997)Economics and Reality.
London: Routledge
.
55.
Leiper, N.
(2004) Tourism Management.
Frenchs Forest: Pearson Education Australia
.
56.
Miossec, J. M.
(1976)
‘Un Modéle de l'Espace Touristique’
, L'Espace Géographique6(1):
41–48
.
57.
Moss, S. E.
,
C. Ryan
and
C. B.Wagoner
(2003)
‘An Empirical Test of Butler's Resort Product Life
Cycle: Forecasting Casino Winnings’
, Journal of Travel Research41(4):
393–399
.
58.
Oppermann, M.
(1998)
‘What Is New With the Resort Cycle?’
, Tourism Management19(2):
179–180
.
59.
Plog, S. C.
(1974)
‘Why Destination Areas Rise and Fall in Popularity’
, Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly14(4):
55–58
.
60.
Phillimore, J.
and
L. Goodson
(eds) (2004) Qualitative Research in Tourism: Ontologies,
Epistemologies and Methodologies.
London: Routledge
.
61.
Rojek, C.
(1995) Decentring Leisure.
London: SAGE Publications
.
62.
Rojek, C.
(1997) ‘Indexing, Dragging and the Social
Construction of Tourist Sights’, pp.
52–74 in
C. Rojek
and
J. Urry
(eds) Touring Cultures: Modern Transformations in Leisure and
Travel.
London: Routledge
.
63.
Russell, R.
and
B. Faulkner
(2004)
‘Entrepreneurship, Chaos and the Tourism Area Lifecycle’
, Annals of Tourism Research31(3):
556–579
.
Sayer, A.
(2001)
‘Reply to Holmwood’
, Sociology35(4):
967–984
.
66.
Sayer, A.
(2004a) Realism and Social Science.
London: SAGE Publications
.
67.
Sayer, A.
(2004b) ‘Why Critical
Realism?’, pp. 6–20 in
S. Fleetwood
and
S.Ackroyd
(eds) Critical Realist Applications in Organisation and Management
Studies.
London: Routledge
.
68.
Sheller, M.
and
J. Urry
(eds) (2004) Tourism Mobilities: Places to Stay, Places in
Play.
London: Routledge
.
69.
Smith, R.A.
(1991)
‘Beach Resorts:A Model of Development Evolution’
, Landscape and Urban Planning21(3):
189–210
.
70.
Smith, V. L.
(ed.) (1977) Hosts and Guests:The Anthropology of
Tourism.
Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania
.
71.
Stockmann, N.
(1983) Antipositivistic Theories of the Sciences: Critical
Rationalism, Critical Theory and Scientific Realism.
Dordrecht: Reidel
.
72.
Tribe, J.
(2001)
‘Research Paradigms and the Tourism Curriculum’
, Journal of Travel Research39:
442–448
.
73.
Tribe, J.
(2004) ‘Knowing About Tourism: Epistemological
Issues’, pp. 46–62 in
J. Phillimore
and
L. Goodson
(eds) Qualitative Research in Tourism: Ontologies, Epistemologies and
Methodologies.
London: Routledge
.
74.
Urry, J.
(2002) The Tourist Gaze.
London: SAGE Publications
.
75.
Wang, N.
(2000) Tourism and Modernity:A Sociological Analysis.
Amsterdam: Pergamon
.
76.
Weaver, D.
(2000)
‘A Broad Context Model of Destination Development Scenarios’
, Tourism Management21(3):
217–224
.
77.
Williams, A. M.
and
G. Shaw
(1997) ‘Riding the Big Dipper:The Rise and
Decline of the British Seaside Resort in the Twentieth
Century’, pp. 1–18 in
G. Shaw
and
A. M.Williams
(eds) The Rise and Fall of British Coastal Resorts.
London: Pinter
.
