Samuel Huntington's ‘clash of civilizations’ argument that in the future most conflicts will be between civilizations has been the source of considerable debate within international relations. Among the criticisms of this argument is the fact that there is a considerable overlap between Huntington's concept of civilizations and religion. In fact, only one of Huntington's eight civilizations has no obvious religious component. This raises the question of whether the concept of civilizations is really a surrogate for religion. Accordingly, this study examines the influence of both religion and Huntington's concept of civilizations on ethnic conflict using data from the Minorities at Risk Phase 3 dataset as well as data on religion and civilizations collected independently. The results show that while there is considerable overlap between religion and civilization, the two are not the same. Also, while it is not clear whether religious or civilizational differences have a greater impact on ethnic conflict, it is clear that neither are they its primary cause. These results cast serious doubt on the validity of Huntington's hypothesis, at least as far as it concerns ethnic conflict.
Almond, Gabriel (1960) ‘Introduction: A Functional Approach to Comparative Politics’, in Gabriel Almond and James C. Coleman (eds) The Politics of the Developing Areas. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
2.
Apter, David (1965) The Politics of Modernization. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
3.
Auvinen, Juha (1997) ‘Political Conflict in Less Developed Countries 1981–89’, Journal of Peace Research34(2): 177–195.
4.
Beckford, James A. (1985) ‘The Insulation and Isolation of the Sociology of Religion’, Sociological Analysis46(4): 347–354.
5.
Beedham, Brian (1999) ‘The New Geopolitics: A Fading Hell’, The Economist31July: s10–s12.
6.
Brecher, Michael and Jonathan Wilkenfeld (1997) ‘The Ethnic Dimension of International Crisis’, in David Carment and Patrick James (eds) Wars in the Midst of Peace, pp. 164–193. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
7.
Carment, David and Patrick James, eds (1997) Wars in the Midst of Peace. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
8.
Cohen, Asher and Bernard Susser (2000) Israel and the Politics of Jewish Identity: Secular-Religious Impasse. Baltimore, MA: Johns Hopkins University Press.
9.
Cox, Harvey (1965) The Secular City. London: SCM Press.
10.
Davis, David R., Keith Jaggers and Will H. Moore (1997) ‘Ethnicity, Minorities, and International Conflict’, in David Carment and Patrick James (eds) Wars in the Midst of Peace, pp. 148–163. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
11.
Davis, David R. and Will H. Moore (1997) ‘Ethnicity Matters: Transnational Ethnic Alliances and Foreign Policy Behavior’, International Studies Quarterly(March) 41(1): 171–184.
12.
Deutsch, Karl W. (1953) Nationalism and Social Communication. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
13.
Deutsch, Karl W. (1981) ‘On Nationalism, World Regions, and the Nature of the West’, in Per Torsvik (ed.) Mobilization, Center-Periphery Structures, and Nation Building, pp. 51–93. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget,
14.
Don-Yehiyah, Eliezer (1999) Religion and Political Accommodation in Israel. Jerusalem: Floersheimer Institute.
15.
Durham, W. Cole, Jr (1996) ‘Perspectives on Religious Liberty: A Comparative Framework’, in John D. van der Vyver and John Witte Jr (eds) Religious Human Rights in Global Perspective: Legal Perspectives, pp. 1–44. Boston, MA: Martinus Njhoff.
16.
Ellingsen, Tanja and Nils Petter Gleditsch (1997) ‘Democracy and Armed Conflict in the Third World’, in Ketil Volden and Dan Smith (eds) Causes of Conflict in Third World Countries, pp. 69–81. Oslo: North-South Coalition & International Peace Research Institute (PRIO).
17.
Esposito, John L. (1998) ‘Religion and Global Affairs: Political Challenges’, SAIS Review, Summer–Fall: 19–24.
18.
Fearon, James D. and David D. Latin (1997) ‘A Cross-Sectional Study of Large-Scale Ethnic Violence in the Postwar Period’, unpublished paper, Department of Political Science, University of Chicago.
19.
Fox, Jonathan (1997) ‘The Salience of Religious Issues in Ethnic Conflicts: A Large-N Study’, Nationalism and Ethnic Politics3(3): 1–19.
20.
Fox, Jonathan (1998) ‘The Effects of Religion on Domestic Conflict’, Terrorism and Political Violence10(4): 43–63.
21.
Fox, Jonathan (1999a) ‘Do Religious Institutions Support Violence or the Status Quo?’, Studies in Conflict and Terrorism22(2): 119–140
22.
Fox, Jonathan (1999b) ‘The Influence of Religious Legitimacy on Grievance Formation by Ethnoreligious Minorities’, Journal of Peace Research36(3): 289–307.
23.
Fox, Jonathan (1999c) ‘Toward a Comprehensive, Dynamic, and Testable Empirical Theory of Ethnoreligious Conflict’, Nations and Nationalism5(4): 431–463.
24.
Fox, Jonathan (2000a) ‘Is Islam More Conflict Prone than Other Religions? A Cross-Sectional Study of Ethnoreligious Conflict’, Nationalism and Ethnic Politics6(2): 1–23.
25.
Fox, Jonathan (2000b) ‘Religious Causes of Ethnic Discrimination’, International Studies Quarterly44(3): 423–450.
26.
Fox, Jonathan (2000c) ‘The Ethnic–Religious Nexus: The Impact of Religion on Ethnic Conflict’, Civil Wars3(3): 1–22.
27.
Fox, Jonathan (2001a) ‘Civilizational, Religious, and National Explanations for Ethnic Rebellion in the Post-Cold War Middle East’, Jewish Political Studies Review13(1–2).
28.
Fox, Jonathan (2001b) ‘Islam and the West: The Influence of Two Civilizations on Ethnic Conflict’, Journal of Peace Research38(4): 459–472.
29.
Greely, Andrew M. (1982) Religion: A Secular Theory. New York: Free Press.
30.
Gregg, Donald P. (1997) ‘A Case for Continued US Engagement’, Orbis41(3): 375–384.
31.
Gungwu, Wang (1997) ‘Learn from the Past’, Far Eastern Economic Review160(18):37–38.
32.
Gurr, Ted R. (1993a) Minorities At Risk. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace.
33.
Gurr, Ted R. (1993b) ‘Why Minorities Rebel’, International Political Science Review14(2): 161–201.
34.
Gurr, Ted R. (1994) ‘Peoples Against the State: Ethnopolitical Conflict and the Changing World System’, International Studies Quarterly38(3): 347–377.
35.
Gurr, Ted R. (2000) Peoples Versus States: Minorities at Risk in the New Century. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace.
36.
Gurr, Ted R. and Barbara Harff (1994) Ethnic Conflict in World Politics. Boulder, CO: Westview.
37.
Gurr, Ted R. and Will H. Moore (1997) ‘Ethnopolitical Rebellion: A Cross-Sectional Analysis of the 1980s with Risk Assessments for the 1990s’, American Journal of Political Science41(4): 1079–1103.
38.
Halliday, Fred (1997) ‘A New World Myth’, New Statesman10(447): 42–43.
39.
Harris, Robin (1996) ‘War of the World Views’, National Review48(20): 69.
40.
Hassner, Pierre (1997a) ‘Morally Objectionable, Politically Dangerous’, The National Interest(46): 63–69.
41.
Hassner, Pierre (1997b) ‘Clashing On’, The National Interest(48): 105–111.
42.
Haynes, Jeff (1994) Religion in Third World Politics. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
43.
Hegre, Håvard, Tanja Ellingsen, Nils Petter Gleditsch and Scott Gates (1998) ‘Towards a Democratic Civil Peace? Democracy, Democratization, and Civil War 1816–1962’, paper presented to the 6th National Conference in Political Science, Group 5: International Relations, Bardola Hoyfjellshotell, Geilo 12–14 January.
44.
Heilbrunn, Jacob (1998) ‘The Clash of Samuel Huntingtons’, The American Prospect(39): 22–28.
45.
Henderson, Errol A. (1997) ‘Culture or Contiguity: Ethnic Conflict, the Similarity States, and the Onset of War, 1820–1989’, Journal of Conflict Resolution41(5): 649–668.
46.
Henderson, Errol A. (1998) ‘The Democratic Peace through the Lens of Culture, 1820–1989’, International Studies Quarterly42(3): 461–484.
47.
Henderson, Errol A. and J. David Singer (2000) ‘Civil War in the Post-colonial World, 1946–92’, Journal of Peace research37(3): 275–299.
48.
Hoffman, Bruce (1995) ‘ “Holy Terror”: The Implications of Terrorism Motivated by a Religious Imperative’, Studies in Conflict and Terrorism18: 271–284.
49.
Horowitz, Donald L. (1985) Ethnic Groups in Conflict. Berkeley: University of California Press.
50.
Huntington, Samuel P. (1993a) ‘The Clash of Civilizations?’, Foreign Affairs72(3): 22–49.
51.
Huntington, Samuel P (1993b) ‘If Not Civilizations, What? Paradigms of the Post-Cold War’, Foreign Affairs72(5).
52.
Huntington, Samuel P. (1996a) The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Order. New York: Simon and Schuster.
53.
Huntington, Samuel P. (1996b) ‘The West: Unique, Not Universal’, Foreign Affairs75(6): 28–46.
54.
Jaggers, Keith and Ted R. Gurr (1995) ‘Tracking Democracy's Third Wave with the Polity III Data’, Journal of Peace Research32(4): 469–482.
55.
Juergensmeyer, Mark (1993) The New Cold War?Berkeley: University of California Press.
56.
Kader, Zerougui A. (1998) ‘The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order’, Arab Studies Quarterly20(1): 89–92.
57.
Kautsky, J. (1972) The Political Consequences of Modernization. New York: Wiley.
58.
Kirkpatrick, Jeane J., Albert L. Weeks and Gerard Piel (1993) ‘The Modernizing Imperative? (A reply to Huntington's “The Clash of Civilizations”)’, Foreign Affairs72(4): 22–26.
59.
Kirth, James (1994) ‘The Real Clash’, The National Interest37: 3–14.
60.
Kowalewski, David and Arthur L. Greil (1990) ‘Religion as Opiate: Religion as Opiate in Comparative Perspective’, Journal of Church and State32: 511–526.
61.
Kuhn, Thomas S. (1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 2nd edn.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
62.
Liebman, Charles S. (ed.) (1997) Religion, Democracy, and Israeli Society. London: Hardwood Academic Publishers.
63.
Lincoln, Bruce, ed. (1985) Religion, Rebellion and Revolution, London: Macmillan.
64.
Little, David (1991) Ukraine: The Legacy of Intolerance. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press.
65.
Martin, David A. (1978) A General Theory of Secularization. Oxford: Blackwell.
66.
Marty, Martin E.andR.ScottAppleby, eds(1991)FundamentalismsandtheState:Remaking Politics, Economies and Militance. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
67.
Marty, Martin E. and R. Scott Appleby, eds (1993) Fundamentalisms and Society: Reclaiming the Sciences, the Family, and Education. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
68.
Marty, Martin E. and R. Scott Appleby, eds (1994) Accounting for Fundamentalisms: The Dynamic Character of Movements. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
69.
Midlarsky, Manus I. (1998) ‘Democracy and Islam: Implications for Civilizational Conflict and the Democratic Peace’, International Studies Quarterly42(3): 458–511.
70.
Minorities at Risk (2001) URL (consulted November 2001): http://www.bsos.umd.edu/cidcm/mar
71.
Nasr, Vali (1998) ‘Religion and Global Affairs: Secular States and Religious Oppositions’, SAIS Review, Summer–Fall: 32–37.
72.
Nussbaum, Bruce (1997) ‘Capital, Not Culture’, Foreign Affairs76(2): 165.
73.
Pfaff, William (1997) ‘The Reality of Human Affairs’, World Policy Journal14(2): 89–96.
74.
Price, Daniel E. (1999) Islamic Political Culture, Democracy, and Human Rights. Westport, CT: Praeger.
75.
Rapoport, David C. (1984) ‘Fear and Trembling: Terrorism in Three Religious Traditions’, American Political Science Review78: 658–677.
76.
Rapoport, David C. (1988) ‘Messianic Sanctions for Terror’, Comparative Politics20(2): 195–213.
77.
Rapoport, David C. (1990) ‘Sacred Terror: A Contemporary Example from Islam’, in Walter Reich (ed.) Origins of Terrorism: Psychologies, Ideologies, Theologies, States of Mind, pp. 103–130. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
78.
Rapoport, David C. (1991) ‘Comparing Fundamentalist Movements and Groups’, in Martin E. Marty and R. Scott Appleby (eds) Fundamentalisms and the State: Remaking Politics, Economies and Militance, pp. 429–461. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press,
79.
Romanucci-Ross, Lola and George DeVos, eds (1995) Ethnic Identity: Creation, Conflict, and Accommodation, 3rd edn.London: Alta Mira.
80.
Rosecrance, Richard (1998) ‘The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order’, American Political Science Review92(4): 978–980.
81.
Rostow, W. (1959) The Stages of Economic Growth: A Non-Communist Manifesto. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
82.
Russett, Bruce (1968) ‘Delineating International Regions’, in J. David Singer (ed.) Quantitative International Politics, pp. 311–352. New York: The Free Press.
83.
Russett, Bruce, John R. Oneal and Michalene Cox (2000) ‘Clash of Civilizations, or Realism and Liberalism Deja Vu? Some Evidence’, Journal of Peace Research37(5): 583–608.
84.
Sahliyeh, Emile, ed. (1990) Religious Resurgence and Politics in the Contemporary World. New York: State University of New York Press.
85.
Sandler, Shmuel (1996) ‘Religious Zionism and the State: Political Accommodation and Radicalism in Israel’, Terrorism and Political Violence8(2): 133–154.
86.
Senghass, Dieter (1998) ‘A Clash of Civilizations – An Idée Fixe?’, Journal of Peace Research35(1): 127–132.
87.
Shupe, Anson (1990) ‘The Stubborn Persistence of Religion in the Global Arena’, in Emile Sahliyeh (ed.) Religious Resurgence and Politics in the Contemporary World. New York: State University of New York Press.
88.
Smith, Anthony D. (1999) ‘Ethnic Election and National Destiny: Some Religious Origins of Nationalist Ideals’, Nations and Nationalism5(3): 331–355.
89.
Smith, Donald E. (1970) Religion and Political Development. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.
90.
Smith, Donald E., ed. (1971) Religion, Politics and Social Change in the Third World. New York: Free Press.
91.
Smith, Donald E., ed. (1974) Religion and Political Modernization. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
92.
Smith, Tony (1997) ‘Dangerous Conjecture’, Foreign Affairs76(2): 163–114.
93.
Stark, Rodney and William Bainbridge (1985) The Future of Religion: Secularization, Revival and Cult Formation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
94.
Sutton, Frank (1968) ‘Social Theory and Comparative Politics’, in Harry Eckstein and David Apter (eds) International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. New York: Macmillan.
95.
Tipson, Frederick S. (1997) ‘Culture Clash-ification: A Verse to Huntington's Curse’, Foreign Affairs76(2): 166–119.
96.
Walid, Abdurrahman (1997) ‘Future Shock’, Far Eastern Economic Review160(18): 38–39.
97.
Walt, Stephen N. (1997) ‘Building Up New Bogeymen’, Foreign Policy106: 177–189.
98.
Wentz, Richard (1987) Why People Do Bad Things in the Name of Religion. Macon, GA: Mercer.
99.
Williams, Rhys H. (1994) ‘Movement Dynamics and Social Change: Transforming Fundamentalist Ideologies and Organizations’, in Martin E. Marty and R. Scott Appleby (eds) Accounting for Fundamentalisms: The Dynamic Character of Movements, pp. 785–833. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
100.
Wilson, Bryan R. (1966) Religion in Secular Society. Baltimore, MA: Penguin.
101.
Wilson, Bryan R. (1976) ‘Aspects of Secularization in the West’, Japanese Journal of Religious Studies3(4): 259–276.
102.
Yamazaki, Masakazu (1996) ‘Asia: A Civilization in the Making’, Foreign Affairs75(4): 106–128.
